SULOCHANA PURUSHOTTAM GINDODIYA vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER DHULE
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that no substantial question of law arises in the appeal. The Court noted that the assessee had never raised the ground of non-applicability of Section 44(A)E before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) or the Tribunal. The Court also referred to Circular No. 684 which clarifies that the amendment takes effect from 1.4.1994, thus applying to assessment year 1994-95 and subsequent years. The authorities had concurrently found that as per the agreement, the assessee was entitled to monthly hire charges of Rs. 4,000/-, with the son bearing all expenses. The assessee declared Rs. 24,000/- as truck rent and claimed Rs. 1,31,751/- as depreciation and professional tax, which was disallowed under Section 44(A)E. Given the concurrent findings of all authorities and the failure to raise the issue before the lower forums, the appeal was dismissed.
What were the facts?
The appeal concerns assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96, challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT had upheld the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), who in turn had upheld the Assessing Officer's order. The assessee, Smt. Sulochana Purushottam Gindodiya, had entered into a lease agreement for a mini truck with her son. The dispute revolves around the applicability of Section 44(A)E of the Income Tax Act and the genuineness of the lease transaction. The assessee declared truck rent of Rs. 24,000/- and claimed depreciation and professional tax of Rs. 1,31,751/-. The authorities disallowed these claims based on Section 44(A)E.
What were the issues?
1. Whether Section 44(A)E, introduced by the Finance Act, 1994, is applicable to assessment year 1994-95, or only from assessment year 1995-96 onwards? 2. Whether the lease agreement for the mini truck between the assessee and her son is a genuine transaction, and if so, should the lease rent be taxed under income from other sources with due depreciation allowed under Section 57? Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that Section 44(A)E should not apply to assessment year 1994-95 as it was introduced in Finance Act, 1994, and would apply from assessment year 1995-96. They also contended that the lease agreement was genuine, and the income should be taxed as 'income from other sources' with depreciation allowed under Section 57. Furthermore, they argued that Section 44(A)E(i) and (ii) could not be applied when the declared income was lower than stipulated. Revenue's contentions: The revenue argued that the amended provision would apply to assessment year 1994-95, as clarified by Circular No. 684 dated 10.6.1994. They also submitted that the authorities had properly appreciated the evidence and that the assessee had not raised the ground of non-applicability of Section 44(A)E before the lower authorities.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 44(A)E,Section 57
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD. TAX APPEAL NO.42 OF 2003 Smt.Sulochana Purushottam Gindodiya, Age 59 years, Occ.Business, R/o Sanjay Building, Agrawal Nagar, Dhule. ... Appellant. Versus 1. The Income Tax Officer, Ward No.2(8), Dhule. 2. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Nasik. ... Respondents. ... Mr.S.P.Shah, advocate holding for Mr.P.V.Barde, advocate for the appellant. Mr.Alok Sharma, counsel for Respondents. ...
CORAM : S.V.GANGAPURWALA AND A.M. DHAVALE,JJ.
Date : 03.05.2018. PER COURT : 1. The appeal pertains to assessment year 1994-95 and 1995-96. 2. The order of the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal is assailed. Under the said judgment the Tribunal has upheld the judgment of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has upheld the order of the assessing Officer. 3. Mr.Shah, learned counsel submits that provisions of Section 44(A) E has been introduced as per the Finance Act, 1994. It will apply for the financial year 1994-95 onwards i.e. assessment year 1995-96 and can not apply for the proceedings involving assessment year 1994-95. The learned counsel further submits that the authorities have also failed to consider that the agreement of lease of mini truck between the appellant and her son is a genuine transaction. The lease rent received for the mini truck from her son was to be taxed as income under the head income from other sources and the due depreciation has to be allowed as per Section 57 of the Income Tax Act. It ought to have been considered that Section 44(A) E(i) and (ii) could not have been applied when the appellant had declared the income lower than as stipulated in
the said Section. The authorities have not applied the legal provisions in its correct perspective. 4. Mr.Sharma, learned counsel submits that the amended provision would apply to the assessment year 1994-95. The same is also clarified as per Circular No.684 dated 10.6.1994. The authorities have properly appreciated the evidence. 5. The appeal can only be entertained on substantial question of law. The appellant had never raised the ground of non-applicability of Section 44(A) E before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and/or before the Tribunal. The Circular in question clarifies that the amendment would take effect from 1.4.1994 and will accordingly apply in relation to assessment year 1994-95 and subsequent years. Moreover, the appellant has never raised this ground before any of the authorities. The authorities have considered that as per the agreement the assessee was entitled to monthly hire charges of
Rs.4,000/- and the responsibility of entire expenses was of the son. The assessee declared the truck rent for those months amounting to Rs.24,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) and claimed depreciation and professional tax amounting to Rs.1,31,751/- (Rupees one lac thirty one thousand seven hundred fifty one). In view of the provisions of Section 44(A) E the same is disallowed by applying the principles. All the authorities are concurrent in this aspect. 6. In light of the above, no substantial question of law arises. The appeal as such is dismissed. No costs. (A.M.DHAVALE,J.) (S.V.GANGAPURWALA,J.) asp/office/Taxappeal42.03
More judgments on Section 57
- Dattatraya Prakash Wankar, Solapur vs ITO WD-2(3), SolapurITA 2210/PUN/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed5 Oct 2026AY 2020-21
- Aurelia Housing Coperative Society Ltd… vs I.T.O., Ward - 49(4), KolkataITA 2198/KOL/2026[2017-2018]Status: Disposed29 Sept 2026AY 2017-2018
- Ramkrishna Bajaj Charitable Trust, Mumbai vs Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax, Circle…ITA 66/MUM/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed29 Sept 2026AY 2016-17
- Zidni Ilma Charitable Trust, Vadodara vs The ITO, Ward-Exemp, VadodaraITA 914/AHD/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed28 Sept 2026AY 2018-19
- Zidni Ilma Charitable Trust, Vadodara vs The ITO, Ward-Exemp, VadodaraITA 913/AHD/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed28 Sept 2026AY 2016-17
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Sampat Raj Jain vs. The State Of Assam And 3 Ors.Gauhati · 3 Nov 2026
- Sri Hardik Gowda vs. Sri Jayaram PKarnataka · 3 Nov 2026
- Shiv Ram vs. State Of Hp And OrsHimachal Pradesh · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Ampl Resources PVT. LTD., Through Sri Om Prakash Pareek, Authorised Signatory vs. The State Of JharkhandJharkhand · 3 Nov 2026