B.U. BHANDARI AUTOLINES PVT. LTD. vs. THE DY. COMM. OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE - 2(4) PUNE AND ANR.

PDF · subscribers
WP/4172/2018HC BombayHCBM01015523201806 April 2018Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP KASHINATH SHINDE,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.S. SANKLECHA4 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the impugned notices, which sought to examine the basis of the statements made on oath and to show cause why the petitioners should not be proceeded against as though tax was due from them, did not warrant interference at that stage. The court found it appropriate for the petitioners to respond to the show-cause notices and make all available contentions to persuade the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax that the notices should be dropped. Consequently, the court declined to entertain the petitions at that stage. However, acknowledging the very short response period of two days, the court extended the time for the petitioners to reply by 15 days from the date of the order. The respondent was directed to consider the response and dispose of the matter in accordance with law, following principles of natural justice. Coercive proceedings were stayed until the disposal of the notices and for two weeks thereafter.

What were the facts?

Two companies, B.U. Bhandari Motors Pvt. Ltd. and B.U. Bhandari Autolines Pvt. Ltd., both belonging to the same group, filed writ petitions challenging identical notices dated March 26, 2018, issued under Section 226(3)(x) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. These notices required the petitioners to support their statements made on oath that no amount was due to a party who was in default to the Revenue. The notices also called upon them to show cause why they should not be treated as an assessee in default. The petitioners were given only two days to respond, failing which coercive proceedings were threatened. The petitions were taken up for final disposal at the request of the counsel.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the impugned notices issued under Section 226(3)(x) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, warrant interference at this stage, considering the short response time and the petitioners' contention that they should not be declared assessees in default without the Assessing Officer first concluding that their statements on oath are not acceptable. Assessee's Contentions: The petitioners argued that the notices were issued in the face of binding Supreme Court decisions. They contended that they should not be declared assessees in default without the Assessing Officer first concluding that their statements made on oath do not merit acceptance. Revenue's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions from the revenue. However, the notices themselves indicate the revenue's intent to examine the basis of the statements made on oath by the petitioners.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 226(3)(x),Section 226(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 4138 OF 2018 B.U. Bhandari Motors Pvt. Ltd. .. Petitioner v/s.

1.

The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle – 2(4), Pune 2.  The Union of India .. Respondents WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 4172 OF 2018 B.U. Bhandari Autolines Pvt. Ltd. .. Petitioner v/s. 1.  The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle – 2(4), Pune 2.  The Union of India .. Respondents Mr. Mihir Naniwadekar i/b Rohan Deshpande for the petitioner Mr. Sham Walve for the respondents

CORAM : M.S. SANKLECHA & SANDEEP K. SHINDE, J.J.

DATED  : 6th APRIL, 2018. P.C. 1. At the request of the Counsel, both the petitions are taken up for final disposal. 1 of 4

2.

These two petitions challenge two identical Notices dated 26 th March,  2018 issued  to the two petitioners (belonging to  the same group) under Section 226(3)(x) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act). The   impugned   notices   dated   26 th  March,   2017   call   upon   the   two petitioners  to   support   the   statements   made  on   oath   under   Section 226(3) of the Act to the effect that no amount is due to a party (its creditors), who is in default of his dues to the Revenue and also to show   cause   as   to   why   the   petitioner   should   not   be   treated  as   an assessee in default.    The impugned notices give only two days time to the petitioners to respond, failing which coercive proceedings against the petitioners was threatened. 3. The petitioner's principal grievance is that the impugned notices are in the face of binding decisions of the Supreme Court and in any event, the petitioner should not be declared to be an assessee in default in the absence of the Assessing Officer first coming to the conclusion that the statement made on oath by the petitioner does not merit acceptance. 4. We note that the impugned notices issued to the two petitioners only seeks to examine the basis of the statements made on oath and 2 of 4

dependent upon that, to show cause why the petitioners should not be proceeded against as though the tax was due from it.   Thus, at this stage the impugned notices do not warrant any interference. It would be appropriate for the petitioners to respond to the show­cause notices dated 26 th March, 2018 and make all contentions available to them to impress upon the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax – respondent no.1 that the impugned notices need to be dropped.    Therefore, we decline to entertain the petitions at this stage. 5. However, as the period to respond to the impugned notices was only 2 days from the date of receipt, we deem it appropriate to extend the time for the petitioners to reply to the impugned notices dated 26 th March, 2018 issued by respondent no.1 by a period of 15 days from today.    The respondent no.1 would consider the petitioners' response to the show­cause notices dated 26 th March, 2018 and dispose of the same in accordance with law after following the principles of natural justice. 6. Needless  to  state  that  the  respondents   would not   adopt   any coercive proceedings against the two petitioners  till such time as the two impugned notices are disposed of in accordance with law and for a 3 of 4

further period of two weeks from the date of communication of its orders to the two petitioners. 7. Both the petitions are disposed of in the above terms.  No order as to costs. (SANDEEP K. SHINDE, J.) (M.S. SANKLECHA, J.) 4 of 4

More judgments on Section 226(3)

All 95 judgments and leading authorities on Section 226(3) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →