M/S.RASHMI MOTORS vs. I.T.O.
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court noted that the tax payable on the sum added to the Assessee's income was not substantial enough to warrant interference. Consequently, the Court decided to leave the question of law open to be urged by the Assessee in an appropriate future case. The Court clarified that the impugned order of the ITAT would not constitute a precedent for any future case involving the Assessee where the same question of law arises. No specific finding was given on the merits of the issue regarding the discarding of books of account due to non-production of the stock register.
What were the facts?
The appeal by M/s. Rashmi Motors (the Assessee) is against an order dated 23rd March, 2006, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Cuttack Bench. The ITAT had confirmed an order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)], which partly allowed the Assessee's appeal against an assessment order dated 22nd March, 2004, passed by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The AO had added Rs.9,19,287/- to the Assessee's declared income, partly on the ground that the Assessee could not produce its stock register, leading the AO to disregard its books of account. The CIT(A) restricted this addition to Rs.1,96,625/-, a figure confirmed by the ITAT.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the learned courts below failed to appreciate that without finding any defects in the audited accounts of the appellant submitted under Section 44B of the Income Tax Act, the income of the appellant could be reassessed, on the basis of a finding that the overall margin of gross profit indicated by the assessee “does not compare well with the margin for the proceeding assessment year.” Assessee's contention: The mere non-production of the stock register was not a serious enough defect to discard the entire books of account. Reliance was placed on Pandit Bros. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR 1995 P & H 42. Revenue's contention: Maintaining a stock register is of great importance. Reliance was placed on S. N. Namasivayam Chettiar v. The Commissioner of Income Tax, 38 ITR 579 (SC).
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
// 1 //
Page 1 of 3
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK I.T.A. No.87 of 2006
M/s. Rashmi Motors …. Petitioner Mr. Sidhartha Ray, Advocate -versus- Income Tax Officer, Cuttack
…. Opposite Party Mr. R.S. Chimanka, Senior Standing Counsel Mr. A. Kedia, Standing Counsel
CORAM: THE CHIEF JUSTICE JUSTICE B. P. ROUTRAY
Order No. ORDER 26.03.2021
1. This appeal is directed against an order dated 23rd March, 2006 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack (ITAT) in ITA No.141/CTK/2005 for the assessment year 2001-02.
By the impugned order, the ITAT has confirmed the order dated 15th October. 2004 passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Cuttack [CIT(A)] partly allowing the Assessee’s IT Appeal No.47 of 2004-05 against an assessment order dated 22nd March, 2004 of the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 143 (3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (IT Act).
// 2 //
Page 2 of 3
While admitting this appeal, the following question of law was framed:
“(i) Whether the learned courts below failed to appreciate that without finding any defects in the audited accounts of the appellant submitted under Section 44B of the Income Tax Act, the income of the appellant could be reassessed, on the basis of a finding that the overall margin of gross profit indicated by the assessee “does not compare well with the margin for the proceeding assessment year.”
This Court heard the submissions of Mr. Ray, learned counsel for the Appellant and Mr. R.S. Chimanka, learned Senior Standing Counsel along with Mr. A. Kedia, learned Standing Court for the Respondent-Income Tax.
The Court notes straight away that the AO by the aforementioned assessment order added an income of Rs.9,19,287/- to the declared income after undertaking a scrutiny assessment. One of the grounds on which the addition was made was that the Assessee was unable to produce the stock register, and, therefore, its books of account were not relied upon.
The appellate authority restricted the addition to Rs.1,96, 625/-. By the impugned order, the ITAT has confirmed this.
Relying on the decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Pandit Bros. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR 1995 P & H 42 it is sought to be contended by Mr. Ray, learned counsel for the Appellant, that the mere non-production of the stock register was not such a serious defect so as to discard the entire books of account of the assessee. On the other hand, on the side of the
// 3 //
Page 3 of 3
Revenue reliance has been placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in S. N. Namasivayam Chettiar v. The Commissioner of Income Tax, 38 ITR 579 (SC) where it was observed that maintaining the stock register was of great importance.
Be that as it may, the Court is of the view that the tax payable on the sum added to the income of the Assessee for the assessment year in question is not so substantial as to warrant interference in the present matter. The better course is to leave the question of law open to be urged by the Assessee in an appropriate case.
It is clarified that the impugned order dated 23rd March, 2006 of the ITAT would not constitute a precedent in any future case involving the assessee in which the above question of law arises.
The appeal is accordingly disposed of in the above terms.
(Dr. S. Muralidhar) Chief Justice
(B.P. Routray) Judge
S.K. Jena/P.A.
More judgments on Section 44B
- The Director of Income Tax, International… vs M/S Star Cruises (India) P. LtdC.A. No.-003334-003336 - 201230 Jul 2026
- Arc Line, Mumbai vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax…ITITA 965/MUM/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed30 Jun 2026AY 2022-23
- Arc Line, Mumbai vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax…ITITA 584/MUM/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed30 Jun 2026AY 2017-18
- Arc Line, Mumbai vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax…ITITA 583/MUM/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed30 Jun 2026AY 2016-17
- Bay Lines, Mumbai vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax…ITITA 524/MUM/2026[2023-24]Status: Disposed30 Jun 2026AY 2023-24
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Anjanarani Jena vs. The Commissioner,CGST, Cx And CustomsOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- M/S Alok Kumar Sethi, Bhubaneswar vs. Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Natuk Mra vs. The Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 10 Nov 2026
- Tatvam Procon Private Limited, Gujarat vs. Commissioner Of CT And GST, CuttackOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Swapna Acharya vs. Superintendent, GST And Central Excise, Bhubaneswar-1Orissa · 10 Nov 2026