Director Of Income Tax international Taxation vs. M/s Baker Hughes Asia Pacific Limited

PDF · subscribers
ITA/20/2013HC UttarakhandUKHC01007535201301 April 2014Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE3 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the issues raised in these appeals are identical to those that were decided in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013, which was decided on March 20, 2014. Consequently, these appeals are also disposed of by answering the issues in favour of the appellant (Revenue), mirroring the decision in the earlier appeal. The reasoning is based on the direct precedent set by the judgment in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013. The ratio decidendi is that if identical issues have been decided in a previous appeal involving the same appellant, then subsequent appeals with identical issues should follow the same outcome. The operative direction is that the appeals are disposed of in favour of the appellant. However, the assessees are granted liberty to pursue any available legal recourse concerning the non-completion of hearings by the Tribunal and associated matters.

What were the facts?

These are multiple Income Tax Appeals filed by the Director of Income Tax (International Taxation)-II, New Delhi, against various respondents including M/s Baker Hughes Asia Pacific Limited, M/s Baker Hughes Oil Field Operation Inc, M/s Baker Hughes Singapore Pte, M/s Halliburton Offshore Services Inc, M/s Presision Energy Services Limited, M/s Siem Offshore AS, and M/s Siem Offshore Inc. The appeals concern issues that were previously raised in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013. The High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital is hearing these appeals. The judgment notes that the issues in these appeals are identical to those in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013, which was decided on March 20, 2014.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the issues raised in these appeals are identical to those decided in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013 (Director of Income Tax (International Taxation)-II, New Delhi versus M/s Seacor Offshore Dubai LLC). Assessee's Contention: Not recorded. Revenue's Contention: The revenue argues that the issues in the present appeals are identical to those decided in a prior appeal (Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013) and therefore, the present appeals should be disposed of in line with that decision. The revenue relies on the decision in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013, decided on March 20, 2014, in favour of the appellant (Revenue).

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL Income Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Baker Hughes Asia Pacific Limited ……….. Respondent

Income Tax Appeal No. 21 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Baker Hughes Oil Field Operation Inc .……….. Respondent

Income Tax Appeal No. 22 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Baker Hughes Singapore Pte

Income Tax Appeal No. 23 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Baker Hughes Singapore Pte

Income Tax Appeal No. 24 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Halliburton Offshore Services Inc ……….. Respondent

Income Tax Appeal No. 25 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Presision Energy Services Limited ……….. Respondent

Income Tax Appeal No. 26 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi . ..…….. Appellant

M/s Siem Offshore AS

AND

Income Tax Appeal No. 27 of 2013

(International Taxation)–II, New Delhi ……….. Appellant

M/s Siem Offshore Inc

……….. Respondent

Present: Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, Advocate for the appellant.

Mr. P.R

. Mulick, Advocate for the respondent.

Coram: Hon’ble Barin Ghosh, C.J.

Hon’ble V.K. Bist, J.

BARIN GHOSH, C.J. (Oral)

The issues raised in these appeals were issues in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013 and the questions arising out of those issues have been answered in favour of the appellant in Income Tax Appeal No. 31 of 2013 (Director of Income Tax (International Taxation)-II, New Delhi versus M/s Seacor Offshore Dubai LLC), decided on 20th March, 2014 and, accordingly, these appeals are also disposed of by answering those issues in favour of the appellant in the present appeals. It shall, however, be open for

the assessees to take such recourse to law as is available to them in relation to non-completion of the hearing by the Tribunal and associated matters.

(V.K. Bist, J.) (Barin Ghosh, C.J.) 01.04.2014 01.04.2014 P. Singh

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →