INCOME TAX OFFICER, THANE vs. TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI, THANE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 2277/MUM/2026Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai25 September 2026AY 2019-2013 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. The assessee's cross-objection was partly allowed. Regarding the disallowance of purchases, the Tribunal noted that while the supplier's genuineness was doubtful, the corresponding sales were not disputed. The Tribunal distinguished the case of Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. by noting that the assessee in the present case had furnished documentary evidence, demonstrated corresponding sales, and the AO had not established any cash trail returning to the assessee. The Tribunal relied on the principle from Mohammad Haji Adam & Co. that in cases of undisputed sales, addition should be confined to the profit element. Considering the past GP ratios of the assessee (averaging around 5.58%), the Tribunal found the CIT(A)'s estimation of 12% to be on the higher side. Therefore, the addition was restricted to 6% of the disputed purchases, amounting to Rs.2,12,480/-. The Tribunal also found no merit in the Revenue's prayer to set aside the matter for fresh assessment based on CBDT Circular No. 5/2024, as the circular did not mandate such action. The grounds raised by the Revenue were dismissed, and Ground 3 of the assessee's cross-objection was partly allowed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue filed an appeal against the order of the CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2019-20, which had restricted the disallowance of purchases from non-existent vendors to 12% of Rs.35,41,340/-. The assessee, Tufail Ahmed Bakhshullah Siddiqui, a steel trader, had declared total income of Rs.16,59,190/-. Information from the Investigation Wing suggested bogus purchases of Rs.35,41,340/- from M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated these purchases as unexplained expenditure under Section 69C and brought them to tax under Section 115BBE, as the supplier was found to be non-existent and did not comply with notices. The CIT(A) partially allowed the appeal, restricting the addition to 12% of the purchases, considering that corresponding sales were not disputed. The assessee also filed a cross-objection challenging the reopening and the addition.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the CIT(A) erred in restricting the disallowance of purchases to 12% of total bogus purchases of Rs.35,41,340/- from non-existent vendors, and not following the decision of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. (Revenue's ground a)? 2. Whether the Assessing Officer erred in issuing Notice u/s 148A and u/s 148 based solely on information from the investigation wing without independent enquiry, contrary to the judgment in Shodiman Investments (P.) Ltd. and Odeon Builders (Assessee's ground 1a and 1b)? 3. Whether the Assessing Officer erred in reopening the case, which should have been done by the First Appellate Authority as per Hexaware Technologies Ltd. vs. ITO (Assessee's ground 2)? 4. Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming alleged Bogus purchases @12%, when payments were made by account payee cheques, sales were accepted, and no cash trail was established, and when addition should be restricted to differential GP as per Mohammad Haji Adam and Co. (Assessee's grounds 3a, 3b, 3d, 3e, 3f, 3g, 3h, 3i)? Assessee's contentions: Reopening was based solely on investigation wing information without independent enquiry (Shodiman Investments, Odeon Builders). Notice u/s 148 should have been issued by the FAO (Hexaware Technologies). Purchases were genuine as payments were by account payee cheques, sales were accepted, quantity records were produced, no cash trail was established, and books were not rejected. Addition should be restricted to profit element as per Mohammad Haji Adam & Co. Revenue's contentions: CIT(A) erred in restricting disallowance to 12% and not following Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. Alternatively, the matter should be set aside to the AO for fresh assessment as per CBDT Circular No. 5/2024.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 69C,Section 115BBE,Section 148A,Section 148,Section 133(6),Section 250

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI

Before: SMT. BEENA PILLAI, HON’BLE & SHRI VIKRAM SINGH YADAV, HON’BLE

For Respondent: Shri Bhupendra Shah, AR

Heard together (2 matters)

ITA 2277/MUM/2026
CO 168/MUM/2026

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, म ुंबई पीठें, म ुंबई INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI BENCH: E BEFORE SMT. BEENA PILLAI, HON’BLE JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI VIKRAM SINGH YADAV, HON’BLE ACCOUNTANT MEMBER

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 (निर्धारण वर्ा/Assessment Year: 2019-20) INCOME TAX OFFICER TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI INCOME TAX OFFICE , 6TH FLOOR, ASHAR IT PARK, ROAD NO. 22, RUPADEVI WAGLE ESTATE,THANE, PADA, ,INDIRA MAHARASHTRA-400604, NAGAR,WAGLE Vs. THANE-400604, ESTATE,THANE 400604 MAHARASHTRA ,MAHARASHTRA, INDIA THANE-400604, MAHARASHTRA अपीलधर्थी Appellant प्रत्यर्थी Respondent

PAN of Assessee: APMPS4122G

अपीलधर्थी द्वारा/Appellant represented Shri Dheeraj Singh Baghel, by: JCIT प्रत्यर्थी द्वारा/Respondent represented by: Shri Bhupendra Shah, AR CO 168/MUM/2026 (निर्धारण वर्ा/Assessment Year: 2019-20) TUFAIL AHMED INCOME TAX OFFICER BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI INCOME TAX OFFICE , 6TH ROAD NO. 22, RUPADEVI FLOOR, ASHAR IT PARK, PADA, ,INDIRA NAGAR,WAGLE WAGLE ESTATE,THANE, ESTATE,THANE 400604 Vs. MAHARASHTRA-400604 ,MAHARASHTRA, INDIA, THANE-400604, THANE-400604, MAHARASHTRA MAHARASHTRA अपीलधर्थी Appellant प्रत्यर्थी Respondent

PAN of Assessee: APMPS4122G

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI अपीलधर्थी द्वारा/Appellant represented by: Shri Bhupendra Shah, AR प्रत्यर्थी द्वारा/Respondent represented Shri Dheeraj Singh Baghel, by: JCIT

सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 16-Jul-2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 25-09-2026 आदेश / ORDER PER SMT. BEENA PILLAI, JUDICIAL MEMBER: Present appeal by the Revenue and the Cross Objection filed by the assessee are directed against the order dated 06/12/2025 passed by the Ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi [“Ld. CIT(A)”], u/s 250 of the Income- tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”) for Assessment Year 2019-20 on following grounds of appeal:

Appeal filed by the Revenue:

“a. On the facts and in circumstances of the case, the CIT(A) erred in restricting the disallowance of purchases to 12% of total bogus purchases of Rs.35,41,340/- from non-existent vendors by not following the decision of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. reported in 172 Taxmann.com 283. b. It is submitted that present appeal may be filed in accordance with the CBDT’s Circular No.5/2024 dated 15.03.2024 as per Para 3.1(c) of the said Circular. The Order of the CIT(A) may kindly be vacated and the matter may be set-aside to the file of the AO for fresh assessment. c. The appellant craves leave to add, amend or alter any ground/grounds, which may be necessary.” Cross Objection filed by the assessee:

“1. In the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Assessing Officer erred in issuing Notice u/s 148: a) only on the basis of information received from investigation wing and without making any enquiry which is against the judgement of Shodiman Investments (P.) Ltd (422 ITR 337 Bombay High court.) 2

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI b) No reopening can be made as was held in the case of Odeon Builders. 2. In the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the JAO erred in reopening the case which was required to be reopened by FAO as per the judgement of Bombay High Court in the case of 464 ITR 430 (Bombay) Hexaware Technologies Ltd. vs. ITO. 3. In the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT[A] erred in confirming alleged Bogus purchases @12%: a) Even though the payment for purchases is made from the books by A/C payee cheques and cannot be termed as bogus and hence section 69C does not apply. b) Without appreciating the fact that no addition can be made even if the supplier is not traceable as per the judgment of the Bombay High Court. d) Sales cannot be made without purchases. e) Quantity records were produced. f) No cash trail is established by the Assessing Officer. g) Without rejecting books of accounts. h) Without showing comparable case of GP of 12% in trading business. i) It was already held by the jurisdictional Bombay High Court in the case of M/S Haji Mohd Adam and also followed by the jurisdictional ITAT in several cases holding that only differential GP between verifiable and unverifiable purchases could only be added instead of whole amount of purchases which is not verifiable. General: This cross objection is filed in time. The cross objection prays leave to add, alter or amend the above grounds of cross objection on or before the disposal of this cross objection.”

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI 2. Brief facts of the case are as under:-

2.1 The assessee is an individual and is carrying on business as proprietor of M/s Hindustan Steels, engaged in trading of steel. The assessee filed his return of income for the year under consideration on 16/10/2019 declaring total income of Rs.16,59,190/-.

2.2 Information was received by the Department, in respect of alleged bogus purchases amounting to Rs.35,41,340/- made by the assessee from M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd. Accordingly, notice u/s 148A(b) was issued which was followed by order u/s 148A(d) dated 31/03/2023. Consequent thereto, notice u/s 148 was issued on 31/03/2023 and reassessment proceedings started.

2.3 During the course of reassessment proceedings, the assessee furnished certain details including copy of Form 26AS, tax audit report, computation of income, purchase invoices and e-way bills pertaining to the purchases made from M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd. The Ld. AO, however, observed that information received from the Investigation Wing indicated that M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd. was engaged in providing accommodation bills without actual delivery of goods. Notice issued u/s 133(6) to the said concern remained uncomplied with and the verification conducted at its stated address revealed that some other entity was occupying the premises. The Ld. AO, thus, treated the entire purchases of Rs.35,41,340/- as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act and brought the same to tax in terms of section 115BBE.

Aggrieved by the order of the Ld.AO, the assessee preferred appeal before the Ld.CIT(A).

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI 3. The Ld.CIT(A), on considering the material placed by the assessee, observed that though the genuineness of the supplier remained doubtful, the corresponding sales had not been disputed. The Ld.CIT(A), was of the opinion that the entire purchases could not be brought to tax u/s 69C and restricted the addition to the profit element embedded in such purchases estimated at 12% of Rs.35,41,340/-. The Ld.CIT(A) accordingly partly allowed the assessee's appeal on this issue.

Aggrieved by the order of the Ld.CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before this Tribunal.

4.

Cross Objection by the assessee

4.1 The assessee, in the Cross Objection, challenged the reopening of assessment as well as the estimation of profit at 12%. It is contended that, the reopening was merely on the basis of information received from the Investigation Wing without independent enquiry by the Ld.AO.

4.2. The assessee placed reliance on PCIT v. Shodiman Investments (P.) Ltd. reported in 422 ITR 337 (Bom.) and CIT v. Odeon Builders Pvt. Ltd.. The assessee also challenged the issuance of notice u/s.148 by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer by placing reliance on Hexaware Technologies Ltd. v. ACIT reported in 464 ITR 430 (Bom.).

4.2 On merits, the assessee contends that payments towards purchases were made through account-payee cheques; corresponding sales have been recorded and accepted; quantitative records were maintained; there is no material demonstrating any cash trail flowing back to the assessee; and that merely because 5

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI the supplier could not be traced or did not respond to notice u/s 133(6), the entire purchases could not be treated as unexplained expenditure. Reliance has also been placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in case of PCIT v. Mohammad Haji Adam & Co. reported in (2019) 103 taxmann.com 459 for restricting the addition to the profit element embedded in the disputed purchases.

4.4. The Ld.DR strongly relied n the assessment order and submitted that the supplier was found to be a non-genuine concern failed to respond to notice issued u/s 133(6). It was submitted that the Ld.CIT(A) was not justified in restricting the addition to 12%.

The Ld.DR on the contrary, placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in PCIT v. Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. reported in (2025) 172 taxmann.com 283 and prayed that the addition made by the Ld.AO be restored. The Ld. DR also relied upon para 3.1(c) of CBDT Circular No.5/2024 dated 15/03/2024 and prayed that, alternatively, the matter be restored to the Ld. AO for fresh assessment.

5.2 The Ld. AR, on the other hand, relied on the grounds raised in the Cross Objection and submitted that the purchases were duly supported by purchase invoices, e-way bills, banking transactions, GSTR-2A and quantitative details. It was submitted that corresponding sales were accepted and there is no evidence brought on record by the Revenue to demonstrate that the purchase consideration paid through banking channels had flown back to the assessee. Reliance was placed on Mohammad Haji Adam & Co. (supra), Shodiman Investments (P.) Ltd. (supra), Odeon Builders Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and Hexaware Technologies Ltd. (supra).

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI Reliance was also placed on the decision of the Coordinate Bench in Arham Star v. ITO [2025] 180 taxmann.com 44 (Mumbai-Trib.) was also brought to our notice.

We have perused the submissions advanced by both sides in light of the record placed before us.

6.

We first take up Grounds 1 and 2 raised in the Cross Objection challenging the validity of the reassessment proceedings.

6.1. Insofar as the reliance on Shodiman Investments (P.) Ltd. (supra) is concerned, we note that the said decision was rendered in the context of the erstwhile reassessment regime requiring formation of “reason to believe”. In the present case, proceedings have been initiated under the reassessment regime substituted with effect from 01/04/2021. The material available with the Ld. AO contained specific information identifying the assessee, the alleged supplier, namely M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd., and the amount of purchases of Rs.35,41,340/-. Notice u/s 148A(b) was issued to the assessee before passing the order u/s 148A(d). It is also an undisputed position emerging from the record that the assessee did not furnish any response at the stage of proceedings u/s 148A.

6.2. Thus, this is not a case where reopening has been initiated merely on the basis of some vague or general information having no nexus with the assessee. The information was specific to the transaction undertaken by the assessee. We therefore do not find merit in the contention that the assumption of jurisdiction itself

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI stands vitiated merely because the information originated from the Investigation Wing.

6.3. The reliance on Odeon Builders Pvt. Ltd. (supra) also does not assist the assessee for invalidating the initiation of reassessment proceedings. The principle laid down therein, regarding addition based solely on unverified third-party information despite supporting evidence furnished by the assessee, would be relevant to appreciating the addition on merits rather than for holding the very initiation of proceedings to be without jurisdiction on the facts before us.

6.4. As regards the contention that notice u/s 148 could not have been issued by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer in view of Hexaware Technologies Ltd. (supra), we note that subsequent thereto section 147A was inserted by Finance Act, 2026 with retrospective effect from 01/04/2021. The said provision contains a non-obstante clause and clarifies the meaning of the Assessing Officer for purposes of sections 148 and 148A. Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Income Tax Officer v. Tej Partap Singh reported in [2026] 185 taxmann.com 1007 (SC), having regard to the aforesaid legislative intervention, set aside the judgments rendered in favour of the assessees on the JAO/FAO issue on that limited ground and remitted the controversy for fresh consideration by the respective Hon’ble High Courts.

6.5. In the circumstances, the decision in Hexaware Technologies Ltd. (supra), as it stood prior to the aforesaid statutory amendment and the subsequent order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, cannot be applied to quash the present reassessment. Accordingly, Grounds 1 and 2 of the Cross Objection are dismissed.

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI We now take up the Revenue's appeal together with Ground no.3 of the assessee's Cross Objection.

7.

It is an admitted position that the assessee recorded the impugned purchases in its books. The assessee furnished purchase invoices and e-way bills and claimed that the payments were made through banking channels. The GSTR-2A details were also placed on record. Further, the assessee furnished details correlating the purchases with subsequent sales. Importantly, the sales declared by the assessee have not been disturbed.

7.1. At the same time, the material collected by the Revenue concerning M/s Moksh Alloy Pvt. Ltd. cannot altogether be ignored. The said concern was found to be connected with the information received from the GST authorities relating to issuance of accommodation bills; notice issued u/s 133(6) remained uncomplied with; and physical verification at the stated address also did not establish the existence of the supplier. Thus, though the purchase of goods as such cannot be discarded when corresponding sales stand accepted, the assessee has not satisfactorily established the purchases from the very party appearing in the books.

7.2. The Hon’ble Bombay High Court in case of PCIT v. Mohammad Haji Adam & Co. (supra) held that, in case of a trader where corresponding sales are not disputed, the entire purchase cannot be brought to tax and the addition has to be confined to the profit element embedded in such purchases. We have also considered the decision in PCIT v. Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. [2025] 172 taxmann.com 283 (Bom.), relied upon by the Revenue. In that case, the assessee had not participated in the reassessment proceedings

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI and had failed to discharge the initial burden of proving the genuineness of the purchases. The finding that the purchases were bogus had attained finality and, in such circumstances, the Hon’ble High Court held that there was no justification for reducing an addition made u/s 69C merely by estimating the profit at 12.5%.

7.2. The factual position before us is materially different. The assessee herein furnished documentary evidence in support of purchases and demonstrated corresponding sales which remain accepted. The Ld.AO has not brought any material on record to establish that the payments made by the assessee through banking channels were returned to the assessee in cash. In this regard, we also find support from the subsequent decision of the Coordinate Bench in Arham Star v. ITO reported in (2025) 180 taxmann.com 44, wherein the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal distinguished Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. (supra) on facts and held that where the assessee furnished purchase and sales records, banking evidence and quantitative details and the corresponding sales were not doubted, the entire purchases could not be disallowed. The Coordinate Bench restricted the addition to the profit element having regard to the facts of that case. The principle emerging therefrom is that Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. (supra) cannot be applied de hors the evidentiary position obtaining in each case. The factual distinction drawn by the Coordinate Bench is material to the present controversy.

7.3. We further note that the comparative gross profit chart forming part of the proceedings before the Ld. CIT(A) shows the GP ratio at 4.62% for A.Y. 2016-17, 7.23% for A.Y. 2017-18, 6.01% for

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI A.Y. 2018-19 and 4.44% for the year under consideration. The average works out to approximately 5.58%. Considering the nature of the assessee's business of trading in steel, the past GP declared, the documentary evidence available on record, the accepted sales on one hand and the failure of the assessee to conclusively establish the genuineness of the stated supplier on the other, we are of the considered view that the estimation made by the Ld.CIT(A) at 12% is on the higher side.

7.4. In the totality of facts and circumstances, we deem it appropriate to restrict the addition to 6% of the disputed purchases of Rs.35,41,340/-, which works out to Rs.2,12,480/-, rounded off. The Ld. AO is directed to restrict the addition accordingly.

7.5. We may also deal with the Revenue's reliance on CBDT Circular No.5/2024 dated 15/03/2024. Para 3.1(c) of the Circular carves out an exception to the monetary limits prescribed for filing Departmental appeals where the assessment is based upon information received from the specified law-enforcement or intelligence agencies. Thus, the said Circular may govern the maintainability of the Revenue's appeal notwithstanding the monetary limit. However, nothing contained in para 3.1(c) mandates that the order of the Ld. CIT(A) be vacated and the matter restored to the Ld. AO for fresh assessment merely because the case falls within such exception. We therefore find no merit in the Revenue's prayer for setting aside the matter on the basis of the said Circular.

Accordingly, the grounds raised by the Revenue stands dismissed. Ground 3 of the Cross Objection filed by the assessee stands partly allowed.

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI Remaining grounds raised by the assessee in its Cross Objection do not require separate adjudication.

In the result, the appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed and the Cross Objection filed by the assessee stands partly allowed.

Order pronounced in the open Court on 25-09-2026.

Sd/- Sd/- VIKRAM SINGH YADAV BEENA PILLAI ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 25-09-2026 Shamik Sr. P.S.

ITA 2277/MUM/2026 & CO 168/MUM/2026 TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI Copy to: TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH INCOME TAX OFFICER SIDDIQUI INCOME TAX OFFICE , 6TH ROAD NO. 22, RUPADEVI PADA, FLOOR, ASHAR IT PARK, ,INDIRA NAGAR,WAGLE WAGLE ESTATE,THANE, ESTATE,THANE 400604 MAHARASHTRA-400604 ,MAHARASHTRA, INDIA, THANE- THANE-400604, 400604, MAHARASHTRA MAHARASHTRA INCOME TAX OFFICER TUFAIL AHMED BAKHSHULLAH SIDDIQUI INCOME TAX OFFICE , 6TH FLOOR, ASHAR IT PARK, WAGLE ROAD NO. 22, RUPADEVI ESTATE,THANE, MAHARASHTRA- PADA, ,INDIRA NAGAR,WAGLE 400604, THANE-400604, ESTATE,THANE 400604 MAHARASHTRA ,MAHARASHTRA, INDIA THANE-400604, MAHARASHTRA

3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE TRUE COPY

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR / SR. PRIVATE SECRETARY I.T.A.T., MUMBAI

More judgments on Section 69C

All 8,586 judgments and leading authorities on Section 69C →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →