RED RAY LABORATORIES,NAGPUR vs. ITO WARD 3(4), NAGPUR

PDF · subscribers
ITA 49/NAG/2026Status: DisposedITAT Nagpur11 September 2026AY 2020-217 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the addition was based solely on uncorroborated third-party data without independent investigation or evidence of payment. It also found a serious violation of natural justice due to the denial of cross-examination opportunity to the assessee. Therefore, the addition for bogus/unaccounted purchases was deleted.

What were the facts?

Reassessment proceedings were initiated against Red Ray Laboratories based on third-party 'parallel tally data' seized during a search on M/s. Special Blasts Ltd. group, alleging bogus purchases of Rs. 36,29,200 from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. The assessee denied these purchases, asserting only sales transactions with the said party, but the Assessing Officer and CIT(A) confirmed the addition.

What were the issues?

The key legal issues were the validity of reassessment based on unverified third-party data, the denial of cross-examination opportunity, and the confirmation of bogus purchase addition under Section 69C without corroborative evidence.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 250,Section 147,Section 143(3),Section 132,Section 69C

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, NAGPUR SMC BENCH, NAGPUR

Before: SHRI MANISH BORAD

For Appellant: Shri Naresh Jakhotia, CA
For Respondent: Shri Shiv Shankar Yadav, Sr.DR
Hearing: 04/08/2026Pronounced: 11/09/2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL NAGPUR "SMC" BENCH, NAGPUR BEFORE SHRI MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER (Through virtual)

ITA No. 49/NAG/2026 (Asst. Year : 2020-21) Red Ray Laboratories, ITO, Ward-3(4), Nagpur D-25, Hingna Road, vs MIDC, Nagpur-440016 PAN : AACFR 3877 N Assessee Revenue

Assessee by : Shri Naresh Jakhotia, CA Department by : Shri Shiv Shankar Yadav, Sr.DR Date of hearing : 04/08/2026 Date of Pronouncement : 11/09/2026

O R D E R This appeal by the assessee is directed against the order of Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)/NFAC, Delhi (for short, “CIT(A)”) dated 25.11.2025 passed u/sec. 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, “Act”) which is arising out of assessment order dated 29.03.2025 passed u/sec. 147 of the Act by the ITO, Ward-3(4), Nagpur for the Assessment Year (A.Y.) 2020-21.

2.

The assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:- “1. Illegal Reassessment Proceeding: That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the reopening of assessment u/s 147 is bad in law, void ab initio and liable to be quashed as it is based solely on unverified third-party "parallel tally data" seized from the premises of another assessee, without any independent enquiry, tangible material or live nexus establishing escapement of income in the hands of the appellant. 2. No Cross Examination Opportunity Provided: That on the facts and in law, whether learned CIT(A) right in confirming the addition done during assessment proceeding

2 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) without providing an opportunity to cross-examine, despite repetitive requests, of the persons whose statements or data were relied upon, thereby violating the principles of natural justice. 3. Addition despite Categorical denial of transaction by Appellant: That the learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of Rs. 36,29,200/-, even though the appellant had categorically denied having made any purchase from M/s SBL Energy Ltd. 4. Addition without cogent Material: That on the facts and in law, whether learned CIT (A) is right in confirming the addition done by AO without any corroborative evidences, cogent material & evidences which establishes that assessee has made bogus purchases? 5. No corroborative Evidences of Bogus Purchase Provided: That the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the entire addition is based only on an uncorroborated parallel tally entry, without existence of any purchase invoice, e-way bill, lorry receipt, GST return, stock entry, delivery proof or banking transaction to support the allegation of purchases. 6. Unwarranted addition under section 69C: That the learned CIT(A) erred in law in confirming the addition u/s 69C without establishing the existence of any actual expenditure incurred by the appellant and without proving the source, nature and genuineness of the alleged expenditure. 7. Ignorance of Affidavit without other material on record: That the learned CIT(A) grossly erred in ignoring the affidavit filed by the appellant affirming on oath that no purchases or cash payments were made to M/s SBL Energy Ltd. This affidavit remained uncontroverted and unchallenged by the Department. 8. Onus to Prove: That the learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition done by AO by shifting the onus to disprove a non-existent purchase on the appellant, even when the Department itself failed to discharge its primary onus of proving that any purchase transaction had actually taken place. 9. General ground: The appellant craves leave to add, alter, amend, or withdraw any of the above grounds before or at the time of hearing.”

3.

Facts of the case, in brief, are that assessee is a partnership firm and engaged in the business of manufacturing of plastic packaging product for the commercial explosive

3 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) companies. Income of Rs. 10,61,600/- declared in the return of income for A.Y. 2020-21 filed on 18.05.2021. Based upon the information received from search and seizure proceedings carried out u/sec. 132 of the Act in the case of M/s. Special Blasts Ltd. group in which tally data was unearthed showing various ledger accounts and as per one ledger account, assessee was shown to have made bogus purchases at Rs.36,29,200/-. Based on this information, re-assessment proceedings were carried out u/sec. 147 r.w.s. 143(3) of the Act. During the course of re-assessment proceedings, assessee expressly denied to have made any purchases from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. It was also submitted that assessee has made regular sales to M/s.SBL Energy Ltd. and proper invoices have been raised and payments have been received, however, Ld. Assessing Officer (AO) was not satisfied with these submissions and based on the search data, made addition for bogus/unaccounted purchases of Rs.36,29,200/- and assessed total income at Rs. 46,90,800/- Aggrieved, assessee preferred appeal before the Ld.CIT(A), but failed to succeed. Now assessee is in appeal before this Tribunal.

4.

Learned counsel for the assessee advanced multifold arguments. Firstly, he submitted that assessee had never made any purchases from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. and, in support of this contention, filed an affidavit placed in the paper book at pages 48–50. Secondly, he submitted that the assessee has entered into regular sale transactions with the said party. In support thereof, he referred to the sale invoices, purchase orders issued by M/s.SBL Energy Ltd., e-way bills and the inward register maintained by the assessee. Thirdly, he submitted that no opportunity of cross-examination was afforded by the Ld. AO despite repeated requests made by the assessee. He contended that entries appearing in the records of third party cannot establish the correctness of alleged addition

4 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) and that the burden of proving the alleged unexplained expenditure lies upon the Revenue. He further submitted that the Ld. AO had not conducted any independent investigation or brought any corroborative material on record and had invoked the provisions of section 69C of the Act merely on the basis of suspicion. It was further submitted that there was no evidence whatsoever of any payment having been made by the assessee towards the alleged purchases. The books of account of the assessee were duly audited and had not been rejected by the Ld. AO. In support of his contentions, learned counsel placed reliance on the following judicial precedents:—

(i) DCIT vs. Mahesh Bansal in ITA no.499/IND/2018, dt. 29.07.2019 (Indore – Trib.) (ii) Smt. Manorama Singhal vs. ITO in ITA No. 130/IND/2020, dt.21.09.2021 (Indore – Trib.) (iii) Durgsingh Gajaram Purohit vs. DCIT in ITA Nos.8380 to 8382/MUM/2025, dt. 09.04.2026 (Mumbai – Trib.) (iv) PCIT vs. Shodiman Investments (P) Ltd. [2020] 422 ITR 337 (Bom. HC) (iv) M/s. Andaman Timber Industries vs. CCE in Civil Appeal No.4228/2006, dt. 02.09.2015 (SC) (v) CIT vs. Smt. P.K. Noorjahan [1999] 237 ITR 570 (SC) (vi) PCIT vs. Vaman International (P) Ltd. [2020] 422 ITR 520 (Bom. HC) (vii) Shree Maya Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. vs DCIT in ITA Nos.227 & 228/NAG/2022, dt. 02.09.2024 (Nagpur – Trib.)

5.

On the other hand, Ld.DR vehemently argued supporting the order of Ld.CIT(A). 6. I have heard the rival submissions and perused the material placed before me. The issue raised is against the bogus /unaccounted purchase at Rs. 36,29,200/- allegedly made by the assessee from M/s.SBL Energy Ltd. The only basis for

5 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) impugned addition is the tally data found during the course of search in the case of M/s. Special Blasts Ltd. group. Ld. AO in the notice issued u/sec. 148 of the Act observed that the said tally data includes a numerous ledger entries and as stated by Mr. Shah Jagrut Vijaykumar Dongaonkar, it solely comprises cash entries and transactions. The details in Annexure A- Parallel Tally “SBLEL-Bogus Purchase” indicate that assessee- Red Ray Laboratories made bogus purchases amounting to Rs. 36,29,200/-. Apart from this information, no other evidence confronted by the Ld. AO to the assessee in support of the allegation for bogus purchases. It is not discernible as to whether Ld. AO has made any independent verification and application of mind before making addition for bogus purchases. Ld. AO has also not provided opportunity of cross- examination to the assessee nor has confronted with the details showing bogus purchases.

7.

I find that assessee has made submissions at all stages including affidavit consistently stating that it has never made any purchases from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. It is also proved that assessee is having regular business transactions with M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. in the nature of sales. In support, ledger account for the A.Ys. 2017-18 & 2018-19 & 2019-20 have been filed. Even ledger account for A.Y. 2020-21 and subsequent years also demonstrates assessee making sales with M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. on regular basis. That the assessee has been issuing regular GST invoices along with tracking number, e-way bills and bank statements received from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. Further, I find that Ld.AO has not provided any supporting documents indicating transport of goods from M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. to the assessee nor has referred to any seized document showing that the assessee had made any payment for such purchases. In totality assessee has furnished all evidences indicating that it is making sale transactions with M/s. SBL

6 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) Energy Ltd. and never entered into purchase transactions with this party. But, Ld. AO has only taken the basis of information received from a search action without making any further investigation or giving any opportunity of cross-examination to the assessee. I find that so far as the facts of the case placed before me are the allegation of Ld. AO is merely based on incomplete information not showing any direct involvement of the assessee of making alleged cash purchase whereas assessee has furnished sufficient evidence to prove that even though it is having regular business transactions with M/s. SBL Energy Ltd. but they are only to the extent of making sales and it has never entered into purchase transactions. Ld. AO has not disputed the book results and had not commented on the purpose of making alleged purchase in cash. Therefore, under the given facts and circumstances of the case, in my considered view impugned addition for bogus/unaccounted purchases is uncalled for.

8.

I also find that even not providing of opportunity of cross- examination, which is a serious flaw and violation of principles of natural justice. I find support from the judgment in the case of M/s. Andaman Timber Industries (supra), where the Hon'ble Apex Court held that not allowing the assessee to cross-examine the witnesses by adjudicating authority though the statements of witnesses were made basis of the impugned order is serious flaw which makes the order nullity inasmuch as it amounted to violation of principles of natural justice. Hon'ble High Court of Rajasthan in the case of CIT vs. Smt. Sunita Dhadda [2018] 406 ITR 220 (Raj) held that as per the principles of natural justice, Ld. AO has to provide opportunity of cross-examination and this view of the Hon'ble Rajasthan High Court has subsequently been affirmed by the Hon'ble Apex Court vide order dated 28.03.2018 in SLP No. 9432/2018. Strictly following the above judicial precedents, I find that in the present case also, assessee

7 ITA No.49/NAG/2026 (Red Ray Laboratories) has not been afforded any opportunity of cross-examination with the statement given by the third party as well as seized records, which is serious violation of principles of natural justice. On this legal ground also, assessee deserves to succeed.

9.

Accordingly, the finding of Ld.CIT(A) is set aside and the addition for bogus/unaccounted purchases of Rs. 36,29,200/- is hereby deleted. Effective grounds of appeal dealt with herein above are allowed and the remaining grounds of appeal become academic in nature, needs no adjudication.

10.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed.

Order pronounced on 11th September, 2026 under Rule 34(5) of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963

Sd/- (MANISH BORAD) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Pune & Dated : 11th Sept., 2026 vr/- Copy of the Order forwarded to: 1. Assessee 2. Revenue 3. PCIT concerned. 4. DR, ITAT, “SMC” Bench, Nagpur. 5. Guard File

BY ORDER Vukkem Digitally signed by Vukkem Rambabu //True Copy// Rambabu Date: 2026.09.11 16:27:19 +05'30' Senior Private Secretary ITAT, Nagpur

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →