BHARAT KUMAR PARAKH,JODHPUR vs. ACIT DC CC 2, JODHPUR, JODHPUR

PDF · subscribers
ITA 84/JODH/2025Status: DisposedITAT Jodhpur03 November 2026AY 2019-202012 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal found that the CIT(A) rejected the valuation reports dated June 17, 2005, solely on the ground that the assessee did not state whether such jewellery was shown in wealth tax returns. The Tribunal noted that the Wealth-tax Act was abolished from AY 2016-17, making the absence of such a return irrelevant for rejecting a valuer's report. The Tribunal also observed that the CIT(A)'s order was silent on tax invoices for gold jewellery and silver, which were mentioned in the assessee's submissions. The Tribunal noted a conflict between the CIT(A)'s finding that the explanation was unsupported by documentary evidence and the assessee's submission that valuation reports and tax invoices were enclosed. Therefore, the Tribunal restored the issue of the addition of Rs. 47,23,844/- to the file of the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO) for fresh adjudication. The JAO is directed to verify the genuineness and relevance of the tax invoices and valuation reports, check for overlaps or double counting of quantities, consider the reasonableness of the holding in light of the family's status and decisions cited, and ascertain if the valuables were part of any settlement proceedings to avoid double taxation. The Tribunal clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the addition, and all contentions were left open. Grounds 1 to 4 were allowed for statistical purposes. Grounds 5 and 6, relating to interest and penalty, were consequential and not adjudicated.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Bharat Kumar Parakh, is an individual belonging to the Rajlaxmi Group. A search and seizure action under section 132(1) was conducted on February 19, 2019, covering the assessee's residence. Valuables including gold jewellery, precious stones, and silver articles worth Rs. 79,58,594/- were found. The Assessing Officer (AO) accepted 950 gms of gold jewellery valued at Rs. 32,34,750/- based on CBDT Instruction No. 1916 and a jurisdictional High Court decision. The remaining valuables, amounting to Rs. 47,23,844/-, were treated as unexplained under section 69A and taxed under section 115BBE. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld this addition. The assessment year in question is 2019-20, and the assessment order was passed under section 143(3) r.w.s. 153B(1)(b) dated June 22, 2021.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the addition of Rs. 47,23,844/- representing unexplained jewellery (silver) under section 69A r.w.s. 115BBE of the Income Tax Act, 1961, made by the AO and upheld by the CIT(A), is valid? 2. Whether the assessment order, which made the addition of jewellery (silver) found during search and seizure, should be quashed for violating principles of natural justice and for disregarding the assessee's submissions? 3. Whether the addition of silver jewellery found during search and seizure should be quashed as it was explained by the assessee with documentary evidence like government-approved registered valuer reports and tax invoices? 4. Whether the addition of silver found during search and seizure proceedings should be upheld without considering the status and standing of the family? 5. Whether the levy of interest under section 234B amounting to Rs. 10,02,618/- is valid? 6. Whether the initiation of penalty under section 271AAB is valid? Assessee's contentions: The jewellery and ornaments belonged to family members and were explained by valuation reports dated June 17, 2005, by a Government approved Registered Valuer and tax invoices for acquisition. Most jewellery was 'stridhan' or gifts received by female members. The AO and CIT(A) erred in not considering this evidence and the family's status. The AO's query was specific to gold jewellery, not silver or precious stones. The CIT(A) wrongly rejected the valuation report for not being shown in wealth tax returns, which were abolished. Reliance was placed on decisions like CIT v. Satya Narain Patni, Jai Kumar Jain, and Ram Prakash Mahawar. Revenue's contentions: Not recorded in the judgment.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 69A,Section 115BBE,Section 143(3),Section 153B(1)(b),Section 132(1),Section 127,Section 142(1),Section 234B,Section 271AAB

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, JODHPUR BENCHES, JODHPUR

Before: SHRI AMIT SHUKLA & SHRI GIRISH AGRAWAL

For Respondent: Shri O.P. Meena – CIT DR
Pronounced: 03.11.2026

INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, JODHPUR BENCHES, JODHPUR BENCH: DB BEFORE SHRI AMIT SHUKLA, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI GIRISH AGRAWAL, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA 84/JODH/2025 (िनधा�रण वष�/Assessment Year: 2019-20) Bharat Kumar Parakh ACIT DC CC 2, Jodhpur 59, Paras House, Narpat Nagar, Pal Road, Aayakar Bhawan, Paota-C Road, Jodhpur – 342008, Jodhpur – 342010 Vs. Rajasthan Rajasthan अपीलाथ� Appellant ��थ� Respondent

Permanent Account Number of Assessee: ABZPP2175M

अपीलाथ� �ारा/Appellant represented by: Ms. Simran Dhawan, Advocate ��थ� �ारा/Respondent represented by: Shri O.P. Meena – CIT DR

सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 13.08.2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 03.11.2026 O R D E R PER GIRISH AGRAWAL, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: This appeal filed by assessee is directed against the order of ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Jaipur-5 vide DIN & Order No. ITBA/APL/S/250/2024-25/1070814671(1) dated 02.12.2024 arising from assessment order passed by ld. Assessing Officer under section 143(3) r.w.s. 153B(1)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act") dated 22.06.2021 for Assessment Year 2019-20.

2.

The grounds of appeal raised by the assessee are as under: 1. On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 47,23,844/- u/s 69A r.w.s 115BBE of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [hereafter referred as "the Act"] made by the ld. Assessing Officer in the impugned assessment order passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s 153B(1)(b) of the Act dated 22.06.2021.

2.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in not quashing the impugned assessment order wherein the Assessing Officer has made addition of jewellery (Silver) found during the course of search & seizure action to the extent of Rs 47,23,844/- disregarding the detailed submission of the appellant, which is in gross violation of principles of natural justice.

3.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in not quashing the impugned assessment order wherein the Assessing Officer has made addition of jewellery (silver) found during the course of search & seizure action even though the same remained explained backed by Government approved Registered Valuer, tax invoices, etc.

4.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in upholding the addition of silver found during the course of search & seizure proceedings without considering the status and standing of the family.

5.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in upholding the levy of interest u/s 234B amounting to Rs. 10,02,618/-.

6.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the appellant's case and in law, the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in upholding the initiation of penalty u/s 271AAB of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

3.

Brief facts of the case are that assessee is an individual. Return of income was filed on 22.08.2019, reporting total income at Rs. 24,93,720/-. A search and seizure action u/s 132(1) was carried out on 19.02.2019, at various premises of Rajlaxmi Group, Jodhpur. Assessee belongs to this group. His residence at 85 Amar Nagar Pal Road Jodhpur was also covered under the search action. Consequent to the search, jurisdiction over assessee was transferred to Central Circle-2 Jodhpur by order u/s 127 of Pr. CIT (Central) Jaipur dated 29.12.2020. Case was selected for compulsory scrutiny. Notice u/s 143(2) was issued on 13.03.2021 and notice u/s 142(1) was issued on 10.04.2021. Assessee filed replies on 23.04.2021 and 16.06.2021. Assessment was completed on 22.06.2021 determining total income at Rs. 72,17,560/-.

3.1. During the search, following valuables were found: i. gold jewellery weighing 263.477 gms valued at Rs. 8,97,136/-, precious stones of 5.10 Ct. valued at Rs. 76,500/- and silver articles weighing 0.549 kg valued at Rs. 22,618/- from residence of assessee; ii. gold jewellery weighing 1999.143 gms valued at Rs. 68,04,622/-, precious stones of 562.50 Ct. valued at Rs. 22,500/- and silver articles weighing 3.282 kg valued at Rs. 1,35,218/- from locker no. 10 of assessee at ICICI Bank Pal Road Jodhpur; and iii. total valuables thus found from premises of assessee amounted to Rs. 79,58,594/-.

4.

Ld. AO recorded that jewellery found from possession of parents of assessee namely, Paras Mal Parakh and Jethi Devi Parakh as per annexure JF-II was not added to income of assessee. This was on the basis of jewellery inventory and submission of assessee. Ld. AO further recorded that vide notice u/s 142(1) dated 10.04.2021 assessee was asked to explain source of gold jewellery found at residence and in locker. Assessee filed reply on 16.06.2021. Ld. AO took note of the family of assessee comprising assessee himself his wife his son and daughter.

4.1. Considering CBDT Instruction No. 1916 dated 11.05.1994, tradition in Hindu culture and decision of jurisdictional High Court in CIT v. Satya Narain Patni [2014] taxmann.com 440 (Raj), ld. AO found 950 gms of gold jewellery valued at Rs. 32,34,750/- acceptable. However ld. AO held that assessee failed to produce documentary evidence in support of remaining valuables found from residence and locker amounting to Rs. 47,23,844/-. This is the balance of Rs. 79,58,594/- left after allowing Rs. 32,34,750/-. Remaining valuables were accordingly treated as unexplained u/s 69A and added to total income. Ld. AO directed that it be taxed as per section 115BBE. Aggrieved, assessee went in appeal before ld. CIT(A).

5.

During the hearing before the first appellate authority, assessee submitted that jewellery and ornaments found during search belonged to family members as under: S.No. Name of Family Jewellery & ornaments (in gms) Silver (in kg) Member 1 Jethi Devi Parakh 379.80 12.13 2 Mahendra Parakh 539.70 15.99 3 Bharti Parakh 318.60 - 4 Sangeeta Parakh 2830.22 3.83 Total 4068.32 31.96

5.1 It was submitted that entire jewellery and ornaments stood reconciled with valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 of Government approved Registered Valuer Shri Patel Umesh Kantilal bearing registration no. CAT. VIII-118-2004-05 and tax invoices for acquisition of jewellery and ornaments. Summary of the same as filed is reproduced below: Jewellery & ornaments as per valuation reports of Sr. Name of Family Silver Government approved No. members (in Kg.) Registered valuer and Tax Invoices (in Grams) 1 Parasmal parakh 513.50 18.79 2 Jethi Devi Parakh 890.05 6.08 3 Mahendra Parakh 670.35 4.91 4 Bharti Parkh 850.52 6.20 5 Bharat Parakh 627.40 - 6 Sangeeta Parakh 1226.89 4.68 Total 4778.71 40.66

5.2 It was further submitted that valuation reports record gold jewellery and ornaments of 4066.65 gms and silver of 24.67 kg. Tax invoices evidence purchase of 712.06 gms of gold jewellery and ornaments and 15.99 kg of silver. Assessee also submitted that most of the jewellery and precious stones belong to female members and were received as ‘stridhan’ and as gifts on various occasions such as marriage, anniversaries, house warming and birth of children. Status of family was also pleaded. Assessee relied on various judicial precedents and prayed for deletion of addition.

5.3 Ld. CIT(A) did not accept valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 on the ground that assessee had not stated whether such jewellery was shown in wealth tax return. It was held that in absence of wealth tax return authenticity of valuation report was not proved and that merely submitting such report was meaningless. Judicial precedents cited were held distinguishable on facts. It was noted that in Jai Kumar Jain jewellery was offered in VDIS and in Ram Prakash Mahawar 50% of silver was accepted as explained. Other decisions were held to relate to jewellery explained after considering CBDT Instruction No. 1916. Ld. CIT(A) noted that ld. AO had already allowed 950 gms of gold jewellery on the basis of the Instruction. It was held that assessee was unable to substantiate procurement and source of the excess jewellery and silver with documentary evidence. The addition was confirmed and the appeal was dismissed. Aggrieved, assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal.

6.

Before us, ld. Counsel for the assessee submitted that valuables found from residence and locker of assessee comprising gold jewellery, precious stones and silver belonged to family members and that their source stood explained. Valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 record gold jewellery of 4066.65 gms and silver of 24.67 kg. Tax invoices for 712.06 gms of gold jewellery and ornaments and 15.99 kg of silver were also furnished. Ld. Counsel submitted that ld. CIT(A) discarded valuation reports solely because assessee did not demonstrate that jewellery was reflected in wealth tax return. Wealth-tax Act stood abolished with effect from AY 2016-17 and no wealth tax return was required for AY 2019- 20. Absence of such return cannot be read as evidence against assessee. Valuation report of Government approved Registered Valuer is independent and contemporaneous third party evidence. Its value is not extinguished merely because it was not referred in a wealth tax return. Tax invoices are primary evidence of acquisition independent of wealth tax compliance. Ld. CIT(A) has not recorded any adverse finding on genuineness of these invoices. Ld. Counsel submitted that finding of ld. CIT(A) that explanation is unsupported by documentary evidence does not correctly appreciate material on record.

6.1 Ld. Counsel submitted that jewellery and precious stones were received as ‘stridhan’ and as gifts on marriages and other occasions and that silver formed part of customary holdings of family accumulated over years. Reliance was placed on following decisions: i. Jai Kumar Jain v. ACIT [2007] 11 SOT 61 (JP.)(URO) wherein silver of 16.895 kg was held reasonable looking to size and status of family of assessee; ii. Ram Prakash Mahawar v. DCIT ITA No. 918/JP/2019 (Jaipur Bench) wherein Tribunal found no error in order of ld. CIT(A) treating 50% of silver items valued at Rs. 1,33,650/- as reasonable holding considering status and standing of family; iii. Preeti Singh v. ACIT [2023] 156 taxmann.com 485 (Delhi-Trib.) wherein addition u/s 69A on account of 227 gms jewellery found in bank locker was deleted as jewellery was gifted on various occasions such as marriage and birth of children; iv. Chandra Pal v. ACIT [2023] 156 taxmann.com 472 (Delhi-Trib.) wherein addition u/s 69A on account of excess jewellery was deleted as assessee had shown sufficient income in returns of preceding years and jewellery was received on several occasions from relatives; v. Ashok Chaddha v. ITO [2011] 14 taxmann.com 57 (Delhi) of Hon'ble Delhi High Court for the proposition that no addition u/s 69A is called for where jewellery stands explained by wealthy status of family and receipt from relatives on several occasions; and vi. Vibhu Aggarwal v. DCIT [2018] 93 taxmann.com 275 (Delhi-Trib.) wherein excess jewellery was held reasonable as assessee belonged to a wealthy family and jewellery was received on occasions from relatives. 6.2 Ld. Counsel further submitted that Rajlaxmi Group had filed settlement application before Income Tax Settlement Commission on 26.12.2019 pursuant to the search of 19.02.2019. Additional income of approximately Rs. 63.36 crores was offered therein. According to ld. Counsel, this additional income encompasses transactions or amounts forming subject matter of impugned addition. Income already offered and taxed in hands of group entities or persons cannot be taxed again in hands of assessee. Reliance was placed on decision of this Tribunal in Kushal Jain v. DCIT ITA No. 835/Jodh/2025 order dated 07.08.2026 arising from same search. In that case addition of Rs. 25,000/- in hands of assessee was held to be part of additional income offered by M/s Rajlakshmi Industries in settlement application. Since the application had been acted upon by Interim Board, the addition was deleted. Ld. Counsel submitted that impugned addition is independently liable to be deleted to the extent corresponding income has been offered and dealt with in settlement proceedings.

6.3 Ld. Counsel further submitted that levy of interest u/s 234B and initiation of penalty u/s 271AAB are consequential to the quantum addition.

7.

We have heard rival submissions and perused material placed on record. Issue before us is narrow. Gold jewellery to the extent of 950 gms valued at Rs. 32,34,750/- found during search has been accepted as explained by ld. AO. What remains in dispute is addition of Rs. 47,23,844/- on account of balance gold jewellery, precious stones and silver found from residence and locker of assessee. Section 69A reads as under: "Where in any financial year the assessee is found to be the owner of any money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article and such money, bullion, jewellery or valuable article is not recorded in the books of account, if any, maintained by him for any source of income, and the assessee offers no explanation about the nature and source of acquisition of the money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article, or the explanation offered by him is not, in the opinion of the Assessing Officer, satisfactory, the money and the market value of the bullion, jewellery or other valuable article may be deemed to be the income of the assessee for such financial year." [Emphasis supplied by us by bold and underline]

7.1 Plain reading shows that addition u/s 69A rests on absence of explanation or an explanation which is not satisfactory. Opinion of ld. AO on this aspect has to be formed after due consideration of explanation offered and evidence furnished by assessee.

7.2 Ld. AO records that notice u/s 142(1) dated 10.04.2021 asked assessee to explain source of gold jewellery found at residence and in locker. Assessment order records no query specific to precious stones or silver. Ld. AO concluded that assessee failed to produce documentary evidence in support of remaining valuables. Assessment order does not discuss valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 or tax invoices which as per submission reproduced by ld. CIT(A) were enclosed by assessee as Annexure 2 and Annexure 3 with reply filed before ld. AO. Assessment order is also silent on contents of reply dated 16.06.2021 as regards these valuables.

7.3 Ld. CIT(A) noted that valuation report of 2005 was furnished but did not accept it for want of wealth tax return. Order of ld. CIT(A) is silent on tax invoices for 712.06 gms of gold jewellery and ornaments and 15.99 kg of silver which find mention in the submission reproduced in the same order. It contains no examination of these invoices viz. dates, parties, quantity and nexus with valuables found. It also does not show that any remand report was called from ld. AO on this aspect.

7.4 We find that ld. CIT(A) discarded valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 solely on the ground that assessee did not state whether jewellery was shown in wealth-tax return. It is submitted that Wealth- tax Act stood abolished with effect from AY 2016-17 and no wealth tax return was required for year under consideration. Absence of such return cannot by itself be a ground to reject valuation report of a Government approved Registered Valuer. Whether jewellery was reflected in any earlier wealth tax return is a matter of verification. We also find an assumption in the order of ld. CIT(A) that stands in conflict with the record. Ld. CIT(A) holds that explanation is unsupported by documentary evidence. The written submission reproduced in the same order refers to valuation reports at Annexure 2 and tax invoices at Annexure 3. This conflict cannot be resolved without verification of valuation reports and invoices.

7.5 Ld. CIT(A) held that possession of jewellery to the extent specified in CBDT Instruction No. 1916 stands explained and that ld. AO had rightly allowed 950 gms of gold jewellery. This does not conclude the matter for balance valuables. Explanation of assessee does not rest on the Instruction alone. It rests also on documentary evidence and on status and customs of family. Reasonableness of holding is a question of fact to be examined with reference to quantity found and status of family. Decisions cited by ld. Counsel viz. Jai Kumar Jain and Ram Prakash Mahawar (supra) deal with silver specifically. Ld. CIT(A) held precedents cited to be distinguishable but did so by noting limited features of two decisions. Facts of other decisions were not examined against facts of assessee.

8.

In view of the above, we find it appropriate to restore the issue of addition of Rs. 47,23,844/- to the file of ld. Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO) for limited purposes. Ld. JAO shall decide the issue afresh after considering the following: i. tax invoices for 712.06 gms of gold jewellery and ornaments and 15.99 kg of silver and valuation reports dated 17.06.2005 recording gold jewellery of 4066.65 gms and silver of 24.67 kg. Ld. JAO shall verify their genuineness and whether they relate to gold jewellery and silver found from residence and locker of assessee. Ld. JAO shall also verify whether quantity as per invoices is independent of or overlaps with quantity recorded by valuer and whether same documents are claimed by other family members so that same quantity is not counted twice; ii. reasonableness of holding of gold jewellery in excess of 950 gms and of precious stones and silver by the family considering its size and status along with decisions cited before us; and iii. whether valuables found or their value of Rs. 47,23,844/- forms part of additional income offered by Rajlaxmi Group in settlement application and dealt with in settlement proceedings. If so ld. JAO shall decide accordingly so as to avoid taxing same income twice. 8.1 Assessee shall furnish all evidences in support of its claim before ld. JAO and shall cooperate in the proceedings without seeking unnecessary adjournments. Ld. JAO shall grant reasonable opportunity of being heard to assessee before passing the order. Ld. JAO is directed to decide the issue in accordance with law.

8.2 We clarify that we have not expressed any opinion on merits of the addition. All contentions of both sides are left open for consideration by ld. JAO. Accordingly, grounds 1 to 4 are allowed for statistical purposes.

8.3 Grounds 5 and 6 relating to levy of interest u/s 234B and initiation of penalty u/s 271AAB are consequential in nature and are therefore not adjudicated upon separately at this stage.

9.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in terms of Proviso to Rule 34(4) of Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963 on 03 November, 2026

Sd/- Sd/- (Amit Shukla) (Girish Agrawal) Judicial Member Accountant Member Dated: 03 November, 2026 MP, Sr.P.S.

Copy to : 1 The Appellant 2 The Respondent 3 DR, ITAT, Mumbai 4 Guard File 5 CIT BY ORDER, NIMISHA Digitally signed by NIMISHA ARORA ARORA Date: 2026.11.03 16:26:44 +05'30' (Dy./Asstt.Registrar) ITAT, Jodhpur

More judgments on Section 69A

All 15,970 judgments and leading authorities on Section 69A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →