GHODAWAT ENERGY PVT. LTD. vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ORS.

PDF · subscribers
WP/8034/2010HC BombayHCBM01037050201011 October 2010Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE V.C. DAGA,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE R.M. SAVANT.8 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the view taken by the revenue authorities (respondent Nos. 2 and 3) in granting partial relief by directing payment of 40% of the demand in installments was a reasonable and possible view, considering the facts and circumstances of the case, and therefore, it did not warrant interference. The Court found that substantial relief had already been granted by staying 60% of the demand pending appeal. The petitioner's failure to make any payment towards the installments, despite the grant of partial relief, demonstrated a lack of bonafides. The Court emphasized that it, not being a court of appeal, would not substitute its views for the impugned orders, which were reasoned and showed application of mind. The Court found no prima facie case or balance of convenience in favour of the petitioner. The petition was dismissed as lacking substance, with the validity of the partial stay orders being considered, but other contentions left open for the Appellate Authority to decide on merits.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Ghodavat Energy Pvt. Ltd., filed its return for AY 2002-2003 declaring an income of Rs. 1,72,61,382. An assessment order under section 143(3) determined the income at Rs. 9,20,88,777. Following a search on February 4, 2009, the Assessing Officer (AO) reopened the assessment under section 147 based on alleged undisclosed sales of Rs. 43,11,71,955. The AO's assessment order dated December 31, 2009, determined the total income at Rs. 52,73,59,020. The petitioner appealed this order and sought a stay of demand. Various stay applications were filed before different authorities, with the Additional Commissioner granting partial relief by directing payment of 40% of the demand in installments. The Commissioner (Central) reiterated this partial relief. The petitioner then filed a writ petition challenging the assessment order, the rejection of stay applications, and a notice for recovery.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the High Court, in its writ jurisdiction under Article 226, should interfere with the orders granting partial stay of demand, considering the pendency of the appeal before the Appellate Authority? (Question of law and fact) Assessee's Contentions: - During the pendency of an appeal, no demand can be made or enforced. - The petitioner has a prima facie good case on merits, and therefore, the appellate authority should be directed to hear and dispose of the appeal expeditiously, with a stay on the entire recovery of the demand until then. Revenue's Contentions: - The authorities below have taken a reasonable view of the matter considering the facts and circumstances. - The High Court, not being a court of appeal, should only examine the decision-making process and should not entertain the writ petition unless the impugned order granting partial relief is found to be perverse. - The CBDT instruction relied upon by the assessee (No.F.No.1/6/69-ITCC dated 21/08/1969) is superseded by instruction No.1914 of CBDT dated 02/12/1993, which allows the AO to grant installments but not to stay the demand merely because an appeal has been filed.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143,Section 147,Section 132,Section 148,Section 226

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 8034 OF 2010 Ghodavat Energy Pvt.Pvt. ...  Petitioner. V/s. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax and others. ...  Respondents. P.J.Pardiwala, Senior Advocate with Ms.Aasifa Khan for the appellant. Vimal Gupta for the respondents. CORAM : V.C.DAGA AND R.M.SAVANT, JJ. DATED : 11th October 2010. P.C. : Perused petition. Heard rival parties. 2. In this petition, filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the basic challenge is to the order dated   18th August,   2010   passed   by   respondent   No.3­ Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) on the application for stay of demand moved by the petitioners on the following backdrop:

Factual Backdrop : 3. The petitioner, on 30th  October, 2002, filed its return   of   income   for   the   assessment   year   2002­2003 declaring   a   total   income   of   Rs.1,72,61,382/­.     The   said return was processed under section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1962 (“Act” for short).   The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Ichalkaranji Circle i.e. the Assessing Officer passed   assessment   order   under   section   143(3)   of   the   Act determining   the   total   income   in   the   sum   of Rs.9,20,88,777/­.   The petitioner has already paid tax on the income so assessed. 4. A search action under section 132 of the Act was carried on 4th February, 2009.  The Assessing Officer based on the information received issued notice under section 148 of the Act.  In response to the said notice, the petitioner filed its objections against the re­opening of assessment which were rejected. 5. On   30th  December,   2009,   the   Assessing   Officer issued   show   cause   notice   to   the   petitioner   seeking explanation   regarding   alleged   undisclosed   sales   to   the extent of Rs.43,11,71,955/­. 6. The petitioner objected to the aforesaid notice on 31st December, 2009 and furnished explanation in respect of   the   alleged   undisclosed   sales   worked   out   by   the Assessing Officer on the basis of production of capacity per machine.

7.

The Assessing Officer, vide his order dated 31st December, 2009, completed assessment under section 143(3) read with section 147 of the Act determining total income in the sum of Rs.52,73,59,020/­ making an addition of Rs. 43,11,71,955/­ on account of alleged undisclosed sales. 8. Aggrieved   by   the   aforesaid   order   dated   31st December, 2009, the petitioner filed an  appeal before the respondent No.5 on 25th  January, 2010.   On the same day, petitioner filed stay application before the respondent No. 1, the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Kolhapur praying for stay of demand till the disposal of appeal by the Commissioner (Appeals), which was dismissed by   the   respondent   No.1,  vide   his   order   dated   15th  March, 2010. 9. The   petitioner   filed   another   stay   application before the respondent No.2, the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle on 8th April, 2010 with one more stay   application   before   the   respondent   No.5,   the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) on 12th April, 2010 and prayed for stay of recovery of demand.  The respondent No. 2, vide his order dated, 27th  April, 2010, granted partial relief to the petitioner directing payment of 40% of the demand in installments. 10. The petitioner, not satisfied with the aforesaid order,   filed   one   more   stay   application   before   the respondent No.3, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Central)

on 28th May, 2010 with a prayer to stay the demand made by the Revenue.   In the meanwhile, the respondent No.1, vide his  letter   dated   28th  May,   2010,  asked   the   petitioner   to make payment of the installments for the months of May and June, 2010 in view of the order of the respondent No.2. 11. The respondent No.3, before whom the application for   stay   was   pending,   vide   his   order   dated   18th  August, 2010,   reiterated   partial   relief   already   granted   by   the respondent No.2 directing the petitioner to make payment of 40% of the demand in installments.     The petitioner filed another   stay   application   before   the   respondent   No.4­ Director   General   of   Income   Tax   (Central)   on   25th  August, 2010.     In   the   meanwhile,   on  20th  September,   2010,  notice under rule 2 to Schedule­II of the Act was issued to the petitioner calling upon it to make payment of the demand within fifteen days from the receipt of the notice. 12. The   petitioner   has   neither   complied   with   the order passed by respondent No.2 nor that of the respondent No.3;   wherein   a   partial   relief   was   granted   to   the petitioner   permitting   it   to   pay   40%   of   the   demand   in installments. 13. The petitioner has now invoked writ jurisdiction of   this   Court   under   Article   226   of   the   Constitution   of India   to   challenge   the   order   dated   31st  December,   2009 passed under section 143 read with section 147 of the Act and order dated 15th  March, 2010 passed by respondent No.1 rejecting the stay application of the petitioner followed

by the orders granting partial relief directing it to make payment of 40% of the demand in installments.  In addition to   these   challenges,   notice   dated   20th  September,   2010 issued under rule 2 of Schedule­II of the Act is also a subject matter of challenge in this petition. Submissions : 14. Mr.Pardiwala,   learned   senior   counsel   appearing for the petitioner urged that during the pendency of the appeal,   no   demand   can   be   made   or   enforced.     He   further submits that the petitioner has  prima facie  good  case on merits as such the appellate authority be directed to hear and   dispose   of   the   appeal   with   expeditious   despatch   and till then entire recovery of the demand should be stayed. 15. The   submissions   made   by   Mr.Pardiwala   were strongly opposed by the learned counsel appearing for the respondents­ Revenue contending that the authorities below have taken a reasonable view of the matter considering the facts and circumstances of the case and that this Court not being a Court of appeal should only examine the decision making process and should not entertain this writ petition unless impugned order granting partial relief is found to be perverse. Consideration : 16. Having   heard   both   parties,   having   examined   the order dated 18th August, 2010, whereunder partial relief has

been   granted   to   the   petitioner   permitting   it   to   make payment of 40% of the demand in installments, we are of the view that the view taken by the respondent Nos.2 and 3 is a reasonable   and   possible   view   looking   to   the   facts   and circumstances of the case, hence it needs no interference. 17. The   order   dated   18th  August,   2010   considers   the prayer made by the petitioner in the following words: “3.3 The assessee has also relied upon CBDT instruction   No.F.No.1/6/69­   ITCC   dated 21/08/1969.  The assessee has contended that as per this instruction in case the assessed income   is   twice   the   returned   income,   the demand   should   be   kept   in   abeyance   till decision   of   appeal. However,   the instruction relied upon by the assessee is not operational as it stands superceded by instruction no.1914 of CBDT dated 02/12/1993 and   which   is   in   force   now. As   per instruction   no.1914,   the   A.O.   can   grant proper installments to the assessee but the demand   cannot   be   stayed   merely   because appeal has been filed. 4. Considering   the   above   findings,   I cannot agree with the assessee’s request of keeping   the   entire   demand   in   abeyance. However,   it   is   noted   that   there   is   some force   in   the   assessee’s   arguments.     Also, the   demand   is   fairly   large. Therefore, keeping   in   view   the   interest   of   the department   as   well   as   the   assessee,   it   is hereby directed that the assessee should pay Rs.13 cr. which is 40% of the demand in 8 equal monthly installments of Rs.1.6 cr. per month   staring   from   August,   2010   to   March, 2011.     The   assessee   should   also   actively pursue   the   appeal   mater   with   CIT(A)   and cooperate   in   the   early   decision   of   the appeal.     In   case   the   decision   is   not

received   by   31/03/2011,   the   installment scheme shall be reviewed. 5. Subject   to   the   above   conditions,   the assessee shall not be treated as an assessee in default so far as it continues to pay the installments regularly.   In case of default in   payment   of   installments,   the   assessee would be deemed to be an assessee in default and necessary action for recovery would be initiated by the A.O.”

(Emphasis supplied) 18. The aforesaid view taken by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Central), Pune cannot be said to be a perverse view.  As stated, the aforesaid view taken is a reasonable and possible view. 19. As a matter of fact, substantial relief has been granted in favour of the petitioner by staying the demand, pending appeal, to the extent of 60% with liberty to the petitioner to make payment of balance 40% in installments. It   appears   that   in   spite   of   grant   of   installments,   the petitioner has not made any payment muchless part­payment to show its bonafides.   The petitioner is insisting upon the absolute stay which, in our opinion, cannot be granted merely because the appeal is pending.   Pendency of appeal cannot be a ground for stay of the recovery in toto. 20. At this juncture, it is relevant to mention that during the course of hearing, we called upon Mr.Pardiwala to   indicate   the   extent   of   amount   which   his   client   can afford to deposit at this stage.   In reply, Mr.Pardiwala

offered to make payment of negligible amount which we found it difficult to accept, especially, when the amount which is due and recoverable from the petitioner is running in crores. 21. In   our   view,   this   Court   not   being   a   court   of appeal would not be justified in substituting its views in place of the impugned orders.  No fault can be found with the   decisions   impugned   or   the   decision     making   process. The impugned order is a reasoned order with application of mind.   In the circumstances, neither prima facie case nor the   balance   of   convenience   lies   in   favour   of   the petitioner.   In the totality of the facts, in our view, this is not a fit case wherein this Court should exercise its   extra   ordinary   writ   jurisdiction   in   favour   of   the petitioner, who has no inclination to show its bonafides. 22. The   petition   is   liable   to   be   dismissed   being without any substance.   However, it is made clear that we have considered the validity of the orders granting partial stay   to   the   petitioner.     We   did   not   examine   other contentions since they are subject matter of appeal pending before   the   Appellate   Authority.     The   Appellate   Authority shall decide appeal on its own merits.  To that extent, all rival contentions are kept open. 23. In the result, petition is dismissed in limine in terms of this order with no order as to costs. (R.M.SAVANT, J.)                       (V.C.DAGA J.)

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →