ROYAL CONNAUGHT BOAT CLUB vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 2(2), PUNE AND ORS

PDF · subscribers
WP/4431/2014HC BombayHCBM01016418201411 November 2014Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.S. SANKLECHA,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE S.C. GUPTE8 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the issue concerning the reopening of assessment within four years, based on the Assessing Officer having not applied their mind to certain income heads, was concluded against the Petitioner by the Court's own decision in Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra). The Court reiterated the principle from that case, stating that to hold an Assessing Officer has accepted what they have overlooked or ignored would render Section 147 meaningless. The Court emphasized that when reopening occurs within four years, the test is whether there is tangible material, not necessarily new material. If income has escaped assessment due to the Assessing Officer ignoring relevant material, the jurisdictional requirement for reopening is fulfilled. The Court also noted that the Petitioner had not raised the objection of 'change of opinion' in their objections filed before the Assessing Officer, deeming it an afterthought, although it acknowledged that a jurisdictional defect like limitation would still be invalid regardless of objection. The Court found no reason to interfere with the impugned notice and dismissed the petition.

What were the facts?

The Petitioner, Royal Connaught Boat Club, challenged a notice dated March 25, 2013, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to reopen its assessment for Assessment Year (AY) 2008-09. The challenge also extended to the assessment order dated March 20, 2014, passed after rejecting the Petitioner's objections. Initially, the Petitioner had filed an appeal before the CIT(Appeals) against the assessment order. However, due to the court's observation that parallel proceedings could not be prosecuted, the Petitioner withdrew the appeal before the CIT(Appeals) to pursue the present writ petition. The Petitioner's primary arguments revolved around the principle of mutuality and the contention that the reopening notice was without jurisdiction due to a change of opinion by the Assessing Officer.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the notice dated March 25, 2013, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for AY 2008-09 is without jurisdiction on the ground that the entire income was governed by the principle of mutuality and hence not taxable? (Question of law) 2. Whether the notice dated March 25, 2013, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for AY 2008-09 is without jurisdiction on the ground that the Assessing Officer had applied his mind to all material facts during the original assessment proceedings under Section 143(3) of the Act, thus constituting a change of opinion? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contentions: - The entire income was governed by the principle of mutuality and therefore not taxable. - The impugned notice is without jurisdiction as the Assessing Officer had applied his mind to all material facts during the original assessment under Section 143(3), indicating a change of opinion. Relied on the principle that a change of opinion by itself is not a valid basis for reopening an assessment. (Implicitly, based on the arguments presented). Revenue's Contentions: - The Assessing Officer had not applied his mind to the claims of income from advertisement charges, catering charges, space hiring charges, and guest fees during the original proceedings. Relied on the decision in Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra) to argue that the Petitioner's contention is no longer open to debate.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148,Section 143(3),Section 147

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

dik

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 4431 OF 2014

Royal Connaught Boat Club, ...Petitioner vs Income Tax Officer & Ors. ...Respondents ..... Mr Prakash Pandit a/w Vijay Pandit and P.C.Tripathi for the Petitioner Mr Vimal Gupta Sr. Advocate for the Respondents. ..... CORAM : M.S.SANKLECHA & S.C. GUPTE, JJ. NOVEMBER 11, 2014 P.C. : This Petition challenges: (a) notice dated 25 March 2013 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ( for short “the Act”), seeking to reopen the assessment for the assessment year 2008-09; and (b) assessment order dated 20 March 2014 for A.Y. 2008-09 passed consequent to the rejection of the objections of the Petitioner to the notice dated 25 March 2013.

During the pendency of this Petition, the Petitioner had filed an appeal to the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) (Appeals), against the order of assessment dated 20 March 2014 in respect of A.Y. 2008-09. This appeal was preferred consequent to the order dated 2 May 2014 of this Court. Be that as it may, thereafter when the Petition came up for admission on 10 September the Petitioner was informed that it would not be open to prosecute two parallel proceedings. Therefore, the petitioner had to prosecute either this Petition or the appeal filed before CIT (Appeals), the Petitioner chose to withdraw the appeal filed before CIT (Appeals) and prosecute the present Petition. Pg 1 of 8

The Petitioner has essentially challenged the impugned notice on two grounds, firstly that the entire income was governed by the principle of mutuality, therefore not taxable and secondly that during passing of the assessment order in regular proceedings on 16 December 2010 under Section 143(3) of the Act all material facts necessary for passing an assessment order were on record before the Assessing Officer and, therefore the impugned notice is without jurisdiction. By our order dated 10 September 2014, we concluded that the income arising on account of advertisement charges, space hire charges, guest fees and catering charges which form basis of the impugned notice, would not be governed by the concept of mutuality as the very basis of mutuality i.e. the identity of contributors and participators, is not satisfied. So far as the second issue is concerned, we were prima facie of the view that no inquiry during original scrutiny proceedings under Section 143(3) of the Act was made in respect of the income arising on account of advertisement charges, space hiring charges, guest fees and catering charges before passing the assessment order dated 16 December 2004 under Section 143(3) of the Act. However, in view of the fact that Top 50 Asien Vs Deputy Director of Income Tax in WP No.1452 of 2012 was admitted on 16 June 2014, on the ground that there appears to be conflict / divergence of views in the decisions rendered by this Court in Asian Paints Ltd. Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr, (2009) 308 ITR 195 (Bom) and Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. Vs Additional CIT & Ors in (2013) 350 ITR 651 (Bom). The divergence appeared to be in respect of whether in respect of a notice issued within four years from the end of the relevant assessment years mere furnishing/disclosure of information during the assessment proceedings would bar the Assessing Officer from reopening the assessment or that application of mind for the furnished/ disclosed information by an Assessing Officer would alone bar issuing of reopening notice. Therefore, in the above view, this Petition, though not admitted at that point of time, was placed for hearing along with Top 50 Asian (supra).

When this matter along with Top 50 Asian (supra) was heard by this Court, it was pointed out to us that both the decisions in Asian Paints Ltd. Pg 2 of 8

(supra) and Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra) are completely reconcilable particularly in view of the fact that the decision rendered in Asian Paints Ltd (supra) was prior to the decision of CIT Vs Kelvinator of India Ltd. 350 ITR 561 (SC) and therefore after the decision in Kelvinator of India Ltd (supra) the mere giving of information would not amount to application of mind and the notice for reopening in such cases may be sustainable. At that point of time, both the Petitioners as well as counsel appearing for Top 50 Asian submitted that the issue being urged by both of them is not on the basis of Asian Paints Ltd (supra) but on the basis that there has been change of opinion in issuing the impugned notice as there was application of mind during the regular assessment proceedings. Therefore, the impugned notice is without jurisdiction even if it is issued within a period of four years from the end of the relevant assessment order. We, therefore, by an order dated 13 October 2013 recalled our order admitting Top 50 Asian (supra) and had subsequently placed the matter for admission on the ground being urged by the Petitioner therein that there has been change of opinion, in view of application of mind making the impugned notice bad. Similar has been the contention of the Petitioner herein.

Now coming to the facts of the present Petition, the impugned notice dated 25 March 2013, seeking to reopen the assessment for the assessment year 2008-09 is supported by the following reasons: 1. The assessee has filed its return of income for the A.Y. 2008-09 on 26/09/2008, returning taxable income of Rs.Nil. 2. According to the decision of the Supreme Court of India in case of M/s Bangalore Club dated 14/01/2013, the interest earned by the mutual association from deposits placed with member banks is not exempt on the ground of mutuality. The Supreme Court also held that for any receipt to be exempt on the principles of mutuality, three conditions have to be satisfied viz. (I) there must be a complete identity between the contributors and participators, ii) the actions of the participators and contributors must be in furtherance of the mandate of the association and iii) there must be no scope of profiteering by the contributors from a fund made by them, which could be Pg 3 of 8

only be expended or returned by them. 3. As per the financial statements submitted by the assessee to the Department for the relevant year, it is observed that it has received Advertisement Charges of Rs.92,022/- and Space hiring charges of Rs.17,52,680/- against which the assessee has offered Nil income for taxation. However, since the said Advertisement charges & space hiring charges have been received from outsiders who are not members of the club, therefore, the said receipts on account of Advertisement charges and space hiring charges do not satisfy the principles of mutuality as laid out by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the above mentioned order and accordingly all receipts should be taxed in the hands of the assessee. Therefore, the receipts of Rs.18,44,702/- has escaped the assessment for the relevant year. 4. Further, it is observed that for the relevant year, the assessee has shown Guest Fees of Rs.8,84,792/- and the same have been claimed as fully exempt by relying upon the principles of mutuality. However, in view of the above mentioned decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the said Guest Fees do not satisfy the principles of mutuality and hence, are taxable in the hands of assessee. Accordingly, the income of Rs.8,84,792/- has also escaped assessment for the relevant year. 5. Further, during the relevant year, the assessee has received Rs.23,34,503/- as the administrative charges – catering and has offered Nil income at tax relying on the principles of mutuality. However, in view of the above mentioned decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the entire receipts from catering to guests of members is taxable as the principles of mutuality are not satisfied. Accordingly, the income of Rs.23,34,503/- has escaped assessment for the relevant year. 6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.124 of 2007 in the case of M/s Bangalore Club, Bangalore in its order dated 14/01/2013 has only interpreted the principle of mutuality and the corresponding law on this issue was already in existence since the time it was framed by the legislature. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has given the correct interpretation which was not earlier available to the assessing officers. As the law, which was already in existence has now been interpreted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the cases Pg 4 of 8

involving this issue are required to be assessed as per the said interpretation of the principle of mutuality laid out in the said order of the Supreme Court dated 14/01/2013. 7. In view of the above discussion, I have reasons to believe that the income totally aggregating to Rs.50,63,997/- (Rs.18,44,702/- (+) Rs.8,84,792/- (+) Rs.23,34,503/-) chargeable to tax has escaped the assessment for the year relevant to assessment year 2008-09. Issue notice u/s 148 of the I.T.Act for reopening the assessment for A.Y. 2008-09.”

The Petitioner objected to the proposed reopening of the assessment by the communication dated 18 February 2014. The objections were rejected by the order dated 3 March 2014 by the Assessing Officer.

Mr Pandit, learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the impugned notice is a clear case of change of opinion on the part of the Assessing Officer and therefore, without jurisdiction. In support, it is submitted by him that the return of income was appended with a note to the effect that the Petitioner is a members club and has always been held to be a mutual association covered by the concept of mutuality. Therefore, exempted from the income tax. In its return of income, particularly in their profit and loss account and balance-sheet, the Petitioner had claimed space hiring charges, guest fees, catering charges, advertisement charges as well as interest on bank deposits, as being exempted from tax on the concept of mutuality. It is submitted that the Assessing Officer by a communication dated 6 December 2010, during the regular assessment proceedings called upon the Petitioner to explain how the interest received from bank deposits by the Petitioner would be covered by the concept of mutuality. Therefore, it follows that the Assessing Officer had applied his mind to the income claimed to be not taxable on account of guest fees, advertisement charges, space hiring charges and catering charges and had come to a conclusion that the same is covered by the concept of mutuality. Therefore, it is submitted that the impugned notice is without jurisdiction.

Mr Gupta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Revenue, Pg 5 of 8

points out that during the original proceedings the Assessing Officer had not applied his mind to the claim of income on the four heads i.e. advertisement charges, catering charges, space hiring charges and guest fees which form the basis of the impugned notice. In particular, he invites our attention to the decision of this Court in Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra), and submit that the contention raised by the Petitioner is no longer open to a debate.

We find that this Court in the case of Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra) had occasion to deal with the similar submission as made by the Petitioner herein. It will be better to reproduce the observations made by the Court with regard to the identical submissions as under: “8. To hold that the Assessing Officer must be deemed to have accepted what he has plainly overlooked or ignored in the assessment order would be to stretch the interpretation of section 147 to a point where the provision would cease to have meaning and content. Such an exercise of excision by judicial interpretation is impermissible. When an assessment is sought to be reopened withina period of four years of the end of the relevant assessment year, the test to be applied is whether there is tangible material to do so. What is tangible is something which is not illusory, hypothetical or a matter of conjecture. Something which is tangible need not be something which is new. An Assessing Officer who has plinly ignored relevant material in arriving at an assessment acts contrary to law. If there is an escapement of income in consequence, the jurisdictional requirement of section 147 would be fulfilled on the formation of a reason to believe that income has escaped assessment. The reopening of the assessment within a period of four years is in these circumstances within jurisdiction. 9. ---- 10. The salient aspect of the case that merits emphasis is that the order of assessment that was passed by the Assessing Officer under section 143 (3) is completely silent in respect of each one of the five points on the basis of which the assessment is sought to be reopened. There is merit in the contention which has been urged on Pg 6 of 8

behalf of the Revenue that no query had been raised during the course of the assessment and the assessment order would ex facie disclose that the Assessing Officer has not applied his mind at all to any of the points on the basis of which the assessment is now sought to be reopened........”

We find that the issue, as raised by the Petitioner is concluded against them by the decision of this Court in Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra). Accordingly, we see no reason to interfere with the impugned notice dated 25 March 2013.

Before closing, we may also point out that in the objections filed by the Petitioner to the reasons given in support of the impugned notice, the Petitioner had not taken up the objection that the impugned notice is without jurisdiction as it is issued on account of change of opinion. We find that the objection taken by the Petitioner was essentially on the merits of its claim that advertisement charges, catering charges, space hiring charges and guest fees, are all covered under the concept of mutuality and therefore not taxable. The Petitioner had not, at any stage, before filing of this Petition taken up the objection with regard to there being a change of opinion on the part of the Assessing Officer while issuing the impugned notice. We are conscious of the fact that if a notice is without jurisdiction, then mere non taking of the objections to reopening notice, would not result in reopening notice, being a notice within jurisdiction, to illustrate if a notice is beyond the period of limitation. However, when the issue for consideration would require some element of facts and application of mind to those facts to rule on a change of opinion, the same should be taken up in the objection filed before the Assessing Officer. This alone would enable the Assessing Officer to decide the objections appropriately. The objection being now taken appears to be a clear case of an afterthought. In any case, the issue stands concluded against the Petitioner by the decision of this case in Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (supra).

Thus, we see no reason to entertain this Petition in the exercise of Pg 7 of 8

our writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. We would also make it clear that we have only examined the merits of the Petitioner's case in the context of the jurisdictional challenge to issue the impugned notice.

Accordingly, the Petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. ( S.C.GUPTE J. )

( M.S.SANKLECHA J. ) Pg 8 of 8

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →