CUTLER HAMMER PROVIDENT FUND TRUST vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER

PDF · subscribers
CWP/28224/2022HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01136083202229 August 2024Author: MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA,MR. JUSTICE SANJAY VASHISTH6 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court considered the submissions and noted that the petitioner had knowledge of filing the return in the wrong format. It was also observed that the petitioner had filed the return in ITR Form 7, which was later revised and filed under Form No. 5. The Court acknowledged that the petitioner had himself corrected his return. Therefore, the Court found no occasion for the petitioner to raise the question regarding the defective ITR for AY 2013-14. However, the Court directed that the petitioner had a remedy in terms of Section 154 of the Act for seeking necessary rectifications. If an application is moved by the petitioner, the respondent shall decide the same on merits and allow the petitioner to file a fresh return, if required, to correct his return. No further adjudication was required by the Court at that stage.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Cutler Hammer Provident Fund Trust, filed a writ petition challenging a penalty notice dated July 18, 2022, issued under Section 221(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for the Assessment Year (AY) 2013-14. The petitioner contended that the demand of Rs. 68,36,280/- arose due to filing the return in the wrong ITR form (Form 7) and section, which was later corrected. The respondent, Income Tax Officer, stated that the return for AY 2013-14 was processed under Section 143(1) on March 17, 2015, creating a demand. The petitioner had filed ITR Form 7, which was declared invalid by the CPC, leading to the demand. The petitioner later filed ITR Form 5, which was processed. The respondent argued that the petitioner had not availed the remedy of appeal under Section 249 of the Act and had not been given a fair opportunity. The petitioner argued that Section 154 of the Act provides for rectification of mistakes.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the demand of Rs. 68,36,280/- raised against the petitioner for AY 2013-14 is erroneous, considering the petitioner filed the return in the wrong ITR form and section, which was subsequently corrected. Assessee's Contention: The petitioner argued that the demand arose due to a procedural error in filing the return in the wrong ITR form (Form 7) and section. They contended that this mistake was later rectified by filing the correct ITR Form 5, which was processed. The petitioner relied on Section 154 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which allows for rectification of mistakes. Revenue's Contention: The respondent argued that the petitioner had not availed the remedy of appeal under Section 249 of the Act and had not been given a fair opportunity to correct the return. They also stated that the return was processed under Section 143(1) and the claim for exemption was rejected by the system due to the wrong ITR form.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 221(1),Section 139(4A),Section 143(1),Section 249,Section 154,Section 156,Section 143(3),Section 186,Section 241

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

107+226

IN TH CUTLER HA INCOME TA CORAM: H

H Present:

SANJEEV P

CM-5739-CW

to R3 and seek

R Main case 1. The wr penalty

Page 1 of 6 HE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA CHANDIGAR

AMMER PROVIDENT FUND T Vs.

AX OFFICER HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN Mr. Samarvir Singh, Advocate w Mr. Agam Bansal, Advocate Ms. Suparna Jain Singh, Advoca Mr. Anshul, Advocate Mr. Jivesh Malik, Advocate for the petitioner. Mr. Varun Issar, Sr. Standing Co for the respondent. RAKASH SHARMA, J.(Oral) WP-2024 Application for placing on record king exemption from filing certi Registry to place the same at app

rit petition has been preferred y notice dated 18.07.2022 passe AB AND HARYANA AT RH CM-5739-CWP-2024 in/and CWP-28224-2022 (O&M) Date of Decision: 29.08.2024 TRUST . . . . Petitioner . . . . Respondent NJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA NJAY VASHISTH with ate ounsel ) d reply along with Annexure R1 ified copy thereof is allowed. propriate place. by the petitioner assailing the ed under Section 221(1) of the

Income account 2. Notice respond

F c fo sy P

Page 2 of 6 e Tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘th t of filing wrong return for the A was issued by this Court where dent, and it is stated by the respo “2. That the contents of Pa are wrong and denied. It is submitt ncome for the assessment year 30.03.2014. Further, the case was he Income Tax Act, 1961, on demand of Rs. 68,36,280/-. If we go he case then it is noticed that the Form 7 u/s 139(4A) due to which hi he same is filed in wrong ITR for not applicable in the case of the regarding the defective ITR is sent he assessee as seen from the CPC Tax Department. The screenshot of Annexure R-1. Since the Petitioner centralised processing centre (her he same return has been transferr assessing officer i.e. office of the u The ITR has been processed by Assessing officer but as the same is form and section the system do exemption of the Petitioner and Therefore, the claim of the exemp system due to filing wrong ITR fo also. The Processing sheet/intimati respondent is attached as annexure The above mistake has a Petitioner in the Assessment Yea again filed the ITR Form 7 under s same got declared invalid by th he Act’) imposing penalty on AY 2013-14. after reply has been filed by the ondent as under: ara No. 2 of the petition ted herein that return of 2013-14 was filed on processed u/s 143(1) of 17.03.2015, creating a o into the background of Petitioner has filed ITR is return got defective as rm and section which is assesee. The intimation t by CPC- Bangalore to 2.0 portal of the Income f the CPC 2.0 is attached does not respond to the reinafter refer as CPC) red to the Jurisdictional undersigned respondent. the then Jurisdictional s filed under wrong ITR does not taken up the a demand is created. ption is rejected by the form and Wrong section ion as available with the R-2. again repeated by the ar 2014-15 wherein he section 139(4A) and the he CPC and when the

P is q

c I 3. The re circumv 154 of provide 4. Faced submits demand with a f the Ac accordi 5. We hav as unde fr

Page 3 of 6 Petitioner receive mail from CP return, he revised the same and fil he same got processed. The scre module of the Income Tax Depart above stated fact is attached as ann s clear that there is mistake from th Assessment Year 2013-14 due to question was raised. The petitioner further stated 143(3) and section 156. Both of this case of the assesee as per proce Income Tax Act, 1961.”

espondent has further objec vented the remedy available to f the Act, and also has not av ed under Section 249 of the Act. with the said objections, learn s that the respondent has not g d of Rs.68,36,280/- by way of fresh notice to be given to the pe ct, so that the petitioner may ingly. ve considered the submissions. S er: “154. Rectification of mistak - [(1) With a view to rectifyin from the record an income-tax a section 116 may,- PC regarding defective led ITR Form No. 5 and eenshot of the CPC 2.0 tment substantiating the nexure R-3. Therefore, it he petitioner side for the which the demand in d about the intimation u/s s is not applicable in the edure laid down in the cted that the petitioner has him as enshrined under Section vailed the remedy of appeal as ned counsel for the petitioner given him fair opportunity. The penalty ought to be withdrawn etitioner under Section 143(1) of be able to correct his return Section 154 of the Act provides ke. ng any mistake apparent authority referred to in

p u

o [ ( b [

Page 4 of 6 (a) amend any order pa provisions of this Act;] (b) [ amend any intimation under sub-section (1) of section 14 27 of 1999, Section 65, for Clause ( (d) [ amend any intimation section 206CB.] [Inserted by Finan 2015), dated 14.5.2015.] [(1-A) Where any matter ha decided in any proceeding by way relating to an order referred to authority passing such order anything contained in any law for amend the order under that sub-se matter other than the matter which and decided.] [ Inserted by Act 31 o 6.10.1964).] (2) Subject to the other pro he authority concerned- (a) may make an amendmen of its own motion, and (b) shall make such amend such mistake which has been brou assessee, and where the authority c [ Certain words omitted by Act 2 (w.e.f. 1.10.1998).] [Commissioner by Act 29 of 1977, Section 29 (w. [Assessing Officer] [ Substituted by 2, for " Income-tax Officer" (w.e.f. 1 [ *] [ Proviso omitted by 38 (w.e.f. 1.6.1994).] (3) An amendment, whic enhancing an assessment or reducin ncreasing the liability of the asses under this section unless the author assed by it under the n or deemed intimation 43.] [ Substituted by Act (b) (w.e.f. 1.6.1999).] under sub-section (1) of nce Act, 2015 (No. 20 of as been considered and y of appeal or revision in sub-section (1), the may, notwithstanding the time being in force, ection in relation to any h has been so considered of 1964, Section 7 (w.e.f. ovisions of this section, nt under sub-section (1) dment for rectifying any ught to its notice by the concerned is the [ *] 21 of 1998, Section 65 r (Appeals)] [ Inserted e.f. 10.7.1978).], by the y Act 4 of 1988, Section 1.4.1988).] also. y Act 32 of 1994, Section ch has the effect of ng a refund or otherwise ssee, shall not be made rity concerned has given

h o

b S J p

Page 5 of 6 notice to the assessee of its inten allowed the assessee a reasonabl heard. (4) Where an amendment is m an order shall be passed in wri authority concerned. (5) Subject to the provision any such amendment has the e assessment, the [Assessing Officer] of 1988, Section 2, for " Inco 1.4.1988).] shall make any refund such assessee. (6) Where any such amend enhancing the assessment or redu made, the [Assessing Officer] [S 1988, Section 2, for " Incom 1.4.1988).] shall serve on the asses n the prescribed form specifying such notice of demand shall be dee section 156 and the provisions o accordingly. (7) Save as otherwise prov sub-section (4) of section 186, no section shall be made after the exp he end of the financial year in wh be amended was passed] [ Substitu Section 29, for " from the date of amended" (w.e.f. 1.10.1984).]. (8) [ Without prejudice to section (7), where an application fo section is made by the assessee on June, 2001 to an income-tax autho section (1), the authority shall p period of six months from the end of application is received by it,- ntion so to do and has le opportunity of being made under this section, ting by the income-tax ns of section 241, where effect of reducing the ] [ Substituted by Act 4 me-tax Officer" (w.e.f. d which may be due to dment has the effect of ucing a refund already Substituted by Act 4 of me-tax Officer" (w.e.f. ssee a notice of demand g the sum payable, and emed to be issued under of this Act shall apply vided in section 155 or o amendment under this piry of four years [from hich the order sought to uted by Act 67 of 1984, f the order sought to be the provisions of sub- or amendment under this n or after the 1st day of ority referred to in sub- pass an order, within a of the month in which the

6.

Keepin petition wrong in the I filed un ITR fo petition 7. Be that the Ac applica same on return. 8. No furt is accor 9. All pen

August 29, 202 Mohit goyal 1. Whethe 2. Whethe

Page 6 of 6 (a) making the amendment; (b) refusing to allow the clai

ng in view the provisions as ner was having full knowledge format. More so, as he had also ITR Form 7, which was later o nder Form No.5 subsequently. O r the subsequent AY 2014-15, ner not to correct his ITR for AY t as it may, the petitioner has rem ct as above for seeking neces ation is moved by the petitioner, n the basis as above, and allow t ther adjudication is required by rdingly dismissed in aforesaid te nding applications also stand disp

(SANJ

r speaking/reasoned?

Y r reportable?

Y or im.]” above, it is apparent that the e of having filed return in the filed return for the AY 2014-15 on revised by him and ITR was Once he has himself corrected his there was no occasion for the Y 2013-14. medy in terms of Section 154 of ssary rectifications. If such an the respondent shall decide the the petitioner, if required, to file this Court at this stage. Petition erms. posed of accordingly. JEEV PRAKASH SHARMA) JUDGE

(SANJAY VASHISTH) JUDGE Yes/No Yes/No

More judgments on Section 221(1)

All 207 judgments and leading authorities on Section 221(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →