FATEHSINH MOHANSINH CHAUHAN,SILVASSA vs. ACIT, VAPI CIRCLE, VAPI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 540/SRT/2025Status: DisposedITAT Surat04 November 2026AY 2016-179 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the rental income earned by the assessee from industrial buildings, which are part of stock-in-trade, is assessable under the head 'Income from House Property', as declared by the assessee, and not under the head 'Income from Business or Profession'. The reasoning was that while the assessee is in the business of dealing in lands and construction, there was no finding that the assessee is in the business of letting out properties. The fact that properties are stock-in-trade does not automatically convert rental receipts into business income. The Tribunal also found force in the assessee's submission regarding Section 23(5), which deals with stock-in-trade properties and implies they are taxable under 'Income from House Property'. The Tribunal directed the AO to recompute the income under 'Income from House Property', allowing admissible deductions and granting consequential relief. The Tribunal noted that the AO should ensure no deduction is allowed twice. The issue of disallowance of taxes and standard deduction (Grounds 2 and 3) were implicitly allowed as they were connected to the primary issue which was decided in favour of the assessee.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan, filed his return for AY 2016-17 declaring Rs. 24,07,090. The AO completed assessment at Rs. 1,07,49,980, re-characterizing the assessee's declared rental income of Rs. 1,90,23,397 from 'Income from House Property' to 'Income from Business or Profession'. The assessee is engaged in the business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings, and the rental income was from industrial buildings held as stock-in-trade. The assessee's appeal to the CIT(A) was unsuccessful. The assessee then appealed to the ITAT. Ground 4 concerning video conferencing was dismissed as not pressed.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the rental income earned by the assessee from industrial buildings, which are part of stock-in-trade, is taxable under the head 'Income from House Property' (as argued by the assessee) or 'Income from Business or Profession' (as argued by the revenue), turning on the interpretation of Sections 22 and 23(5) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. 2. Whether the disallowance of Rs. 1,63,750 claimed as deduction for taxes paid to a local authority for rental property is justified. 3. Whether the disallowance of standard deduction of Rs. 81,52,885 under Section 24 of the Act is justified. Assessee's contentions: The rental income is rightly offered under 'Income from House Property' based on Sections 22 and 23(5). Section 23(5) specifically deals with stock-in-trade properties. Decisions relied on: Chennai Properties and Investments Ltd. (SC), Rayala Corporation (P) Ltd. (SC), Principal Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Noor Resorts (P) Ltd. (HP) are distinguishable as they apply to businesses of letting out properties. Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. New India Industries Ltd. (Guj) supports the assessee's claim. Grounds 2 and 3 are connected to the primary issue of income head classification. Revenue's contentions: The lower authorities' orders are supported. The industrial buildings were stock-in-trade in the business of dealing in lands and construction. Interest and other expenses associated with properties were claimed as deductions in computing 'Income from Business or Profession', justifying the re-characterization.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 142(1),Section 143(2),Section 22,Section 23(5),Section 24,Section 28

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, SURAT BENCH, SURAT

Before: MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE & SHRI B.M. BIYANI

For Appellant: Shri Hardik Vora, Advocate
For Respondent: Shri Ashish Kumar, Sr. DR
Hearing: 02.11.2026Pronounced: 04.11.2026

आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, सूरत न्यायपीठ, सूरत IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL SURAT BENCH, SURAT BEFORE MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI B.M. BIYANI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA No.540/SRT/2025 Assessment Year: 2016-17 Fatehsinh Mohansinh ACIT, Chauhan, Vapi Circle, Vapi Haveli, Income Tax Office, 8th Floor, बनाम Swaminarayan Marg, Fortune Square-II, Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Above TBZ, / Silvassa S.O. Chala, VAPI, Vs. Dadra and Nagar Haveli Gujarat-396191 Gujarat-396230 (Assessee/Appellant) (Revenue/Respondent) PAN: ABPPC6997C Assessee by Shri Hardik Vora, Advocate Revenue by Shri Ashish Kumar, Sr. DR Date of Hearing 02.11.2026 Date of Pronouncement 04.11.2026 आदेश / O R D E R Per B.M. Biyani, A.M.: Feeling aggrieved by the order of first appeal dated 27.03.2025 passed by learned Commissioner of Income-Tax (Appeals)-Addl/JCIT(A)-7, Mumbai [“Ld. CIT(A)”], which in turn arises out of the assessment-order dated 29.11.2018 passed by learned Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Vapi

Page 1 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan Circle, Vapi [“Ld. AO”] u/s 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”] for Assessment-Year [“AY”] 2016-17, the assessee has filed this appeal.

2.

The background facts leading to the present appeal are such that the assessee-individual filed his return of income for AY 2016-17 declaring a total income of Rs. 24,07,090/-, comprising income under the heads “Income from House Property”, “Income from Business or Profession” and “Income from Other Sources”. The case was selected for scrutiny assessment and the Ld. AO issued notices u/s 143(2)/142(1), which were complied with by the assessee. Ultimately, the Ld. AO completed the assessment u/s 143(3) at a total income of Rs. 1,07,49,980/-. The main reason for the variation in income was the re-characterisation of rental income. While the assessee declared the rental income under the head “Income from House Property” (taxable amount Rs. 1,90,23,397/-), the Ld. AO treated the same as part of “Income from Business or Profession”. Aggrieved, the assessee carried the matter in first-appeal before Ld. CIT(A) but did not succeed. Still aggrieved, the assessee has come in the present appeal before us.

3.

The assessee has raised the following grounds:

“1. On the facts and circumstances of the case as well as law on the subject, the learned AddI/JCIT (A) has erred in confirming the income of Rs. 2,73,40,032/- as business income instead of rental income. 2. On the facts and circumstances of the case as well as law on the subject, the learned AddI/JCIT (A) has erred in confirming the disallowance of Rs. 1,63,750/- which was claimed as deduction on account of taxes paid to local authority for rental property.

Page 2 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan 3. On the facts and circumstances of the case as well as law on the subject, the learned AddI/JCIT (A) has erred in confirming the disallowance of standard deduction u/s 24 of the Act of Rs. 81,52,885/-. 4. On the facts and circumstances of the case as well as law on the subject, the learned AddI/JCIT (A) has erred in confirming order, which was passed without providing video conferencing.” 4. At the start of hearing, Ld. AR for assessee submitted that the assessee is not pressing Ground No. 4. The Ld. DR for revenue does not have any objection against this submission. Accordingly, Ground No. 4 is dismissed as non-pressed.

5.

As regards the remaining Ground Nos. 1 to 3, Ld. AR submitted that all these grounds are connected to the basic issue whether the rental income earned by the assessee is taxable under the head “Income from House Property” or “Income from Business or Profession”, and once that issue is resolved, there is no necessity to adjudicate each ground independently. The Ld. DR for revenue did not object to this submission. We proceed accordingly in subsequent discussions.

6.

Thus, the limited controversy before us is the correct head under which the rental income earned by the assessee is taxable.

7.

The undisputed facts, as accepted by the Ld. AO on Page 10 of the assessment-order, are as under:

(i) The assessee is engaged in the business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings; and

Page 3 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan (ii) The assessee has earned rental income from industrial buildings which were part of stock-in-trade/business assets.

8.

Taking into account above facts, the Ld. AO has assessed the rental income under the head “Income from Business or Profession”. However, the claim of assessee is that he is engaged in the “business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings” but not engaged in the “business of letting out buildings”. Ld. AR submitted that the assessee has made this submission consistently before both of the lower authorities but the lower authorities have not correctly understood the case of assessee.

9.

Ld. AR drew our attention to the provision of section 22, which is the charging section of “Income from House Property”, according to which “the annual value of property consisting of any buildings or lands appurtenant thereto of which the assessee is the owner”, shall be chargeable to income- tax under the head “Income from House Property”. Further attention is drawn to section 23(5) which clearly provides that where the property is held as stock-in-trade and it is not let during the year, the annual value of such property, for a period of first two years, shall be taken to be Nil. According to Ld. AR, the charging section 22 as well as computing section 23(5) makes it very clear that the income from property held as stock-in-trade would be taxable under the head “Income from House Property”. Ld. AR further submitted that the Ld. CIT(A) has relied upon the decisions of Chennai Properties and Investments Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income-tax

Page 4 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan (2015) 56 taxmann.com 456 (SC); Rayala Corporation (P) Ltd. Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax (2016) 72 taxmann.com 149 (SC); and Principal Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Noor Resorts (P) Ltd. (2022) 145 taxmann.com 353 (Himachal Pradesh) but those decisions are applicable where the assessee is engaged in the business of letting out properties, which is not the case of present assessee. Further, the Ld. AO has relied upon Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. New India Industries Ltd. (1993) 201 ITR 208 (Guj) but in that case, the Hon’ble Court decided that the rental income would be taxable under the head “Income from House Property”, hence that decision is supporting the assessee’s claim and not the revenue’s stand.

10.

With above submissions, Ld. AR contended that the rental income was rightly offered by assessee under the head “Income from House Property”, hence the grounds raised by assessee deserve to be allowed.

11.

Per contra, Ld. DR for revenue supported the orders of the lower authorities. Ld. DR submitted that the industrial buildings were admittedly held as stock-in-trade in the course of the assessee's business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings. Further, the Ld. AO has noted that the assessee incurred interest expenditure and other expenses associated with the properties, which have been claimed as deduction in computing “Income from Business Profession”. Therefore, the rental income arising from properties were rightly assessed under the head “Income from Business or

Page 5 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan Profession”. Ld. DR accordingly pleaded that the action of Ld. AO, as sustained by Ld. CIT(A), deserves to be upheld.

12.

We have considered rival contentions of both sides and perused the orders of the lower authorities as well as the material on record to which our attention has been drawn.

13.

Section 22 brings to tax under the head “Income from House Property” the annual value of buildings owned by the assessee, while section 28 brings to tax the profits and gains of a business carried on by the assessee. The mere fact that an assessee carries on a business of dealing in lands and construction of building and has let out the properties held as stock-in- trade for sale, does not, by itself, decide the head under which the rental income is chargeable; the nature of the activity giving rise to the income has to be seen. In Chennai Properties and Investments Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court treated the rent as business income because letting out of properties was itself the business of the assessee. Other decisions relied by Ld. CIT(A), namely Rayala Corporation (P) Ltd. (supra) and Noor Resorts (P) Ltd. (supra), also apply where the assessee is engaged in the business of letting out properties. On the other hand, in New India Industries Ltd. (supra), relied upon by the Ld. AO, the Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court has held that the rental income was taxable under the head “Income from House Property”.

Page 6 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan 14. In present case, the assessee is admittedly engaged in the business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings, as noted in para 7 above. The lower authorities have not recorded a finding that the assessee is engaged in the business of letting out the properties and nothing has been brought to our notice to demonstrate so. The fact that the buildings form part of stock-in-trade is relevant, but it cannot, by itself, convert the rental receipts into business income. Similarly, the contention of Ld. DR that the interest and other expenses associated with the properties were claimed in computing business income does not decide the head of income, which depends on the nature of the income and not on the head under which the assessee has claimed the expenses. Since the assessee is engaged in the business of dealing in lands and construction of buildings, those expenses have been incurred for carrying on such business and therefore allowable as deduction. However, the Ld. AO may ensure that no deduction is allowed twice once in computing “Income from Business or Profession” head and again in computing “Income from House Property” head.

15.

We also find force in the submission made by Ld. AR that the section 23(5) of the Act itself deals with the properties held as “stock-in-trade” and gives a window of two years for taxing at “Nil” annual value (provided the property is not let out) and after expiry of two years, the annual value as computed u/s 23 becomes taxable. Thus, it is manifest from section 23(5)

Page 7 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan that a property held as stock-in-trade is taxable under the head “Income from House Property”.

16.

In view of the above, we hold that the rental income earned by the assessee from the industrial buildings held as stock-in-trade is assessable under the head “Income from House Property”, as declared by the assessee, and not under the head “Income from Business or Profession”. Accordingly, the claim of assessee is allowed. We direct the Ld. AO to recompute the income under the head “Income from House Property”, allowing the deductions admissible under the Act and to grant the consequential relief in accordance with law. Thus, the grounds raised by assessee are allowed.

In result, this appeal is partly allowed. 17.

Order pronounced in open court on 04/11/2026

Sd/- Sd/- (SUCHITRA KAMBLE) (B.M. BIYANI) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Surat दिन ांक /Dated : 04/11/2026

Kishore/Sr. PS Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) (5) Departmental Representative

Page 8 of 9

ITA No.540/SRT/2025 (A.Y. 2016-17) Fatehsinh Mohansinh Chauhan (6) Guard File By order HEMA KISHORE Digitally signed by HEMA KISHORE JAKKA JAKKA Date: 2026.11.04 19:53:14 +05'30' UE COPYAssistant Registrar/Sr. PS Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Surat Bench, Surat

Page 9 of 9

More judgments on Section 142(1)

All 18,912 judgments and leading authorities on Section 142(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →