Director Of Income Tax international Taxation-ii New Delhi vs. M/s Westerngeco International Ltd.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/43/2014HC UttarakhandUKHC01002572201413 November 2018Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ALOK SINGH2 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the law declared by a coordinate Division Bench of the same Court continues to bind it unless and until it is reversed by the Supreme Court. The Court noted that while the Revenue had appealed the earlier Division Bench judgment (Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012) to the Supreme Court and leave to appeal had been granted, the operation of that judgment had not been stayed. Therefore, following the binding precedent of its own Division Bench, the High Court dismissed the appeal preferred by the Revenue. The Court did not need to independently decide the question of law as it was bound by the prior judgment. The ratio decidendi is that a High Court is bound by its own Division Bench judgments unless they are stayed or overruled by the Supreme Court.

What were the facts?

This case involves an appeal by the Director of Income Tax (appellant) against M/s Western Geco International Ltd. (respondent-assessee). The appeal challenges a prior order, though the specific assessment year(s) and the authority that passed the order under challenge are not explicitly stated in this judgment. The procedural history indicates that the appellant's counsel fairly stated that the question of law in this appeal is covered by a Division Bench judgment of the Uttarakhand High Court in Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012 dated May 20, 2013. The Revenue had appealed this earlier judgment to the Supreme Court, and leave to appeal was granted, with the matter pending as Civil Appeal No. 770 of 2014. The operation of the Division Bench judgment had not been stayed.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the pendency of a Special Leave Petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court against a Division Bench judgment of the High Court renders that judgment inoperative for the purpose of binding a coordinate bench of the same High Court. Assessee's Contention: The mere pendency of an appeal before the Supreme Court does not render the earlier Division Bench judgment of the High Court inoperative. The Division Bench judgment continues to bind the High Court. Furthermore, the question of law has been decided in favour of the assessee by the Supreme Court in Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax & another, reported in AIR 2015 SC (Supp) 1862. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue acknowledged that the question of law is covered by a Division Bench judgment of the High Court but highlighted the pendency of their appeal before the Supreme Court.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

Income Tax Appeal No. 43 of 2014

Director of Income Tax.

..………. Appellant

Versus

M/s Western Geco International Ltd.

..………. Respondent

Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, Senior Standing Counsel for the appellant. Mr. Chetan Joshi, Advocate for the respondent.

JUDGMENT

Coram: Hon’ble Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J. Hon’ble Alok Singh, J.

Dated: 13th November, 2018

RAMESH RANGANATHAN, C.J. (Oral)

While fairly stating that the question of law, which arises for consideration in this appeal, is covered by a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012 dated 20.05.2013, Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Income Tax, would submit that, aggrieved by the said order, the Revenue has carried the matter in appeal to the Supreme Court; leave to appeal was granted by the Supreme Court; and the matter is pending in Civil Appeal No. 770 of 2014.

2.

Mr. Chetan Joshi, learned counsel for the respondent-assessee, would submit that mere pendency of an appeal before the Supreme Court does not render the earlier judgment of the Division Bench inoperative; the Division Bench judgment in Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012 dated 20.05.2013 would continue to bind this Court; and, in any event, the question of law, which arises for consideration in this appeal, has been answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue by the Supreme Court in Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax & another, reported in AIR 2015 SC (Supp) 1862.

3.

While leave to appeal has been granted by the Supreme Court against the order of the Division Bench in Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012 dated 20.05.2013, it is fairly stated by Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, learned Senior

Standing Counsel, that, to the best of his knowledge, operation of the said judgment has not been stayed.

4.

As the law declared by a coordinate Division Bench of this Court would continue to bind us, unless and until it is reversed by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 770 of 2014, we dismiss this appeal preferred by the Revenue following the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Income Tax Appeal No. 39 of 2012 dated 20.05.2013.

(Alok Singh, J.)

(Ramesh Ranganathan, C. J.) 13.11.2018

13.11.2018 G

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →