BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION,MUMBAI vs. DCIT- 19(1), PIRAMAL CHAMBERS
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that while the purchases were not fully genuine, a 100% disallowance was not justified as corresponding sales were accepted. The addition was restricted to 10% of the impugned purchases to represent the profit element.
What were the facts?
The assessee, a diamond trading firm, had its assessment reopened based on information about accommodation entries. The Assessing Officer disallowed purchases aggregating to Rs. 5,31,20,779/- treating them as non-genuine.
What were the issues?
Whether the reassessment proceedings were validly initiated and whether the entire amount of non-genuine purchases could be disallowed when corresponding sales were accepted.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 37,Section 147,Section 144B,Section 148A,Section 149
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI
Before: SMT. BEENA PILLAI, HON’BLE & SMT. RATNA DASGUPTA, HON’BLE
आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, म ुंबई पीठें, म ुंबई INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI BENCH: B BEFORE SMT. BEENA PILLAI, HON’BLE JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SMT. RATNA DASGUPTA, HON’BLE ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA 2581/MUM/2026 निर्धारण वर्ा/Assessment Year: 2013-14) BHARAT TRADING DCIT- 19(1) CORPORATION CIRCLE- 19(1), 5TH FLOOR, BW- 4150, BHARAT DIAMOND PIRAMAL CHAMBERS, BOURSE, BKC, BANDRA Vs. LALBAUG (EAST), MUMBAI-400051, MUMBAI-400012, MAHARASHTRA MAHARASHTRA अपीलधर्थी Appellant प्रत्यर्थी Respondent
Permanent Account Number of AABFB8760D Assessee:
अपीलधर्थी द्वारा/Appellant represented by: Shri Rahul Sarda, AR प्रत्यर्थी द्वारा/Respondent represented by: Shree Kumar C. (SR DR) सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 12-Aug-2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 27-08-2026 आदेश / ORDER PER SMT. BEENA PILLAI, JUDICIAL MEMBER: Present appeal filed by assessee arises out of the order dated 23/02/2026 passed by NFAC, Delhi [hereinafter referred to as “Ld.CIT(A)”] for A.Y. 2013-14, on the following ground/s of appeal:-
“1) Ground 1 - The NATIONAL FACELESS APPEAL CENTRE (NFAC) failed to appreciate that the AO had not followed the procedure prescribed under section 148A in terms of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Ashish Agarwal vide order dated 04.05.2022 and had failed to provide the material relied on by the AO for initiation of reassessment proceedings. Therefore, the
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION initiation of reassessment proceedings are bad in law and the assessment order is liable to be quashed and set aside. 2) Ground 2 - The NFAC failed to appreciate that even during the assessment proceedings, despite request from the Appellant, the AO did not provide the documents OR statements relied on by the AO and also did not provide opportunity of cross examination. Hence, the addition of Rs. 5,31,20,779 is bad in law and is liable to be deleted. 3) Ground 3 - The NFAC failed to appreciate that the purchases made by the Appellant were supported by documentary material and were genuine, and hence, the same could not have been disallowed. 4) Ground 4 - Without prejudice to the above, the NFAC failed to appreciate that addition, even if any, could have been made only to the extent of the positive difference, if any, between the gross profit element in the undisputed purchases and the disputed purchases as per the ratio of the judgement of the Honble Bombay High Court. 5) Ground 5 - Without prejudice to the above, the NFAC failed to appreciate that the Report of the Task Group for Diamond Sector (issued by the Govt. of India) itself shows that GP rate for entities engaged in trading of diamonds was only 2 percent. Hence, the addition, if any, ought to have been restricted to 2 percent of the disputed purchases. 6) Ground 6 - The Appellant states that the above Grounds of Appeal are in addition to, in the alternative and without prejudice to each other and further craves leave to add, amend, delete OR alter any Grounds of Appeal.” 2. Brief facts of the case are as under:-
The assessee is a partnership firm engaged in the business of trading and manufacturing of cut and polished diamonds. The assessee purchases diamonds from various local parties and also imports the same, which are sold either in the local market or by way of exports. The assessee also undertakes manufacturing of diamonds. For A.Y. 2013-14, the assessee filed its return of income on 17/09/2013 declaring total income of Rs. 32,56,410/-.
2.1. Subsequently, the case of the assessee was reopened. An original notice u/s 148 was issued on 16/04/2021 under the erstwhile provisions of the Act. Pursuant to the directions of the
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. Ashish Agarwal reported in 444 ITR 1, the said notice was treated in accordance with the new reassessment regime and notice u/s 148A(b) was issued on 23/05/2022. The assessee filed its objections thereto; however, the objections were rejected and an order u/s 148A(d) was passed on 30/06/2022, followed by issuance of notice u/s 148 on the same date.
2.2. The reassessment proceedings emanated from information received from the Investigation Wing pursuant to search and seizure proceedings conducted in the case of the Bhawarlal Jain Group on 03/10/2013. As per the information available with the Department, various concerns controlled and managed by the said group were engaged in providing accommodation entries, including bogus purchase and sales entries. The information indicated that the assessee had allegedly obtained accommodation entries in the nature of bogus purchases from four concerns, namely, Mahalaxmi Gems Pvt. Ltd., Amit Diamond, Naman Exports and Rahul Exports, aggregating to Rs. 5,31,20,779/-.
2.3. During the reassessment proceedings, the Ld.AO examined the genuineness of the aforesaid purchases. Notices u/s 143(2) and 142(1) were issued and various details were called for from the assessee, including purchase and sales ledgers, stock register, party-wise details and confirmations from the concerned parties. The assessee furnished its responses and also produced confirmations and other documentary material in support of the transactions. The Ld. AO, however, was not satisfied with the evidences furnished by the assessee and, inter alia, observed that
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION the assessee had failed to satisfactorily establish the genuineness of the purchases.
2.4. The Ld. AO accordingly treated the purchases aggregating to Rs. 5,31,20,779/- as non-genuine and disallowed the entire amount u/s 37 of the Act. Consequently, the assessment was completed u/s 147 r.w.s. 144B of the Act on 25/05/2023, determining the total income at Rs. 5,63,77,189/-, as against the returned income of Rs. 32,56,410/-.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid assessment order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Ld.CIT(A), challenging both the validity of the reassessment proceedings as well as the addition made on account of alleged bogus purchases.
Before the Ld.CIT(A), the assessee reiterated that the purchases from the aforesaid four parties were genuine. It was submitted that the payments had been made through account- payee cheques and were duly reflected in the bank statements and books of account; the purchases and corresponding sales were recorded in the purchase, sales and stock registers; the books were audited u/s 44AB of the Act; there was quantitative tally of stock; and the concerned parties had confirmed the transactions through ledger confirmations and affidavits. The assessee further contended that the Ld.AO had made the addition of 100% of the alleged bogus purchases merely on the basis of assumptions, surmises and conjectures.
3.1. The assessee also challenged the validity of the reassessment proceedings on the ground that the notice issued u/s 148A(b) on 23/05/2022 was beyond six years from the end of the relevant
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION assessment year and, therefore, was barred by limitation u/s 149. On merits, the assessee contended that the purchases were genuine and relied upon the documentary evidence placed on record, besides judicial precedents including the decision of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in Principal Commissioner of Income- tax-17 v. Mohommad Haji Adam & Co. reported in [2019] 103 taxmann.com 459 (Bombay) and the judgment of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in Principal Commissioner of Income-tax, Surat-I v. Tejua Rohitkumar Kapadia reported in [2018] 94 taxmann.com 324 (Gujarat). The assessee also contended that the Ld. AO had not afforded an opportunity of cross-examination of the persons whose statements were allegedly relied upon.
3.2. The Ld.CIT(A), after considering the assessment order, the submissions of the assessee and the material available on record, upheld the reopening of the assessment. The Ld.CIT(A) observed that the reopening was based on specific information received from the Investigation Wing pursuant to the search and seizure action in the case of the Bhawarlal Jain Group and that the procedure prescribed u/s 148A had been duly followed in terms of the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India & Ors. v. Ashish Agarwal (supra). The Ld. CIT(A), therefore, found no infirmity in the issuance of notice u/s 148 or in the reopening on the ground of limitation.
3.3. On merits, the Ld. CIT(A) observed that the assessee had not furnished cogent documentary evidence conclusively establishing the genuineness of the impugned purchases and had failed to produce, inter alia, conclusive evidence regarding actual movement of goods, transportation details, delivery challans, confirmations
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION and the financial capacity and independent existence of the suppliers. The Ld. CIT(A) accordingly held that the assessee had failed to controvert the findings of the Investigation Wing and that the Ld. AO was justified in treating the impugned transactions as non-genuine. The addition of Rs. 5,31,20,779/- was consequently sustained and the grounds raised by the assessee were dismissed.
Aggrieved by the order of the Ld. CIT(A) the assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal.
