COMMI. OF IT-I, LUDHIANA vs. BHARAT BHUSHAN SURI
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the revenue. The Court noted that the CIT(Appeals) had deleted the addition, finding that the assessee maintained regular, audited books of account, filed VAT returns without defects, and showed improved Gross Profit and Net Profit rates compared to the previous year. The Tribunal, in its order, observed that the addition was made merely on account of the difference in stock values reported in the balance sheet and to the bank. The Tribunal emphasized that the stock statement furnished to the bank was to avail maximum overdraft facility and that the assessee's sales and purchases were verifiable from the books of account, which were accepted by the Sales Tax Department. The Tribunal found no material to show that the assessee possessed a higher quantity of stock than declared in the balance sheet, and this finding was not controverted by the revenue. The High Court affirmed the Tribunal's conclusion, stating that the findings of fact were not erroneous or perverse. The Court distinguished the present case from B.T. Steels Limited, where the Tribunal had found more stock with the assessee and no satisfactory explanation. The Court found the facts similar to Sidhu Rice and General Mills, where the addition was deleted as no material beyond the bank's stock statement was brought on record by the AO.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Shri Bharat Bhushan Suri (HUF), filed its return for assessment year 2006-07 declaring an income of ₹1,70,240. The Assessing Officer (AO) noted a discrepancy between the stock statement submitted to the bank (₹72,65,770) for a cash credit limit and the stock shown in the assessee's books of account (₹41,78,915). The AO added the difference of ₹30,86,855 to the assessee's income. The CIT(Appeals) partly allowed the appeal, deleting the addition, a decision upheld by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The revenue appealed to the High Court against the ITAT's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts and in law, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition of ₹30,86,855 made by the AO on account of excess stock, based on the difference between the stock statement submitted to the bank and that submitted to revenue authorities, despite the assessee failing to substantiate the difference with documentary proof? (Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961) 2. Whether, on the facts and in law, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition of ₹30,86,855 when the Punjab and Haryana High Court had decided a similar issue in favour of the revenue in the case of B.T. Steels Limited v. CIT? Assessee's arguments: The CIT(Appeals) and the Tribunal concurrently held that there was no difference in the quantity of stock as disclosed in the books of account, hypothecated with the bank, and filed with the Sales Tax Department. The VAT returns were accepted by the Sales Tax Department. Reliance was placed on the High Court's decision in CIT v. Sidhu Rice and General Mills, arguing that the findings of fact by the appellate authorities were not illegal or perverse. Revenue's arguments: The AO was justified in making the addition due to the difference of ₹30,86,855 in the stock reported in the balance sheet and to the bank. Both the CIT(A) and the Tribunal erred in deleting the addition. Reliance was placed on the High Court's judgment in B.T. Steels Limited.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNAJB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) Date of decision:22.10.2013 Commissioner of Income Tax I, Ludhiana ….Appellant Vs. Shri Bharat Bhushan Suri (HUF), Prop. M/s Varun Auto Inds, E-525, Phase VI, Focal Point, Ludhiana. ….Respondent CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JASPAL SINGH Present: Mr. Rajesh Katoch, Advocate for the appellant-revenue. Mr. Pankaj Jain, Advocate and Mr. Daman Dhir, Advocate for the respondent-assessee. Ajay Kumar Mittal,J. 1. This appeal has been preferred by the revenue under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short, “the Act”) against the order dated 30.6.2010, Annexure A.III, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, 'A', Chandigarh in ITA No.143/CHD/2010, for the assessment year 2006-07, claiming following substantial questions of law:- i) Whether on the facts and in law, the Hon'ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was justified in deleting the addition of `30,86,855/- made by the Assessing Officer on account of excess stock on the basis of difference in stock statement which was submitted to bank and that submitted to revenue authorities thereby ignoring the fact that the assessee had Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 2 failed to substantiate its own submission on the difference in the two stocks statements with any documentary proof? ii)Whether on the facts and in law, the Hon'ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was justified in deleting the addition of `30,86,855/- made by the Assessing Officer when the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court has decided the issue in favour of the revenue in the case of B.T.Steels Limited v. CIT (2010) 328 ITR 471? 2. A few facts relevant for the decision of the controversy involved, as narrated in the appeal, may be noticed. The assessee firm filed its return of income on 29.10.2006 for the assessment year in question declaring total income of ` 1,70,240/-. The case was selected for scrutiny and notice under Section 143(2) of the Act was issued on 4.10.2007. The assessee was enjoying Cash Credit limit of ` 65 lacs from bank of Baroda, SSI, Focal Point, Ludhiana against hypothecation of stocks and book debts and as per the stock statement submitted to the bank, the value of stock as on 31.3.2006 was ` 72,65,770/- as against ` 41,78,915/- as per books of account. The Senior Bank Manager certified that the inspection used to be carried out by the officials of the Bank after every 2-3 months interval. The assessee failed to explain the difference in the two stock statements. The Assessing Officer made an addition of ` 30,86,855/- on account of difference between stock statement as per account books of the assessee and the stock statement submitted to the bank at the closure of the financial year. The assessment was completed under Section 143(3) of the Act on 31.12.2008, Annexure A.I, at assessed income of ` 32,83,306/-. Aggrieved by the order, the assessee filed appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals [CIT(A)]. Vide order dated 17.11.2009, Annexure A.II, the Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 3 CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal, deleting the addition on account of difference in stock statement in view of the decision of this Court in CIT v. Sidhu Rice and General Mills, (2006) 281 ITR 428. Not satisfied with the order, the revenue filed appeal before the Tribunal. Vide order dated 30.6.2010, Annexure A.III, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal. Hence the present appeal by the revenue. 3. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there was variation in the stock shown in the books of account of the assessee which was hypothecated by him with the Bank for availing overdraft facility. It was urged that the difference of ` 30,86,855/- in the stock as reported in the balance sheet and to the Bank was by the assessee himself and in such circumstances, the Assessing Officer was right in making the addition to the said extent. It was argued that the CIT(A) as well as the Tribunal had erred in deleting the aforesaid addition. Reliance was placed upon judgment of this Court in B.T.Steels Limited's case (supra). 4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the assessee submitted that the CIT(A) as well as the Tribunal had concurrently recorded a finding that there was no difference in the quantity of stocks which was disclosed in the books of account and hypothecated with the Bank and also the sales tax department with whom the VAT returns had been filed, had accepted the said stock as per books of account. Relying upon judgment of this Court in Sidhu Rice and General Mills's case (supra) it was submitted that the findings recorded by the CIT(A) and the Tribunal were findings of fact and in such circumstances, no illegality or perversity could be said to be there in the orders passed by the appellate authorities. Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 4 5. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record, we do not find any merit in the appeal. 6. The CIT(A) while deleting the addition on account of difference between the stocks as per books of account and as shown to the Bank for seeking over draft facility had recorded that the assessee had maintained regular books of account for the activities carried out. The accounts had been audited by the auditor. The assessee had filed VAT returns regularly and no defect in the books of account had been found by the Assessing Officer in those proceedings. The Gross Profit as well as Net Profit was better as compared to previous year's accepted results as in the last year, gross profit rate was 7.8% whereas in the current year it was 8.67% and similarly Net Profit was 0.31% in the last year as compared to 0.48% in the current year. 7. The Tribunal while dismissing the appeal of the revenue vide order dated 30.6.2010, Annexure A.III, had recorded as under:- “We have considered the rival submissions carefully. In this case, it is evident from the order of the Assessing Officer that the addition of Rs.30,86,855/- has been made merely on account of difference in the stock as reported in the balance sheet and to the bank. It is also clear that over-draft facility in the bank had been obtained against hypothecation of stock statement furnished. The claim of the assessee is that there is no difference in stock position in as much as the stock statement furnished to the Bank is of a higher value to avail maximum over draft facility. On the contrary, the sales and purchases of the assessee are verifiable from the books of account and as pointed out before the CIT(Appeals), the same have been accepted by the Sales Tax Department with whom monthly VAT returns are being filed. No doubt, there Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 5 is a difference between stock reported in the balance Sheet and that communicated to the Bank. So, however, by itself this would not lead to a conclusion that the assessee has certain undisclosed stock unless it is shown that the difference is in quantitative terms. The CIT(Appeals) in our view, correctly followed the judgment of the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High court in the case of Sidhu Rice and General Mills (supra) to delete the addition. Infact, the finding of the CIT(Appeals) is that there is no material on record to show that the assessee was, infact in possession of higher quantity of stock than those declared in the balance sheet. This finding has not been controverted by the revenue before us in any manner and therefore, we hereby affirm the conclusion of the CIT(Appeals). Accordingly, the appeal of the revenue is dismissed.” The findings of fact recorded by the Tribunal were not shown to be erroneous or perverse in any manner. 8. We may now advert to the judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the parties. 9. The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the revenue as well as for the assessee, were dealing with the cases where the findings recorded by the Tribunal were upheld by this Court. In B.T.Steels Limited's case (supra), where addition was made on the basis of variation between stock hypothecated with the bank and stock shown in the books of account, the Tribunal had come to the conclusion that there was more stock actually lying with the assessee and the assessee had not given satisfactory explanation, which is not the case in the present case. 10. In Sidhu Rice and General Mills's case (supra) on which learned counsel for the assessee placed reliance, it was held that except for Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
ITA No.71 of 2011 (O&M) 6 the photo copy of the stock statement furnished to the bank, the Assessing Officer had not brought any material on record to show that the assessee possessed stocks as reflected in the said statement as against the stocks depicted in the balance sheet. It was also found that the books of account were regularly maintained by the assessee and had been accepted by the department. It was in these circumstances that this court came to the conclusion that the findings recorded by the Tribunal were based on record and no addition could be made in such a case. 11. In view of the above, the substantial questions of law are answered against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. The appeal stands dismissed. (Ajay Kumar Mittal)
Judge October 22, 2013
(Jaspal Singh) ‘gs’
Judge
Singh Gurbax 2013.11.14 12:50 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document High Court Chandigarh
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Basant Ballabh Punetha vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Satyavan vs. Commissioner Central Goods And Services Tax CommissionerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026
- Deepak Kumar Daiya vs. State Of West Bengal And Ors.Calcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Pawan Kumar Rajgaria vs. State Of West BengalCalcutta · 4 Nov 2026
- Mohammed Fazil vs. State Of ChhattisgarhChhattisgarh · 4 Nov 2026