COMNR.OF I.TAX vs. NILAGIRI ENGINEERING

PDF · subscribers
ITA/30/2009HC OrissaODHC01028378200913 April 2017Author: MR. JUSTICE I.MAHANTY,MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT MOHANTY7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that welding rods and electrodes used for the maintenance and repair of machinery are not entitled to CENVAT credit as capital goods. This decision was based on the Tribunal's earlier larger bench decision in Triveni Engg. & Industries Ltd. –v- CCE, Meerut, which was confirmed by the Supreme Court. The Tribunal noted that the Supreme Court had dismissed an appeal in the case of SAIL vs. CCE on a similar issue. The Tribunal found no error in its view, stating that it had considered the material and followed the earlier decision confirmed by the Supreme Court. While the appellant contended that credit for such items was allowed subsequently, the Tribunal opined that this would not make a difference as it had no occasion to consider those subsequent decisions. The appeal was disposed of without a fresh decision on the merits of the subsequent developments.

What were the facts?

The appellant, an assessee, is challenging an order dated 31.07.2009 passed by the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Eastern Zone, Kolkata. The CESTAT had allowed an appeal by the Department, reversing the decision of the First Appellate Authority. The dispute concerns the eligibility of CENVAT credit on welding rods and electrodes. The First Appellate Authority had allowed the credit, interpreting the definition of 'inputs' broadly and relying on Supreme Court decisions. The Department appealed this, and the CESTAT, following its larger bench decision confirmed by the Supreme Court, denied the credit for welding electrodes used for maintenance and repair of machinery, classifying them as not capital goods. The appeal was filed in 2009 and heard on multiple dates.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in holding that welding rods and electrodes do not qualify as capital goods, thus disentitling the appellant from claiming CENVAT credit on these items (under Section 57Q of the Central Excise Rules read with Rule 2 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004)? 2. Whether the Tribunal erred by disregarding the Supreme Court's decision in JK Cotton and Spinning and Weaving Mills? 3. Whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted the definition of 'Capital Goods' as per Section 57Q of the Central Excise Rules read with Rule 2 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, in light of the Supreme Court's ruling in Commissioner of Central Excise Vs. Jawahar Mills Ltd.? Assessee's Contentions: The appellant argued that welding rods and electrodes should be considered capital goods, relying on the broad definition of 'inputs' and the Supreme Court's liberal interpretation in CCE Vs. M/s Solaris Chemtch Ltd. They also cited a Tribunal decision in favour of the assessee on an identical issue. The appellant further relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbator –v- Jawahar Mills Ltd., emphasizing the liberal language of the definition of capital goods and the user-based determination of eligibility. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue contended that the Tribunal was justified in denying credit, following its larger bench decision in Triveni Engg. & Industries Ltd., which was confirmed by the Supreme Court. The Tribunal's decision was also supported by the dismissal of an appeal by the Supreme Court in the case of SAIL vs. CCE.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 57Q, Rule 2(k)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

6.

20.02.2019 Heard Mr. S. Ray, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Mohapatra, learned counsel for the Commission of Central Excise Department.

By way of this appeal, the appellant has challenged the order dated 31.07.2009 passed by the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Eastern Zone, Kolkata in Appeal No.Ex.Ap.36 of 2009, whereby learned Tribunal has allowed the appeal preferred by the Department and reversed the view taken by the First Appellate Authority.

Though this appeal was filed on 16.11.2009, the matter came up for hearing on different dates. Lastly, the matter has come today for admission.

Learned counsel for the appellant has framed the following substantial questions of law for determination in this appeal.

“(A) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal is justified to give its finding that welding rods and electrodes cannot come within the meaning of Capital goods and thus whether the appellant can claim Cenvat credit on these goods?

(B) Whether the Tribunal is just and proper to give a go bye to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case of JK Cotton and Spinning and Weaving Mills, reported in 91 ELT 34?

(C) Whether the Tribunal has correctly interpreted “Capital Goods” as defined u/s 57Q of the Central Excise Rules read with Rule 2 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 and whether such interpretation is correct in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Commissioner of Central Excise Vs. Jawahar Mills Ltd, reported in 2001 (132) ELT 3?”

OTAPL No.30 of 2009

Learned counsel for the appellant has taken us to the order of the First Appellate Authority. After considering the same, the First Appellate Authority has allowed the appeal, relevant portion of which reads as under:

“As such, the conclusion drawn by the CESTAT in the above referred pronouncements that the repair and maintenance of plant and machinery is essential to carry out manufacture and the welding electrodes used for such maintenance and repair qualify as inputs appears correct. The definition of inputs, as per Rule 2(k) of Cenvat Credit Rules encompasses “all goods………… used in or in relation to the manufacture of final products whether directly or indirectly and whether contained in the final product or not…” As such, the definition is broad based and this is also supported by the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CCE Vs. M/s Solaris Chemtch Ltd. 2007 (214) ELT 481 (SC) where in the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the expression “in relation to” must be given a wide connotation.

“The words “in relation to” which find place in Section 2(f) of the said Act has been interpreted by this Court to cover process generating intermediate products and it is in this context that it has been repeatedly held by this Court that if manufacture of the final product cannot take place without the process in question then that process is an integral part of the activity of manufacture of the final product. Therefore, the “words” in relation to the manufacture” have been used to widen and expand the scope, meaning and content of the expression “inputs” so as to attract goods which do not enter in to finished goods.

In addition it is also seen that the Hon’ble Tribunal, 2004 (166) E.L.T. 397 (Tri. Mumbai) has also passed similar order in favour of the appellant in an identical issue.”

The Department has preferred appeal against the order of the First Appellate Authority.

Learned Tribunal while considering the same has followed the earlier decision of the larger Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Triveni Engg. & Industries Ltd. –v- CCE, Meerut; reported in 2005 (186) E.L.T. 158 (Tri.-LB), which was confirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, reads as under:

“6. I find larger Bench of the Tribunal in the case Triveni Engg. & Industries Ltd. (supra) held that the credit is not available in respect of welding electrodes as capital goods. This issue also came before the Tribunal in the case of SAIL vs. CCE, Ranchi-2008 (222) E.L.T. 233 whereby after considering the earlier decision on the issue the Tribunal held that the credit is not available. On the Appeal filed by SAIL the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed the appeal after condoning the delay. The same is reported as SAIL vs. CCE-2008 (229) ELT A-127 (SC). In respect of the decision of the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court I find in Appeal No.33/07 the Hon’ble High Court held that welding electrodes are not entitled for credit whereas without noticing another decision in the case Hindustan Zinc (supra’) allowed the credit. As the Appeal against decision of the Tribunal in the case of SAIL(supra) is dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court therefore respectfully following the above decision I find that welding electrodes which are used for the maintenance and repair of the machinery are not entitled for the credit as capital goods. In respect of penalty as now Hon’ble Supreme Court upheld the order passed by the Tribunal and earlier there was divergent views therefore it is not a case for imposition of any penalty.

7.

Another issue involved in this Appeal is in respect of credit of Rs.670/- (Rupees Six Hundred and Seventy only) on foundation bolts. The issue is already settled by the Tribunal in the case of

Reliance Industries Ltd. vs. CCE, Surat-2007 (210) E.L.T. 422 (Tri.-Mumbai) in favour of the assessee. Hence I find no infirmity whereby the credit in respect of foundation bolts is allowed in the impugned order.”

We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

Learned counsel for the appellant relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbator –v- Jawahar Mills Ltd.; reported in 2001 (132) E.L.T. 3 (SC), wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court more particularly at paragraphs-4 and 6 has observed as follows:

“4. The aforesaid definition of ‘Capital goods’ is very wide. Capital goods can be machines, machinery, plant equipment, apparatus, tools or appliances. Any of these goods if used for producing or processing of any goods or for bringing about any change in any substance for the manufacture of final product would be ‘Capital goods’, and, therefore, qualify for availing Modvat Credit. Per clause (b), the components, spare parts and accessories of the goods mentioned in clause (a) used for the purposes enumerated therein would also be ‘Capital goods’ and qualify for Modvat Credit entitlement. Clause (c) makes moulds and dies, generating sets and weigh bridges used in the factory of the manufacturers as capital goods and thus qualify for availing Modvat Credit. The goods enumerated in clause (c) need not be used for producing the final product or used in the process of any goods for the manufacture of final product or used for bringing about any change in any substance for the manufacture of final product and the only requirement is that the same should be used in the factory of the manufacturer. Thus, it can be seen that the language used in the explanation is very liberal.

6.

The contention of learned Additional Solicitor General that the aforesaid decision and other decisions referred by the Tribunal in the impugned order were cases involving sales tax and income tax and, therefore, the Tribunal should not have relied on those decisions is without any substance because the real question is that of the principle laid down by a decision. In view of the liberal language of the provision, Mr. Rohtagi fairly and very rightly did not seriously dispute that if any of the items enumerated in explanation 1(a) is used for any purpose mentioned therein for the manufacture of final products, it would satisfy the test of ‘Capital goods’. The main contention of Mr. Rohtagi, however, is that the question whether an item falls within the definition of ‘Capital goods’ would depend upon the user it is put to. The submission is that parts of the items in respect whereof availing of Modvat credit has been allowed by the Tribunal could not be treated as ’Capital goods’ as the manufacturer could not establish that the entire item was used in the manufacture of final product. To illustrate his point, Mr. Rohtagi submitted that part of a cable may go into the machine used by the manufacturer and, thus, may qualify the requirement of clause 1(a) and, at the same time, another part of the cable which is used only for lights and fans would not so qualify. We have no difficulty in accepting the contention of the learned Additional Solicitor General that, under these circumstances, user will determine whether an item qualifies or not the requirement of clause 1(a). However, in the present cases this aspect has no relevance. It was not the case of the revenue at any stage before the authorities that an item does not satisfy the requirement of ‘Capital goods’ within the meaning of the Rule on the ground of its user as it now sought to be urged by the learned counsel. The case of the revenue has all through been that the items in question per se are not ‘Capital goods’ within the meaning of the expression as defined in Explanation 1(a). In respect of the cables of which Mr. Rohtagi gave example, the stand of the revenue before the Tribunal was that

the cables per se cannot be treated as ‘Capital goods’. The stand of the revenue was not as has been projected now by Mr. Rohtagi. In this view, the question of directing remand of these matters for fresh decision by the Tribunal does not arise. On the facts and circumstances of these cases, therefore, the stand that the items in question are not used for manufacture of final product cannot be accepted for the reasons aforestated.”

In our considered opinion, learned Tribunal has considered the case following the earlier decision, which was confirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The material which was released has been considered by learned Tribunal in the earlier decision and came to a conclusion that the petitioner is not entitled to such credit.

In that view of the matter, we find no error in the view taken by learned Tribunal following the earlier decision. However, learned counsel for the appellant contended that subsequently credit for such item is allowed. In our considered opinion, that would not make any difference in view of the fact that learned Tribunal has no occasion to consider the subsequent decision(s).

This appeal stands disposed of.

Urgent certified copy of this order be granted on proper application.

……..…………………

K.S. JHAVERI

(CHIEF JUSTICE)

……..……………………

K.R. MOHAPATRA

(JUDGE)

bks/jm

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →