COMNR.,OF INCOME TAX vs. DIWAN CHAND GARG

PDF · subscribers
ITA/21/2012HC OrissaODHC01026719201214 November 2018Author: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE K.R.MOHAPATRA4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the CESTAT's conclusion that the demand of duty separately for the period prior to 07.04.2008 was not sustainable and that common registration could not be denied retrospectively was correct. The Court found no reason to defer from the view held by the CESTAT and the Supreme Court in M/s Lohia's case (Supra). The reasoning was based on the interpretation that the term 'factory of production' does not necessarily imply a single physical premise, but rather the complete process of production. The eight factors outlined by the Board were considered indicative of interlinkage, and in this case, the units were found to be part of the same integrated manufacturing process for tractors, despite physical separation by public roads. Therefore, the separate demand of duty was not sustainable.

What were the facts?

The appeals and writ petition concerned M/s Escorts Limited (Unit No.1), Faridabad, and the Commissioner of Central Excise. The core issue revolved around whether three units of the assessee, separated by public roads, constituted a single factory for the purpose of central excise registration and duty demand. The assessee argued that despite physical separation, the units were interlinked and part of a single manufacturing process for tractors. The revenue contended that separate registrations were required due to the distinct locations. The CESTAT had previously ruled that the demand of duty separately for the period prior to 07.04.2008 was not sustainable, and common registration could not be denied retrospectively.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the three units of M/s Escorts Limited, despite being physically separated by public roads, constitute a single 'factory of production' for the purpose of central excise registration, turning on the interpretation of the term 'used in the factory of production' and the guidelines issued by the Board vide notification dated 26.06.2001. Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that the units were interlinked, with parts manufactured in one unit and used in another for the final product (tractor). They relied on the eight factors outlined by the Board to demonstrate interlinkage, including common raw material receipt, electricity supply, labour, administration, sales tax, and income tax assessment. Revenue's Contentions: The revenue's position, as inferred from the context and the CESTAT's prior finding, was that separate registrations were necessitated by the separate premises, and common registration should not be granted retrospectively.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Not specified in the provided text

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN TH

Page 1 of 4 HE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA CHANDIGAR

AB AND HARYANA AT RH CEA-21-2012(O&M)

CEA-22-2012(O&M) CEA-23-2012(O&M) CEA-24-2012(O&M) CEA-25-2012(O&M) CEA-26-2012(O&M)

Escorts Limit Union of Indi CORAM: H

Present: M N

SANJEEV P

1.

By way petition are be 2. There i as the same production’ h sheet Produc 510..

Page 2 of 4 ted

a and others

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN Mr. Rishabh Kapoor, Sr. Standin for the appellant(s) (through vide None for the respondent(s).

RAKASH SHARMA, J.(Oral) y of this common order afore eing decided. is no question of law found to b is no more res integra. The has been interpreted by the Hon cts Vs. Commissioner of Custom

CWP-23630-2014(O&M) Date of Decision: 16.09.2024 NJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA NJAY VASHISTH ng Counsel eo conferencing mode).

esaid six appeals and one writ be made out in the present cases e term ‘used in the factory of n’ble Apex Court in ‘M/s Lohia ms New Delhi’ 2008 (11) SCC

3.

The guide provide that s are in separat or more prem interlinked, bu factors have t the same facto 4. The fac that these fac commissioner were being m were adjacent final good ava

Page 3 of 4 lines issued by the Board vide separate registration is normally te premises. However, there is a mises are actually part of the sam ut are segregated by public road to be examined to decide wheth ory and such eight factors are rep “(1) Interlinked process p in one premises are subst for manufacture of final pr (2) Large number of ra received/proposed to be r the premises. (3) common electricity sup (4) There is common labou (5) “Common administrati (6) Common sales tax regi (7) Common Income Tax a (8) Any other factor as ma of the manufacturing proce ctors have been outlined but th ctors are not exhaustive list of r to decide the issue. The CES manufactured at one premise whil t to one another, ultimately man ailable for sale.

e notification dated 26.06.2001 y required where the industries an exception in cases where two me factory, where processes are d, canal or railway line. Various er the two premises are parts of produced herebelow: product manufactured/produced tantially used in other premises roducts. w materials are common and received commonly for both/all pplies. ur/work force, ion/work management. istration and assessment. assessment. ay be indicative of inter linkage esses.” he notification in specific states f indicators and it was for the STAT found that tractor’s parts le the two other premises, which nufactured the tractor, which is a

d d l h

5.

Thus, t premises sepa namely the un factory of pro factory as suc Here the fin conclusion th 07.04.2008 w denied retrosp 6. We do or in the judg (Supra), the a 7. Pending accordingly.

September 16 Rashmi 1. Whethe 2. Whethe

Page 4 of 4 the said three units, although arated by public roads and at a c nit No.1 from unit No. 2 and 3 oduction. The word ‘factory of p ch, but the complete process of nal product being ‘a tractor’, hat the demand of duty sepa was not sustainable and the c pectively to the concerned respon not find any reason to defer from gment passed by the Hon’ble S aforesaid six appeals and the wri g miscellaneous application(s)

(SANJ , 2024 r speaking/reasoned?

Y r reportable?

separately situated in different certain distance from each other, were actually being used in the production’ would not indicate a production of the final product. the CESTAT has reached to rately for the period prior to ommon registration cannot be ndents. m the view as held by CESTAT Supreme Court in Lohia’s case it petition are hereby dismissed. ), if any, shall disposed of JEEV PRAKASH SHARMA) JUDGE

(SANJAY VASHISTH) JUDGE Yes/No Yes/No

, T

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →