BharatTax.net
SearchITATHigh CourtsSupreme CourtPhrasesAI ResearchHistory

Filters

BharatTax.net

Free search engine for ITAT (Income Tax Appellate Tribunal) judgments across all 28 benches in India.

Quick Links

  • Search Judgments
  • Browse by Bench
  • Recent Judgments

About

BharatTax provides free access to Income Tax Appellate Tribunal orders for legal research and reference.

© 2026 BharatTax.net. All rights reserved.

107 results for “house property”+ Section 17(2)(iii)clear

Sorted by relevance

Delhi2,345Mumbai2,176Bangalore859Karnataka678Chennai487Jaipur439Ahmedabad401Hyderabad398Kolkata347Chandigarh257Surat221Pune217Indore205Cochin171Visakhapatnam136Telangana124Amritsar107Rajkot100Raipur87Lucknow68Calcutta61Nagpur59SC57Cuttack56Patna33Guwahati29Jodhpur28Agra26Allahabad24Rajasthan15Dehradun14Orissa9Varanasi8Kerala6Ranchi3Jabalpur2Panaji2Andhra Pradesh2Punjab & Haryana2A.K. SIKRI ROHINTON FALI NARIMAN1Himachal Pradesh1ARIJIT PASAYAT C.K. THAKKER1J&K1T.S. THAKUR ROHINTON FALI NARIMAN1H.L. DATTU S.A. BOBDE1Gauhati1

Key Topics

Section 153A120Section 1155Section 13(3)55Addition to Income55Section 26353Section 143(3)38Deduction35Section 250(6)26Section 69A26

MAX FINANCIAL SERVICE LIMITED ,NAWANSHAHR vs. PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -1, JALANDHAR

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is therefore partly allowed

ITA 121/ASR/2020[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar31 Mar 2021AY 2015-16
For Appellant: Shri Deepak ChopraFor Respondent: Smt.Prabhjot Kaur, CIT
Section 143(3)Section 263

section 263 ,as stated above, have still to be fulfilled for applying the explanation. The case laws holding so, as pointed out by the Ld.Counsel for the assessee are as under: i. Torrent Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Vs. DCIT, ITA No.164/Ahd/2018, decision dated 08.08.2018. ii. Asian Homes Pvt. Ltd. Vs. PCIT (2012) 78 ITR (Trib) 240 (Mumbai). iii. Citystar Ganguly Projects

SHIROMANI GURDWARA PARBANDHAK COMMITTEE vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-I,

In the result the appeal of the Assessee is allowed

Showing 1–20 of 107 · Page 1 of 6

Section 14424
Undisclosed Income21
House Property15
ITA 530/ASR/2009[]Status: Disposed
ITAT Amritsar
16 Aug 2021

Bench: : Shri Laliet Kumar & Dr. Mitha Lal Meenav.S. Cit – I Shirmoni Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee Amritsar Teja Singh Mundri Hall Sri Amritsar Pan:Aants1981K (Appellant) (Respondent)

Section 10Section 12ASection 2Section 80Section 80GSection 80G(5)(iii)

section 80G(2)(B), the Central Government notifies places of public worship owing to their historical, archaeological, or artistic importance. The following Gurudwaras due to their historical importance have been notified u/s 80G(2)(B) by the Central Government. 1. Gurudwara Harminder Sahib, SO 1974, Dated 19.06.1965. 2. Gurudwara DukhNiwaran Sahib, SO 885, Dated 31.12.1975. 3. Gurudwara Shri Hemkunt Sahib

INDIAN TOOLS TECHNOLOGY CENTRE ,JALANDHAR vs. INCOME TAX OFICER WARD II(1), JALANDHAR

ITA 234/ASR/2018[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar21 Feb 2022AY 2014-15

Bench: Sh. Ravish Sood & Dr. M. L. Meena

For Appellant: Sh. J. S. Bhasin, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. Rohit Mehra, D.R
Section 143(3)Section 25Section 57

2,47,81,520/- 86,35,795/- 3,34,17,315/- 17,48,00,000/- 3.1 Thus, in the subsequent year, entire amount of Rs. 17.48 erores was returned to the DIPP along with interest. The assessee argued during assessment 4 proceedings that interest paid was on account of funds received from DIPP which had been paid given the fact

M/S LORD MAHAVIRA HOMEOP[ATHIC MEDICAL COLLEGE & HOSPITAL ,LUDHIANA vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD- ( EXEMPTIONS), JALANDHAR

In the result the 2nd ground raised by the assessee is liable to be allowed

ITA 139/ASR/2020[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar21 Sept 2021AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Laliet Kumar & Dr. Mitha Lal Meena

Section 12Section 12ASection 143(3)

Houses of the State Legislature with retrospective effect from 01- 04-1998 and having received the Hon'ble Governor's assent on 13-08-2015, the Government of Karnataka notified the same as the VTU (Amendment) Act, 2015 (the Amendment Act), vide its notification dated 18-08-2015. Again the assessee made another application for registration under section 12AA

LORD MAHAVIRA HOMOEOPHATIC MEDICAL COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL ,LUDHIANA vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER (EXEMPTIONS), JALANDHAR

In the result the 2nd ground raised by the assessee is liable to be allowed

ITA 383/ASR/2018[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar21 Sept 2021AY 2014-15

Bench: Shri Laliet Kumar & Dr. Mitha Lal Meena

Section 12Section 12ASection 143(3)

Houses of the State Legislature with retrospective effect from 01- 04-1998 and having received the Hon'ble Governor's assent on 13-08-2015, the Government of Karnataka notified the same as the VTU (Amendment) Act, 2015 (the Amendment Act), vide its notification dated 18-08-2015. Again the assessee made another application for registration under section 12AA

M/S LORD MAHAVIR HOMEOPATHIC MEDICAL COLLAGE & HOSPITAL,LUDHIANA vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD- ( EXEMPTIONS), JALANDHAR

In the result the 2nd ground raised by the assessee is liable to be allowed

ITA 125/ASR/2020[2016-17]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar21 Sept 2021AY 2016-17

Bench: Shri Laliet Kumar & Dr. Mitha Lal Meena

Section 12Section 12ASection 143(3)

Houses of the State Legislature with retrospective effect from 01- 04-1998 and having received the Hon'ble Governor's assent on 13-08-2015, the Government of Karnataka notified the same as the VTU (Amendment) Act, 2015 (the Amendment Act), vide its notification dated 18-08-2015. Again the assessee made another application for registration under section 12AA

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST,, JALANDHAR

ITA 344/ASR/2010[2007-08]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 2007-08

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

THE DCIT, JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 39/ASR/2007[2003-04]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 2003-04

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST,JALANDHAR vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR

ITA 185/ASR/2001[1994-95]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1994-95

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

DCIT, JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 328/ASR/2007[2004-05]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 2004-05

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 261/ASR/2004[1999-2000]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1999-2000

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 272/ASR/2004[1997-98]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1997-98

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

M/S SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST,JALANDHAR vs. THE ADDL. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR

ITA 129/ASR/2002[1998-99]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1998-99

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 177/ASR/2006[2001-02]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 2001-02

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST,JALANDHAR vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR

ITA 184/ASR/2001[1993-94]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1993-94

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR vs. M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST, JALANDHAR

ITA 421/ASR/2009[2006-07]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 2006-07

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

M/S. SADHU SINGH HAMDARD TRUST,JALANDHAR vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JALANDHAR

ITA 186/ASR/2001[1994-95]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar07 Dec 2023AY 1994-95

Bench: Dr. M. L. Meena & Sh. Anikesh Banerjee

For Appellant: Sh. Gunjeet Singh Syal, AdvFor Respondent: Sh. S. M. Surendranath, Sr. D. R
Section 11Section 11(1)(a)Section 13Section 13(1)Section 13(3)Section 13(3)(c)Section 2(15)

III, Jalandhar Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant I.T.A. No. 129/Asr/2002 Assessment Year: 1998-99 M/s Sadhu Singh Hamdard Vs. Addl. Commissioner of Income Trust, Nehru Garden Road, Spl. Range, Jalandhar Jalandhar [PAN: AAATS 3278A] (Respondent) (Appellant 3 ITA Nos. 184 to 186/Asr/2001 &Ors. Sadhu Singh Hamdard Trust v.Asstt. CIT& Ors. Appellant by : Sh. Gunjeet Singh

M/S. JAMMU DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,,JAMMU ( J&K) vs. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JAMMU

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes and the appeal of the department is dismissed

ITA 498/ASR/2013[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar20 Mar 2019AY 2005-06

Bench: Sh. N. S. Saini & Sh. N. K. Choudhryita No. 498/Asr./2013 : Asstt. Year : 2005-06 Jammu Development Authority, Vs Dy. Commissioner Of Income Vikas Bhawan, Rail Head Tax, Circle-I, Complex, Jammu, J & K Jammu (Appellant) (Respondent) Pan No. Aadfj7335A Ita No. 494/Asr./2013 : Asstt. Year : 2005-06 Dy. Commissioner Of Income Vs Jammu Development Authority, Tax, Circle-I, Vikas Bhawan, Rail Head Jammu Complex, Jammu, J & K (Appellant) (Respondent) Pan No. Aabcp1720E Assessee By : Shri. R. K. Gupta, Ca & Shri. Vasu Gupta, Ca Revenue By : Shri. M. P. Singh, Cit Dr Date Of Hearing :21.02.2019 Date Of Pronouncement : 22.03.2019 Order Per N. S. Saini: These Are The Cross Appeals Filed By The Assessee & Revenue Against The Order Of Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) Dated 06.05.2013, Jammu.

For Appellant: Shri. R. K. Gupta, CA &For Respondent: Shri. M. P. Singh, CIT DR

iii. Receipts & Payment Account b. Nazul Account - Receipts & Payment Account. 3A.2.3.6.It is prayed to your kind honour to kindly take the revised accounts as above on record to correctly determine the income taxable in the hands of the appellant after including the income that is accruing to the appellant and duly allowing the expenditure deductible in its hands as reflected

THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JAMMU vs. M/S. JAMMU DEVELPMENT AUTHORITY,, JAMMU

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes and the appeal of the department is dismissed

ITA 494/ASR/2013[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar20 Mar 2019AY 2005-06

Bench: Sh. N. S. Saini & Sh. N. K. Choudhryita No. 498/Asr./2013 : Asstt. Year : 2005-06 Jammu Development Authority, Vs Dy. Commissioner Of Income Vikas Bhawan, Rail Head Tax, Circle-I, Complex, Jammu, J & K Jammu (Appellant) (Respondent) Pan No. Aadfj7335A Ita No. 494/Asr./2013 : Asstt. Year : 2005-06 Dy. Commissioner Of Income Vs Jammu Development Authority, Tax, Circle-I, Vikas Bhawan, Rail Head Jammu Complex, Jammu, J & K (Appellant) (Respondent) Pan No. Aabcp1720E Assessee By : Shri. R. K. Gupta, Ca & Shri. Vasu Gupta, Ca Revenue By : Shri. M. P. Singh, Cit Dr Date Of Hearing :21.02.2019 Date Of Pronouncement : 22.03.2019 Order Per N. S. Saini: These Are The Cross Appeals Filed By The Assessee & Revenue Against The Order Of Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) Dated 06.05.2013, Jammu.

For Appellant: Shri. R. K. Gupta, CA &For Respondent: Shri. M. P. Singh, CIT DR

iii. Receipts & Payment Account b. Nazul Account - Receipts & Payment Account. 3A.2.3.6.It is prayed to your kind honour to kindly take the revised accounts as above on record to correctly determine the income taxable in the hands of the appellant after including the income that is accruing to the appellant and duly allowing the expenditure deductible in its hands as reflected

M/S ACTIVE TOOLS (P). LIMITED,JALANDHAR vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE -II, JALANDHAR

ITA 260/ASR/2019[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar16 Aug 2021AY 2014-15

Bench: : Shri Laliet Kumar & Dr. Mitha Lal Meena

Section 115Section 133ASection 142(1)Section 154Section 68Section 69Section 69ASection 69BSection 69CSection 69D

property, profits and gains of business or profession, or capital gains, nor as it income from "other sources" because the provisions of sections 69,69A, 69B and 69 treat unexplained investments, unexplained money, bullion etc. and unexplained expenditure as deemed income where the nature and sources of investment, acquisition or expenditure, as the case may be, have not been explained