D.Y. PATIL EDUCATION SOC. vs. MR. SARDAR SINGH MEENA COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, PUNE AND ANR.

PDF · subscribers
WP/5496/2018HC BombayHCBM01021764201809 August 2018Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP KASHINATH SHINDE,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.S. SANKLECHA5 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the impugned order dated April 2, 2018, and the show-cause notice dated February 23, 2018, were liable to be set aside. The primary reasoning was that the show-cause notice failed to provide sufficient indication of the reasons for the proposed transfer, making it impossible for the Petitioner to effectively respond and satisfy the authorities. The court cited its own decisions in Ramswaroop & Ors. and Global Energy P. Ltd., emphasizing that a mere statement of 'coordinated investigation' is insufficient without particulars. Furthermore, the impugned order relied on a report dated December 21, 2017, which was not disclosed to the Petitioner, constituting a breach of the principles of natural justice (Audi Alteram Partem). The setting aside of the order and notice does not preclude the respondents from taking fresh action in accordance with law. All other contentions were left open to be urged before the appropriate authorities.

What were the facts?

The Petitioner, D.Y. Patil Education Society, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated April 2, 2018, passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions), Pune. This order transferred the Petitioner's assessment proceedings from Kolhapur to Mumbai under Section 127 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Petitioner contended that the transfer order was without jurisdiction. The procedural history involved a show-cause notice dated February 23, 2018, proposing the transfer, and the impugned order which relied on a report dated December 21, 2017. The petition was disposed of at the admission stage.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the show-cause notice dated February 23, 2018, proposing the transfer of the Petitioner's case from Kolhapur to Mumbai for coordinated investigation, provided sufficient reasons to enable the Petitioner to meet the Revenue's case, thereby complying with principles of natural justice and the ratio in Ramswaroop & Ors. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Global Energy P. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax? (Question of law and fact, turning on Section 127 of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's Contentions: The show-cause notice was vague, merely stating 'facilitating better co-ordinated investigation' without particulars, making it impossible to respond. The impugned order relied on a report dated December 21, 2017, which was not disclosed to the Petitioner, violating principles of natural justice. Other grounds included lack of meeting of minds between authorities of the same rank and the notice not being signed by the Commissioner. Revenue's Contentions: The decision to transfer was to facilitate better coordinated investigation as the case was part of a group of cases, and notice of this was issued to the Petitioner. There was no reason to interfere with the transfer order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 127

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO.  5496 OF 2018

D.Y. Patil Education Society ..  Petitioner v/s. Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions) Pune and Anr. ..Respondents Mr. J.D. Mistri, Senior Counsel a/w Mr. Niraj Sheth I/b MINT and for the appellant for the respondent

CORAM : M.S. SANKLECHA &

SANDEEP K. SHINDE, J.J.

DATED  : 9th AUGUST, 2018. P.C. 1. At the request of the parties, the petition itself is being disposed finally at the stage of admission. 2. This   petition   under   Article   226   of   the   Constitution   of   India challenges the order dated 2nd  April, 2018 passed by the respondent no.1 – Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions).     The impugned order   transfers   the   petitioner's   case   (assessment   proceedings)   from Kolhapur to Mumbai under Section 127 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (Act). 1 of 5 Uday Shivaji Jagtap Digitally signed by Uday Shivaji Jagtap Date: 2018.08.13 10:53:44 +0530

3.

The grievance of the petitioner is that the impugned order dated 2nd April, 2018 is without jurisdiction on the following amongst other grounds :­ (a) It seeks to transfer the petitioner's case from Kolhapur to Mumbai for coordinated investigation without setting out reasons in support thereof.   Our attention is invited to the show­cause notice dated 23rd February, 2018 proposing the transfer of the petitioner's case from Kolhapur to Mumbai merely on the stated ground of facilitating better co­ordinated   investigation.     This   it   is   submitted   is   without   any particulars, thus making it impossible to meet the Revenue's case.  This it is submitted is contrary to the binding decisions of this Court in Ramswaroop and Ors. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, 388 ITR 208 and Global Energy P. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, 356 ITR 502; (b) The impugned order dated 2nd  April, 2018 which relies upon evidence   in   the   form   of   report   dated   21st  December,   2017   to substantiate that the transfer of the case from Kolhapur to Mumbai without the same having been disclosed to the petitioner either in the show­cause notice nor in any time prior to the passing of the impugned order.  Thus, in breach of principles of natural justice; and 2 of 5

(c) Other grounds such as no meeting of minds by the Authorities of the same rank and the notice not being signed by the Commissioner of Income Tax.

4.

Mr. Walve, learned Counsel appearing in support of the Revenue submits that the decision to transfer the petitioner's case from Kolhapur to Mumbai was to facilitate better co­ordinated investigation as it was a part   of the group of cases.   Thus, that was the reason to seek the transfer and notice of the same was issued to the petitioner.  Thus, he submits that there is no reason for interfering with the impugned order of transfer. 5. This petition could be disposed of at this stage on the challenge to the impugned order dated 2nd April, 2018 on the basis the grievance of   being   passed   in   breach   of   principles   of   natural   justice   without examining the other contentions raised by the petitioner.  We find that the notice dated 23rd February, 2018 proposing the transfer did not give sufficient indication for the reasons to transfer the petitioner's case from Kolhapur to Mumbai.   Therefore, making it impossible for a party to meet the Revenue's case and satisfy the Authority concerned that the proposed reasons for the transfer are not justified.   In fact, this Court in 3 of 5

Ramswaroop and ors. (supra)  while dealing with the requirement of the notice proposed transfer of a case observed as under :­ “Thus as already stated above, the show­cause notice, in fact should have contained specific reason based on material facts, which should be clear so that the petitioners in that case could exercise their right to have hearing on substantial questions in a meaningful manner.”

Therefore, merely stating that the transfer is proposed / being done for the purposes of co­ordinated investigation is not sufficient as held by this Court in Global Energy P. Ltd. (supra). 6. Moreover,   the   impugned   order   dated   2nd  April,   2018   has admittedly placed reliance upon a report dated 21st December, 2017 of the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax to justify the transfer of the petitioner's case.   Not only no copy of the above report dated 21st December, 2017 was furnished to the petitioners at any time before the passing of the order but even the notice dated 23rd February, 2018 does not advert to it.  Thus, this would be a classic case of breach of Audi Aleram Partem Rule. 7. In the above view, we set aside the impugned order dated 2nd April, 2018 as well as the Show­cause Notice dated 23rd February, 2018 4 of 5

(respondents rely upon the same in support of the impugned order). However, this setting aside of the impugned order dated 2nd April, 2018 and the Show­cause Notice dated 23rd February, 2018 would not in any manner prohibit the respondents from taking such action as is available to it for transfer of the petitioner's case, in accordance with law. 8. Accordingly,  the  petition is  allowed in the  above terms.   All contentions are left open to be urged before the Authorities under the Act. (SANDEEP K. SHINDE J.) (M.S. SANKLECHA, J.) 5 of 5

More judgments on Section 127

All 1,067 judgments and leading authorities on Section 127 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →