PIERRE THEVERGE, REP. BY AGENT KSEB, vs. ASST. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,

PDF · subscribers
ITA/17/2007HC KeralaKLHC01025011200730 November 2018Author: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.VINOD CHANDRAN,HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK MENON6 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court, while acknowledging the questions of law raised, decided to answer them in favour of the revenue and against the assessee, albeit on a different reasoning than that of the Tribunal. The Court referred to its own judgment in Horace Dansereau v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Circle I(1), Thiruvananthapuram (2018(1) KHC 111), which covered similar issues. The operative part of that judgment directed the Assessing Officer to employ Section 195A to properly compute the amounts within two months of receiving a certified copy of the judgment, if any balance was due after the assessees had already paid up amounts. The appeal was rejected with these directions for computation, implying that the tax liability, including the component paid by KSEB, was to be considered as income and taxed accordingly, with Section 195A being applicable for computation. The Court did not expressly leave any issue undecided.

What were the facts?

The assessee, a foreign national, was an employee deputed by an overseas consultant to work in India for KSEB. He offered for taxation the income received in India and treated the tax component paid by KSEB as income from other sources. The Assessing Officer (AO) added this tax component to the salary paid, treating it as part of the total salary as per Section 195A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and computed the tax liability. The first appellate authority reversed the AO's order, directing the tax paid by KSEB to be taxed as income from other sources. The Revenue appealed to the Tribunal, and the assessee filed cross-objections, which were later withdrawn. The Tribunal allowed the Revenue's appeal, upholding the AO's order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that under the contract, KSEB was not liable to bear the income tax on the salary received by the appellant from the consultant company? (Question of law and fact, concerning contract interpretation) 2. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that the salary and tax portions were paid by the foreign consultant SNC-Shawinigan, despite Clause 1.9.1 of the contract indicating KSEB was to bear the tax portion? (Question of law and fact, concerning contract interpretation) 3. Whether the Tribunal ought to have held that Clause 1.9.1, being earlier and contradictory to Clause 1.9.2, should prevail, making KSEB liable for the tax burden? (Question of law and fact, concerning contract interpretation) 4. Whether the Tribunal ought to have held that Section 195A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was inapplicable, negating the need for grossing up the appellant's income? (Question of law, concerning statutory application) Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that Clause 1.9.1 of the contract clearly indicated KSEB's liability to bear the tax. They contended that if clauses were contradictory, the earlier clause should prevail. They also argued that Section 195A had no application, thus grossing up was unnecessary. Revenue's contentions: The judgment does not explicitly record the Revenue's arguments before the Tribunal, but their appeal was allowed, upholding the AO's order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 195A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.VINOD CHANDRAN & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK MENON FRIDAY ,THE 30TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2018 / 9TH AGRAHAYANA, 1940 ITA.No. 17 of 2007 AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT IN ITA 815/2004 of I.T.A.TRIBUNAL,COCHIN BENCH DATED 28-04-2006 APPELLANT/S: PIERRE THEVERGE, REP. BY AGENT KSEB, AGENT KSEB, PATTOM TRIVANDRUM. BY ADVS. SRI.E.K.NANDAKUMAR (SR.) SRI.ANIL D. NAIR RESPONDENT/S: ASST. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE I(1), TRIVANDRUM. OTHER PRESENT: SRI RAJA KANNAN, SRI JOSE JOSEPH SC THIS INCOME TAX APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 30.11.2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

J U D G M E N T Vinod Chandran, J The petitioner was an employee deputed by the overseas Consultant, who returned his income received in India and showed the tax component paid by the KSEB as “income from other sources”. The Assessing Officer added on the tax paid by KSEB, returned as “income from other sources”, to the salary paid and computed the total salary paid as provided in Section 195A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ('Act' for short). Tax was determined for the said component of salary and deductions were made with respect to the tax paid by the KSEB. The balance was demanded from the assesses, the foreign national, who was in India by virtue of the contract between the KSEB and the overseas Consultant. 2. The assesses filed appeals before the first Appellate Authority, who, based on Emil

Webber v. Commissioner of Income Tax - 200 ITR 483

, reversed the order of the Assessing Authority and directed the tax paid by the KSEB, returned as other income, to be taxed as “income from other sources”. An appeal was taken by the Department to the Tribunal and cross objections were filed by the assesses. The cross objections were later withdrawn. The Tribunal allowed the appeal of the Department upholding the order of the Assessing Authority. 3. The questions of law raised are as follows: 1. Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal was right in law and on facts in holding that under Annexure A contract, KSEB was not liable to bear the income tax liability on the salary received by the appellant from the consultant company? 2. Whether the Hon'ble Tribunal was

right in law and on facts in holding that in the instant case the salary and the tax portions were paid by the foreign consultant Snc-Shawinigan as evidenced by clause 1.9.1 clearly indicated that the tax portion was to be borne by KSEB? 3. Ought not the Hon'ble Appelate Tribunal to have held that insofar as clauses 1.9.1 and 1.9.2 were mutually contradictory, the earlier clause 1.9.1 had to prevail and accordingly the liability to bear the tax burden of the appellant was on KSEB and not on SNC- Shawinigan? 4.Ought not the Hon'ble appellate Tribunal to have held that the provisions of Section 195A did not have any application to the facts and

circumstances of the instant case and accordingly, there was no necessity for grossing up the income of the appellant while determining his tax liability? 4. The issues and questions raised are covered by a judgment of this Court reported in 2018(1) KHC 111 [

Horace Dansereau v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Circle I(1), Thiruvananthapuram]

. This Court upheld the order of assessment on a different reasoning from that of the Tribunal. We extract the operative portion of the order in paragraph 10 as follows:- “We are of the opinion that the question of law raised has to be answered in favour of the revenue and against the assessee on a different reasoning than that given by the Tribunal. We are told that in many of the assessment orders the computation has not been properly made.

The Assessing Officer would, hence, employ Section 195A and compute the amounts properly within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this judgment. The assessees are said to have paid up the amounts already. Only if there is a balance due, the same would have to be satisfied by the assessee or its agent.” The questions have been answered against the assessee and in favour of the revenue. The appeal is rejected with the directions as given in the earlier judgment for computation. There is no order as to costs. Sd/- K. Vinod Chandran, Judge Sd/- Ashok Menon, jma Judge

More judgments on Section 195A

All 193 judgments and leading authorities on Section 195A →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →