G R BROTHERS,FIROZABAD vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD-2(2)(1), FIROZABAD

PDF · subscribers
ITA 566/AGR/2026Status: DisposedITAT Agra04 November 2026AY 2023-2412 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the enhanced rent of Rs. 12,14,100/- never accrued to the assessee. It was undisputed that the assessee received only Rs. 63,00,000/- during the year, which was offered to tax under Section 44AD. The Tribunal agreed with the assessee's submission that the enhanced rent was only a notional rent and not real income that could be brought to tax. The AO had not proved the assessee's submission of receiving only Rs. 5,25,000/- per month without escalation up to March 31, 2025, to be incorrect. While the AO noted that the reduced rent was for a period until February 2022 and thereafter rent was payable as per the agreement, the Tribunal found that the enhanced rent of Rs. 12,14,100/- was not sustainable. The addition made by the AO was deleted. The Tribunal found that the assessee's appeal was liable to be allowed. No issue was expressly left undecided.

What were the facts?

The assessee, G.R. Brothers, a firm engaged in construction and property letting, filed its return for Assessment Year 2023-24 declaring an income of Rs. 14,21,891/-. The case was selected for scrutiny due to a discrepancy between Form 26AS and the declared rental income. The assessee had let out a commercial building to M/s. Airplaza Retail Holdings Private Limited at a monthly rent of Rs. 5,44,500/- as per an agreement dated 12.12.2017, with a 15% escalation every three years. The assessee claimed that post-Covid-19, the lessee unilaterally agreed to a revenue-linked rent, reducing it to Rs. 5,25,000/- per month from February 2021, without escalation until March 31, 2025. The Assessing Officer (AO) calculated the rent based on the original agreement, including a 15% escalation for FY 2022-23, arriving at Rs. 6,26,175/- per month and total receipts of Rs. 75,14,100/-, proposing an addition of Rs. 12,14,100/-. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] dismissed the assessee's appeal, upholding the AO's addition.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in law, the learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of Rs. 12,14,100/- made by the AO on account of alleged under-reporting of business receipts, which was based on a notional, hypothetical, and estimated income computed by mechanically applying the 15% escalation clause from the original agreement, despite evidence of a mutually agreed reduced rent. Assessee's Contention: The addition is erroneous as it is based on notional income. The assessee relies on Supreme Court judgments in E.D. Sassoon & Co. Ltd. v. CIT, CIT v. Shoorji Vallabhdas & Co., Godhra Electricity Co. Ltd. v. CIT, and CIT v. Excel Industries Ltd., stating that income accrues only when there is a real, enforceable right to receive it, not on mere entitlement or bookkeeping entries. The assessee argues that rental receipts are business income under the PGBP head, which does not admit notional rent, unlike Section 23. They also contend that the AO and CIT(A) ignored uncontroverted evidence, including the lessee's confirmation and the parties' consistent conduct, and misread the agreement dated 03.03.2021. The assessee also cites Chennai Properties & Investments Ltd. v. CIT, Rayala Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, and Karanpura Development Co. Ltd. v. CIT for the principle that business income head does not permit notional rent. Revenue's Contention: The learned Senior Departmental Representative supported the orders of the authorities below.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 250,Section 143(3),Section 144B,Section 44AD,Section 23

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, AGRA (SMC

Before: SHRI SUNIL KUMAR SINGH & SHRI BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH

For Appellant: Shri Sahib P. Satsangi, CA
For Respondent: Shri Anil Kumar, Sr. DR
Hearing: 01.09.2026Pronounced: 04.11.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, AGRA (SMC) BENCH, AGRA BEFORE: SHRI SUNIL KUMAR SINGH, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA No. 566/Agr/2026 Assessment Year: 2023-24 G.R. Brothers, Vs. Income-tax Officer, S.N. Road, Firozabad (UP) - Ward 2(2)(1), Aayakar 283203 Bhawan, Dabrai, Firozabad – 283203. PAN :AAPFG9947F (Appellant) (Respondent) Assessee by Shri Sahib P. Satsangi, CA Department by Shri Anil Kumar, Sr. DR Date of hearing 01.09.2026 Date of pronouncement 04.11.2026 ORDER PER : BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: This appeal is directed against the impugned order dated 22.05.2026 passed in appeal No. NFAC/2022-23/10465367 by the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [hereinafter referred to as the “CIT(A)] u/s. 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) for the A.Y. 2023-24, wherein ld. CIT(A) has dismissed assessee’s appeal.

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

2.

Brief facts of the case: The assessee is a firm incorporated on 01.04.2015. During the year, it was engaged in the business of construction, running, maintenance and letting out of commercial properties. The assessee firm filed its return of income on 29.07.2023 declaring total income at Rs.14,21,891/-. The case was picked up for scrutiny under CASS on the following reason: “(1) Amount credited in Form 26AS is significantly more as compared to the rent/annual lettable value as shown in Return of Income.” 2.1 During the course of assessment proceedings, it emerged that the assessee had let out its commercial building at Firozabad and leased it to M/s. Airplaza Retail Holdings Private Limited (Vishal Mega Mart) for 12 years from 12.12.2017 at monthly rent of Rs.5,44,500/- with 15% escalation every three years. The assessee submitted before the AO that post Covid-19, the lessee unilaterally moved to revenue-linked rent and by letter dated 03.03.2021 reduced the rent to Rs.5,25,000/- per month and paid only Rs.5,25,000/- per month without any escalation upto 31.03.2025. The AO noted that during the year, the assessee received rental receipts of Rs.63,00,000/- (every month’s rent of Rs.5,25,000/-). The AO upon noting the agreement dated 12.12.2017 entered into between both the parties, noted that the rate of rent was agreed at Rs.33/- per sq. ft. tentatively to be Rs.5,44,500/- per month. The AO also

2 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

noted that besides this, an increment of rent on the effective date was also agreed at 15% increase on expiry of every three years. Vide notice u/s. 142(1) of the Act dated 11.01.2025 and 23.01.2025, the AO asked the assessee to furnish computation of monthly rent, after accounting for increments and annual lettable value of the property. According to the AO, there was no response from the assessee and in terms of the agreement, the AO proposed to estimate the effective date of leased agreement i.e., 12.12.2017 and accordingly applied the increment of 15% applicable for F.Y. 2022-23. Thus, the AO worked out the monthly rent at Rs.6,26,175/- and according to the AO, the gross receipts for F.Y. 2022-23 and for the assessment year 2023-24 should be Rs.75,14,100/-. Accordingly, the AO issued a show cause notice on 05.02.2025 proposing a variation of Rs.12,14,100/- (Rs.75,14,100 – Rs.63,00,000/-).

2.2 The assessee explained before the AO that all things were good between both the parties (lessor and lessee) until the wide spread of Covid-19 pandemic, which continued for almost two years. The assessee also explained that after the outbreak of Covid 19, the lessee M/s. Airplaza Retail Holdings Private Limited had implemented new policy for payment of rent on the basis of percentage of revenue achieved by them. It was further submitted that due to low revenue achieved by the retail 3 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

market, the lessee enforced the rescheduled monthly rent w.e.f. February, 2021 and the lessee reduced the rent to Rs.5,25,000/- and calculated the said amount as gross receipts of Rs.63,00,000/- u/s. 44AD of the Act and filed its return of income and paid the due taxes accordingly.

2.3 The AO did not accept the above plea of the assessee and upon perusal of the details filed by the assessee, it was noted that an agreement for reduction of rent was agreed on 03.03.2021 and noted that as per the said agreement, the amount payable was Rs.5,25,000/- for the period commencing from Feb. 2021 till Feb. 2022 for one year and post February, 2022, the rent payable shall be as per agreement, which hereby pertains to the F.Y. 2022-23. Further, the assessee also furnished copy of email dated 17.12.2023 stating that since the rent paid by the lessee was at the rate less than the agreement and thus requested the lessee to pay arrears. The AO further noted that in this regard, the assessee had brought agreement on record, which states that rent payable to the assessee had been reduced to Rs.5,25,000/- for F.Y. 2022-23. The AO also noted that notwithstanding the above, the rent is taxable on accrual basis and not on the basis of actual receipts and also noted that no documentary evidence was furnished by the assessee for 4 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

reduced rental income to be received from the lessee for F.Y. 2022-23. The AO also noted that the communication trail clearly stated that the rent shall be payable as per agreement post Feb. 2022 and accordingly observed that the contention of the assessee regarding the receipt of reduced rent could not accepted. Accordingly, the AO computed the lease rent based on the details furnished by the assessee to be at Rs.6,26,175/- and determined gross receipts of the assessee for F.Y. 2023-24 at Rs.75,14,100/-. The AO also held that since the expenses have already been claimed by the assessee for its business and accordingly, the assessee had under reported the business receipts of Rs.12,14,100/- and accordingly taxed the same as its business income.

2.4 Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee filed an appeal before the learned CIT(A) who dismissed the appeal of the assessee. The learned CIT(A) agreed with the findings of the AO and the relevant extract of the order of ld. CIT(A) in para 6.1 is reproduced as under: “6.1. During the course of appellate proceedings the assessee stated that the rent was reduced by the ease and the assessee firm was left with no option to accept the same as there was no one in the market to offer such an amount of rent to the appellant. Further, the assessee during the appellate proceedings failed to furnish the rental agreement held between the assessee-firma and the other party of reducing the rental income. The assessee stated that the copy of the emails held with the party regarding the reduction of rental income was submitted. However, on going through the same it can clearly be seen that the agreement for reduction as per the email trails was 5 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

agreed on 03.03.2021 which clearly stated that the amount payable shall be Rs.5.25,000/- for the period from February 2021 till February 2022 and after that the rent shall be payable as per the agreement. Further, it can be seen that the assessee during the assessment as well as appellate proceedings failed to submit the agreement which stated that the rent payable to the assessee had been reduced to Rs.5.25,000/- for the F.Y 2022- 23. Further, it can clearly be seen from the emails that it has been mentioned that the rent shall be payable as per the agreement post February 2022. In view of this fact, the AO has correctly estimated the rent received by the assessee at Rs.6,26,175/- and calculated the rent amounting to Rs.75,14,100/-for the F.Y. 2023-24. In view of this fact, I do not find any excuse to take a divergent view from the findings of the AO and therefore confirm the addition made by the AO on account of business income amounting to Rs.12,14,100/-. Accordingly, the Grounds of appeal raised by the assessee vide Nos. 2 to 4 are hereby dismissed.” 3. Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee filed an appeal before us by filing 10 grounds of appeal. Further, during the course of hearing, the assessee filed concise grounds of appeal, which are reproduced as under: “CONCISE GROUNDS OF APPEAL 1. That the order dated 22.05.2026 passed under section 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”) by the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), NFAC, Delhi [“the learned CIT(A)”], confirming the assessment order dated 10.03.2025 passed under section 143(3) read with section 144B of the Act, is erroneous, arbitrary and excessive, both on the facts of the case and in law. 2. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned CIT(A) has grossly erred both on facts and in law in confirming the addition of Rs. 12,14,100/- made by the learned Assessing Officer on account of alleged under-reporting of business receipts, which addition is founded purely on notional, hypothetical and estimated income computed by mechanically applying the 15% escalation clause of the lease agreement dated 12.12.2017 without appreciating the confirmation of the lease, affidavit of the partner of the appellant

6 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

firm solely on lessee’s letter dated 03.03.2021. (Original Ground Nos. 2,3,4 & 5) 3. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned Authorities below have erred both on facts and in law in ignoring that the actual rent received by the appellant during the year under consideration was only Rs. 63,00,000/- (Rs. 5,25,000/- per month), which stands fully corroborated by Form 26AS, AIS, bank statement of the appellant, and the lessee's own confirmation and no material to the contrary have been brought on record. 4. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned CIT(A) has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the addition without appreciating that the appellant had declared its income under the presumptive taxation scheme of section 44AD of the Act on the basis of actual gross receipts/turnover of Rs. 63,00,000/-. 5. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned CIT(A) has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the addition despite the fact that the learned Assessing Officer failed to make any enquiry or seek any verification whatsoever from the lessee, M/s Airplaza Retail Holdings Pvt. Ltd., regarding the actual rent paid or the operation of the escalation clause, and the addition made without any such enquiry and without bringing any clinching or cogent material on record is based on mere surmises, conjectures and presumptions, and deserves to be deleted. 6. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) is a non-speaking order passed in violation of the principles of natural justice, inasmuch as the learned CIT(A) has merely reiterated the findings of the learned Assessing Officer without independently considering and adjudicating upon the cogent evidence and material placed on record by the appellant. 7. That the appellant craves leave to add, alter, amend, modify or withdraw any or all of the above grounds of appeal before or at the time of hearing of the appeal.”

4.

At the time of hearing, the learned AR filed a synopsis for hearing, which is reproduced as under:

7 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

“SYNOPSIS FOR HEARING ISSUE Whether the addition of Rs. 12,14,100/- made u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B, and confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A), NFAC vide order dated 22.05.2026, by notionally applying the 15% escalation clause of the Lease Agreement dated 12.12.2017 (monthly rent estimated at Rs. 6,26,175/- against actual rent of Rs. 5,25,000/-), is sustainable when the said escalation was admittedly never acted upon and the amount was neither received by, nor ever accrued to, the appellant. FACTS IN BRIEF The appellant firm's sole business is letting out its commercial building at Firozabad, leased to M/s Airplaza Retail Holdings Pvt. Ltd. ("Vishal Mega Mart") for 12 years from 12.12.2017 at Rs. 5,44,500/- p.m. with 15% escalation every 3 years. (Lease Agreement PB Page Nos. 25-48) Post Covid-19, the lessee unilaterally moved to revenue-linked rent (PB Page No. 55) and, vide letter dated 03.03.2021, reduced rent to Rs. 5,25,000/- p.m. (PB Page No. 59) In consistent conduct, it paid only Rs. 5,25,000/- p.m., without any escalation, up to 31.03.2025; (F.Y. 2020-21 receipts: Rs. 33,77,195/- (PB Page No. 68); F.Y. 2021-22 receipts: Rs. 56,70,000/- (PB Page No. 69) and F.Y. 2022-23 receipts : Rs. 63,00,000/-) The first escalation (10% of Rs. 5,25,000/- to Rs. 5,77,500/- p.m.) took effect only from 01.04.2025, and the lessee's e-mail dated 08.04.2025 confirms that nothing was outstanding up to 31.03.2025. (PB Page No. 70) For A.Y. 2023-24 the appellant received actual rent of Rs. 63,00,000/- (corroborated by Form 26AS/AIS, TDS (PB Page No. 72) and bank statement (PB Page Nos. 13-15)) and offered it u/s 44AD, declaring business income of Rs. 14,11,001/-(PB Page No. 81). Reconciliation of rent received and credited in the bank account is attached. The learned AO, without any enquiry from the lessee, taxed notional rent of Rs. 75,14,100/- (Rs. 6,62,175 pm. (15% escalation on Rs. 5,44,500/- rent as per agreement dated 12.12.2017 less disclosed rental income of Rs. 5,25,000/- pm.) and added Rs. 12,14,100/-as deemed business income.

8 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

The Ld. CIT(A) confirmed the addition relying solely on the letter dated 03.03.2021 (PB Page No. 59), without dealing with the uncontroverted Affidavit of the partner dated 28.07.2025 (PB Page Nos. 65-71), the lessee's confirmation dated 08.04.2025 (PB Page No. 70), the year-wise rent statements and the e-mail trail on record in respect of communication 17.12.2023 (PB Page No. 64). SUBMISSIONS WITH LEGAL CITATIONS I. No real income; hypothetical income not taxable. Under section 5 of the Income Tax Act. 1961, only income received or accrued is chargeable. Income embodies a right to receive; a mere claim under a clause never enforced creates no accrual. In E.D. Sassoon & Co. Ltd. v. CIT (1954) 26 ITR 27 (SC), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that income accrues or arises only when the assessee acquires a legal, enforceable right to receive it, creating a corresponding debt due from another party. CIT v. Shoorji Vallabhdas & Co. (1962) 46 ITR 144 (SC), Supreme Court held that income-tax is a levy on real income, and hypothetical or book-entry income that never materializes cannot be taxed. Godhra Electricity Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1997] 225 ITR 746 (SC), The Apex Court ruled that income-tax is a levy on real income. If income does not result or materialize at all, it cannot be taxed merely because bookkeeping entries were made CIT v. Excel Industries Ltd. (2013 358 ITR 295 (SC), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that income under the Income Tax Act, 1961, does not accrue upon a mere entitlement or bookkeeping entry, but only when a real, enforceable right to receive it arises. II. Business income head admits no notional rent. The rental receipts are business income (Chennai Properties & Investments Ltd. v. CIT [2015] 373 ITR 673 (SC); Rayala Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT [2016] 386 ITR 500 (SC); Karanpura Development Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1962] 44 ITR 362 (SC)), a position accepted by the AO himself. Unlike section 23 (annual lettable value), the PGBP head contains no deeming fiction permitting taxation of rent not received; u/s 44AD, "turnover or gross receipts" means actual receipts. The Revenue having accepted that the source and the head of income cannot notionally deem a business income / turnover. III. Addition rests on conjecture; no enquiry made. The Authorities below made no verification from the lessee u/s 9 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

133(6)/131 despite full details on record. An assessment cannot rest on suspicion, surmise or guesswork. Dhakeswari Cotton Mills Ltd. v. CIT (1954) 26 ITR 775 (SC); Umacharan Shaw & Bros. v. CIT (1959) 37 ITR 271 (SC). IV. Uncontroverted evidence ignored. The sworn Affidavit of the partner deposing the month-wise rent actually received stands uncontroverted and could not be brushed aside without cross-examination or contrary material. Mehta Parikh & Co. v. CIT (1956) 30 ITR 181 (SC). The lessee's confirmation dated 08.04.2025 (no dues up to 31.03.2025) and the parties' consistent conduct conclusively negate any accrual of the differential of Rs. 12,14,100/-. V. The Ld. CIT(A) misread the letter dated 03.03.2021. Post- February 2022 the contractual rent was never in fact, paid or escalated, and the subsequent conduct of the parties (reduced rent till 31.03.2025 with a fresh 10% escalation only from 01.04.2025) governs the real income of the year. PRAYER It is accordingly prayed that the addition of Rs. 12,14,100/- be deleted, the consequential interest and penalty proceedings be quashed, and the returned income of Rs. 14,21,891/- be accepted.” 5. On the other hand, the learned Sr. DR supported the orders of the authorities below.

6.

We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record. In this case, the assessee received a rent of Rs. 63,00,000/- in its bank account from M/s Airplaza retail holding Pvt. Ltd. (Vishal Mega Mart) in respect of letting out its commercial building property at Firozabad to the said party @ Rs 5,25,000/- per month. The AO noted that the said property was let out by the assessee vide agreement dated 12.12.2017 which provided rent @ Rs. 5,44,500/- per month with 15%

10 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

escalation every 3 years. However, the assessee submitted before the AO that M/s Airplaza retail holding Pvt. Ltd (Vishal Mega Mart) intimated vide letter dated 03.03.2021 (placed at page no. 55 of the paper book) to the assessee referring to the covid-19 lockdown period unilaterally reduced the rent to revenue link and the rent was reduced to Rs. 5,25,000/- vide letter dated 03.03.2021 (placed at page no. 59 of the paper book). It was further submitted that it paid only Rs. 5,25,000/- per month without escalation up to 31.03.2025. This fact that the submission of the assessee that it received only Rs. 5,25,000/- per month from M/s Airplaza retail holding Pvt. Ltd. (Vishal Mega Mart) without escalation up to 31.03.2025 including during the F.Y. 2022-23 has not been proved to be incorrect by the AO. However, the AO noted that in the letter dated 03.03.2021 (placed at page no. 59 of the paper book) it was stated that the reduced rent of Rs. 5,25,000/- per month was payable from February 2021 for a period of one year till February 2022 and post February 2022 the rent shall be payable as per the agreement. The AO also noted that rent was taxable on accrual basis and no documentary evidences was furnished by the assessee seeking arrears from Airplaza retail holding Pvt. Ltd. (Vishal Mega Mart). Accordingly, the AO calculated the rent at Rs. 6,26,175/- with an escalation of 15% of the original rent of Rs. 5,44,500/- as agreed upon in the rent agreement dated 12.12.2017 and 11 | P a g e

ITA No.566/Agr/2026

calculated the gross rent for the year at Rs. 75,14,100/- and taxed the difference of Rs. 12,14,100/- (Rs. 75,14,100 – 63,00,000/-). However, in the given facts of the case, we agree with the submission of the assessee that the enhanced rent of Rs. 12,14,100/- never accrued to the assessee and it is undisputed that during the year the assessee received a sum of Rs. 63,00,000/- only which has been offered to tax by the assessee u/s 44AD of the Act. Therefore, the enhanced rent of Rs 12,14,100/- is only a notional rent and not the real income which can be brought to tax during the year in the hands of the assessee. Accordingly, the addition of Rs. 12,14,100/- is not sustainable in the case of the assessee and the same is deleted. Therefore, the appeal of the assessee is liable to be allowed.

7.

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed. Order pronounced in the open court on 04 /11 /2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (SUNIL KUMAR SINGH) (BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 04/11/2026 *aks/- Copy forwarded to: 1. Appellant Aamir Digitally signed 2. Respondent by Aamir Siddiqui 3. CIT Siddiqui Date: 2026.11.04 4. CIT(A) 17:31:25 +05'30' 5. DR Asst. Registrar, ITAT, Agra

12 | P a g e

More judgments on Section 144B

All 13,343 judgments and leading authorities on Section 144B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →