S T RETAIL INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED,TIRUPPUR vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, COIMBATORE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 4039/CHNY/2026Status: DisposedITAT Chennai30 October 2026AY 2018-1923 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the addition on account of GST on suppressed sales is not sustainable. The reasoning is that the net profit of 17% estimated on the suppressed sales already takes into account the entire benefit derived from these receipts, including the GST component. Therefore, a separate addition for GST would constitute taxing the same income twice. The grounds of the assessees on this issue are allowed, and the AO is directed to delete the separate addition made for GST. Regarding depreciation, the Tribunal upheld the disallowance made by the Ld.CIT(A). The reasoning is based on the second proviso to Section 43(1) of the Act, which states that expenditure incurred for acquiring an asset where cash payments exceeding Rs. 10,000 are made in a day shall be ignored for determining the actual cost. Since the assets in question were acquired out of cash generated from suppressed sales, and the depreciation was claimed from AY 2018-19 onwards (to which the proviso applies), there is no actual cost on which depreciation can be allowed under Section 32. The Tribunal noted that the assessee's counsel fairly accepted that Section 32 does not override the second proviso to Section 43(1). The grounds of the assessees on this issue are dismissed. Consequently, the income from suppressed sales will be assessed at 17% of the suppressed sales without deducting the disallowed depreciation.

What were the facts?

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Chennai Bench, heard cross-appeals filed by three entities of the Shiva Textiles group: M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles, M/s. Kulithalai Shiva Textiles, and M/s. S.T. Retail India Private Limited (collectively, the assessees), and the Revenue. These appeals pertained to assessment years 2016-17 to 2022-23, arising from assessment orders passed under Section 147 read with Section 143(3) and Section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, following a search conducted on November 2, 2022. The assessees are engaged in the retail sale of textiles and garments. During the search, suppressed sales were detected by comparing data in the 'SS Posting' database with sales recorded in regular books and GST returns. This suppression was accepted by the Managing Partner. The assessments were reopened, and the assessees offered additional income at 17% of suppressed sales as net profit, and claimed depreciation on assets acquired from unaccounted cash from AY 2018-19 onwards.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the addition made on account of Goods and Services Tax (GST) on suppressed sales is sustainable, considering that the net profit on such sales has already been brought to tax? - Assessee's Contention: The GST component is part of the receipts from suppressed sales, and taxing it separately would amount to double taxation. The net profit estimation already accounts for the entire benefit derived. - Revenue's Contention: Not explicitly recorded, but implied by the addition made. 2. Whether depreciation claimed on assets acquired out of cash generated from suppressed sales is allowable, given the provisions of Section 43(1) of the Act? - Assessee's Contention: Depreciation is claimed on assets acquired from suppressed sales. The assessees' case is that the consideration for these assets was paid in cash. They also argued that Section 32 of the Act does not override the proviso to Section 43(1). - Revenue's Contention: The disallowance of depreciation by the Ld.CIT(A) is upheld, as the cost of assets was met in cash, rendering it ignored for actual cost determination under the second proviso to Section 43(1) of the Act, effective from April 1, 2018.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132,Section 143(3),Section 147,Section 148,Section 32,Section 43(1),Section 139(1),Section 131(1A)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ‘B’ BENCH, CHENNAI

Before: SHRI MANU KUMAR GIRI & SHRI S. R. RAGHUNATHA

Hearing: 21.08.2026Pronounced: 30.10.2026

आदेश/ O R D E R PER BENCH :

These are cross appeals filed by three concerns of the Shiva Textiles group, namely M/s.Karur Shiva Textiles, M/s.Kulithalai Shiva Textiles and

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-3-: M/s.S.T. Retail India Private Limited (hereinafter collectively referred to as “the assessees”), and by the Revenue, against the respective orders of the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-20, Chennai [hereinafter referred to as “the Ld.CIT(A)”], arising out of the assessment orders passed u/s.147 r.w.s.143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) for the Assessment Years (AYs) 2016-17 to 2021-22 and u/s.143(3) of the Act for the AY 2022-23, consequent to the search conducted on 02.11.2022. Since the issues involved are common and arise out of the same search action, the appeals were heard together and are disposed of by this common order for the sake of convenience. The appeal of M/s.Karur Shiva Textiles for the AY 2022-23 in ITA No.1673/Chny/2026, against the order of the Ld.CIT(A) dated 30.01.2026 arising out of the assessment order dated 30.03.2024 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle-2, Coimbatore [hereinafter referred to as “the AO”], is taken as the lead case, and the facts and figures of that case are referred to in this order wherever necessary. At the outset, the Registry has noted a delay of 115 days in filing the following appeals in ITA No.4037, 4038 & 4039/Chny/2026, by the assessee. We have considered the condonation petition filed by the assessee explaining the reasons for the delay. Having regard to the reasons state therein and the facts and circumstances of the case, we are satisfied that the revenue had demonstrated sufficient cause for the delay. Accordingly, the delay as discussed above in filing the appeal by the assessee is condoned, and the appealsare admitted for adjudication on merits. Similarly, the Registry has also noted a delay of 29 days in filing the appeals in ITA No. 2517 & 2525/Chny/2026, and delay of 35 days in filing the appeals in ITA No 2662, 2663 & 2664/Chny/2026,delay of 36 days in filing the appeals in ITA No.2685/Chny/2026 &delay of 52 days in filing the appeals in ITA No.3032, 3033 & 3034/Chny/2026,57 days in filing the following appeals in ITA No.3159, 3160 & 3161/Chny/2026 by the revenue. We have considered

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-4-: the condonation petition filed by the Revenue explaining the reasons for the delay. Having regard to the reasons state therein and the facts and circumstances of the case, we are satisfied that the Revenue had demonstrated sufficient cause for the delay. Accordingly, the delay in filing the appeal as detailed aboveby the revenue is condoned and the appealsare admitted for adjudication on merits. 2. The brief facts of the case are that M/s.Karur Shiva Textiles and M/s.Kulithalai Shiva Textiles are partnership firms carrying on the business of retail sale of textiles, garments and apparel at Karur and Kulithalai respectively, and M/s.S.T. Retail India Private Limited is a company carrying on the same business through its establishments at Tirupur, Salem and Ooty. The assessees regularly maintained books of account and filed their returns of income u/s.139(1) of the Act. As per their regular books, the gross profit (GP) ratio and net profit (NP) ratio of M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles ranged between 17.47% and 20.26% and between 6.27% and 10.80% respectively during the financial years 2015-16 to 2021-22; those of M/s.Kulithalai Shiva Textiles ranged between 19.74% and 21.12% and between 7.79% and 10.05%; and those of M/s.S.T.Retail India Private Limited ranged between 21.01% and 27.23% and between 4.76% and 10.06% respectively.

3.

A search u/s.132 of the Act was conducted on 02.11.2022 in the cases of the assessees and certain other concerns of the Shiva Textiles and Meghna Silks groups, covering their business premises and the residences of the partners/directors. In the course of the search, it was found that sales at the billing counters were recorded by scanning the barcode of each item in the “SS Retail” software (“POS” software in the Salem and Ooty establishments of M/s. S.T. Retail India Private Limited), from where the daily sales were transferred to the regular books maintained in Tally. The software was capable, through a separate application described as “SS Posting”, of reducing or deleting a portion of the sales before the reduced figures entered

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-5-: the regular books and the GST returns, while the actual sales data remained preserved in the SS Posting database, which had been backed up. By comparing the sales preserved in the SS Posting database with the sales recorded in the regular books, the Department quantified the suppressed sales of each assessee for each year. The search also yielded the “310 Note Books”, a physical record maintained by the Head Cashier of the cash collected from the billing counters and its subsequent movement and utilisation, and the “310 Tally”, its computerised counterpart, containing entries described as “Lot Purchase”, “Lot Cash”, “Lot Purchase Cash” and “MD’s Account”.

4.

In the post-search proceedings, statements were recorded u/s.131(1A) of the Act, and the suppression of sales as identified by the Department was accepted by the Managing Partner, Shri N. Ravichandran, in his sworn deposition dated 15.02.2023. The assessments for the AYs 2016-17 to 2021- 22 were reopened u/s.147 of the Act and, in response to the notices u/s.148 of the Act, the assessees filed returns of income on 22.06.2023 offering additional income at 17% of the suppressed sales by way of net profit, as explained in the affidavit of Shri N. Ravichandran, and, from the AY 2018-19 onwards, claimed depreciation on the fixed assets acquired out of the unaccounted cash. For the AY 2022-23, which was taken up for scrutiny by issue of notice u/s.143(2) dated 16.06.2023, the assessees offered the additional income on the same basis in the course of the assessment proceedings. The suppressed sales and the additional income so offered are as under: Assessee Suppressed sales Income @17% Depreciation NP (Rs.) claimed (Rs.) AY 2016-17 to 2022-23 (Rs.) M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles 98,55,18,957 16,75,38,223 1,03,56,449 M/s. Kulithalai Shiva Textiles 43,56,28,897 7,40,56,912 51,74,650 M/s. S.T.Retail India Pvt. Ltd. 1,12,51,33,582 19,12,72,709 5,40,31,518

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-6-: 5. In the lead case, M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles had filed its original return of income for the AY 2022-23 on 02.09.2022, declaring a total income of Rs.8,67,60,100/-. Against the suppressed sales of Rs.10,98,37,268/- for the year, quantified from the seized database, the assessee offered additional income of Rs.1,86,72,336/- at 17% thereof and, after claiming fresh depreciation of Rs.22,02,546/- on the assets acquired out of the unaccounted cash, a net additional income of Rs.1,64,69,789/-.

6.

The AO did not accept the 17% NP offered by the assessees, holding that such a rate could not be accepted in the absence of separate books for the accounted and unaccounted transactions. Instead of determining the profit embedded in the suppressed sales, the AO relied on the entries in the 310 Note Books, the 310 Tally and the “Lot Purchase”, “Lot Cash”, “Lot Purchase Cash” and “MD’s Account” records, treating them as representing cash generated from suppressed sales and taken out by the partners/directors for personal purposes, investments and other payments outside the books, and brought the amounts so recorded to tax as undisclosed income. In the lead case, against suppressed sales of Rs.10,98,37,268/-, the AO determined undisclosed income of Rs.5,59,23,870/-, which works out to 50.92% of the suppressed sales. The additions in the case of M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles are as under: AY Addition by AO (Rs.) Effective rate Suppressed sales (Rs.) 2017-18 18,78,20,695 5,67,83,531 30.23% 2018-19 14,93,35,566 8,49,72,000 56.90% 2019-20 12,74,01,199 4,01,79,000 31.54% 2020-21 12,31,96,137 5,05,05,000 41.00% 2021-22 10,41,50,301 5,01,56,452 48.16% 2022-23 10,98,37,268 5,59,23,870 50.92%

7.

In the lead case, the AO, vide order dated 30.03.2024 passed u/s.143(3) of the Act, added the entire sum of Rs.5,59,23,870/- quantified from the 310 Tally for the year as undisclosed income from business, and further

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-7-: added Rs.8,10,414/- being the income from the food court business offered by the assessee at 40% of the receipts of Rs.20,26,034/-, determining the total income at Rs.14,34,94,384/-.

8.

Similar additions were made in the cases of the other two assessees. In the case of M/s. S.T. Retail India Private Limited, the additions for the AYs 2019-20 to 2022-23 aggregated to Rs.18,65,74,055/- on suppressed sales of Rs.43,79,12,295/-, the effective rates ranging from 28.60% to 83.27%.

9.

On appeal, the Ld.CIT(A) did not accept the method adopted by either party. As regards the method of the AO, the Ld.CIT(A) found that the 310 Note Books were available for the full financial year only for the FYs 2016-17 and 2021-22, and for the other years were available only for a few months or not at all, while the 310 Tally was available for the full year only for the FYs 2020-21 and 2021-22, was not available for the FYs 2014-15 to 2018-19 and was only partly available for the FYs 2019-20 and 2022-23. He held that records so incomplete could not form a reliable basis for the undisclosed income of an entire year. He further found that the cash withdrawn under the head “Lot Purchase” had been utilised for diverse purposes, including unaccounted purchases, business expenses, investments and personal expenditure, and that on some occasions amounts had been returned to the business and recorded as “Lot Income”, so that the entire “Lot Purchase” amount could not be equated with income. As regards the 17% NP offered by the assessees, the Ld.CIT(A) held that a uniform rate could not be applied mechanically across all years without examining the actual trading results.

10.

The Ld.CIT(A) set up a camp office at the office of the AO at Coimbatore and examined the seized SS Retail and SS Posting databases, the 310 records, the statements recorded and the findings of the post-search investigation, taking the database of M/s.Karur Shiva Textiles for the AY 2022- 23 for detailed study. In paras 6.2.11 and 6.2.12 of his order, he found that a

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-8-: barcode for an item could be generated only after its inward (purchase) entry was made in the software, so that the purchase details of the items sold were available in the same database. He held that, if the actual sales were taken from the seized database, the purchases recorded in the same database had also to be considered. In paras 6.2.18 to 6.2.25, he reconstructed the trading account of each year by adopting the net sales (exclusive of GST) as per the SS Posting database, the purchases as per the database after certain adjustments, including exclusion of entries identified as “own purchase”, and the opening stock, closing stock and direct expenses as per the returns, and treated the excess of the gross profit so reconstructed over the gross profit returned as the gross profit on the suppressed sales. From this, he allowed (i) unaccounted employee costs, by estimating the total employee costs at 6% of the actual sales and allowing the excess over the amount claimed in the books, and (ii) other unaccounted expenses at 1% of the suppressed sales. He made a further addition of the GST collected on the suppressed sales and retained by the assessees, quantified from the seized database and the GSTR-9 returns. He also disallowed the depreciation claimed on assets acquired out of the unaccounted cash, invoking section 43(1) of the Act, the investments in such assets aggregating to Rs.44,28,74,777/-. Accordingly, in the lead case, the gross profit on the suppressed sales of Rs.10,98,37,268/- was determined at Rs.6,54,14,093/-.

11.

In the lead case, the Ld.CIT(A) reconstructed the trading account for the AY 2022-23 by adopting the sales of Rs.91,28,22,726/- as per the seized database and the purchases of Rs.66,22,27,336/- as per the database, along with the opening stock, closing stock and direct expenses as per the return, and determined the gross profit at Rs.22,25,26,132/- (24.38%) as against the gross profit of Rs.15,71,12,039/- (19.57%) as per the books, the difference of Rs.6,54,14,093/- being treated as the gross profit on the suppressed sales. After allowing the unaccounted employee costs and other expenses of

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-9-: Rs.10,98,373/- at 1% of the suppressed sales, he determined the undisclosed income from the suppressed sales at Rs.1,24,46,357/-. To this he added Rs.64,09,855/- being the GST collected on the suppressed sales and retained by the assessee, quantified by comparing the GST on the sales as per the seized database with the GST payable as per the GSTR-9 return. He thus restricted the addition to Rs.1,88,56,212/- and directed the AO to delete the balance of Rs.3,70,67,658/-. He also held that the assessee was not entitled to the depreciation of Rs.22,02,546/- claimed on the assets acquired in cash, in view of the second proviso to s.43(1) of the Act.

12.

Aggrieved by the orders of the Ld.CIT(A), both the Revenue and the assessees are in appeal before the Tribunal. The grounds of appeal raised by the assessee in the lead case in ITA No.1673/Chny/2026 are as under:

“1. The order of the learned CIT(A)-20 is wrong, illegal and is opposed to law. 2. The learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining additions based on estimations and assumptions which are excessive, arbitrary, and not supported by cogent evidence, thereby resulting in an unjust and inflated determination of taxable income. 3. The learned CIT(A) erred in confirming additions based on selective reliance on materials without granting proper opportunity for reconciliation and without considering the appellant’s detailed submissions in entirety. 4. The learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining additions based on estimations and assumptions which are excessive, arbitrary, and not supported by cogent evidence, thereby resulting in an unjust and inflated determination of taxable income. 5. The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the very existence of parallel records maintained in different forms clearly establishes their inherent unreliability and lack of completeness. It is further submitted that no independent corroborative evidence has been brought on record by the Revenue to establish that the entries contained in such records reflect the true and complete state of affairs. In the absence of proper reconciliation and verification, reliance on such fragmented and inconsistent data is wholly unjustified, rendering the computation of income arbitrary, unsustainable, and liable to be set aside. 6. The learned CIT(A) erred in adopting Gross Profit margins significantly higher than those disclosed in the regular books of account and in comparable years, without assigning any cogent justification. Such adoption results in an unrealistic and excessive estimation of income, rendering the addition arbitrary and unsustainable in law.

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-10-: 7. The learned CIT(A) erred in adopting a taxable Profit computation based on incorrect assumptions relating to purchases, stock, and expenses, without properly appreciating that accurate determination of profit necessarily requires proper consideration of opening stock, purchases, other expenses and closing stock. 8. The learned CIT(A) erred in adopting a Gross Profit-based approach without appreciating that correct determination of profit requires accurate figures of opening stock, purchases, sales, and closing stock. The stock figures adopted were assumed without proper verification, and any error therein directly distorts the GP computation. The methodology adopted is therefore fundamentally flawed and unsustainable. 9. The learned CIT(A) erred in failing to consider material evidence demonstrating discrepancies between physical stock and software records during the course of search, including sworn statements evidencing such mismatches. By mechanically adopting stock figures as per the returns, the learned CIT(A) has ignored crucial evidence on record, resulting in an erroneous and unsustainable determination of income. 10. The learned CIT(A) erred in treating the unaccounted purchase values appearing in SS Retail/software as actual cost, without appreciating that such entries are merely notional and randomly entered. Instances clearly demonstrate that purchase costs are recorded at unrealistic figures such as Rs.0.01 for a product which was sold for Rs. 120, and the staff entering such data are not privy to the actual cost of purchases as all unaccounted purchases are handled by the partners directly. 11. The learned CIT(A) erred in relying on purchase entries relating to unaccounted transactions, without appreciating that such purchases lack invoices and verifiable details, and that costs are randomly entered, with even the appellant’s name used as a placeholder supplier. Reliance on such artificial and unreliable entries is legally untenable and renders the addition unsustainable 12. The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that unaccounted purchases are made without invoices and that no reliable or verifiable cost data exists in respect thereof. The entries recorded in the software are merely placeholders and do not reflect the actual cost of purchases. Consequently, any computation based on such artificial and unreliable entries results in distorted and inflated estimation of profit, rendering the addition unsustainable in law. 13. The learned CIT(A) erred in law and on facts in treating “lot purchase” entries as indicative of income or unexplained expenditure, without appreciating that such entries merely represent application of cash generated from suppressed sales already considered in the computation of income. 14. The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that these records are summary in nature, devoid of item-wise details or supporting particulars, and do not constitute independent sources of income. The impugned treatment results in double taxation of the same income and is therefore arbitrary, unsustainable, and liable to be deleted.

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-11-: 15. The learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining the estimation of salary at 6% and other expenses at 1% of suppressed sales, which is wholly arbitrary and without any empirical basis. 16. The learned CIT(A) failed to consider the actual data evidencing higher employee expenses and instead adopted an arbitrary estimation without any cogent basis, resulting in an incorrect and inflated computation of income. The disallowance is therefore unsustainable in law. 17. The learned CIT(A) erred in law and on facts in restricting the allowance of employee benefit expenses to 6% of total sales on an ad hoc basis, without appreciating that complete and detailed records of such expenses were available in the seized material, namely the 310 Notebooks and 310 Tally, which have also been acknowledged in the appellate order. 18. The learned CIT(A) failed to see that ad hoc estimation of expense disregards business realities, scale of operations, number of employees, and substantial showroom overheads. Such arbitrary restriction of expenses results in artificial inflation of profits and is contrary to settled principles of law. 19. The learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining the estimation of employee expenses at 6% of suppressed sales, without appreciating that actual data reflects significantly higher ratios. The comparative analysis demonstrates that such expenses range between 10% to 12%. The estimation of 6% adopted is therefore arbitrary and results in an inflated computation of income, rendering the addition unsustainable. 20. The learned CIT(A) erred in not considering comparable industry data, which demonstrates that salary ratios typically range from 10% to 12% or higher, with substantial variation depending on the scale and nature of operations. The failure to consider such relevant benchmarks renders the estimation arbitrary and unsustainable. 21. The learned CIT(A) further erred in restricting other expenses to 1% of suppressed sales, without appreciating that actual data demonstrates such expenses to be in the range of 4% to 10%. The learned CIT(A) failed to consider the nature of the retail textile business, which inherently involves substantial overheads and even in the accounted business other expenses range between 4% to 10%. The estimation adopted is therefore unrealistic, contrary to the evidence on record, and unsustainable in law. 22. The learned CIT(A) erred in failing to consider expense ratios from subsequent years (post-search) where complete and reliable accounting data is available, which clearly demonstrate that employee and other expenses are significantly higher than the estimates adopted. Such evidence constitutes the most reliable benchmark for determining true profitability and ought to have been duly considered; failure to do so renders the estimation arbitrary and unsustainable. 23. The learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of GST collected on suppressed sales as income. In the present case, the assessee has also made unaccounted purchases as evident from the seized software. On such purchases, GST would have been paid to suppliers, giving rise to eligible ITC. Since these purchases were unaccounted, the assessee has not claimed the corresponding

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-12-: ITC in the regular GST returns. By adding the entire GST collected on suppressed sales as income without allowing adjustment for ITC on unaccounted purchases, the AO has effectively taxed a gross figure, ignoring the net tax mechanism inherent in GST. 24. The learned CIT(A) erred in observing that the appellant had not furnished working or details in respect of investments and depreciation, without appreciating that the relevant financial statements, seized materials, and supporting details were already submitted during investigation proceedings itself. 25. The learned CIT(A) erred in disallowing the claim of depreciation on assets acquired out of undisclosed income solely on the ground of mode of payment, without appreciating that the existence and use of such assets for business purposes are not in dispute. The learned CIT(A) failed to consider that the provisions of section 40A(3) and the second proviso to section 43(1) ought to be interpreted in a manner that does not deny legitimate depreciation on genuine assets, and therefore the disallowance is unsustainable in law. 26. The learned CIT(A) erred in denying depreciation on assets acquired out of undisclosed income without appreciating that the existence and use of such assets for business purposes are not in dispute and that depreciation is a statutory allowance under section 32 of the Act. The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the mode of payment alone cannot disentitle the claim of depreciation when the genuineness of the assets is accepted, and therefore the disallowance is unsustainable in law.” 13. [The grounds of appeal raised by the Revenue in its cross appeal for the AY 2022-23 in the case of M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles may be inserted here.] In substance, the revenue contended that the Ld.CIT(A) erred in rejecting the computation made by the AO on the basis of the seized 310 Note Books, 310 Tally and the “Lot Purchase” records, in allowing the benefit of unaccounted purchases without any correlation of such purchases with the suppressed sales, in reducing the additions on the basis of estimated expenditure, and in recording findings on unaccounted purchases without affording an opportunity to the AO. The grounds of appeal raised by the assessees, in substance, contend that the Ld.CIT(A) erred in computing the income on the suppressed sales on the basis of purchase values in the seized database which were nominal or notional, resulting in commercially implausible gross profit rates; in not accepting the NP of 17% offered on the suppressed sales; in omitting, in the case of M/s. S.T. Retail India Private Limited for the AY 2021-22, the purchases recorded in the SAP software for certain branches; in making a separate addition of the GST component of the

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-13-: suppressed sales; and in disallowing the depreciation claimed on the assets acquired.

14.

The ld.DR, appearing for the Revenue, relied on the orders of the AO and the written submissions filed. The ld.DR submitted that the seized 310 Note Books and 310 Tally are contemporaneous records of the cash generated from the suppressed sales and its utilisation, and that the Ld.CIT(A) ought not to have discarded them. It was submitted that, though the Ld.CIT(A), on examining the seized material at the camp office, found evidence of unaccounted purchases, there was no correlation between any particular unaccounted purchase and the suppressed sales, and the assessees had neither maintained separate books for their unaccounted transactions nor discharged the burden of establishing that the unaccounted purchases were utilised to effect the suppressed sales. It was further submitted that the seized database did not contain the year-end closing stock, that the assessees themselves had offered income at 17% of the suppressed sales, and that the Ld.CIT(A) had recorded findings on unaccounted purchases without giving the AO an opportunity to rebut them. The ld.DR placed reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of Smt.N.Saroja v. ACIT on the evidentiary value of contemporaneous seized records, on the presumptions u/s.132(4A) and 292C of the Act, and on the decision in B.Kishore Kumar v. DCIT, [2015] 62 taxmann.com 215 (SC), on the evidentiary value of admissions made in the course of search, and prayed that the additions made by the AO be restored.

15.

Per contra, the ld.AR for the assessees, relying on the written submissions filed by the assessee, submitted that the existence and quantum of the suppressed sales are not in dispute, and the only question is the quantum of income embedded in them. It was submitted that the entries described as “Lot Purchase” only represent cash withdrawn from the sales collections, which was deployed for purchases, expenses, investments and

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-14-: other purposes and was at times returned to the business, so that the movement of cash cannot be equated with income; that the method of the AO resulted in effective profit rates of 30% to 57%, which bear no relation to the trading results of the business; that the presumptions u/s.132(4A) and 292C relate to the ownership and the truth of the contents of the seized material and not to the character of each entry as income; that the decision in N.Saroja (supra) concerned the evidentiary value of loose sheets, which is not in dispute, and B.Kishore Kumar (supra) concerned a categorical admission of undisclosed income, whereas the assessees have admitted only the suppressed sales; and that the Ld.CIT(A), having examined only the seized material already available with the AO, in exercise of his powers u/s.250(4) of the Act, did not violate any principle of natural justice. Reliance was placed on the decisions of the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in CIT v. President Industries (2002) 258 ITR 654 (Guj) and CIT v. Samir Synthetics Mill (2010) 326 ITR 410 (Guj).

16.

In support of the assessees’ appeals, the ld.AR submitted that, while the method of the Ld.CIT(A) is more balanced than that of the AO, the purchase values entered in the SS Retail software against many items were nominal or notional values entered only to generate barcodes, and not the actual cost of the goods, and the typed set titled “Extract of Data from Seized Material (SS Software) from Meghna Silks, Musiri” dated 23.09.2026 was relied on to show instances where the apparent margins run into several hundred per cent. It was submitted that, as a result, the gross profit determined by the Ld.CIT(A) on the suppressed sales ranges from 29.57% to 79.18% in the case of M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles (59.56% in the lead case, as against 19.57% in the regular books), from 22.24% to 56.20% in the case of M/s.Kulithalai Shiva Textiles, and reaches 1557.11% in the case of M/s.S.T. Retail India Private Limited for the AY 2021-22, where the additional gross profit of Rs.10,40,96,700/- far exceeds the suppressed sales of Rs.66,85,229/-

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-15-: , on account of the omission of the purchases recorded in the SAP software for the Salem, Simla Division and Ooty branches. The ld.AR contended that the NP of 17% offered, which is well above the NP of 4.76% to 10.80% disclosed in the regular books, is a reasonable measure of the income from the suppressed sales, and relied on the orders of the Chennai Benches of the Tribunal in Gunasekaran Mannar v. ACIT (ITA Nos.1855 to 1858, 1863 & 1864/Chny/2025, order dated 22.01.2026), K V Tex Firm v. ACIT (ITA Nos.1859, 1860 & 1865/Chny/2025, order dated 04.02.2026) and New Saravana Stores Bramandamai v. DCIT (ITA Nos.1611 to 1615/Chny/2023, order dated 06.08.2024). In the alternative, it was prayed that the matter be remitted for verification of the actual purchase values. It was further submitted that, the NP having been estimated on the entire suppressed sales, the GST component of those very sales stands subsumed and cannot be added separately; and that depreciation, being a statutory allowance on assets genuinely acquired and used for business, as explained in Mysore Minerals Ltd. v. CIT (1999) 239 ITR 775 (SC) and ICDS Ltd. v. CIT (2013) 350 ITR 527 (SC), ought to be allowed.

17.

We have heard the rival submissions, perused the orders of the authorities below and carefully examined the material available on record. It is not in dispute that the assessees suppressed sales, and the quantum of the suppressed sales determined from the seized SS Posting database is accepted by both sides. The common question in these appeals is the quantum of income to be assessed in respect of the suppressed sales. Three methods are before us: the method of the AO, who treated the cash recorded in the 310 Note Books, 310 Tally and the “Lot Purchase” records as income; the method of the Ld.CIT(A), who reconstructed the trading results from the sales and purchases in the seized database; and the NP of 17% on the suppressed sales offered by the assessees. The subsidiary questions are the separate addition of GST and the disallowance of depreciation. We shall first

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-16-: take up the appeals of the Revenue, which seek restoration of the method of the AO.

18.

The suppressed sales represent turnover, and not income. Sale proceeds necessarily comprise the cost of the goods sold and the expenses incurred in effecting the sales, and it is only the profit element embedded in them that can be brought to tax, unless it is found that the cost of the goods sold was itself an undisclosed investment. The Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in CIT v. President Industries (2002) 258 ITR 654 (Guj) has held, on this reasoning, that the entire amount of undisclosed sales cannot be treated as income in the absence of a finding that the corresponding purchases were themselves made out of undisclosed funds. In the present case, there is no such finding; on the contrary, the Ld.CIT(A), on examining the seized material, has found that the material evidences unaccounted purchases as well, which the Revenue itself acknowledges in its written submissions.

19.

The method of the AO does not measure the profit embedded in the suppressed sales at all. The entries in the 310 records described as “Lot Purchase” and the like record cash taken out of the sales collections. The Ld.CIT(A) has found, on examination of the seized material and the statements, that such cash was applied for various purposes, including unaccounted purchases of stock, business expenses, investments and personal expenditure, and that some of it returned to the business as “Lot Income”. The application of cash is not the same thing as the earning of income; the sum withdrawn in a year may include the cost of goods and expenses as much as the profit. More fundamentally, the 310 records are admittedly incomplete, being available for the full year only in some years and for some months or not at all in others, so that the cash recorded in them can neither be a measure of the whole year’s income where it is used, nor a basis where it is absent. The result of the method, effective profit rates of 30% to 57% of the suppressed sales in the lead assessee and up to 83% in M/s. S.T.

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-17-: Retail India Private Limited, as against NP rates of about 5% to 11% in the regular books of the same business, shows that what has been taxed is the movement of cash and not the profit on the suppressed sales.

20.

We do not find merit in the reliance placed by the Revenue on the presumptions u/s.132(4A) and 292C of the Act and on the decisions cited. The presumptions relate to the ownership of the seized material and the truth of its contents. The assessees do not dispute that the 310 records belong to them or that the entries in them are true. The question is not whether the cash movements recorded are true, but whether they represent income, and that is not answered by the presumptions. The decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in N. Saroja (supra), as we understand it, concerns the evidentiary value of contemporaneous loose sheets found in the course of search; here, the evidentiary value of the seized records is not in dispute. Likewise, the principle that an admission made in the course of search is good evidence, on which B.Kishore Kumar (supra) is relied upon, does not assist the Revenue, since what the assessees have admitted is the suppression of sales, and not that the cash withdrawn under the description “Lot Purchase” is their income. As regards the alleged violation of natural justice, the Ld.CIT(A), whose powers are co-terminous with those of the AO u/s.250(4) and 251 of the Act, examined at the office of the AO the very seized material on which the AO had based the assessments. No fresh material was obtained behind the back of the Revenue, and the Revenue has had full opportunity to meet the findings before us. We, therefore, uphold the finding of the Ld.CIT(A) that the method of the AO cannot be sustained. The grounds raised by the Revenue on this issue are dismissed.

21.

Coming to the method of the Ld.CIT(A), we agree with him in principle that, the suppressed sales having been taken from the seized database, the purchases recorded in the same database cannot be ignored, and that the income from the suppressed sales has to be ascertained after accounting for

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-18-: the cost of the goods sold and the expenses incurred. The soundness of the result of such a reconstruction, however, depends entirely on the reliability of the purchase values in the database. The barcode mechanism noted by the Ld.CIT(A) in paras 6.2.11 and 6.2.12 of his order establishes that an inward entry had to be made in the software before an item could be billed; it does not establish that the value entered against each item was its actual cost. The results of the reconstruction show that the purchase values are not reliable as a measure of cost. In the lead case, the gross profit attributed to the suppressed sales is 59.56%, three times the GP of 19.57% in the regular books of the same year; in the case of M/s.Karur Shiva Textiles it rises to 79.18% for the AY 2021-22, and in the case of M/s. Kulithalai Shiva Textiles to 56.20% for the AY 2022-23, as against regular GP of about 20%. In the case of M/s.S.T.Retail India Private Limited for the AY 2021-22, the additional gross profit of Rs.10,40,96,700/- exceeds the suppressed sales of Rs.66,85,229/- itself many times over, which is an impossible result and is explained by the omission of the purchases recorded in the SAP software for certain branches. No material has been brought on record by the Revenue to show that the same goods, sold across the same counters to the same class of customers, yielded a margin two or three times higher merely because the sales were not recorded in the books. Further, the database does not contain the year-end stock, and the Ld.CIT(A) has had to adopt the stock as per the returns, which relate only to the accounted business. The reconstruction, therefore, though more balanced than the method of the AO, does not yield a reliable measure of the real income from the suppressed sales.

22.

The alternative prayer of the assessees is to remit the matter for verification of the actual purchase values. We do not consider this to be a fruitful course. The issue covers seven assessment years and three assessees, and the verification would require the actual cost of individual items sold several years ago to be ascertained, when the very database from

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-19-: which it would have to be ascertained is shown to be unreliable on that point. Such an exercise is unlikely to produce a better result than a reasonable estimate. Where the income from suppressed sales cannot be ascertained with precision, it has tobe estimated on a fair and reasonable basis having regard to the trading results of the business. The assessees have themselves declared, and discharged tax on, income at 17% of the suppressed sales by way of net profit. This rate is higher than the NP disclosed in the regular books in every year for every assessee, which ranges from 4.76% to 10.80%, and is of the same order as the GP of the regular business of the two firms. The rate of 17% was not one thrust upon the assessees, but one adopted by them in their returns and computations filed after the search, and the Revenue itself relies on that offer. In the lead case, the income at 17% of the suppressed sales works out to Rs.1,86,72,336/-, which is broadly in line with the income of Rs.1,88,56,212/- determined by the Ld.CIT(A) after his detailed examination of the seized material, inclusive of the GST component, and bears a reasonable relation to the trading results of the business, unlike the income of Rs.5,59,23,870/- determined by the AO. In our considered view, 17% of the suppressed sales is a fair and reasonable estimate of the net income earned on the suppressed sales, and is preferable both to the cash-based method of the AO and to a reconstruction founded on unreliable purchase values.

23.

The rate of 17% so adopted is a rate of net profit. It represents the income from the suppressed sales after meeting the cost of the goods sold and all the expenses incurred in effecting those sales, including the salary, wages, bonus and other expenses paid in cash out of the unaccounted collections. Once the income is estimated at a net rate on the entire suppressed sales, no further deduction can be allowed on account of the unaccounted employee costs or other business expenditure, since such expenditure stands subsumed in the net profit so estimated; to allow it again would amount to a double deduction. The allowances of the unaccounted

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-20-: employee costs at 6% of the total sales and of the other expenses at 1% of the suppressed sales, made by the Ld.CIT(A) as part of his reconstruction of the trading results, therefore, do not survive independently once the income is estimated at 17% of the suppressed sales. For the same reason, the grounds of the assessees seeking a higher allowance of such expenditure, and the grounds of the Revenue against the allowance of such expenditure by the Ld.CIT(A), do not require separate adjudication.

24.

Accordingly, we direct the AO to determine the income from the suppressed sales of each assessee for each year at 17% of the suppressed sales as determined from the seized database and accepted by the assessees, without any further deduction on account of unaccounted employee costs, other business expenditure or depreciation. The method adopted by the AO and the reconstruction made by the Ld.CIT(A) are substituted accordingly. The grounds of the assessees on this issue are partly allowed, and the corresponding grounds of the Revenue are dismissed.

25.

As regards the separate addition of GST, the Ld.CIT(A) has found that GST was collected from customers on the suppressed sales and was not remitted to the Government. The income from the suppressed sales has now been estimated at 17% of the suppressed sales as a whole. The GST component is part of the very same receipts from the same transactions, and the net profit estimated on those receipts takes into account the entire benefit derived by the assessees from them. The GST component thus stands subsumed in the net profit so estimated, and a separate addition of it, over and above the income estimated on the same sales, would amount to taxing the same receipts twice. We, therefore, direct the AO to delete the separate addition made on account of GST. The grounds of the assessees on this issue are allowed.

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-21-: 26. As regards depreciation, the Ld.CIT(A) has found that the assets on which depreciation was claimed in the returns filed in response to the notices u/s.148 of the Act were acquired out of the cash generated from the suppressed sales, and that finding is not disputed; indeed, the case of the assessees is that the consideration for such assets was paid in cash. The depreciation claimed by the assessees in the returns filed in response to the notices u/s.148 of the Act, which has been disallowed by the Ld.CIT(A) and is deducted by the assessees from the income offered at 17% of the suppressed sales, is as under: Asst. Year Karur Shiva Textiles Kulithalai Shiva S.T. Retail India Pvt. (Rs.) Textiles (Rs.) Ltd. (Rs.) 2018-19 8,44,623 11,37,146 4,33,902 2019-20 23,08,627 10,23,432 35,61,142 2020-21 25,53,379 10,09,026 35,53,658 2021-22 24,47,274 9,54,135 1,85,45,895 2022-23 22,02,546 10,50,911 2,79,36,922 Total 1,03,56,449 51,74,650 5,40,31,518

27.

The second proviso to section 43(1) of the Act, inserted by the Finance Act, 2017 with effect from 01.04.2018, provides that where an assessee incurs any expenditure for acquiring an asset in respect of which a payment, or aggregate of payments, made to a person in a day otherwise than by an account payee cheque drawn on a bank or an account payee bank draft or by use of the electronic clearing system through a bank account or through such other electronic mode as may be prescribed, exceeds ten thousand rupees, such expenditure shall be ignored for the purposes of determination of the actual cost. The depreciation in dispute is claimed only from the AY 2018-19 onwards, to which the proviso applies. The cost of the assets having been met in cash, it is to be ignored in determining their actual cost, and there remains no actual cost on which depreciation can be allowed u/s.32 of the Act. The decisions in Mysore Minerals Ltd. (supra) and ICDS Ltd. (supra) on ownership and use of the asset do not dilute the statutory restriction on the actual cost;

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-22-: the ld.AR himself has fairly accepted that section 32 of the Act does not override the second proviso to section 43(1) of the Act. We, therefore, uphold the disallowance of depreciation made by the Ld.CIT(A). The grounds of the assessees on this issue are dismissed. Consequently, the income from the suppressed sales in each year shall be the income at 17% of the suppressed sales, without deduction of the depreciation claimed on such assets.

28.

Applying the above directions to the lead case, the income of M/s. Karur Shiva Textiles from the suppressed sales for the AY 2022-23 is determined as under: Particulars Amount (Rs.) Suppressed sales as per the seized database 10,98,37,268 Income at 17% net profit on the suppressed sales 1,86,72,336 Nil Less: Depreciation claimed on assets acquired in cash (disallowed) Income from the suppressed sales to be assessed 1,86,72,336 Addition by the AO 5,59,23,870 1,88,56,212 Addition as restricted by the Ld.CIT(A) (incl. GST of Rs.64,09,855)

29.

The AO shall, accordingly, assess the income from the suppressed sales in the lead case at Rs.1,86,72,336/- in place of the addition of Rs.5,59,23,870/- made by him and the sum of Rs.1,88,56,212/- determined by the Ld.CIT(A). The addition of Rs.8,10,414/- on account of the income from the food court business, which was offered by the assessee and has not been disputed before us, stands. The income from the suppressed sales in the other appeals shall be determined in the same manner, at 17% of the suppressed sales of the respective years, without deduction of depreciation.

30.

The grounds relating to the levy of interest are consequential in nature, and the AO shall recompute the interest, if any, while giving effect to this order. The remaining grounds of both parties are either general in nature or not pressed, and require no separate adjudication. The AO shall give effect to

ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 and ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 :-23-: this order in each of the appeals in accordance with the above directions, after affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the assessees. 31. In the result, the appeals of the Revenue in ITA Nos.2517, 2525, 2662 to 2664, 2685, 3032 to 3034 & 3159 to 3161/Chny/2026 are dismissed, and the appeals of the assessees in ITA Nos.1648, 1651 to 1656, 1668 to 1673, 1676, 1680 to 1682 & 4037 to 4039/Chny/2026 are partly allowed. Order pronounced in the court on 30th October, 2026 at Chennai. Sd/- Sd/- (मनुकुमारिग�र) (एस.आर.रघुनाथा) (MANU KUMAR GIRI) (S. R. RAGHUNATHA) �या�यकसद&य/Judicial Member लेखासद&य/Accountant Member चे�नई/Chennai, .दनांक/Dated, 30th October, 2026. SANDE Digitally signed Devdas/ SNDP Sr. Ps by SANDEEP EP आदेशक#��त0ल1पअ2े1षत/Copy to: KUMAR Date: 2026.11.06 1. अपीलाथ�/Appellant KUMAR 09:44:57 +05'30' 2. ��यथ�/Respondent 3.आयकरआयु3त/CIT– Chennai/Coimbatore/Madurai/Salem 4. 1वभागीय��त�न�ध/DR 5. गाड फाईल/GF

More judgments on Section 132

All 16,113 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →