PARESH VANITLAL SHAH,MUMBAI vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 15(1), MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 4696/MUM/2025Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai19 August 2026AY 2011-1222 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia) for transport charges was not warranted as the recipient had disclosed income and provided transporter's PAN. The issue of MVAT claim was restored to the Assessing Officer for factual verification.

What were the facts?

The assessee, engaged in wholesale metal business, faced additions for alleged bogus purchases and MVAT claims. Notices to purchase parties were returned unserved, and the assessee failed to provide supporting documents.

What were the issues?

Whether disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia) is justified for procedural non-compliance when substantive conditions are met, and whether MVAT claimed as expenditure requires further verification to avoid double claim.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 147,Section 69C,Section 43B,Section 194C(6),Section 194C(7),Section 40(a)(ia)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, “C” BENCH, MUMBAI

Before: SHRI NARENDER KUMAR CHOUDHRY, JM & SHRI ARUN KHODPIA, AM

For Appellant: Shri Devendra Jain, Shri Ajay Soneji, Sr. DR
Hearing: 19.08.2026

आयकरअपीलीयअिधकरण�ायपीठमुंबईम�। IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL “C” BENCH, MUMBAI BEFORE SHRI NARENDER KUMAR CHOUDHRY, JM & SHRI ARUN KHODPIA, AM I.T.A. Nos.6270-6271 & 4696/Mum/2025 (Assessment Years: 2010-11 & 2011-12) Paresh Vanitlal Shah Income Tax Officer Ward 41(2)(4), 1402, 14th Floor, Centre Point, 90 Mumbai Feet Road, Mulund East, Vs. Room No.402, Kautilya Bhavan, Maharashtra-400081 Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai, Maharashtra-400051 PAN: AAEPS6162P Assessee- अपीलाथ� / Appellant Revenue-��थ�/ Respondent :

Assessee by : Shri Devendra Jain : Shri Ajay Soneji, Sr. DR Revenue by : 30.06.2026 Date of Hearing : 19.08.2026 Date of Pronouncement

O R D E R Per Bench: The captioned three appeals pertain to same assessee, arises against the orders passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [in short, “the Ld. CIT(A)”], dated 31.03.2025 for the Assessment Year (AY) 2010-11 and dated 02.06.2025 for AY 2011-12. The impugned orders, emanating from order u/s 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [in short, “the Act”] dated 26th March, 2013 and order u/s 147 dated 23rd March, 2016 for AY 2010-2011 and order u/s 143(3) dated 28th March, 2014 for AY

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 2011-12.Since, all the three appeals are of the same assessee, having identical and interconnected issues, facts and circumstances, therefore, are heard together and decided under this consolidated order.

2.

It is noticed that the appeals filed by the assessee for AY 2010-11 are delayed by 123 days, for which the assessee has furnished an affidavit stating reasons of delay, which after consideration are found to be sufficient cause and beyond the control of assessee, without any deliberate attempt or mala fide intentions to cause such delay. Therefore, in the interest of justice, the delay in filing of appeal stands condoned.

3.

First, we shall be taking the appeal of assessee u/s 143(3) for AY 2010-11:

3.1 Briefly stated, the assessee is an individual running its business as proprietary concern in the name and style of “Padmashree Metal Industries”. The assessee is engaged in the wholesale business of ferrous and non-ferrous metals. The return of income for AY 2010-11 was filed on 24.09.2010 declaring total income of Rs.18,63,803/-. Subsequently, the case of assessee was selected for scrutiny under CASS. Statutory notices were issued which were responded by the assessee.

3.2 During the assessment, it is noticed by the Ld. AO that the assessee had declared purchases of Rs.37.55 crores and sale of Rs.38.76 crores. To verify the genuineness of the purchases, Ld. AO issued notice u/s 133(6) of the Act to six

ITA Nos.6270-6271 6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah Paresh Vanitlal Shah parties at the addresses provided by assessee. In case of four parties, the notices parties at the addresses provided by assessee. In case of four parties, the noti parties at the addresses provided by assessee. In case of four parties, the noti could not be served and werereturned back unserved by the postal authorities could not be served and werereturned back unserved by the postal authorities could not be served and werereturned back unserved by the postal authorities with remark “Not Known”. The details of such parties culled out from the with remark “Not Known”. The details of such parties culled out from the with remark “Not Known”. The details of such parties culled out from the assessment order are as under: assessment order are as under:

3.3 The assessee, thereafter thereafter, was asked to furnished sale and purchas asked to furnished sale and purchase bills and ledger copy of the aforesaid parties ledger copy of the aforesaid parties, but no response. The issue was discussed by but no response. The issue was discussed by the Ld. AO with the Authorized Representative (AR) of the assessee and after the Ld. AO with the Authorized Representative (AR) of the assessee and after the Ld. AO with the Authorized Representative (AR) of the assessee and after narrating an elaborate finding in terms of narrating an elaborate finding in terms of modus operandi of such sellers of such sellers and the bogus purchase transactions bogus purchase transactions, the Ld. AO picked up the highest credit balance of , the Ld. AO picked up the highest credit balance of Rs.13,37,647/- to be treated as treated as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act. unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act. Further, the Ld. AO doubted doubted the assessee’s claim of MVAT payment of MVAT payment of Rs.17,69,132/- in the P & L account. Accordingly, assessee vide letter dated & L account. Accordingly, assessee vide letter dated & L account. Accordingly, assessee vide letter dated 18.02.2013 was asked to explain why claim of expenses on account of MVAT of 18.02.2013 was asked to explain why claim of expenses on account of MVAT of 18.02.2013 was asked to explain why claim of expenses on account of MVAT of Rs.17,69,132/- paid on behalf of the suppliers should not be disallowed. The paid on behalf of the suppliers should not be disallowed. The paid on behalf of the suppliers should not be disallowed. The

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah assessee submitted that he had claimed on one time deduction at the time of payment of VAT to Maharashtra State Government and the purchase value is taken only the net of such VAT amount. The Ld. AO was not convinced with the submissions of the assessee, therefore had made an addition of Rs.17,69,132/- on account of MVAT claim of the assessee.

3.4 With the aforesaid two additions, the assessment was completed against which the assessee has preferred an appeal before the Ld. CIT(A), however, Ld. CIT(A) was also not convinced with the contentions raised by the assessee, therefore, the additions made by the Ld. AO were confirmed with a further enhancement for bogus purchase transactions u/s 69C from Rs.13,37,647/- to Rs.23,50,168/-,following the order of Ld. CIT(A) passed against the order u/s 143(3) r.w.s 147 for AY 2010-11.

4.

The facts regarding second appeal of the assessee against re-opening u/s 147 for AY 2010-11. As per information received from Maharashtra Sales Tax Department through DGIT (Inv.), Mumbai during the year under reference, the assessee is engaged in bogus/hawala transactions to the tune of Rs.1,42,90,920/-. Accordingly, a notice under section 148 after recording the reasons to do so, was issued. The notice was duly served and responded by the assessee. During the reopening assessment proceedings, it is observed by the Ld. AO that the assessee's total Turnover declared was Rs 38.76 crores and GP was 3.30%. The assessee has made purchases from the following alleged parties: 4

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah

Sr. No. Name of the party PAN. Amount 1 Om Shanti Trading AACPJ7746G 121360/- 2. Parasvnath Trading Co. AACPJ3869N 148876/- 3. Vasant Impex Pvt. Ltd. AACCV4655M 736629/- 4. Arihant Trading Co., ACYPL 5277A 1343303/- 5. Sunita Wire & Cables AEIPG2934D 11940752/- Total 14290920/- 4.1 The issue was discussed at length, the Ld. AO found it appropriate to estimate the addition on aforesaid bogus purchase at 8% over and above the GP ratio declared by the assessee. Accordingly, an addition of Rs.11,43,274/- was made.

4.2 Assessee challenged the aforesaid issue before the Ld. CIT(A), who was not convinced with the submissions and contentions of the assessee, has decided the issue by enhancing the income of the assessee to 100% of the bogus purchases amounting to Rs 1,42,90,920/-. The Ld. CIT(A) also confirmed the addition on account of MVAT under section 143(3) for Rs.17,69,132/- stating that the expenses are not at all related to the genuine business transaction of the assessee and thus such claim is not allowable.

4.3 It is further noted by the Ld. CIT(A) that as per provisions of section 43B, the deduction is allowable in respect of tax/duties/cess payable by the assessee whereas in the present case the VAT was not Payable by the assessee. Thus, the law arose only because Sales Tax Authorities found that so-called suppliers of

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah the assessee had provided fake purchase invoices without remitting back to the government treasury. Accordingly, the addition was confirmed.

5.

Coming to the brief facts of the case for AY 2011-12, again during the assessment proceedings under section 143(3), the issue arose regarding bogus purchases from the following parties:

Amount of purchases by Name Remarks assessee in F.Y. 2008-09 (Rs) Shah Industries 5,01,879 Not known Sunshine Trading 18,13,458 Left Padmavathi Trading 57,16,581 Not known Arihant Trading 88,96,478 Not claimed

5.1 The Ld. AO has issued notices under section 133(6), which arereturned back with remark "Not Known/Left/Not Claimed” are identical lines as the assessment was completed for AY 2010-11. The Ld. AO has made addition of peak credit in the ledger account of such parties for Rs.36,44,186/- and have also made an addition of transport charges for Rs.11,40,200/- paid to M/s. Savita Logistics, where the assessee has not deducted tax at source. Further, the Ld. AO has made an addition of Rs.82,494/- qua the claim of assessee for commission paid to M/s. Arihant Trading Company whereas the purchase from M/s. Arihant Trading Company was already held as bogus in the assessment, the commission is also treated as bogus and added back to the income of assessee.

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 5.2 The assessee, being aggrieved has filed an appeal before the Ld. CIT(A) and had made a lengthy submission stating that the transactions are not bogus. However, Ld. CIT(A) was not convinced with the submissions of the assessee as well as the findings of the Ld. AO of estimating the profit on the purchases or addition on account of peak credit. He therefore, issued a notice of enhancement u/s 251(1)(a) on 20.11.2019, which was not responded by the assessee, therefore he confirmed the entire amount of bogus purchases amounting to Rs.1,69,28,396/- as not allowable u/s 37 of the Act. Further, the issue of TDS is also decided against the assessee as the assessee has not furnished the necessary evidence like PAN Number of the party to whom the payments were made, therefore, as per provisions of section 194C(6), the claim of assessee that no TDS is applicable as he has fulfilled the condition laid down was treated untenable and the disallowance was confirmed.

6.

Being aggrieved with all the aforesaid three orders by Ld. CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before us.

7.

At the outset, Ld. AR of the assessee discussed the issues at length which on direction of the Bench are summarized in a written note. The same is extracted as under:

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah “Background of the case: 1. [chases from the following 4 parties

Name of Purchase Party Transaction Amount

Shri Bhanwarlal Jain Rs.1,48,876/-

Shri NakharaUdarramji Rs.13,43,303/- Mithalal Jain Rs.1,21,360/- VasantImpex P. Ltd Rs. 7,36,629/- TOTAL Rs.23,50,168/- The Assessing Officer made an addition under section 69C of Rs.13,37,647/- for highest credit balance of Purchases. The Assessing Officer also made addition of MVAT Payment of Rs.17,69,132/-. 2. For A.Y 2011-12, the Assessing Officer in the Assessment Order dated 28.03.2014 made addition under section 69C of Rs.36,44,186/- on peak credit of Purchases from 4 parties. The Assessing Officer also made addition of Rs.11,40,200/- on account of Transport charges since TDS was not deducted by assessee on the payments made to M/s Savita Logistics. 3. Then for the same A.Y 2010-11, the AO reopened the assessment on the basis of information received from the Maharashtra Sales Tax Department through DGIT(Inv), Mumbai in respect of purchases from 5 parties including the 4 parties which were the subject matter of original assessment u/s 143(3). The only new Purchase party was Sunita Wire & Cables from whom Purchases was made of Rs.1,19,40,752/-.

Purchases subject matter of assessment u/s 143(3) Rs.23,50,168/- New Purchase u/s 147 (Sunita Wire & Cables) Rs.1,19,40,752/- Total Purchases Rs.1,42,90,920/-

The Ld. Assessing Officer in the Assessment Order dated 23.03.2016 under section 147 made addition of Rs.11,43,274/- being 8% of total purchases from 5 parties (including purchases from 4 parties included in the original assessment order under section 143(3)) of Rs.1,42,90,920/- and assessed income at Rs.61,13,850/-.

4.

Thus there were 3 appeals before the CIT(A) :  Against order u/s 143(3) dated 26.03.2013 for A.Y. 2010-11.  Against order u/s 147 dated 23.03.2016 for A.Y. 2010-11.  Against order u/s 143(3) dated 28.03.2014 for A.Y. 2011-12.

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 5. The common issue of disallowance of purchases was decided by the Ld. CIT(A) in its Order dated 31.03.2025 for A.Y 2010-11, in which he dismissed all the grounds pertaining to additions brought forward from the appeal pending against order under section 143(3) dated 26.03.2013. The Ld. CIT(A) confirmed the disallowance of the VAT claim of Rs.17,69,132/-, holding the expense to be not related to business transaction of assessee. The Ld. CIT(A) enhanced the addition of alleged bogus purchases to 100% of purchases of Rs.1,42,90,920/-.

6.

The Ld. CIT(A) in its Order dated 02.06.2025 for A.Y 2011-12, enhanced the addition to 100% of alleged bogus purchase of Rs.1,69,28,396/- as not allowable under section 37 and also sustained the addition made by the Assessing Officer of Rs.11,40,200/- on account of Transport charges.

Issues Involved:

I. Alleged Bogus Purchase: i. The appellant is engaged in the whole sale business in Ferrous and Non-ferrous metals and allies. In the course of assessment and reassessment proceedings, the appellant submitted a. Stock Register b. Quantitative details of stocks c. Copy of ledger account of parties d. Bills e. Delivery challan and f. Details of payment through banking channel. ii. The Books of Accounts for A.Y 2010-11 and A.Y 2011-12 were duly audited and there was no adverse remark in the audit report about purchases and corresponding sales. iii. Further, the Books of Accounts were never rejected by the Ld. Assessing Officer. iv. The appellant had disclosed Gross Profit rate of 3.30% for A.Y 2010-11 and for A.Y 2011-12 was 2.50%, which is in consonance with the gross profit rate in ferrous and 9

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah non ferrous metal business as upheld in a series of judgements of coordinate benches of the Tribunal. v. The Assessing Officer has accepted the above facts in all the 3 impugned assessment orders that the appellant is a trader and his sales are not doubted. The AO has verified the day to day quantitative details and given a finding of fact that without purchases, sales can not be effected and hence the assessee has purchased these goods from grey market and inflated the price by arranging bills from these suppliers. The AO has therefore given a finding that only issue remains is estimation of disallowance in in respect of such inflation in prices, which he has estimated to be 8%.

vi. The relevant extract from the assessment orders are as below: 1. In the Assessment Order for A.Y 2010-11u/s 143(3) dated 26.03.2013: a) In para 5.8, page 5: "In response to this office questionaaire dated 18.02.2013, the assessee vide submissions dated 25.02.2013 filed during assessment proceedings further stated as under: "We are producing stock register for your verification. Quantitative details of stocks,purchases,sales and closing stock as per statement attached". b) In para 5.11, page 8 : "This indicates that the material has not been received from these parties by the assessee and the material shown to have been purchased from said parties was actually purchased from undisclosed party and out of undisclosed sources and to regularize the said purchases in its books of account, the assessee has taken accommodation entries from the bogus parties". c) In para 5.11, page 8: "We will now have to consider as to how much deduction should be allowed to the assessee in respect of the cost of purchase of the material said to have been received by him from the said parties which were not genuine". d) In para 5.11, page 8: "The goods were not received from the parties from whom it has shown to be purchased. Therefore the goods must have been purchased by the assessee from a different source which is exclusively within the knowledge of the assessee". e) In para 5.21, page 14: "The assessee maintains a day to day stock register and all invoices of purchases and sales are said to be paused through the stock register". f) In para 5.21, page 14: "This indicates that the material has not been received from these parties by the assessee and the material shown to have been purchased from said parties was actually purchased from undisclosed party and, because the quantitative

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah details tally, to regularize the said purchases in his books of account, the assessee has taken accommodation entries from the bogus parties". 2. In the Assessment Order u/s 143(3) dated 28.03.2014 for A.Y 2011-12 a) In para5.15, page 11: "From the audit report, in this case, it is noticed that the assessee is wholesaler in ferrous and non-ferrous metal and alloys. The assessee has also maintained quantitative tally of purchases and sales". b) In para 5.15, page 11: "In this situation, it is apparently a case where even if purchases have been made, the same have not been made from the parties appearing in the list of party-wise purchases". 3. In Assessment Order u/s 147 Order dated 23.03.2016 for A.Y 2010-11: a) In para 4.5, page 3: "The assessee has, however, contended that the purchases from the above parties have been duly accounted for in the books of accounts and corresponding sales has been effected. There are many judicial pronouncement on this issue now wherein the courts have taken the view that in cases of non-existent parties from whom purchases are shown to have been made, only part of such purchases can be disallowed wherein the corresponding sales are treated as genuine or the profit element embedded in such sales can only be brought to tax. Considering the above view taken by the courts, it would be inappropriate to disallow the entire purchases made from certain alleged bogus parties". b) In para 4.5, page 3 and 4: "Since the purchases have not been confirmed by the parties concerned, it is also possible that the alleged purchases might have made by the assessee from unregistered dealers(URD purchase), but so as to reduce the profit margin and marginalize the tax liability the assesse might have obtained inflated bills from the above mentioned hawala parties. Therefore, what can be taxed in cases of such transactions is the profit element embedded and not the entire purchases". c) In para 4.6, page 4: "Further it is pertinent to note here that without receiving the material the corresponding production/sales would not have been possible i.e. the material has been received by the assessee from the sources best known to him. At the same time, it is also possible that asseessee purchases goods from some other suppliers and received bills from someone else, which is commonly known as grey market and this is so; the asseessee has been benefitted by providing margin of grey markets". d) In para 4.7, page 4: "Considering all the facts and circumstances of the case, I have no other option but to constrained to hold on a balancing of facts as the payments have been effected through cheques and the fact that the purchases made from the parties concerned have been recorded in the books of accounts of the assessee, from which itself the subsequent sales have been effected, go on to show that it may not be appropriate to outrightly hold that the purchases are bogus merely because the parties are not traceable now". e) In para 4.7, page 4: "It is further noticed from the Website of the Maharashtra VAT Department, the Sales-tax Department has not treated these parties as bogus but they have only been categorized as suspicious dealers, Thus treating the entire purchases 11

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah made from the parties as not genuine merely on the basis of suspicion would be against the principles of natural justice. Nevertheless, disputed purchases carry with it a natural corollary of dispute sales to that extent".

vii. Contention of the appellant: It would be very inappropriate to disallow the entire purchases made from alleged bogus parties. Therefore what can be taxed in cases of such transactions is the profit element embedded and not the entire purchases. There are many judicial pronouncements on the issue wherein the courts have taken the view that in cases of non-existent parties from whom purchases are shown to have been made, only part of such purchases can be disallowed wherein the corresponding sales are treated as genuine or the profit element embedded in such sales can only be brought to tax. Judicial Pronouncements: 1. In the case of Mr. Manish P. Lathia, HUF vs Income Tax Officer 27(2)(2) in ITA No.2906/M/2024 for A.Y 2009-10; the Hon'ble ITAT, considering the nature of the appellant's business in ferrous articles, directed to adopt a 5% gross profit rate, subject to adjustment for the gross profit already declared, which is in line with the settled legal principle applicable to this line of business and ensures that only the real income of the appellant is taxed. 2. In case of Metalex Tube Industries vs. Income tax Officer ward, 19(2)(2), Mumbai in ITA No.5999/Mum/2024 for A.Y 2009-10 ; ITA No. 5998/Mum/2024 for A.Y 2007- 08; the Hon'ble ITAT held that in considering the peculiar facts of the case and the nature of the appellant's business only a reasonable estimate of the profit element embedded in the alleged bogus purchases can be brought to tax and not the entire purchase value. The Revenue's appeals were dismissed, while the assessee's appeals were partly allowed by granting substantial relief through reduction of the addition from 3% to 1% of the alleged bogus purchases. This judgment, therefore, strongly supports the appellant's contention that in cases where sales are accepted and quantitative records remain undisputed, any addition, if at all warranted, must be confined only to a reasonable profit element and cannot exceed the margin of profit embedded in such purchases. viii. Accordingly, considering that the appellant's declared Gross Profit rates are already reasonable and the sales have not been disputed. Without prejudice, even if any addition is considered necessary, it cannot exceed 2-3 % of the alleged bogus purchases, as consistently held by the jurisdictional Tribunal in identical cases involving traders in ferrous and non-ferrous metals. Hence, the impugned addition deserves to be deleted or suitably restricted in accordance with the settled judicial precedents. II. Transport Charges: (A.Y 2011-12) i. The appellant has paid 11,40,200/- in the previous year to M/s Savita Logistics during the A.Y 2011-12 out of which it claimed Rs.5,06,778/- as expenditure as debited to profit and loss account, but the Assessing Officer disallowed Rs.11,40,200/- which was more than the claimed amount. The appellant has not deducted TDS on the payments made to M/s Savita Logistics as per the conditions laid down under section 194C(6). Reason for disallowance is noncompliance with section 194C(7). 12

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah

ii. The requirement contained in section 194C(7) regarding furnishing of particulars to the prescribed authority is merely procedural in nature and hence the Transport charges cannot be disallowed. Non-compliance, if any, with the procedural requirement under section 194C(7) cannot nullify the substantive benefit available under section 194C(6). iii. Further, the Appellant has placed on record the acknowledgement evidencing the filing of the Return of Income by M/s. Savita Logistics, along with the copy of the transporter's PAN, thereby complying with section 194C(7) in substance though not in form. Accordingly, no disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) is warranted. iv. Further, the disallowance is factually incorrect, as the amount of Rs. 11,40,200/- was neither claimed as an expenditure nor debited to the Profit and Loss Account for the relevant assessment year. The actual transport charges claimed during the year were only Rs. 5,06,778/-. which is shown in the page 66 of the paper book. III. MVAT Claim: (A.Y 2010-11) i. The appellant has incurred and paid expenses on account of MVAT of Rs.17,69,000/-. The payment became necessary because the suppliers had defaulted in discharging their respective MVAT liabilities payable to the Sales Tax Department and hence as per Section 48(5) of the MVAT Act, 2002, set off is not allowed for the input tax paid and thus it becomes the expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in the course of the Appellant's business and represented a statutory liability borne by the Appellant. It is, therefore, respectfully submitted that the expenditure cannot be disallowed merely because the payment was initially attributable to the suppliers' default, as the Appellant was legally obliged to discharge the liability. ii. Sec 48(5) of the MVAT Act, 2002 is reprodcued below: "For the removal of doubt it is hereby declared that, in no case the amount of set-off or refund on any purchase of goods shall exceed the amount of tax in respect of the same goods, actually paid, if any, under this Act or any earlier law, into the Government treasury except to the extent where purchase tax is payable by the the claimant dealer on the purchase of the said goods effected by him: iii. The appellant vide submission dated 18.02.2013 and 25.02.2013 produced original purchase bills and delivery challan of all purchases made during F.Y 2009-10 and the Assessing Officer himself has acknowledged this fact in para 5.8 of the assessment order dated 26.03.2013..Thus, the primary documentary evidence was available before the Assessing Officer at the time of framing the assessment. The statutory audit records placed on record also corroborate the appellant's claim. iv. The Hon'ble Bench during the Hearing directed the appellant to place on record the VAT Ledger and Challans. However, the appellant is unable to produce the VAT ledger and challans before the Hon'ble Bench in such a short time because of the fire that took place on 29.12.2024 due to short circuit in the office of the appellant in Girgaon, Mumbai, which destroyed the old records (including books of accounts, sale bills, purchase bills, bank statements) and these records were either burned or damaged not readable. This circumstance is beyond the control of the appellant and cannot negate the evidence that had already been produced and acknowledged during the original 13

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah assessment proceedings. Proof of fire is already placed in the PB at page 73 to 79. In these exceptional circumstances, and in the interest of justice, the Appellant most respectfully prays that the issue of MVAT claim may kindly be restored to the file of the Assessing Officer for the limited purpose of enabling the Appellant to reconstruct the records and furnish the VAT Ledger, challans for fresh verification in accordance with law after affording the Appellant a reasonable opportunity of being heard.”

7.1 With aforesaid arguments ld. AR rests his arguments.

8.

Per contra, Ld. DR on behalf of the Revenue submitted that the Ld. CIT(A) has rightly decided the issue by enhancing the addition to 100% of the bogus purchases, as the assessee was unable to establish genuineness of the transactions. It is, thus, requested to uphold the order of Ld. CIT(A).

9.

We have considered the rival submissions, perused the material available on record. The issue regarding alleged bogus purchases, we find that in the present case the assessee has submitted certain documents like stock register, quantitative details of stock, copy of ledger accounts of parties, bills, delivery challan and details of payment through banking channel. It is further clarified that the books of accounts of assessee for both AYs under consideration were duly audited and there was no adverse remark by the Auditor in the audit report.

10.

Further, it was submitted by the Ld. AR that the books of account of the assessee, along with the quantitative details maintained therein, were duly produced before and examined by the Ld. Assessing Officer. However, no specific adverse finding or infirmity was recorded by the Ld. Assessing Officer either with regard to the books of account or the quantitative particulars

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah maintained by the assessee. It was contended that, in the absence of rejection of the books of account under the provisions of the Act and when the corresponding sales and quantitative details have not been disputed by the Revenue Authorities, the consumption and availability of the goods cannot be disregarded merely because the purchases from the parties in question have been treated as non- genuine. In such circumstances, the Ld. AR submitted that the possibility of procurement of the goods from sources other than the parties appearing in the purchase invoices cannot be ruled out and, consequently, the entire amount of such purchases cannot be treated as income of the assessee. According to the Ld. AR, at the highest, only the profit element embedded in such purchases could be brought to tax.

11.

In support of the aforesaid proposition, the Ld. AR placed reliance upon the decision of the Coordinate Bench of the Tribunal, Mumbai, in the case of Mr. Manish P. Lathia, HUF vs. Income Tax Officer, Ward 27(2)(2), wherein, in the context of the business of ferrous articles, the profit element in respect of alleged non-genuine purchases was directed to be estimated at 5%. Reliance was also placed upon the decision of the Coordinate Bench of the Tribunal, Mumbai, in the case of Metalex Tube Industries vs. Income Tax Officer, Ward 19(2)(2), Mumbai, wherein the addition in respect of alleged bogus purchases was restricted by estimating the profit element at a rate ranging between 1% and 3%.

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 12. It was, accordingly, submitted that, having regard to the nature of business carried on by the assessee, the books of account maintained by it, the quantitative details and the fact that the corresponding sales have not been disputed, the addition, if any, ought to be confined to the profit element embedded in the alleged purchases. The Ld. AR, therefore, prayed that such profit element may appropriately be estimated at 2% to 3% of the alleged bogus purchases. It was further submitted that the assessee had already disclosed gross profit at the rate of 3.3% for AY 2010-11 and 2.5% for AY 2011-12. Accordingly, it was contended that, while determining the taxable profit element, the gross profit already disclosed by the assessee should be duly given credit/adjustment, so that there is no duplication in bringing the same profit component to tax.

13.

On a fair and holistic consideration of the entire factual matrix of the issue, we find that, in one of the cases (AY) under consideration, the Ld. AO had made the addition on the basis of the peak credit, which was subsequently enhanced by the Ld. CIT(A). In the other case, the Ld. AO had estimated the profit element at 8% of the alleged non-genuine purchases, which estimation was also enhanced by the Ld. CIT(A). However, the order of enhancement does not disclose any cogent or legally sustainable basis for adopting a higher quantum of addition, nor does it set out any specific reasoning as to why such enhancement was warranted on the facts of the case.

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 14. We further find that the books of account of the assessee, including the quantitative records such as stock register, quantitative details and audited financial statements/audit reports, have not been rejected, disturbed or adversely commented upon by the Revenue Authorities. In the circumstances, where the corresponding sales and quantitative particulars have also not been disputed, the factum of consumption and availability of the goods cannot be altogether disregarded merely because the purchases recorded in the names of the concerned parties have been held to be non-genuine. The circumstances, therefore, indicate that, even if the purchases reflected in the books are not accepted as having been made from the stated parties, the possibility of the assessee having procured the corresponding goods from the grey market or other alternative sources cannot be ruled out.

15.

Accordingly, in such circumstances, the entire amount of the alleged non- genuine purchases cannot, by itself, be treated as the income of the assessee, particularly when the corresponding sales and quantitative details have not been disturbed by the Revenue. The appropriate basis, therefore, would be to bring to tax only the profit element embedded in such purchases, representing the probable saving in cost or the additional margin arising on account of procurement from the alternative/grey market source. Such an approach is also in consonance with the principle emerging from the judicial precedents relied upon by the assessee and the decisions of the Hon'ble Courts in cases involving similar factual circumstances 17

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 16. Under such circumstances, we find that a 3% gross profit rate would be reasonable in the present case, where the income on alleged bogus purchases to be estimated at 3% of the said purchases, which would be reduced by the rate of gross profit already declared by the assessee. Accordingly, for AY 2010-11 since the assessee has already declared a gross profit of 3.3%, no further addition is called for. For AY 2011-12, the assessee has declared a gross profit of 2.5%, therefore an addition of 0.5% of the alleged bogus purchases would be fair to be made. The order of Ld. CIT(A), on this aspect therefore is set aside and the Ld. AO is directed to recomputed the addition in accordance with aforesaid observations.

17.

Coming to the issue of transport charges, it was submitted by the Ld. AR that, for AY 2011-12, the assessee had claimed transport charges amounting to ₹5,06,778/-, whereas the Ld. Assessing Officer has made a disallowance of ₹11,40,200/-. It was submitted that the aforesaid disallowance has been made on the ground of alleged non-compliance with the provisions of section 194C(7) of the Act. The Ld. AR, however, contended that the assessee had duly complied with the substantive conditions prescribed under section 194C(6) of the Act and had furnished the requisite particulars in respect of the transporter.

17.1 It was further submitted that the requirements prescribed under section 194C(7) are essentially procedural in nature and that non-compliance, if any, with such procedural requirement cannot result in denial of the substantive

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah benefit available to the assessee under section 194C(6), particularly when the essential conditions prescribed under the said provision have otherwise been duly fulfilled. In support thereof, the Ld. AR submitted that the assessee had furnished acknowledgement evidencing filing of the return of income by M/s. Savita Logistics, along with the PAN of the transporter, thereby demonstrating compliance with the statutory requirements in substance, though there may have been a technical or procedural lapse in the manner contemplated under section 194C(7) of the Act.

17.2 It was, accordingly, contended that, once the substantive conditions contemplated under section 194C(6) stand satisfied and the identity and tax particulars of the transporter are duly established, the mere alleged procedural non-compliance under section 194C(7) cannot, by itself, justify invocation of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act. The Ld. AR, therefore, submitted that no disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) was warranted in respect of the transport charges so claimed by the assessee.

17.3 On a thoughtful consideration of the facts and material available on record, we find that the assessee was required to comply with the statutory requirements relating to deduction and compliance of tax at source in order to avail the benefit contemplated under section 194C(6) of the Act. However, it is also evident from the material placed on record that the Revenue Authorities were duly apprised of the fact that the corresponding income, in respect of which tax was allegedly not

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah deducted at source, had been duly disclosed by the recipient/transporter in its return of income. Further, the assessee had furnished before the Ld. AO the PAN of the concerned transporter, thereby establishing the identity and relevant tax particulars of the recipient.

17.4 In the aforesaid factual circumstances, where the corresponding income has been duly subjected to taxation in the hands of the recipient and the requisite particulars of the transporter were available with the Revenue, the mere procedural non-compliance, if any, with the provisions of section 194C(7) cannot, in our considered view, justify the consequential disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) of the Act. The object and purpose of the relevant provisions being substantially satisfied, the disallowance made under section 40(a)(ia) is, therefore, not warranted on the facts of the present case. Accordingly, the disallowance made under section 40(a)(ia) of the Act in respect of the transport charges is directed to be deleted.

18.

With regard to the third issue concerning the claim of MVAT, we find that the issue essentially involves factual verification as to whether the amount of MVAT claimed by the assessee as expenditure has also been availed as input tax credit/set-off, thereby resulting in a double claim. The assessee was, therefore, required to furnish the relevant documentary evidence, including copies of the VAT returns, VAT ledger account and challans/payment records, to facilitate proper verification of the claim. It is the specific contention of the assessee that,

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah in the facts of the present case, the benefit of set-off/input tax credit in respect of the MVAT paid was not available and, consequently, the amount constituted expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of its business.

18.1 Having regard to the aforesaid factual controversy, we are of the considered view that the issue cannot be adjudicated conclusively without verification of the relevant records. Accordingly, in the interest of justice, we deem it appropriate to restore the issue to the file of the Ld. Assessing Officer with a specific direction to verify the claim of MVAT with reference to the VAT returns, ledger accounts, challans and other relevant records furnished by the assessee. The Ld. AO shall specifically examine whether the amount claimed as expenditure has been availed as input tax credit/set-off or has otherwise been claimed twice. In the event the assessee's claim that no such credit/set-off has been availed, found factually correct, the allowability of the amount as business expenditure shall be examined in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Act.

18.2 The Ld. AO shall thereafter pass a fresh order on this issue, in accordance with law, after affording the assessee a reasonable and effective opportunity of being heard. The assessee shall, in turn, furnish all requisite documentary evidence and explanations necessary for proper adjudication of the issue.

ITA Nos.6270-6271& 4696/Mum/2025 Paresh Vanitlal Shah 18.4 Accordingly, the issue is restored to the file of the Ld. AO for limited factual verification and fresh adjudication in the aforesaid terms. The ground raised by the assessee is accordingly allowed for statistical purposes.

19.

In result, the appeal of assessee for AY 2010-11 in ITA No. 6271/MUM/2026 against order u/s 143(3) and in ITA No.6270/MUM/2025 against the order u/s 143(3) r.w.s 147 are partly allowed and the appeal for AY 2011-12 in ITA No.4696/Mum/2025 is allowed in terms of our aforesaid observations qua the respective grounds of appeals.

Order pronounced in the open court on 19-08-2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (NARENDER KUMAR CHOUDHRY) (ARUN KHODPIA) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER

Mumbai, Dated : 19-08-2026. Ankit K., Sr. PS Copy of the Order forwarded to : 1. The Appellant 2. The Respondent 3. DR, ITAT, Mumbai 4. Guard File 5. CIT

BY ORDER,

(Dy./Asstt. Registrar) ITAT, Mumbai

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →