COMNR.OF INCOMETAX vs. METALLOY INDIA
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court dismissed the Tax Revision Case. Regarding the first issue, the Court held that the definition of 'business' under Section 2(bbb) of the Act includes any transaction connected with or incidental or ancillary to trade, commerce, manufacture, adventure, or concern. Explanation (II) to this definition further clarifies that any transaction of sale or purchase of capital assets pertaining to such business shall be deemed to be business. Since the old, unusable machinery was a capital asset, its sale by the petitioner was considered a sale made in the course of business and exigible to tax. The Court distinguished the cited case of M/s. Coromandel Fertilizers, stating it dealt with the sale of plant and machinery as part of the sale of the entire business, not the sale of unserviceable machinery in the course of running business. On the second issue, the Court found no merit in the contention that Sections 5A and 5E are mutually exclusive. It reasoned that Section 5E pertains to receipts on the transfer of the right to use goods, considered a deemed sale. Section 5A levies tax on 'turnover,' which includes transactions under Section 5C or amounts realizable under Section 5E. Therefore, Section 5A is an additional impost, not a tax on the amount realizable from the transfer of the right to use goods, but an additional tax on the transaction. The Court relied on its own decision in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Navayuga Engineering Company Limited and the Supreme Court's decision in Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Aysha Hosiery Factory (P.) Ltd., which held turnover tax to be an additional impost unrelated to the sale or purchase of goods.
What were the facts?
The petitioner, M/s. Spectra Bottling Company (P) Ltd., filed a Tax Revision Case (TREVC) against an order of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh, dated September 5, 2003, for the assessment year 1996-97. The petitioner had sold old, unserviceable, and obsolete machinery during the assessment year. The petitioner contended that this sale should not be taxed as it occurred prior to the closure of its business and that tax had already been levied under Section 5E of the APGST Act for rentals on bottles and crates, making a levy under Section 5A impermissible due to the non-obstante clauses in both sections. The respondent is the State of Andhra Pradesh.
What were the issues?
1. Whether a sale of old, unserviceable, and obsolete machinery prior to the actual closure of business can be considered a sale in the course of business for the purpose of taxation under the APGST Act, 1957. 2. Whether turnover tax under Section 5A of the APGST Act can be levied when tax has already been levied under Section 5E of the Act, given that both sections contain non-obstante clauses. Assessee's Arguments: - The sale of old, unserviceable machinery is not taxable as it occurred before the business closure. Reliance was placed on M/s. Coromandel Fertilizers v. State of Andhra Pradesh. - Since tax was levied under Section 5E on rentals (treated as transfer of right to use goods), no further tax can be levied under Section 5A. - Both Section 5A and Section 5E have non-obstante clauses, making them mutually exclusive. The levy under Section 5E should preclude any levy under Section 5A. Revenue's Arguments: - The order of the Tribunal does not suffer from any error giving rise to questions of law for consideration by the Court.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 2(bbb),Section 2(n),Section 5A,Section 5C,Section 5E
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
(Petition under Section 2Z(1) ot ApcST Act, 1957 to revise the Order dt. 05-09-2003 in TA No. 1013 t 2OOO on the file of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh. Hyderabad, preferred against the Qrder of the Deputy Commissioner (CT), Vizianagiram in G.R.No.7757l1990-91/Rc.No.592193-8-2 dated 29-06-1993, preferred against the Order of the Commercial Tax Officer, M.G.Road (East), Vizianagaram, in Assessment No.775711990-91, DT.05-09-i 991. IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THURSDAY,THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF JUNE TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTYTHREE PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE T. VINOD KUMAR THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK TAX REVISION CASE NO: 135 OF 2004 ...RESPONDENT Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI S. SURTBABU Counsel for the Respondent : SRI K. RA"JI REDDY, Special Senior Standing Counsel The Court delivered the following Order : Between: M/s.. Spectra,Boftling Company (P) Ltd., Hyderabad, represented by its Chairman Sri K. Satyanarayana ...PETITioNER State of Andhra Pradesh represented by the State Representative before the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Andhra piadesh, Hyderibad
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE T. VINOD KUMAR THE HON,BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK TA)( REVISION CASE NO. 135 of2OO4 ORDER: (per tlonble Sri Justice T.Vinod Kumar) The Tax Revision Case (TREVC) is preferred 'ly the petitioner/ appellant aggrieved by the order passed by th': Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short the TribunalJ in T.A. No.1O13 of 2OOO clated 05.O9.2003 for the assessment year l')96-97 under APGST Act, 1957 (for short the ActJ raising the following questions of law: t ).whelher a sale pnor to the actual cloatre of business could be considered as a sate in the course of business. )). SecondLg, uhere ct non-abstante clouse is emploAed tn tun cl(trging sections, Luheth.er Tumouer Tax under rrnrle. .Jectron 5 E. -l). l-trutlly, Luhether o non obstante clctuse tn Sectic'n 5-A ctuenrties atl olher charging sections in the APGST Act.
Heard Sri S. Suribabu, learned Counsel appealing on behalf of rhe petitioncr and Sri K. Raji Reddy, learned Special Senior Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent and pcrusecl the record. 3. tt is the casc of Revision Petltioner that it had sold somc olrl, unservict:ablc machinery which has become obsolete during
the assessment year 1996_97 ald the same cannot be brought to tax inasmuch as the petitioner had closed its business subsequently +. Petitioner further contends that the Tribunal also erred in not appreciating that tJre assessing authority having levied tax under the provisions of Section 5E of the Act on rurnover relating to rentals on bottles and crates received by it by treating the same as transfer of Right to use goods; and that no tax under Section 5A of tlre Act can be levied again. 5. Petitioner would further contends that both the provisions o[ Sections 5A and 5E of the Act begin with a non_obstante clause and since, tax is levied by invoking the provisions o[ Section 5E of the Act, the power to levy tax under Section 5A of the Act would not be available being mutually exclusive. Thus, the order of the Tribunal rejecting the contentions put forth by the revision petitioner gives rise to the questions of law raised in the presen( Revision Case.
Per contra, learned Special Senior Stalding Counse I r,".hile supporting the reasoning of the Tribunal in dismrssing Appeal would submit that the order of the Tribuna.l does thc not
J i ! suffer from any error giving rise to questions of law for consideration bY this Court. 1 . We have taken note of the respective submissions' S. In so far as the claim o[ the petitioner tlLat sale' of old unusuable and obsolete machinery cannot be subjectec' to tax by placing reliance on the decision rendered in M/s' Coromandel Fertilizers v. State of Andhra Pradeshr is concerned, it is to be noted that the issue under consic'eration in the above said case was whether the Sales Ta>: can be levied on the plant and machinery when the same are being sold as part of sale of business and did not deal vt'ith the Lssue o' sale of unserviceable and obsolele machinery in the course of the running of the business. g. On the other hand, the definilion o[ "busin'zss" in Section 2(bbb) of the Act takes into its ambrt, any transac lion in connection with or incidenlal to or anciliary to suctL trade, commerce, manufacture, adventure or concern' Irurther, Explanation (II) thereto specifies as under: "AnA transaction of sale or purchase of capital assets pertaining to such trade, commerce, manufacturr', aduenture or concerrl shall be deemed to be business and the e4tression I 27 APSTJ 313
"capital assefs,, shalt haue th.e same meaning as a,ssigned. to it in Income Tax Act, 1961. 10. When the term " busines{ as delined in the Act is taken into consideration and applied to the facts of the present case, it is seen that old unusable machinery which is admittedly a capital asset and sale thereof by the petitioner would have to be considered as a sale made in the course of " business. and the receipts on account of such sale would be exigible to tax under the provisions of the Act. 11 . With regard to other contention that both the provisions of Sections 5-A and Section 5_E of the Act begin with non_obstante clause and are mutually exclusive, we are unable to appreciate thc said contention for the following reason. 1l .1 Firstly, it is to be seen that levy of tax under Section 5E of the Act is in relation to receipts on transfer of right to use thc goods, which activity is considered as a deemed sale undcr Explanation IV to detinition of "sa? as defrned under Section 2(n) of the Act 1l .2 Secondly, the lerlr of tax under Section 5A of the Act is in relation t<t "tuntouef as dehned under Section 2(s) of the Act. The delinition, includes the transactions under Section 5C ) {
or the amount realiasable under Section 5E of the Act. Thus, the lery of tax under Section 5A of the Act is an adrlitional impost and is not a tax on the amount realiasable on acccunt of granting of right to use goods. Thus, the levy of tax under Seclion 5A is in the nature of additional tax on the transaction of transfer of right to use goods. 7L. On a similar contention being raised, this Court in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Navayuga Engineering Company Limited2 rejected the same upholding the order of the Tribunal. 13. Further, the Hon'lcle Supreme Court in Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Aysha Hosiery Factory (P.) Ltd.3, considering an analogous provision under [.lerala (]eneral Sales Tax Act, 1963, had heid the turnover tax t() bc unrclated to the sale or purchase of goods ancl the tzrx Levied is an additional impost. In view of the abovc, thc issue is no longer res integra. 1+ Resultantly, the questions of lar.r' raised in the l)resent revision case does not merit any consicleration and ansu'ered against the petitioner. II r (2007) 4s APSTJ I r It9921 8s STC l06 (SC); AIR 1992 SC 874
t5 as to costs Accordingly, the Tax Revision Case is dismissed. No order As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand closed //TRUE COPY// sd/- K. sRtNlvAsA RAO JOINT REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER To 1. The Sales Tax Appeltate Tribunal, Andhra pradesh. Hyderabad. 2. The Deputy Commissioner (CT;, Vizianagaram- 3. The Commerciat Tax Officei, M.c.Road GrJt), Virirn"o"rr. 1. 9n" 99 to S. Suribabu, Advocate (OpUC 5. One CC to Sri K. Rali Reddy, Speiiat Seriior Standing Counsel, High Court for the State of Telangana ai ttyderabad 6. Two CD Copies ! i l ,%
HIGH COURT DATED:15/06/2023 ORDER 1&.tL TflC.No.135 of 2004 DISMISSING THE TAX REVISION CASE \\'ITHOUT COSTS ,.'l.:,\,,\i , ..t ,, \-: ,.^J .\ta,)/./.. _ -:::_.: _:- t, I lL 2\ %
More judgments on Section 5A
- Sebastian Amancio Dsouza, Comoti Vado vs Assessing Officer, Aaykar BhavanITA 194/PAN/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed27 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- Sebastian Amancio Dsouza, Comoti Vado vs Assessing Officer, Aaykar BhavanITA 194/PAN/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed27 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- The Assessing Officer, Textiles Committee vs M/S. Premium Suiting Pvt. LtdC.A. No.-000785-000785 - 201626 Oct 2026
- Pasquel Francisco Colaco, Verem vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 189/PAN/2024[2010-11]Status: Disposed3 Jul 2026AY 2010-11
- Pasquel Francisco Colaco, Verem vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 188/PAN/2024[2009-10]Status: Disposed3 Jul 2026AY 2009-10
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Sanjurani Giri vs. The Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Deepankar Mohanty vs. Union Of INDIAOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Dinabandhu Majhi vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax, CT And GST, KoraputOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Makardhwaj Kaudi vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahoo Supply Agency, Balasore vs. Central Board Of Indirect Taxes And CustomsOrissa · 17 Nov 2026