THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, PANAJI., vs. THE SESA GOA EMPLOYEES CO-OP. CREDIT SOCIETY LTD.,
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court acknowledged the position stated by the learned Standing Counsel for the Department. The Court noted that a committee has been formed to examine the matters in light of the CBDT Circular dated July 11, 2018, and that the process of examination has been initiated. The Department requested, and was granted, four weeks' time to complete this examination and make an appropriate statement to the Court. Consequently, the hearing of these group of matters was deferred. The Court did not decide on the merits of any of the appeals or applications. The principle derived from this order is procedural: the Court is willing to grant time for the Revenue to assess the applicability of a CBDT Circular to pending appeals and to make a statement accordingly. No issue was expressly left undecided, but the substantive issues of the appeals remain to be addressed.
What were the facts?
This judgment concerns a large number of Tax Appeals and Miscellaneous Applications filed before the High Court of Bombay at Goa. The appeals are filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (the Revenue) against Damodar Mangalji Mining Co. (the Assessee) and other respondents. The matters were listed in view of a Circular issued by the CBDT on July 11, 2018. The High Court had previously directed the Income Tax Department to form a committee to examine which of these listed matters were covered by the aforementioned Circular. The Standing Counsel for the Department informed the Court that the committee has been formed and the examination process has commenced. The Department requested four weeks to complete this examination and make an appropriate statement.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the matters listed before the High Court are covered by the CBDT Circular dated July 11, 2018? (Question of fact and law) The Revenue, through its Standing Counsel, argued that a committee has been formed to examine the listed matters in light of the CBDT Circular dated July 11, 2018. The Revenue requested four weeks' time to complete this examination and make a statement to the Court regarding which matters are covered by the Circular. The Assessee's contentions are not recorded in this specific order, but their presence as respondents indicates they are affected by the Revenue's appeals. The judgment does not explicitly name any specific provisions of the Income Tax Act that are the subject of the appeals, nor does it cite any specific precedents or circulars other than the one from CBDT dated July 11, 2018.
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
1 TXA58/06 & connected matters IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA. TAX APPEAL NO.58/2006. The Commissioner of Income Tax … Appellant. Versus Damodar Mangalji Mining Co. ... Respondent. Ms. Susan Linhares, Advocate for the Appellant. Ms. Vinita Palyekar, Advocate for the Respondent. AND TAX APPEAL NOS.67/2006, 74/2006, 75/2006, 24/2008, 27/2008, 51/2008, 18/2009, 26/2012, 29/2012, 34/2012, 60/2008, 8/2009, 9/2009, 8/2010, 14/2010, 24/2010, 3/2011, 10/2011, 11/2011, 26/2011, 17/2013, 5/2014, 13/2013, STA 3436/2013, 13/2013, 14/2013, STA 3428/2013, 18/2013, 24/2014, 25/2014, 27/2015, 28/2015, 31/2014, 34/2014, 55/2015, 56/2015, 1/2017, 12/2016, 17/2017, 1/2018, 2/2018, 3/2018, 5/2018, 6/2018, 9/2018, 10/2018, 11/2018, 14/2017, 16/2018, 17/2018, 18/2018, 19/2018, 20/2018, 21/2018, 22/2018, 23/2018, 24/2018, 26/2018, 27/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 35/2018, 36/2018, 38/2018, 41/2018, 49/2017, 71/2017,110/2017, 111/2017, 112/2017, 113/2017, 114/2017, 115/2017, 116/2017, 117/2017, 118/2017, 126/2017, 127/2017, 129/2017, 130/2017, 131/2017, 132/2017, 133/2017, 135/2017, 137/2017, 142/2017, 145/2017, 150/2017, 152/2017, 101/2017, 40/2018, 49/2018, 50/2018, 51/2018, 52/2018, 53/2018, 54/2018, 55/2018, 56/2018 and 60/2018. MCA NOS.652/2018 IN TXA 77/2014, 653/2018 IN TXA75/2014, MCA 654/2018 IN TXA 25/2011 AND TXA 59/2018. Ms. Susan Linhares, Standing Counsel for the Appellant in Tax Appeal Nos. 58/2006, 67/2006, 74/2006, 75/2006, 24/2008, 27/2008, 51/2008, 18/2009, 26/2012, 29/2012, 34/2012, 60/2008, 8/2009, 9/2009, 8/2010, 14/2010, 24/2010, 3/2011, 10/2011,
2 TXA58/06 & connected matters 11/2011, 26/2011, 13/2013, 14/2013, 24/2014, 31/2014, 34/2014, 55/2015, 56/2015, 1/2017, 12/2016, 17/2017, 1/2018, 2/2018,3/2018, 5/2018, 6/2018, 9/2018, 10/2018, 11/2018, 14/2017, 16/2018, 17/2018, 18/2018, 19/2018, 20/2018, 21/2018, 22/2018, 23/2018, 24/2018, 26/2018, 27/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 35/2018, 36/2018, 38/2018, 41/2018, 49/2018, 71/2017, 110/2017, 111/2017, 112/2017, 113/2017, 114/2017, 115/2017, 116/2017, 117/2017, 118/2017, 126/2017, 127/2017, 129/2017, 130/2017, 131/2017, 132/2017, 133/2017, 135/2017, 137/2017, 142/2017,145/2017, 150/2017, 152/2017, 101/2017, 40/2018, 149/2018, 50/2018, 51/201852/2018, 53/2018, 54/2018, 55/2018, 56/2018, 60/2018, 59/2018 and stm3436/2013, stm3428/13. Mr. R. G. Ramani, Advocate for the Appellant in TXA Nos. 17/2013, 18/2013, 25/2014, 27/2015. Mr. S. N. Joshi, for the Applicant in MCA Nos.652/2018, 653/2018, 654/2018. Ms. S. Linhares, Advocate for the Respondent in MCA Nos.652/2018, 653/2018, 654/2018. Mr. P. Sawant, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal Nos.67/2006, 74/2006, 75/2006, 26/2012, 29/2012, 34/2012, 8/2010 and 14/2010. Ms. Vinita Palyekar, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal Nos.58/2006, 24/2008, 27/2008, 8/2009, 9/2009, 5/2014, 56/2015, 1/2017 and 12/2016, 24/2014 and 101/2017. Mr. R. Menezes, Advocate holding for Mr. A. F. Diniz, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal no.3/2011. Mr. R. Menezes, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal nos. 10/2011,11/2011, 26/2011 Mr. S. N. Joshi, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal Nos.31/2014., Mr. S. M. Singbal, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal No.55/2015. Mr. S. Karpe, Advocate for the Respondent in Tax Appeal
3 TXA58/06 & connected matters Nos.3/2018, 21/2018 and 36/2018, 132/2017, 133/2017, 142/2017 and 145/2017. Mr. G. Panandikar and Ms. E. Dukle, Advocates for the Respondent in Tax Appeal Nos.17/2018, 18/2018, 19/2018, 24/2018, 49/2018, 50/2018, 51/2018, 52/2018, 53/2018, 54/2018, 55/2018, 56/2018 and 60/2018. Mr. R. G. Ramani, Advocate for Respondents in Tax Appeal Nos. 13/2013, 14/2013. Mr. R. Rivankar, Advocate for Respondents in Tax Appeal Nos.17/2017, 12/2018, 5/2018, 6/2018, 10/2018, 11/2018, 14/2017, 16/2018, 20/2018, 27/2018, 30/2018, 35/2018, 38/2018, 49/2017, 71/2017, 110/2017, 112/2017, 113/2017, 126/2017, 127/2017, 131/2017, 135/2017, 114/2017 to 118/2017. Coram : N.M. Jamdar & Prithviraj K.Chavan, JJ. Date : 6 September 2018. P.C.: Matters have been listed on board in view of the Circular issued by the CBDT on 11 July 2018. By our earlier order, we had directed the Department-Income Tax to form a Committee to examine the matters as to which matters are covered by this Circular. The learned Standing Counsel for the Department states that Committee has been formed and process of examining the matters is initiated. The learned Standing Counsel on instructions from Ms. Rijula Uniyal, Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, states that four weeks time may be granted and within the said period, matters which are listed will be examined and appropriate statement will be made.
4 TXA58/06 & connected matters 2. In view of this position, we defer the hearing. Accordingly, these group of matters is adjourned to 4 October 2018. To be listed under the caption `For Directions'. Prithviraj K. Chavan, J. N.M. Jamdar, J.
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Ms Akher Ali vs. The Union Of INDIAGauhati · 5 Nov 2026
- Paonta Hp Centre vs. State Of Hp And OthersHimachal Pradesh · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Multitech Agro INDIA (Opc) PVT LTD vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 5 Nov 2026
- Gopa Satya Madhava Subbarao vs. The State Of Andhra PradeshAndhra Pradesh · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Kallu Cable vs. The Commissioner State Goods And Service TaxUttarakhand · 5 Nov 2026