ACIT, DEHRADUN vs. M/S. OIL & NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD., DEHRADUN
In favour of the assessee: the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. From the AI summary of this appeal.
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's appeal, following the Uttarakhand High Court's decision in the assessee's own case. It held that dry-docking expenses are revenue in nature and that the Tatipaka Refinery's activities qualified for deduction under Section 80-IB(9).
What were the facts?
The Revenue appealed the CIT(A)'s order allowing deduction under Section 80-IB(9) for Tatipaka Refinery and treating dry-docking expenses as revenue. The assessee claimed deductions for refining and separation activities, and for dry-docking of offshore rigs and vessels.
What were the issues?
Whether activities of Tatipaka Refinery qualify for deduction under Section 80-IB(9) and whether dry-docking expenses are revenue or capital in nature.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 80-IB(9), Section 80-IB(2)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, DELHI BENCH ‘F’: NEW DELHI
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL DELHI BENCH ‘F’: NEW DELHI BEFORESHRI S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER AND SHRI SUDHIR KUMAR, JUDICIAL MEMBER ITA No.1639/Del./2016, A.Y. 2008-09 Asstt. Commissioner of Income Vs. M/s. Oil & Natural Gas Tax, Circle-1, Corporation Ltd., Dehradun Tel Bhawanm Dehradun PAN: AAACO1598A (Appellant) (Respondent)
Assesseeby Shri Ajay Vohra, Sr. Adv. Shri Kunal Pandey, Adv. Shri Jitendra Bhati, CA Revenue by Shri G C Srivastava, Special Counsel Shri Kalrav Malhotra, Adv. Shri Pushkar, Adv. Date of Hearing 15/01/2026 Date of Pronouncement 13/04/2026 ORDER PER S. PRIFAUR RAHMAN, AM The Revenue has filed appeal against the order of the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-Dehradun [“Ld. CIT(A)”, for short] dated 21.01.2016 for the Assessment Year 2008-09. 2. The Revenue has raised revised grounds of appeal: 1
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
“1. Ld. CIT(A), Dehradun has erred in law and on the facts while allowing the deduction u/s 80-IB(9) of Rs. 35,50,21,698/- on account of Tattipaka Refinery, without appreciating the facts that sites in respect of which deduction u/s 80-IB(9) has been claimed by the assessee, are not engaged in refining of mineral oil. 2. The Ld. CIT(A), Dehradun has erred in law and on the facts while deleting the addition of Rs. 1591,92,00,000/- made on account of royalty payment without appreciating the facts that the quantum of royalty paid to state Governments on the basis of pre-discount price exceeds the limit of 20% of the sale consideration of crude oil, which is in violation of sec. 6A of the Oil Field (Regulation & Development) Act. 3. The Ld. CIT(A), Dehradun has erred in law and on the facts holding that the Dry Docking expenses of Rs. 1,32,17,64,512/- are revenue in nature. 4. That the order of the Ld. CIT(A) be set-aside and that of the Assessing Officer be restored.
We shall deal with issues raised by the revenue ground wise:-
With regard to ground no. 1 the relevant facts are,the assessee had, for the assessment year under consideration, claimed deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Income tax Act, 1961 (for short‘the Act’), amounting to Rs.6458,72,84,498/-, in respect of profits derived by undertakings engaged in production/refining of mineral oil, subsequently, which was revised to Rs. 889,54,21,687/- during the course of assessment proceedings. The aforesaid claim comprised of profit derived from (i) commercial production of mineral oil
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
of Rs.594,66,38,618/- and(ii) refining and processing of mineral oil amounting to Rs. 294,87,83,069/- which included claim of Rs. 11,52,53,443/-in respect of the Tatipaka Refinery engaged in refining of mineral oil. During assessment proceedings, the assessing officer did not allow deduction on undertakings engaged in refining, including the Tatipaka Refinery, without giving any reason for the same. 3.1 Aggrieved with the above order, the assessee preferred an appeal before Ld CIT(A) and during the course of appellate proceedings, the assessee revised its claim of deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Act from Rs. 889,54,21,687/- to Rs. 917,61,79,505/-. The aforesaid claim comprised of profits derived from (i) commercial production of mineral oil of Rs. 598,76,28,181/- and (ii) refining and processing of mineral oil amounting to Rs. 318,85,51,324/-, including claim of deduction of Tatipaka refinery was enhanced from Rs. 11,52,53,443/- to Rs. 35,50,21,698/-.It is relevant to note that the issue of claim of deduction of section 80-IB(9)(iv) of the Act on commercial production of mineral oil of Rs. 598,76,28,181/- was decided against the assessee by the Ld. CIT(A). As regards the claim of deduction under section 80-IB(9)(iii) on refining mineral oil, Ld. CIT(A) allowed the deduction claimed by the assessee for the unit Tatipaka Refinery of Rs. 35,50,21,698/- but disallowed the balance claim of 3
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Rs. 283,35,29,636/- on the ground that activities undertaken by such undertakings did not constitute refining as known in oil and gas industry. It is relevant to note that the assessee had filed appeal bearing ITA No. 1744/Del/2016 against the order of the CIT(A) before the ITAT, however, the samewas settled under the Direct Tax Vivad se Vishwas Act, 2020. 3.1 The limited issue raised in the present ground of appeal filed by the Department is regarding claim of deduction in respect of the Tatipaka Refinery of Rs. 35,50,21,698/- which was allowed by the CIT(A), holding that the said undertaking undisputedly carried out refining of crude oil i.e., extraction of various fractions from mineral oil by a process of fractional distillation, such as Petrol, Diesel, SKO, LPG, C2-C3, Naptha, etc., but disallowed the balance claim of Rs. 283,35,29,636/- in respect of profits derived from refining operations from other undertakings on the ground that activities carried out by other undertakings only entailed separation of water, gas and contaminants resulting in a purer form of crude oil and did not involve ‘refining activities. 4. Aggrieved with the above order, the Revenue is in appeal before us. 5. At the time of hearing, Ld. DR submitted as under: “a. At the outset, it is imperative to note the brief background and context in which these appeals have come up for hearing. For A.Y. 2008-09, the Assessee as well as the Revenue filed appeals before the Hon'ble Tribunal 4
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
against the order of the CIT(A). Revenue's appeal bears number 1639/Del/2016 and Assessee's appeal (since withdrawn on account of disclosure under VSVS) had number 1744/Del/2016. b. That, Ground No. 1 of the Assessee's appeal (since withdrawn) was directed against the finding that the- (i) the conditions of the provisions of Section 801B(2) were not satisfied; and (ii) the activity of separation' was not covered within the meaning of refining for the purposes of deduction under Section 801B(9). c. That, the A.O., in his order of assessment, had rejected the claim of deduction under Section 801B(9) on these grounds: - 1. The conditions laid down in sub-section (2) of Section 801B was not fulfilled which was a primary condition. (Page 14 of the assessment order). The Assessee raised the primary contention that the conditions of Section 801B(2) were not applicable in their case. Driven by this legal plea, the Assessee preferred not to file any details to demonstrate that the conditions stipulated therein were satisfied unit wise. 2. The undertaking must begin commercial production within the time frame and the Assessee in this case is not engaged in commercial production. (Page 14-15 of the assessment order). d. Before CIT(A), the Assessee raised various grounds which included: - 1. Not allowing deduction under Section 8018. 2. Holding that the conditions of Section 801B(2) were not satisfied. 3. Holding that undertakings were not engaged in commercial production of mineral for the purposes of Section 801B(9). 4. Not allowing deduction under Section 8018 in respect of profits from Tatipaka refinery.
e. The CIT(A) reached a finding that:-
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Before an entity can be held to be eligible for the benefit of Section 801B(9), it must fulfil the condition laid down in Section 801B(2) of the Act. (Para 24 at Page 21 CIT(A)'s order). 2. The Assessee has so far not been able to show that the said conditions of Section 80IB(2) have been fulfilled. Hence it is not entitled to the benefit of deduction under Section 801B(9). 3. In view of the judgement in the case of Hindustan Colas, 151 TTJ 421, the fulfilment of the conditions of Section 801B(2) was a must for claiming the benefit of deduction under Section 801B(9) of the Act. The Assessee cannot be granted the benefits of Section 801B(9) of the Act. (Para 14-16 at Pages 36-37 of CIT(A)'s order). 4. The Assessee has two types of activities: (i) refining of crude oil at Tatipaka refinery, and (ii) separation activities at other stations. (Para 19 at Page 44 of CIT(A)'s order). 5. The separation activities are not entitled to deduction under Section 8018(9). The disallowance in that regard is upheld. (Para 20 at Pages 46 of CIT (A)'s order). 6. A deduction of Rs. 35,50,21.698/- was allowed to the Assessee under Section 8018(9) on account of refining of mineral oil at Tatipaka and the balance claim in respect of profits from separation activities is rejected. (Para 21 at Pages 47 of CIT(A)'s order).
PRELIMINARY SUBMISSION CONTRADICTORY FINDINGS RENDERED BY THE CIT[A] AND CONSPICUOUS ADMISSION BY THE ASSESSEE REGARDING NON-SUBMISSION OF RELEVANT DOCUMENTS BEFORE THE AO a. The Revenue submits that from a reading of Para 21 of the order of CIT(A) it is clear that he has not given any basis to show as to how the Tatipaka refinery is engaged in the refining of mineral oil. Even if it be so, how the Assessee could be held entitled, without satisfying the basic conditions of Section 801B(2) have not been dealt with.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
b. It appears from the paper-book filed by the Assessee that they've relied upon sample copies of invoices in respect of the products manufactured/sold at Tatipaka refinery, copy of Form ERI evidencing registration number, various products manufactured at that site and brief process and schematic layout at Tatipaka refinery complex. The certificate given with the paper-book records that these documents were placed before authorities below. However, it does not specify whether these documents were before A.O. as well. No remand report appears to have been called from the A.O. C. It appears on the face of it that certain documents were placed before CIT(A) which were never confronted to the AO, byway of remand report or otherwise and relief was given without affording opportunity to the AO as per the statutory mandate. d. The finding of CIT(A) is not based on any material and if based on material made available in the paper-book, the A.O. does not seem to have been provided with any opportunity for the same. e. The deduction under Section 8018 can be claimed only by the undertakings which fulfil the conditions laid down in sub-section (2) of Section 8018. Having upheld the finding of the A.O. that the conditions of 80IB(2) are not satisfied in this case, the CIT(A) could not have given any relief under Section 801B(9) in respect of profits from Tatipaka refinery. f. Imperatively and crucially, the Assessee's ground of appeal against the finding of CIT(A) with regard to applicability of Section 801B(2) does not survive any more in view of the withdrawal of appeal under VSVS. While the adverse findings do not become any precedent against the taxpayer if matters are settled under VSVS, the fact remains that the findings of CIT(A) with regard to applicability of Section 801B(2) for this year has attained finality. In that view of the matter, the relief allowed by CIT(A) under Section 801B(9) is wholly unjustified and is not liable to be sustained.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
At this juncture, it is imperative to advert to the alternate and without prejudice submission of the Assessee (raised in Para 39 of its submission). It has been contended by the Assessee 'on a without prejudice basis that it fulfils all the conditionalities of Section 801B(2) with respect to the refinery in Tatipaka. It has, accordingly been urged by the Assessee that even if the findings of the CIT(A) regarding applicability of conditions prescribed in Section 801B(2) to Section 801B(9) are affirmed, the same would make no impact for this particular industrial undertaking.
The Revenue submits that this assertion of the Assessee, is unverified and pre-emptive in nature, for the following reasons-
a. There is not an iota of evidence led by the Assessee to show that it has fulfilled the conditionalities of Section 801B(2). It needs to be appreciated that the various conditions specified in Section 801B(2) [such as determining whether the industrial undertaking is formed by splitting up or reconstruction of a business already in existence or not etc.] requires extensive factual verification, which admittedly has not been conducted at any stage. b. At the cost of repetition, it is stated that driven by the legal argument on the applicability of Section 801B(2), the Assessee never led, on fact, any material to that effect. c. The argument of the Assessee that the industrial undertaking was set- up as far back as in 2021, cannot lead to an automatic conclusion that the conditions of Section801B(2) are fulfilled, especially when, the verification of this claim has not been conducted by the Assessing Officer during the year under consideration when the deduction is being claimed. It needs to be appreciated that in the initial years also, the said legal ground was raised and the assessee never filed any piece of paper to show that the conditions were satisfied. d. It needs to be appreciated that an undertaking may have been set-up in 2001, however, when a deduction has not been claimed in any of the 8
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
years earlier and is being claimed for AY 2008-09, the AO will only examine the facts during the proceedings being undertaken for AY 2008-09. This would entail examination of Form 10CCB filed along with the return of AY 2008-09 along with the relevant documents. To assert orally, that the conditions of Section 801B(2) get fulfilled in its case (on a without prejudice basis), without leading any evidence on this count, would, if accepted, result in a dangerous precedent. e. The request of the Assessee, entails seeking a ruling without obtaining any opportunity in this regard to the AO. This plea is a gross violation of principles of natural justice.
SUBMISSIONS OF REVENUE ON MERITS-THE APPLICABILITY OF SECTION 80IB a. The CIT(A) has affirmed the denial of benefit of Section 80-IB primarily on the ground that the conditions under Section 80IB(2) are not fulfilled. The claim of the Assessee is that Section 80IB(2) is not applicable to them as the Assessee is not an industrial undertaking. b. The provisions of Section 801B falls within the ambit of Chapter VI-A and under the sub-head of 'Deductions in respect of certain incomes which are in the form of profit linked incentives for the promotion of certain industries or sectors of economy. Certain deductions relate to capital intensive projects while others may relate to certain industries or services that need to be supported so that entrepreneurs make investments in these sectors and the desired sector gets impetus and growth. c. The above background is necessary to consider the context in which the words and the expressions are used in different provisions of this Chapter. d. The provisions contained in Section 801A were introduced for the first time by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1991 w.e.f. 1.4.1991. In its original version, the eligible businesses formed part of sub-section (1) 9
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
of 80-IA and the conditions under sub-section (2) were the same as it exists today However, due to subsequent amendments, the provision became very cumbersome and therefore the Finance Act, 1999 bifurcated this section into twoi.eSection 80IA and Section 80IB. e. While the former was confined to diedluccionsavailattie to infrastructure facilities, the latter live. Section 308 was in the form of a general incentive provision catering to different kinds of undertakings, enterprises or entities engaged in the businesses that need the necessary impetus. f. The heading of the Section 80-IB reads as under- ‘Deduction in respect of profits and gains from certain industrial undertalktings other than infrastructure development undertakings’. g. As evident from the heading itself that this section in its entirety applies to certain industrial undertakings other than infrastructure development undertakings. The division was obvious Section 80IB provided for infrastructure development undertakings and Section 80- IB for certain industries undertakings other than those engaged in infrastructure development. h. Sub-section (2 of Section 800B provides general conditions, which apply to all undertaking/enterprises across the board while sub-section (3) to (118) provides for only the amount and period off deduction in respect of different kinds of undertakings. Sub-section to (218) do not provide for the eligibility for deduction Certain conditions specific to these businesses, particularly regarding their ownership on date commencement etc, do come in, wherever necessary, conditions stipulated insub-section (2) stand incorporated in those sub sections of 80IB. i. The primary question in the present appeal is whether the expression undertaking wed in sub-section is in contradistinction to industrial undertaking used in sub-section 2. In the alternative, as CIT(A) has elaborately discussed the issue, these two words are interchangeable 10
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
under the scheme off the Act and if that be so the conditions stipulated in sub-section (2) would apply across the board to all the businesses- referred in different provisions j. It is submitted that neither off these two expressions are defined im Section 80-18 of the Act. The term ‘industrial undertaking’ is defined under other provisions of the act whether specifically indicated or not. 1. Section 10(15) Explanation 1-- For the purposes of this sub-clause, the expression "industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is engaged in- (α) the manufacture or processing of goods, or (aa) the manufacture of computer software or recording of programme on any disc, tape, perforated media or other information device, or (b) the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power, or (ba) the business of providing telecommunication services, or (c) mining, or (d) the construction of ships, or (da) the business of ship-breaking, or (e) the operation of ships or aircrafts or construction or operation of rail systems.
Section 33B Explanation. -- In this section, "Industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is mainly engaged in the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power or in the construction of ships or in the manufacture or processing of goods or in mining, goods or in mining. 3. Section 72A. (7) For the purposes of this section,- 11
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
(aa) "industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is engaged in- (i) the manufacture or processing of goods, or (ii) the manufacture of computer software, or (iii) the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form o (iiia) the business of providing telecommunication services, whether basic or cellular, including radio paging, domestic satellite service, network of trunking, broadband network and internet services, or (iv) mining, or (v) The construction of ships, aircrafts or rail systems: k. The word undertaking has been defined only in the context of demerger which would not be of any relevance to the present controversy. The relevant extracts of the Act setting forth the definition of an 'undertaking' are as follows: -
Section 2(19AA) Explanation 1. For the purposes of this clause, "undertaking" shall include any part of an undertaking, or a unit or division of an undertaking or a business activity taken as a whole, but does not include individual assets or liabilities or any combination thereof not constituting a business activity.
Section 2(420) Explanation 1-- For the purposes of this clause, "undertaking" shall have the meaning assigned to it in Explanation/to clause (19AA).
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
The 'undertaking' is a word of wide import and it has been defined in P Ramanatha Aiyar's Advanced Law Lexicon (4th Edition) as extracted hereunder. -
(i) Anything undertaken; any business, work or project which one engages in or attempts: an enterprise [WEBSTER'S Dictionary, as referred in Workmen v. Indian Standards Institution, (1975) 2 SCC 847, 853 to 855, p. 5) (ii) The expression "undertaking" has the same meaning as the expression 'business." Loknath Misra v. State of Orissa, AIR 1952 Ori 42. (S. 299(2), Government of India Act, 1935) m. Similarly the word 'industrial undertaking' finds a definition in the following decisions-
(i) The concept of 'industrial undertaking' for the purpose of Sections 80HHA and 80-1 of the Act have to be construed liberally in broader commercial sense keeping its object in view. It is not necessarily to be confined to manufacture and production of articles and even in the absence of either of them there can be an 'industrial undertaking. /Ship Scrap Traders v. CIT, (2001) 251 [ITR 806 (Bom)] [Income-tax Act (43 of 1961), S. 80 HHA and 80-1] (ii) The expression 'industrial undertaking' as used in Section 54D of the Act should be understood in a wide sense so as to take in its fold any project or business a personmay undertake [Alikunju (P.), M.A. Nazeer Cashew Industries v. CIT, (1987) 166 ITR 804 (Ker)] [Income-tax Act 43 of 1961), 5. 54D).
n. However, apart from these general meaning of the word, it may be worthwhile to see the manner in which these two expressions have been used by the legislature in different provisions of the Income Tax Act. (i) Clause (iv) of sub-section (2) of Section 80-IB:- Sub-section (2) of Section 80-1B provides four conditions, which have to be cumulatively 13
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
satisfied in order to claim deduction under the section. The fourth condition, provided in clause (iv) of the sub-section sets out the minimum number of workers which the industrial undertaking ought to have. In laying down such condition, the clause says that the undertaking must employ ten or more workers where the manufacturing is done with the aid of power and twenty or more workers, where the manufacturing is done without the aid of power. Therefore, sub-section (2) itself does not differentiate between an 'undertaking' and 'industrial undertaking and uses the two terms interchangeably. (ii) Sub-section (1) read with sub-section (11) of section 80-IA: Sub- section (1) provides that an undertaking of an eligible business will be entitled to claim the deduction specified in the section. Sub-section (11) gives Central Government the power to direct that certain class of industrial undertakings shall not be allowed the deduction under the section. If the two expressions are said to carry different meanings, sub- section (11) becomes otiose as an industrial undertaking would in any case not be eligible for deductions under this section as the section only gives deductions to undertakings and if industrial undertakings are per se not eligible under this section, the Central Government cannot possibly take away a benefit which does not and cannot exist.
(iii) Proviso to section 10B(2) read with section 33B- Section 33B provides for allowing a deduction of a sum by way of rehabilitation allowance, where the business of an industrial undertaking is discontinued due to specified circumstances in a previous year and the said business is re-established within a period of three years. Section 10B allows deduction of profits of export-oriented undertakings. Sub-section (2) of the section prescribes three conditions, subject to which deduction is to be allowed. The second condition prescribed under clause (ii) says that the undertaking should not have been formed by splitting up or reconstructing a business, already in existence. However, an exception is provided to this clause by way of a proviso. As per the proviso, an undertaking which is re- 14
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
established in terms of section 33B of the Act is not required to satisfy the condition provided in clause (ii) to sub-section (2) to section 10B of the Act. Therefore, section 33B covers industrial undertaking. whereas proviso to section 10B(2)(ii) calls the same industrial undertaking, an undertaking. (iv) Sub-Section (4) of Section 80A Section 80A is the first section of Chapter VI-A and contains general provisions which govern all the deductions under the said Chapter, i.e. from Section 80C to Section 80U. Sub-section (4) of this section provides that deduction under any of the sections of this Chapter or Section 10A etc., once allowed, will not be allowed again under any other section of the Act and the deduction under any of the sections of the Chapter should in no circumstance exceed the profits and gains of the undertaking. Had the legislature really envisaged two distinct categories of 'undertaking' and 'industrial undertaking, it would have separately covered both such categories under the above provision. If the interpretation put forth by the assessee is accepted, it would mean that section 80A applies to all the sections which deal with 'undertakings' but does not apply to sections which deal with 'industrial undertakings, meaning thereby, industrial undertakings are allowed to claim deduction of more than its profits. The consequences of such an interpretation would be absurd, (v) Sub-section (1) of read with sub-section (4) of Section 72A o. Further, it is humbly submitted that the interpretation that sub-section (2) would apply only to industrial undertaking as different from undertaking or enterprise may lead to most undesirable consequences and would defeat the very object and purpose of this enactment.
p. It may therefore be appreciated that undertaking and industrial undertaking are used interchangeably in the entire Act and these cannot be read in contradistinction to each other for the purpose of Section 80- IB. It may also be appreciated that this being an incentive provision, there must be a strict interpretation as held by a Constitution Bench of the 15
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Commissioner of Customs (Import) Mumbai Vs. M/s Dilip Kumar and Company and Ors [[2018] 95 taxmann.com 327 (SC)). It has been held that-
1) Exemption notification should be interpreted strictly, the burden of proving applicability would be on the assessee to show that his care comes within the parameters of the exemption clause or exemption notification. 2) When there is ambiguity in exemption notification which is subject to strict interpretation, the benefit of such ambiguity cannot be claimed by the subject/assessee and it must be interpreted in favour of the revenue. 3) The ratio in Sun Export case (supra) is not correct and all the decisions which took similar view as in Sun Export Case (supra) stands over-ruled." q. Further, it may, thus, be appreciated that Section 80-1B is an exemption of an incentive provision and any ambiguity in the interpretation of the use of the words industrial undertaking or undertaking must necessarily be in resolved in favour of Revenue. The case cited above being from a Constitution Bench of the Apex Court overrules all other decisions which have held that incentive provision must get a liberal interpretation if two views are possible, decision should go in favour of Assessee. This decision of the Apex Court lays down the law relating to the rule of interpretation and would apply to both direct taxes and indirect taxes.
r. From a close analysis of various sub-sections of 80-1B, it emerges that there are three categories of classes of taxpayers to whom this provision applies:
1) Taxpayers engaged in the business of manufacture or production of article or thing including ship building:
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
2) Taxpayers engaged in the business of rendering services like hotels, multiplex theatres, convention centres, hospitals, housing etc.; 3) Companies carrying on scientific research.
s. In the first category, the expressions used is industrial undertaking or undertaking interchangeably. In the second category, the conditions similar to sub-section (2) have been separately provided for. In the third category, the condition for approval from the prescribed authority takes care of the conditions stipulated in sub-section (2) and hence not separately provided for. In the case of housing projects, a separate Section 80-IBA has since been introduced having conditions similar to Section 80-18 (2). Prior to this amendment the approval by the prescribed authority took care of such conditions. t. Further, it has to be appreciated that the conditions stipulated in sub- section (2) are the fundamental conditions to prevent the misuse or unintended use or abuse of the incentive provisions and this condition runs across all incentive provisions contained in this sub-chapter. It would hit at the very root of these provisions and lead to absurd consequences if the view canvassed by the Assessee is accepted. u. It is submitted that the issue today stands fully covered by the decision of the Coordinate Bench of the Hon'ble Tribunal in this case, as explained in subsequent paragraphs. v. The Assessee has referred to certain decisions for relying on the proposition that the words industrial undertaking and 'undertaking' have to be read in contradistinction to each other. All these decisions are qua sub-sections other than sub-section (9) of 80-IB. The Ld. CIT(A) has referred to the decision of Hindustan Colas Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Income tax (140 ITD 277) which is directly on sub- section (9) and has to be preferred over other decisions. The observations of the Hon'ble Tribunal in the case of Hindustan Colas is reproduced below: 17
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
"2.1.15 We have carefully considered the issue. The phrase " Industrial undertaking" has not been defined in section 8018 The phrase "industrial undertaking" has been defined in the Explanation to section 33B as per which it means an undertaking which is mainly engaged in the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power or in the construction of ships or in manufacture or processing of goods or in mining. Thus the phrase "industrial undertaking" among other things means an undertaking manufacturing or producing any goods. Section 8018 applies to various businesses as mentioned in sub section (3) to sub section (118) some of which relate to industrial undertakings producing certain article or goods not being article or thing listed in the Eleventh Schedule while others relate to non-manufacturing businesses such as business of shipping, running of hotel, multiplex theatre. scientific research etc. The sub-sections (3) to sub section (118) give rate of deduction depending upon status of the assessee, nature of business carried on and also mentions the period for which deduction is available The sub-sections (3) to (5) are applicable to industrial undertakings meaning thereby undertakings manufacturing or producing article or things. In sub-section (11) also, the phrase "industrial undertaking" has been used as it refers to setting up and operation of cold storage plant, which has been referred to as individual undertaking in sub-section (2). In other sub-sections, the word "industrial undertaking" has not been mentioned. In sub-section (9) the word "undertaking" has been used and in this sub-section rate of deduction as well as period for which it is allowable has been given in respect of commercial production of mineral oil, natural gas or refining of mineral oil. Any undertaking producing mineral oil or gas has to be considered as industrial undertaking in terms of the definition of the term discussed earlier. The assessee admittedly is 18
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
manufacturing/producing value added products by using bitumen as raw material after applying certain processes. Therefore, it cannot he accepted that the assessee is not an industrial undertaking. The word "undertaking" used in sub-section (9) is a wider term which also includes industrial undertakings. The word "undertaking" has been used because sub-section refers not only to production of mineral oil but also refining of mineral oil which may not be an industrial undertaking. Therefore, the word "undertaking" used in section 801B(9) has to be interpreted In the context of business being done. Since the assessee itself has claimed that it is producing commercial products using bitumen as raw material the assessee is to he considered as Industrial undertaking. Therefore, in our view, the conditions prescribed in section 801B(2) will be applicable in the case of the assessee. The decisions of the Tribunal relied upon by the assessee cannot be accepted as a binding precedent as various aspects mentioned above have been omitted to be considered in the said cases. We, therefore, hold that provisions of section 801B(2) will be applicable in case the assessee is found to be producer of mineral oil." w. The Assessee's reliance on some of the decisions are distinguishable as they are rendered under other provisions of Section 801B, whereas the case of Hindustan Colas (supra) is directly in reference to this particular section. x. In view of the above it is submitted the use of the word undertaking in sub-section(9) which relates to Assessee's engaged in mining activity and the production of mineral oil or gas has to be read as being interchangeable with industrial undertakingused in sub-section (2) and therefore all the conditions contemplated in sub-section(2) would be applicable in the case of the Assessee as well.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
The Assessee has not been able to establish that these conditions stand satisfied in their case and this finding of fact has been recorded both by the Ld. AO and Ld. CIT(A) in their respective orders. The Assessee has not controverted the same. It is, therefore, not eligible for deduction under Section 80-IB. The amount of deduction, whether it be computed on the basis individual oil wells or on the basis of licensed area, is immaterial and inconsequential under these circumstances.”
On the other hand, Ld. AR submitted that Sub section (9) of section 80IB of the Act provides for deduction in respect of profits derived by undertakings engaged in the commercial production or the refining of mineral oil.It is respectfully reiterated that the Tatipaka Refinery of the assessee satisfied all the requirements necessary for claiming deduction under section 80-IB(9) in respect of refining of mineral oil namely: - (a) Undertaking had started refining mineral oil on or after 01-10-1998. (b) assessee had obtained & produced audit reports in respect of its refinery eligible for the deduction under section 80-IB(9) in Form 10CCB. (c) The profits worked out in the Profit & Loss accounts and From 10CCB pertain to the refining of mineral oil taking place in the refinery. The assessee had entered into contract dated 17.10.2000 with M/s Nicco Corporation Ltd. for setting up a new Refinery at Tattipaka. The said Refinery commenced its operations on 03.09.2001; the date of commencement of
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
operations and address of the Tatipaka undertaking has been reported at item 8 and item 10 respectively by the Auditors in Audit Report (Form 10CCB) obtained in terms of 80IB(13) read with Section 80-IA(7). (Refer, pg. no. 16 of the Paperbook). In the Audit Report, the Auditors have clearly certified that the undertaking satisfies the conditions stipulated in section 80-IB and the amount of deduction claimed under this section is as per the provisions of the Income-tax Act. (Refer, Form 10CCB placed in the paperbook at pages 15-21) The assessee had also obtained a Registration Certificate issued by Asst. Commercial Tax Officer, Rajamundhry, Commercial Taxes Department in Form D-1 which also states that the Refinery has started operation w.e.f., September 2001. The Tatipaka Refinery is undisputedly a new Refinery setup by the assessee and engaged in refining of crude oil i.e., extraction of various fractions from mineral oil by a process of fractional distillation, such as Petrol, Diesel, SKO, LPG, C2- C3, Naptha, etc. The aforesaid is evident from the following: Sample copies of invoices in respect of each of the products sold by Tatipaka Mini-refinery placed at pages 22-36 of the Paperbook; Copy of Form ER1 (Return of Excisable Goods) evidencing the registration number and various products manufactured placed at pages 37-45 of the Paperbook; 21
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
It is pertinent to note that the assessing officer has also not doubted admissibility of the claim and/or the accuracy of the amount of deduction claimed by the assessee. In view of the above, considering that undertaking satisfies all the conditions required for claiming deduction under section 80IB(9) of the Act and is undisputedly, carrying out refining activity, the CIT(A) had rightly allowed the claim of deduction that section. 7. In the rejoinder, Ld. AR submitted that the contention of the DR that the provisions of sub-section (2) of section 80-IB, which prescribes certain further conditions to be fulfilled by an ‘industrial undertaking’ are applicable to the undertaking referred to in sub-section (9) thereof, i.e., an undertaking engaged in the business of commercial production or refining of mineral oil is not sustainable as elaborated hereunder: Conditions prescribed in section 80-IB(2) are not applicable to an I. undertaking eligible for deduction under section 80-IB(9) A. Legislative history of section 80IB – Extension of erstwhile provisions of section 80IA 2. Prior to insertion of section 80-IB in the statute by the Finance Act, 1999 with effect from 01.04.2000, the similar provisions qua tax holiday to
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
certain specified businesses were prescribed only in section 80-IA of the Act. 3. Under the aforesaid erstwhile section, the tax holiday by way of deduction from profits at specified percentage was available to the following diverse categories of businesses including an industrial undertaking. The relevant extract of sub-section (1) of the erstwhile section 80-IA is reproduced as under: “80-IA. (1) Where the gross total income of an assessee includes any profits and gains derived from any business of an industrial undertaking or a hotel or [operation of a ship or developing, maintaining and operating any infrastructure facility [or scientific and industrial research and development] [or providing telecommunication services whether basic or cellular] [including radio paging, domestic satellite service or network of trunking and electronic data interchange services or construction and development of housing projects] [or operating an industrial park or commercial production [or refining] of mineral oil in the North Eastern Region] [or in any part of India on or after the 1st day of April, 1997] (such business being hereinafter referred to as the eligible business)], to which this section applies, there shall, in accordance with and subject to the provisions of this section, be allowed, in computing the total income of the assessee, a deduction from such profits and gains of an amount equal to the percentage specified in sub-section (5) and for such number of assessment years as is specified in sub-section (6)”
It is pertinent to mention that on perusal of aforementioned sub- section (1) of erstwhile section 80-IA, it would be appreciated that the 23
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
business of an “industrial undertaking” and other businesses viz., Business of operation of a Ship or Business of any hotel; or Undertaking engaged in commercial production or refining of mineral oil etc. were separated by the use of term‘or’ and, therefore, the business of ‘industrial undertaking’ and other businesses, including business of commercial production or refining of mineral oil, were clearly considered as independent and separate from each other. 5. In terms of the aforesaid erstwhile section, it was further clear that the conditions prescribed in sub-section (2) of section 80IA, which are pari- materia to conditions in section 80-IB(2), i.e.,– (i) the industrial undertaking is not formed by splitting up or the re-construction of a business already in existence; or (ii) the industrial undertaking is not formed by the transfer to a new business of machinery or plant previously used for any purpose, was not applicable to other businesses, for which separate conditions were prescribed in sub-sections (3) to (4F) of section 80-IA of the Act. 6. In other words, the scheme of the erstwhile section 80-IA clearly drew distinction between the business of an ‘industrial undertaking’ and
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
other businesses including undertaking engaged in business of commercial production or refining of mineral oil. 7. Since section 80-IA as successively amended and was unwieldy, the section was restructured into two parts, viz., sections 80-IA and 80-IB by the Finance No.(2) Act 1999 w.e.f. 1.4.2000 and the eligible businesses were divided for eligibility under sections 80-IA and 80-IB of the Act.
Post restructuring, section 80-IA dealt with tax holiday to industrial undertakings or enterprises engaged in infrastructure development, etc. and section 80-IB dealt with businesses other than infrastructure businesses.
For instance, section 80-IA covered following businesses: a) Undertaking engaged in the business of (i) developing or (ii) operating and maintaining or (iii) developing, operating and maintaining any infrastructure facility; b) Undertaking providing telecommunication services whether basic or cellular, including radio paging, domestic satellite service, network of trunking, broadband network and internet services.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
whereas, section 80-IB covered following businesses, which were covered within the scope of erstwhile section 80-IA:
Industrial undertaking set up in an industrially backward State/notified industrially backward district engaged in the manufacture or production of an article or a thing; Business of operation of a Ship; Business of any hotel; Business of scientific research and development; Commercial production / refining of mineral oil; Business of developing and building housing projects. 10. As mentioned in the memorandum explaining provisions in Finance Bill,1999 (Enclosed at pages 18-19 of Case laws paper book), “the restructured sections seek to retain the benefits hitherto provided in section 80-IA”. In this regard, it is respectfully submitted that the newly inserted section 80-IB carried forward the benefit of tax holiday available to existing businesses under the erstwhile section 80-IA, without any intent of dilution or inserting additional burden / condition upon such businesses.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Thus, the basic scheme and ethos relating to allowing tax holiday to relevant businesses under section 80-IB remained the same, as prescribed in the erstwhile section 80-IA of the Act, albeit in the new avatar. B. Section 80-IB – Independent and self-contained 12. Section 80-IB of the Act is a composite section providing tax holiday to various kinds of business, referred to as the ‘eligible business’. 13. Unlike the provisions of erstwhile section 80-IA, where the qualification for different eligible businesses, conditions for eligibility and amount of deduction of profits for such businesses, was dealt with together in different sub-sections, viz., (1), (2) to (4F) and (5), respectively, under the provisions of 80-IB of the Act, each sub-section independently deals and prescribes conditions for eligibility and amount of deduction available to different businesses on a stand-alone basis. 14. Each of the aforesaid sub-section(s) dealing with independent and distinct businesses are self-contained, prescribing conditions to be fulfilled by such businesses and the amount of deduction of profits available thereto. In other words, the various sub-sections governing the grant of deduction to different categories of eligible businesses are independent and separate codes, mutually exclusive, which do not overlap or impinge on each other. 27
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
From the aforesaid, it follows that sub-section (9) of section 80-IB of the Act provides for deduction of 100% of the profits derived by an undertaking engaged in commercial production and/or refining of mineral oils upon satisfaction of the conditions laid down in that sub-section. As per clause (ii) of said sub-section, the undertaking located in any part of India should begin commercial production of mineral oil on or after 1st day of April, 1997. In case the undertaking is engaged in refining of mineral oil, it should begin refining on or after the 1st day of October, 1998. 16. The aforesaid sub-section (9), it would be appreciated, is a self- contained provision which prescribes independent and stand-alone conditions which are required to be fulfilled by an undertaking engaged in the business of commercial production and/or refining of mineral oil for the purpose of claiming deduction under that section. There is no inter-play or dependence between sub-section (9) and the other sub-sections of section 80-IB of the Act. C. Terms ‘industrial undertaking’ and ‘undertaking’ in section 80IB are distinct terms. 17. Apart from the submissions hereinbefore, it is respectfully submitted that the word “industrial undertaking” used in section 80-IB(2) of the Act 28
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
is, even otherwise, substantially distinct from the word “undertaking” used in, inter alia, sub-section (9) and the two expressions have not been and cannot be used interchangeably. 18. On perusal of section 80-IB, it would be appreciated that the business of ‘industrial undertaking’ was considered as separate and distinct from other businesses, in as much as, separate provisions were cast for providing deduction to business of ‘industrial undertaking’, viz., sub- sections (3), (4), (5) which clearly use the term “industrial undertaking”. On the other hand, sub-sections (6), (7), (7A), (7B), (8), (8A), (9), (10), (11), (11A), (11B), (11C) deal with businesses other than that of “industrial undertaking” viz. Operation of a Ship; Hotel undertaking, Commercial production/refining of mineral Oil, Scientific research and development etc., and, therefore, such sub-sections do not use the term “industrial undertaking” instead use specific terms such as “undertaking”, “Multiplex theater”, “Hotel” etc. 19. The terms ‘industrial undertaking’ and ‘undertaking’ connote different meanings is further elucidated hereunder: Meaning of term ‘industrial undertaking’ Definition under Income Tax Act 29
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
The term “industrial undertaking” has not been defined for the purposes of section 80-IB, nor generally under the Act, except for specific provisions of the Act, elaborated as under: 21. The term ‘Industrial undertaking’ has been defined in section 33B of the Act for the purpose of that section and reads as under: “Explanation.—In this section, "industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is mainly engaged in the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power or in the construction of ships or in the manufacture or processing of goods or in mining. (emphasis supplied) 22. Likewise, Explanation 1 to section 10(15)(iv) of the Act has also defined the expression "industrial undertaking" for the purpose of the said provision which reads as under: “Explanation 1].—For the purposes of this sub-clause, the expression "industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is engaged in— ( the manufacture or processing of goods; or a ) ( the manufacture of computer software or recording of a programme on any disc, tape, perforated media or a other information device; or ) ( the business of generation or distribution of electricity b or any other form of power; or ) ( the business of providing telecommunication services; b or a ) ( mining; or 30
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
c ) ( the construction of ships; or d ) ( the business of ship-breaking; or d a ) ( the operation of ships or aircrafts or constructionor e operation of rail systems”. ) Definition under other Statutes: 23. The term ‘Industrial undertaking’ is defined in section 3(d) of the Industrial Development and Regulation Act, 1951 as “any undertaking pertaining to a scheduled industry carried on in one or more factories by any person or authority including Government.” 24. In view of the above, it would be appreciated that there is no uniform meaning of the term “industrial undertaking”, which has been defined differently under the different statutes keeping in mind the context or the purpose for which the said term is used in the relevant provision / statute. 25. Accordingly, considering that the term “industrial undertaking” has not been defined for the purpose of section 80-IB of the Act, the same has to be interpreted and understood in common parlance and/or in the context of the provisions of that section. 31
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
In this regard, reliance is placed on the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Ansal Housing & Construction Ltd. v. CIT: 320 ITR 420 (Delhi), wherein while dealing with the issue as to whether business of construction and sale of multistoried residential buildings and complexes and other real estate business would be treated as an ‘industrial undertaking’ for the purpose of allowing amortization of expenditure which is otherwise capital in nature under section 35D of the Act, the Court interpreted that where the ‘industrial undertaking’ has not been specifically defined, the same has to be understood as per its meaning in common parlance, i.e., factories carrying on some manufacturing activity. 27. The ambit of section 35D of the Act was subsequently enlarged by the Finance Act, 2008 w.e.f. 01.04.2009 by replacing the word ‘industrial undertaking’ with ‘undertaking’, so as to make available the benefit of amortization of expenditure under that section to all businesses. The CBDT vide Circular No. 1/2009 dated 27-3-2009 providing explanatory notes to the provisions of Finance Act, 2008, in the context of provisions of section 35D, clarified as under: “11. Extending the provision of section 35D relating to amortization of preliminary expenses to all undertakings 32
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
11.1 Section 35D provides for deduction of certain specified preliminary expenses. After the commencement of business, the deduction was being allowed to only an industrial undertaking or unit. In order to provide a level playing field to the services sector, the section has been amended to provide the benefit of amortization to all assessees after commencement of his business, in connection with the extension of his undertaking or in connection with his setting up a new unit.”
In view of the above, it would kindly be appreciated that the terms ‘industrial undertaking’ and ‘undertaking’ connote and convey different meanings. It is precisely for the aforesaid reason that the Legislature has consciously used the expression ‘industrial undertaking’ in sub-sections (3) to (5) while sub-sections (9), (10), (11A), (11B), (11C) of section 80-IB of the Act employ the term ‘undertaking’. 29. In that view of the matter, it is submitted that the conditions prescribed in sub-section (2), which are applicable to industrial undertaking alone, have no application to undertakings engaged in other businesses referred in sub-sections (6) to (11C) of section 80-IB of the Act,
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
including business of commercial production and/or refining of mineral oil under sub-section (9) thereof. D. Judicial Precedents in favour of Appellant 30. Reliance is placed on the following decisions wherein it has been held that conditions contained in sub-section (2) of section 80IB are applicable to ‘industrial undertaking’ and not to other businesses specified in other provisions of that section: - The Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Parth Corporation Ltd. v. ITO: 23 SOT 368, held that the provisions of sub-section (2) had no application for claiming deduction under section 80-IB(10); consequently, the condition that the assessee should be an industrial undertaking was not applicable for claiming deduction under the latter sub-section. (Refer Page 36-43 Of Case laws Paper book)
- The aforesaid decision was followed by the Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal in the case of G.V. Corporation Ltd. v. ITO: 133 TTJ 178 (Refer Pages 44-51 Of Case laws Paper book)
- Likewise, the Delhi Bench of Tribunal in the case of ACIT v. S.K. Dynamics (P) Ltd. : 7 ITR (AT) 80, while adjudicating the issue regarding the applicability of sub-section (2) of Section 80-IB of the Act vis-à-vis deduction claimed under section 80-IB(8A) of the Act, held that the provisions of sub-section (8A) and not sub-section (2) will have to be 34
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
considered for the purpose of deciding the issue as to whether the assessee is entitled to deduction under section 80-IB or not. (Refer Pages 52-60 Of Case laws Paper book)
- Reliance is also placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi bench of the Tribunal in the case of DCIT v. L T Foods: ITA No. 4046 and 4164/Del/2013 wherein the Tribunal held that conditions contained in sub- section (2) of section 80IB are applicable to ‘industrial undertaking’ and not to other businesses specified in other provisions of that section including deduction claimed under section 80IB(11A) of the Act. (Refer Pages 121-187 Of Case laws Paper book)
- To the same effect are the following decisions: Enem Nostrum Remedies (P) Ltd. v. ACIT: 119 ITD 427 (Mum Trib.) Nyati Builders (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT: (2014) 65 SOT 0112 (Pune) ((URO)) Parakar Hospital & Research Institute Pvt. Ltd. v. PCIT: ITA No.795/Pun/2015 (Pune Trib.) 31. In that view of the matter, there is no interplay between sub-section (2), on the one hand, and sub-section (9) of section 80-IB of the Act, on the other hand, considering that sub-section (9) is applicable to an undertaking engaged in commercial production and/or refining of mineral oil and provisions of sub-section (2) are only applicable to an industrial
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
undertakings claiming benefit under sub-sections (3) to (5) of the said section. Decision in the case of Hindustan Colas v. ACIT: 151 TTJ 421 (Mum.) II. relied upon by the Department Representative 32. In case of Hindustan Colas v. ACIT: 151 TTJ 421 (Refer Pages 302- 316 of the Case laws Paper book), the assessee, a joint venture between HPCL and Colas SA France was, formed for manufacture of various bitumen-based products. The assessee purchased bitumen from refiners and used the same as raw material for production of bitumen based products after applying certain processes thereon. The assessee claimed deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Act on profits derived from said business, contending that it was engaged in manufacture/production of mineral oil or refining of mineral oil, as bitumen based products were mixture of hydrocarbons, which fell within the meaning of ‘mineral oil’ as per Circular No. 57 dated 23-3-1971 of CBDT (F. No. 156(26)/71-TPL). 33. The assessing officer disallowed the aforesaid claim of deduction on the ground that bitumen was a by-product generated from refining mineral oil and was not ‘mineral oil’. Independent of the above, the assessing officer further alleged that the assessee did not even otherwise satisfy 36
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
conditions stipulated under section 80-IB(2) and was, therefore, not entitled to deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Act. On appeal, the CIT(A) upheld the action of assessing officer. 34. On further appeal, the Tribunal observed that the assessee had claimed deduction on the basis that the assessee was a producer and not refiner of mineral oil. It was observed by the Tribunal that the issue as to whether the assessee was producer or refiner of mineral oil had to be decided after obtaining expert opinion and after necessary examination. Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the issue regarding claim of deduction to the file of the CIT(A) to decide as to whether assessee could be said to be producer or refiner of mineral oil. 35. As regards the contention of the assessing officer regarding the applicability of section 80-IB(2), it was contended by the assessee before the Tribunal that since the assessee claimed deduction under section 80IB(9) which used the term “undertaking”, provisions of the former section, which are applicable only to an “industrial undertaking”, would not be applicable thereto. Rejecting the aforesaid condition of the assessee, the Tribunal held that the word ‘undertaking’ used in the aforesaid section was wide enough to include “industrial undertaking”. The Tribunal held 37
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
that the word “industrial undertaking” implied undertaking engaged in manufacture of product and since the assessee, in the present case, was engaged in manufacturing / producing value added products by using bitumen as raw material applying certain processes, the same fell within the meaning of “industrial undertaking”, which was covered within the scope of “undertaking” eligible for deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the conditions prescribed in section 80-IB(2) were also applicable to the assessee. 36. In the first place, the aforesaid decision is clearly distinguishable from the facts of the present case in as much as the assessee in the aforesaid case was engaged in the business of manufacture / production of value added products from the raw material, viz., bitumen which was itself a by-product arising from refining of mineral oil and not refining of mineral oil, unlike the facts of the present case where the assessee is undisputedly engaged in refining of mineral oil. In the aforesaid facts viz., the assessee in that case being engaged in manufacturing activity, the Tribunal held the assessee to be an “industrial undertaking”. As a consequence, the qualifying conditions contained in section 80-IB(2) of the Act were admittedly applicable to the industrial undertaking engaged in 38
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
manufacture of value added products by using by-products of mineral oil and not to undertaking engaged in refining of mineral oil. 37. The other observations of Hon’ble Tribunal regarding meaning of the word “undertaking” and application of section 80-IB(2) to section 80- IB(9), in our respectful submission were rendered, without considering the scheme of the Act, as elaborately discussed supra, and the earlier decisions of co-ordinate benches of Tribunal specially in the case of Parth Corporation Ltd. (supra) and G.V. Corporation (supra). Thus, the said decision is per incuriam in so far as the issue regarding inter play between section 80-IB (2), on the one hand and section 80-IB(9) of the Act, on the other hand, is concerned. Accordingly, the said decision cannot, it is respectfully submitted, be considered as a binding precedent. 38. For the aforesaid cumulative reasons, it is respectfully submitted that provisions of sub-section (9) and not sub-section (2) will have to be considered for the purpose of deciding the issue as to whether the appellant is entitled to deduction under section 80-IB (9) or not. III. Without prejudice, the appellant has complied with the conditions prescribed in section 80-IB (2) of the Act
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Without prejudice to our contention that the provisions of sub- section (2) of section 80-IB are not applicable to an undertaking engaged in commercial production or refining of mineral oil covered under sub section (9) thereof, even assuming for the sake of argument (without conceding), that the former provisions are applicable to an undertaking eligible for deduction under section 80-IB(9) of the Act, it is respectfully submitted that the appellant even otherwise satisfies the conditions contained in the former sub-section, in respect of Tatipaka refinery.” 8. Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed thatthe issue under consideration is that the two types of activities viz, refining of crude oil at Tatipaka refinery and separation activities at the other stations. The AO had disallowed the deductions claimed by the assessee u/s 80IB(9) of the Act, which includes deduction claimed for both activities. In appeal, Ld CIT(A) had allowed the deduction claimed by the assessee relating to Tatipaka refinery u/s 80IB(9) of the Act and other activities basically involving separation activity. The assessee had settled the above issue under VSV scheme. However, the revenue is in appeal before us. The basic issue are interpretation of the definition relating to “Industrial undertaking” and “undertaking” as mentioned in the section 80IB(1) and 80IB(9) of the Act. The above issue was elaborately 40
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
considered by Ld CIT(A) and held that the meaning of undertaking as mentioned in the section 80IB(9) is applicable to the activities covered by the above section and the term industrial undertaking as referred in the section 80IB(1) and (2) are general, which connotes different meaning. 9. We observed from the assessment order that the AO had grossly observed that the assessee is involved in activities such as Exploration, development, production, separation and refining for production of products such as petrol, diesel etc. Since, the AO observed that the assessee had various units and has not fulfilled the conditions stipulated in section 80IB(9) of the Act. He observed that assessee had not fulfilled the all conditions stipulated in section 80IB(2) of the Act by interpreting the terms industrial undertaking and undertaking mentioned in the sub-section 2 and sub-section 9 of the Act and further observed that the condition of commercial production as mentioned in the sub-section 9 also was not fulfilled. After careful consideration of the submissions made by both the parties, we noticed that the terms/definition relating to industrial undertaking and undertaking are already settled by the coordinate bench in the cases of S.K Dynamics (P) Ltd (supra) and L T Foods (supra). We also observed that the other tribunals Mumbai and Ahmedabad also gave similar decisions. Therefore, we are inclined to decide the issue in favour of the assessee. 41
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
10.Coming to the other issue of commercial production, we noticed and as discussed in the above paragraph that the AO had observed that the assessee had involved in various activities which includes Exploration, development, production, separation and refining for production of products such as petrol, diesel. The AO had rejected the claim of the assessee with the observation that there is no commercial production in these activities. However, we observed that yes there is no commercial production in exploration, development and separation activities whereas the refining for production involves commercial activities, wherein it refines the crude oil and produces the petrol, diesel etc from it and sells the same to the general distribution. It is separate commercial activities, as defined in the section 80IB(9) of the act, the assessee is in the activity of the commercial in nature and they have recorded commercial production and sales activities. Therefore, in our view, the assessee had already fulfilled the conditions mentioned in the sub-section 9 of the Act. Therefore, in our considered view, the assessee is eligible to claim deduction u/s 80IB(9) of the Act relating to the activities in the Tatipaka Unit. Therefore, we are inclined not to disturb the findings of Ld CIT(A) in this regard. In the result, ground raised by the revenue in this regard is dismissed.
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
With regard to ground no. 2, the assessee, as per the provisions of the Oilfield (Regulation and Development) Act, 1948 (‘Oilfield Act’) read with the Petroleum and Natural Gas Rules, 1959, is required to pay royalty on the well- head value of its crude oil production to the respective State Government (‘SG’) in respect on onshore production and to the Central Government (‘CG’) in respect of offshore production). Well-head price is determined as per the scheme formulated by the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas (‘MOP&NG’) vide Gazette Notification dated 16th December 2004.In view of the unprecedented rise in the international prices of crude oil, the assessee was directed by CG to sell its crude oil to refining / oil marketing companies at a discounted price in order to partly offset the adverse impact of such unprecedented rise. However, the MOP&NG, vide letter no. P-20012/28/97-PP dated 30-10-2003, conveyed the decision of the CG that the revenue of SG in terms of royalty on crude oil shall not be affected by the discount offered to refining/ oil marketing companies and thus, while assessee has been selling its crude oil to its customers at a discount, it had to pay royalty to the SG based on the pre-discount prices for onshore production of crude oil.During the relevant assessment year, the assessee paid royalty amounting to Rs.2736.05 crores to various State Governments in respect of the onshore production computed @ 20% of the pre-discounted sale price of 43
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
the crude oil to refining / oil marketing companies in accordance with the provisions of section 6A of the Oilfield Act read with the MOP&NG letter dated 30.10.2003. 11.1 Aggrieved, the assessee filed appeal before the Ld. Assessing Officer, During the assessment order, the assessing officer has worked out the “excess royalty” of Rs. 1591.92 crores paid by the assessee, being the difference between royalty based on pre-discount prices (i.e. Rs.2736.05 crores) and royalty based on post-discount prices (i.e. Rs.1144.13 crores) and disallowed the same, for the following reasons:- 1. The assessee has paid more royalty i.e., exceeding the limit of 20% as fixed by the Oilfield Act and as such excess payments amount to manipulation of profits and reduction of tax, and 2. Excess royalty is an expenditure incurred for sales foregone by the assessee by offering discounts to its customers and thus is not allowable.
11.2 Aggrieved with the above order, the assessee filed appeal before the Ld. CIT(A). After considering the submission of the assessee, Ld. CIT(A) deleted the addition by relying on the decision of Hon’ble Uttarakhand High Court in assessee’s own case for the assessment year 2006-07, deleted the aforesaid
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
disallowance by holding that there was no violation of the Oilfield Act in computing the royalty paid to the SGs and thus there was no excess payment of royalty which could warrant addition as made by the assessing officer. 12. On the other hand, Ld. AR submitted that the aforesaid action of the AO is unsustainable on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law as the payment of royalty has been made as per the scheme formulated by MOP&NG under the Oilfield Act, read with letter dated 13.10.2003 of MOP&NG. It is to be appreciated that the assessee in terms of the Oilfield Act, is required to follow the directives of Government regarding the method of quantifying the royalty payable to the Central/State Government, subject to the ceiling of 20% of the wellhead price of crude oil. Hence, the payment of royalty by ONGC is wholly and exclusively for the purpose of its business. Further, the royalty paid by the assessee is allowable business deduction under section 37 of the Act.It is pertinent to point out that the aforesaid issue is covered in favour of the assessee by the order dated 21.05.2015 of the Hon’ble Uttarakhand High Court for the assessment year 2006-07 in ITA No. 18 & 23 of 2010, reported as 235 Taxman 65 (Uttarakhand) wherein the Court held that the royalty paid by the assessee @ 29% to State Government whichexceeded prescribed statutory limit of 20 % as per instructions and guidelines of Central Government, was allowable 45
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
deduction under section 37 and could not be said to be a payment hit by Explanation to section 37 of the Act. It is pertinent to point out that the Department has accepted the aforesaid decision of the High Court and has not filed an SLP before the Supreme Court on this issue. In view of the above, the assessee is eligible for deduction for whole of amount paid towards the royalty on pre-discount price and ground by the Department deserves to be dismissed. 13. On the other hand, Ld DR relied on the findings of lower authorities. 14. Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that similar issues were considered by the Hon’ble Uttarakhand High Court in assessee’s own case and held in favour of the assessee. Respectfully following the above decision, we are inclined to dismiss the ground raised by the revenue in this regard. In the result, grounds raised by the revenue is dismissed. 15. With regard to ground no. 3, the assessee, during the relevant assessment year, had number of off-shore rigs and multi-support vessels (MSVs), which are used in the business of exploration of oil on high seas. The said rigs and MSV’s, as per statutory requirement, have to compulsorily undergo survey within certain specified intervals in order to determine whether the same are seaworthy and can operate in an efficient and safe manner. Such survey is termed as dry docking 46
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
and expenses incurred in relation thereto are termed as dry-docking expenses. Dry-docking is a periodical and routine exercise wherein the structural and mechanical fitness of a floating installation is tested so as to ensure that it continues to be seaworthy and operates efficiently and safely. Further,the dry- docking expenses incurred by the assessee are amortized in the books of accounts in accordance with relevant Accounting Standards issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India and in line with the accounting policy consistently followed in past assessment years. However, in the return of income, the said expenses are claimed as deduction in the year of incurrence and the amount amortized / written off in the books of accounts is added back in computation of taxable income and offered to tax. Further, the assessee, in the Return of Income for relevant assessment year, claimed deduction of an amount of Rs.250,31,66,138/- on account of dry-docking expenses incurred during the year. However, out of the said expenditure, an amount of Rs. 94,81,49,065/- was itself claimed by the assessee as capital in nature during the course of assessment proceedings and accordingly the claim of dry-docking expenses stood reduced to Rs. 155,50,17,073/-. Since the said expenditure was merely incurred for preservation of an existing asset and did not create a new asset or an advantage
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
of an enduring nature, the expenses were treated as revenue in nature and claimed as business deduction. 15.1 During the assessment proceedings,the assessing officer, however, treated the aforesaid expenditure of Rs. 155,50,17,073 incurred in respect of dry docking of offshore rigs/vessels as capital expenditure and allowed depreciation thereon @ 15% amounting to Rs. 23,32,52,561/-. Accordingly, the balance amount of Rs. 1,32,17,64,512/- was disallowed. 15.2 Aggrieved with the above order, the assessee filed appeal before the Ld. CIT(A). The CIT(A), relying on the order of the Hon’ble Uttarakhand High Court and on the decisions of the Coordinate Bench for various assessment years in assessee’s own case, deleted the aforesaid disallowance by treating the expenditure incurred on dry-docking as revenue in nature. 15.3 At the time of hearing, the Ld. AR submitted that the aforesaid action of the AO is unsustainable on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law as dry-docking expenses are statutorily required to be incurred by the assessee and such expenditure has been incurred to preserve and maintain as already existing asset and even after incurrence of such expenses, the vessel continues to operate in the same normal manner and no new asset comes into existence. The expenditure on dry docking cannot therefore, be held to be capital expenditure. 48
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Further, he pointed out that the aforesaid issue is covered in favour of the assessee by the order(s) of the Supreme Court / Uttarakhand High Court for various assessment years, as under: AYs 2004-05 and 2005-06: Uttarakhand High Court vide its judgment dated 14th May 2015 in I.T.A. Nos. 19 of 2010, 20 of 2010, 21 of 2010 & 22 of 2010. (Copy placed at pages 55-60 of the Paperbook) AY 2006-07: Uttarakhand High Court vide its judgment dated 21st May 2015 in I.T.A. Nos. 18 & 23 of 2010, (Copy placed at pages 61-65 of the Paperbook) After that SLP filed by the Revenue against the aforesaid decisions of the High Court was dismissed by the Supreme Court vide common order dated 28 November, 2016 in SLP © No. 147/2016 (SC). It is placed at pages 64 to 65 of the paper book. Further submitted that the Delhi Bench of the Tribunal in assessee’s own case for assessment years 2000-01 and 2001-02 has decided the issue in favour of the assessee. It is placed at pg. no. 66-81 of the Paper book. Further, it is also submitted that the Assessing Officer, respectfully followed the decision of the jurisdictional High Court for AYs 2004-05 to 2006-07, did not
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
make any disallowance on the aforesaid issue in the completed assessment for Assessment Year 2013-14 and onwards. In view of the above, he submitted that the dry-docking expenses are allowable as revenue expenditure and ground raised by the Department deserves to be dismissed. 16. Aggrieved, the Revenue is in appeal before us and at the time of hearing Ld. DR relied on the findings of the lower authorities. 17. Considered the rival submission and material placed on record.We observed that similar issues were considered by the Hon’ble Uttarakhand High Court in assessee’s own case and held in favour of the assessee. We observed that this is recurring issue, the coordinate bench had considered similar issues in the past and decided in favour of the assessee. Respectfully following the above decisions, we are inclined to dismiss the ground raised by the revenue in this regard. In the result, grounds raised by the revenue is dismissed. 18. In the result, appeal filed by the revenue is dismissed. Order pronounced in the open court on this 13th April, 2026. Sd/- sd/- (SUDHIR KUMAR) (S.RIFAUR RAHMAN) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 13/04/2026/Binita, Sr. PS 50
ITA No.1639/Del/2016
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Gayatri Priyadarshini Bisoi vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax, CT And GST, Cuttack-Ii,Cuttack, OdishaOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026