The Ld.AR submitted that the reassessment proceedings were vitiated by denial of an effective opportunity under section 148A(b) of the Act. It was contended that, although the notice under section 148A(b) referred to information allegedly received from the Investigation Wing concerning the Bhawarlal Jain Group and the alleged accommodation entries, the material forming the basis of such information was never furnished to the assessee.
4.1. The Ld.AR submitted that the assessee had repeatedly requested the Assessing Officer to furnish the documents/material relied upon for proposing reassessment, including the material allegedly received from the Investigation Wing and the statements or other evidence on the basis of which the purchases were characterised as bogus. Despite such repeated requests, the relevant material was not supplied to the assessee.
It was therefore argued that the assessee was placed in a position where it was required to rebut an allegation without being furnished the underlying material on which the allegation was founded. According to the Ld.AR, merely stating in the notice that
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION information had been received from the Investigation Wing cannot be regarded as furnishing the material relied upon by the Ld.AO.
4.2. The Ld.AR further submitted that the requirement of section 148A(b) is not merely a procedural formality. The assessee must be given a meaningful and effective opportunity to respond to the information/material relied upon by the Assessing Officer. In the absence of disclosure of such material, the objections filed by the assessee could not have been effectively considered. The subsequent order under section 148A(d), therefore, was contended to be vitiated for violation of the principles of natural justice.
4.3. It was further submitted that the defect was particularly material in the present case because the entire reassessment originated from the alleged findings of the Investigation Wing in the search proceedings in the Bhawarlal Jain Group. Unless the material pertaining specifically to the assessee and the four suppliers was disclosed, the assessee could not effectively demonstrate why the purchases were genuine.
4.4. The Ld.AR accordingly submitted that the failure to furnish the material despite repeated requests rendered the assumption of jurisdiction under section 148 invalid, and the reassessment proceedings deserved to be quashed on this ground itself.
4.5. On merits, the Ld.AR submitted that the Ld.AO proceeded on the erroneous premise that the entire purchases of ₹5.31 crore were bogus and consequently disallowed the entire amount, without properly appreciating the corresponding sales and the overall trading results of the assessee. The Ld.AR placed the following broad figures for A.Y. 2013-14:
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION Particulars Approx. amount Total turnover/sales ₹21.20 crore Alleged bogus purchases ₹5.31 crore Sales corresponding to alleged ₹5.91 crore purchases Other/genuine sales ₹15.30 crore Other/genuine purchases ₹14.54 crore
4.6. The Ld.AR submitted that the alleged purchases of approximately ₹5.31 crore had resulted in corresponding sales of approximately ₹5.91 crore. Thus, the alleged purchases could not be viewed in isolation from the sales effected against them.
4.7. It was further submitted that the assessee had disclosed total sales of approximately ₹21.20 crore and had carried on substantial genuine business during the year. The corresponding genuine purchases were approximately ₹14.54 crore against genuine sales of approximately ₹15.30 crore. According to the Ld.AR, these figures demonstrated that the assessee was carrying on an actual and substantial business in diamonds and that the alleged purchases formed part of the trading cycle reflected in the books.
4.8. The Ld.AR particularly emphasised that the gross profit arising from the sales allegedly relatable to the impugned purchases was higher than the gross profit earned from the other genuine sales forming part of the same turnover. It was therefore argued that there was no commercial or accounting basis for treating the entire purchase cost of ₹5.31 crore as non-genuine while simultaneously accepting the corresponding sales.
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION 4.9. According to the Ld.AR, if the Department's case was that the assessee had obtained accommodation bills without actually purchasing the goods, the Revenue was required to explain how the assessee could have effected sales of approximately ₹5.91 crore corresponding to those purchases, particularly when the assessee was engaged in the business of trading and manufacturing of diamonds and the quantitative details, stock records and corresponding sales were available.
4.10. The Ld.AR therefore contended that, even assuming some irregularity in the identity or source of the suppliers, the material on record did not justify disallowance of 100% of the purchases, particularly when the corresponding sales had been accepted and the assessee had disclosed the resulting profit in its books.
4.11. On the contrary, the Ld.DR placed on record a paper book containing the reply furnished by the Ld.AO in response to the assessee's challenge to the validity of the reassessment proceedings. The Ld.DR submitted that, contrary to the contention of the assessee, the material relied upon for initiating the reassessment proceedings had in fact been furnished to the assessee along with the notice issued under section 148A(b) of the Act. It was, therefore, contended that the assessee had been duly confronted with the information/material forming the basis of the proposed reassessment and had been afforded an opportunity to submit its objections. The Ld. DR accordingly submitted that there was no violation of the procedure prescribed under section 148A or of the principles of natural justice.
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION 4.12. On merits, the Ld.DR relied on the principle laid down by Hon’ble Bombay High Court in case of Shorline Hotel(P.)Ltd. vs.CIT reported in (2018) 98 taxmann.cm 234, in order to support the view taken by authorities below. He submitted that on perusal of the decision, one can discern that purchases/expenses are to be treated as non-genuine in the present facts. He also emphasizes on the evidentiary deficiencies in establishing the genuineness of such transactions.
We have perused the submissions advanced by both sides in light of records placed before us.
As regards the challenge to the validity of the reassessment proceedings on the ground that the material relied upon by the Ld.AOr was not furnished to the assessee despite repeated requests, we find that there is a factual dispute between the parties. The assessee contends that the material relied upon by the Ld.AO was not furnished, whereas the Ld.DR, relying upon the response of the Assessing Officer placed in the paper book, submits that the relevant material was furnished along with the notice issued under section 148A(b) of the Act.
5.1. In the circumstances, and having regard to the material presently available before us, we deem it appropriate to keep the said legal issue open, without expressing any final opinion thereon. The same, therefore, does not form the basis of our decision on the merits of the addition.
Coming to the merits, it is an admitted position that the purchases from the four parties, aggregating to ₹5,31,20,779/-, are not being supported by the assessee as genuine purchases from
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION the stated suppliers in the ordinary sense. The controversy before us is, therefore, essentially whether the entire amount of such purchases is liable to be disallowed, or whether the addition is required to be restricted to the profit element embedded in such purchases.
6.1. We find considerable force in the contention of the Ld. AR that the impugned purchases cannot be examined in isolation from the corresponding sales. The assessee is engaged in the business of trading and manufacturing of cut and polished diamonds. During the relevant previous year, the assessee disclosed total sales/turnover of approximately ₹21.20 crore. Against the impugned purchases of approximately ₹5.31 crore, corresponding sales of approximately ₹5.91 crore are stated to have been effected, and such sales form part of the disclosed turnover. The Revenue has not disputed the corresponding sales or excluded the same from the turnover of the assessee.
6.2. The assessee has also placed on record the purchase bills relating to the impugned transactions and the corresponding sales have admittedly been accounted for. Thus, this is not a case where the entire transaction represented a fictitious entry without any corresponding trading activity. The very fact that the goods allegedly purchased through the impugned parties have entered into the trading/manufacturing cycle and corresponding sales have been recorded assumes significance while determining the quantum of addition.
6.3. In these circumstances, we are unable to accept the approach of the Assessing Officer in treating the entire purchase amount of
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION ₹5,31,20,779/- as income of the assessee. Such an approach would result in taxing the entire purchase value while simultaneously accepting the corresponding sales forming part of the turnover. The purchase cost is an expenditure incurred in the course of earning the corresponding sales, and once the sales have been accepted, the question that arises is essentially as to what extent the assessee derived an advantage by obtaining the purchase bills from the stated parties rather than making purchases from identifiable and genuine suppliers.
6.4. We also find that the adoption of the gross-profit rate of the earlier years, as suggested in the course of the proceedings, would not provide a sound basis for quantification in the present case. The trading results of different years cannot necessarily be transplanted into the present year without considering the peculiar nature of the transactions and the trading results of the year under consideration. More importantly, if the allegation is that accommodation purchase bills have been obtained in respect of actual purchases, the addition has to be directed towards the additional profit or saving embedded in such transactions, rather than the entire face value of the purchases.
6.5. We have also taken note of the submission of the Ld.AR that the sales relatable to the impugned purchases are approximately ₹5.91 crore, whereas the impugned purchases are approximately ₹5.31 crore, resulting in a trading surplus thereon. The Ld.AR has further submitted that the gross profit attributable to the transactions represented by the impugned purchases is higher than the gross profit disclosed on the other sales. Though this factor by itself cannot establish the genuineness of the purchases,
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION it is certainly a relevant circumstance while determining whether the entire purchase value can be brought to tax as unexplained income.
6.6. At the same time, we cannot accept the contention that merely because corresponding sales have been accepted, the impugned purchases must necessarily be accepted in full. The material on record, as discussed by the lower authorities, indicates deficiencies in establishing the genuineness of the stated suppliers and the transactions through them. The assessee has itself accepted that the purchases from the four parties cannot be regarded as genuine purchases from those parties. Therefore, some addition on account of the benefit derived from obtaining accommodation purchase bills is warranted.
6.7. The crucial question, therefore, is whether the entire ₹5.31 crore can be treated as income. In our considered view, the answer has to be in the negative. If the Revenue's case is accepted that the assessee had in fact procured the goods and thereafter recorded the purchases through accommodation bills, the underlying purchase of goods cannot simultaneously be treated as wholly non- existent. The acceptance of the corresponding sales necessarily indicates that goods had entered the business cycle of the assessee. What remains unexplained is the true source/actual cost of such purchases and the benefit, if any, obtained by the assessee through the accommodation bills.
6.8. A disallowance of 100% would, therefore, amount to treating the entire purchase consideration as the assessee's income, notwithstanding the corresponding sales and the business activity
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION carried on by the assessee. Such an approach, in our view, does not properly reflect the real income arising from the transaction.
6.9. We have also considered the reliance placed by the assessee on the decision of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in PCIT v. Mohammad Haji Adam & Co., (supra) The principle emerging from the said decision is that, where the purchases are found to be non- genuine but the corresponding sales are accepted, the addition is required to be considered with reference to the profit element embedded in the disputed purchases, rather than mechanically treating the entire purchase amount as income.
6.10. However, the said decision cannot be applied mechanically to the facts of every case. The quantum of addition has to depend upon the facts and material available in the particular case, including the nature of business, the extent of evidence available, the trading results and the circumstances in which the purchases have been held to be non-genuine. We, therefore, do not find it appropriate to apply the gross-profit rate or the precise methodology adopted in Mohammad Haji Adam & Co.(supra) mechanically to the present case. The said decision nevertheless supports the fundamental proposition that acceptance of corresponding sales is a relevant consideration in determining the quantum of addition.
6.11. In the peculiar facts of the present case, we are of the view that a reasonable estimate has to be made of the profit element embedded in the impugned purchases. The assessee has admittedly obtained accommodation purchase bills, while the corresponding sales have been disclosed and accepted as part of
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION the turnover. Having regard to the nature of the diamond trading business, the quantum of the impugned purchases, the corresponding sales, the evidences furnished by the assessee, the deficiencies noticed by the lower authorities, and the admitted position regarding the impugned purchases, we consider that an addition of 10% of the impugned purchases would meet the ends of justice.
6.12. Accordingly, the addition is restricted to 10% of ₹5,31,20,779/- as representing the profit/benefit embedded in the impugned purchases. The balance addition is directed to be deleted. We make it clear that the above estimation is confined to the peculiar facts of the present case and shall not be understood as laying down a universal rate applicable to all cases involving alleged bogus purchases. The rate of estimation necessarily depends upon the facts and evidence of each case.
Accordingly, the grounds raised by the assessee stands partly allowed.
In the result, appeal filed by the assessee stands partly allowed.
Order pronounced in the open court on 27-08-2026.
Sd/- Sd/- RATNA DASGUPTA BEENA PILLAI ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 27-08-2026 SC, Sr.P.S.
ITA 2581/MUM/2026 BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION Copy to: BHARAT TRADING CORPORATION, BW- 4150, BHARAT DIAMOND 1 BOURSE, BKC, BANDRA (EAST), MUMBAI-400051, MAHARASHTRA DCIT- 19(1), CIRCLE- 19(1), 5TH FLOOR, PIRAMAL 2 CHAMBERS, LALBAUG, MUMBAI-400012, MAHARASHTRA 3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE TRUE COPY
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR / SR. PRIVATE SECRETARY I.T.A.T., MUMBAI
More judgments on Section 37
- Lowes India Private Limited, Bangalore vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1245/BANG/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax… vs Pureways Infra Pvt. Ltd. (Earlier Known As…ITA 114/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax… vs Pureways Infra Pvt. Ltd. (Earlier Known As…ITA 113/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Pureways Infra Private Limited, New Delhi vs DCIT Central Circle-30, New DelhiITA 7361/DEL/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Pureways Infra Private Limited, New Delhi vs DCIT Central Circle-30, New DelhiITA 7338/DEL/2025[2019-20]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Shashibhusan Moharana vs. The Superintendent Of CGST And Central Excise, DhenkanalOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Paramount Tea Marketing PVT. LTD. vs. Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 4 Nov 2026
- Md. Junaid vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Sanjeevini Health Care vs. M/S.Vijayalakshmi And AssociatesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Trilok Chandra vs. State Tax OfficerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026