RAMKUMAR HUF,TRICHY vs. ITO, WARD-3(2), TRICHY

PDF · subscribers
ITA 2076/CHNY/2026Status: DisposedITAT Chennai01 September 2026AY 2013-1411 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the re-characterization of income and application of Section 50C without proper notice to the assessee required fresh adjudication. The issues regarding the head of income, applicability of Section 50C, claim for deduction under Section 54, and taxation of the co-owner's share were restored to the CIT(A) for fresh consideration.

What were the facts?

The assessee, a HUF, sold a property consisting of land and a building. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated the land as stock-in-trade and the building as business income, leading to a higher tax liability. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) partially allowed the appeal, but certain issues remained contentious.

What were the issues?

The key issues were the correct head of income for the building sale, the applicability of Section 50C, the assessee's claim for Section 54 deduction, and the taxability of the co-owner's share.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 45(2),Section 54F,Section 50C,Section 2(42A),Section 54

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ‘C’ BENCH, CHENNAI

Before: SHRI S.S. VISWANETHRA RAVI & SHRI S. R. RAGHUNATHA

Hearing: 29.06.2026Pronounced: 01.09.2026

आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, ‘C’ न्यायपीठ, चेन्नई IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL ‘C’ BENCH, CHENNAI श्री एस एस विश्वनेत्र रवि, न्याविक सदस्य एवं श्री एस. आर. रघुनाथा, लेखा सदस्य के समक्ष BEFORE SHRI S.S. VISWANETHRA RAVI, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI S. R. RAGHUNATHA, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER आयकर अपील सं./ITA No.2076/Chny/2026 ननिाारण वर्ा / Assessment Year: 2013-14 Ramkumar HUF The Income Tax Officer 95-A, Thiru-Vi-Ka Nagar vs. Ward - 3(2), Puthur S.O., Trichy. Tiruchirappalli – 620 017. (प्रत्यर्थी/Respondent) [PAN: AAGHR6284M] (अपीलार्थी/Appellant)

अपीलार्थी की ओर से/Appellant by : Smt. G.Vardhini Karthik, Advocate & Shri. S.Karthik, CA प्रत्यर्थी की ओर से/Respondent by : Shri. Pelli Prem Kumar, Sr.AR सुनवाई की तारीख/Date of Hearing : 29.06.2026 घोर्णा की तारीख/Date of Pronouncement : 01.09.2026 आदेश /O R D E R PER S. R. RAGHUNATHA, AM : The present appeal preferred by the assessee is directed against the order dated 16.02.2026 passed by the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [hereinafter referred to as “the ld. CIT(A)”], arising out of the assessment order dated 29.03.2016 passed by the Income Tax Officer, Ward 3(2), Tiruchirappalli [hereinafter referred to as “the AO”] u/s.143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [hereinafter referred to as “the Act”], for the Assessment Year 2013-14.

:-2-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

2.

The brief facts of the case, as emanating from the records, are that the assessee is a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) and filed its return of income for the assessment year under consideration on 03.05.2014, declaring a total income of Rs.58,560/-. The case was selected for scrutiny, inter alia, on account of substantial investment in immovable property vis-à-vis the income returned by the assessee.

3.

During the course of assessment proceedings, the AO noticed that the assessee had, jointly with another co-owner, acquired land in the earlier assessment years and thereafter constructed a three-storied residential building thereon during the financial year 2012-13. Subsequently, the land together with the building was sold for an aggregate consideration of Rs.1,50,00,000/-. As against the stated sale consideration, the guideline value adopted for stamp duty purposes was Rs.2,56,06,000/-, comprising Rs.2,06,06,000/- towards the land and Rs.50,00,000/- towards the building. It was further noticed that, in the course of proceedings before the Stamp Valuation Authority, the building was referred for valuation to the Assistant Engineer, who estimated the cost/value of construction at Rs.99,18,137/-.

4.

In the return of income, the assessee offered long-term capital gain in respect of its 50% share in the land and claimed deduction u/s.54F of the Act. The AO, however, was of the view that the land, though originally acquired and held as a capital asset, had subsequently been converted into stock-in-trade and, accordingly, invoked the provisions of section 45(2) of the Act. According to the AO, since the conversion of the capital asset into stock-in-trade had taken place within a period of 36 months from the date of acquisition, the resultant capital gain was liable to be assessed as short-term capital gain. The AO accordingly computed short-term capital gain at Rs.79,13,058/-.

:-3-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

5.

As regards the building constructed on the said land, the AO noticed that the assessee had accounted for Rs.25,00,000/-, representing its 50% share in the building component of the sale consideration, and, after claiming the expenditure relating to the construction/business activity, had disclosed a net loss. The AO, however, adopted the value of the building at Rs.99,18,137/- and, after reducing the building component of Rs.25,00,000/- disclosed by the assessee, brought the differential amount of Rs.74,18,137/- to tax as additional business income.

6.

Consequently, after allowing the business expenditure claimed by the assessee, the AO determined the business income at Rs.60,18,759/-. The assessment was thus completed vide the order dated 29.03.2016 u/s.143(3) of the Act by determining the total income of the assessee at Rs.1,39,90,375/-, as against the returned income of Rs.58,560/-.

7.

Aggrieved by the aforesaid assessment order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the ld.CIT(A). The ld.CIT(A), vide order dated 16.07.2020, dismissed the appeal of the assessee. Being aggrieved, the assessee carried the matter in further appeal before this Tribunal. This Tribunal, vide order dated 20.09.2024, set aside the order of the ld.CIT(A) and restored the matter to his file for fresh adjudication on the merits of the case in accordance with law. Pursuant to the directions of this Tribunal, the ld.CIT(A) passed the impugned appellate order dated 16.02.2026, whereby the appeal of the assessee was partly allowed. Being aggrieved by the relief denied and the findings sustained by the ld.CIT(A), the assessee is once again in appeal before us.

8.

The ld. CIT(A), on consideration of the material available on record, observed that the assessee held only 50% undivided share in the subject property, while the remaining 50% share was owned by the co-owner, Shri Daniel Jayakaran. The AO, however, while framing the assessment, brought to

:-4-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

tax 50% of the sale consideration attributable to the land amounting to Rs.1,03,03,000/- and the entire value of the building of Rs.99,18,137/-, as determined by the Stamp Valuation Authority, in the hands of the assessee. In doing so, the AO re-characterised the land as having been converted into stock- in-trade and assessed the income arising from the transaction partly as business income and partly as short-term capital gain.

9.

The ld. CIT(A), after examining the documentary evidence placed on record, including the purchase deeds and the sale deed, found that the assessee had acquired 50% undivided share in the land during the financial year 2009-10 and continued to hold the same till its transfer during the relevant previous year. The ld. CIT(A) further found that no material had been brought on record by the AO to establish that the assessee had, at any point of time, converted the land into stock-in-trade or treated the same as a trading asset. According to the ld.CIT(A), mere construction of a building upon the land and its subsequent sale would not, in the absence of cogent material demonstrating an intention to carry on an adventure in the nature of trade, result in conversion of the land from a capital asset into stock-in-trade.

10.

The ld.CIT(A), therefore, held that the land continued to retain its character as a capital asset. Since the assessee had held his 50% undivided share therein for a period exceeding 36 months, the gain arising on transfer thereof was held to be assessable under the head “Long-Term Capital Gains”. Accordingly, the AO was directed to compute the long-term capital gain arising from transfer of the assessee’s 50% share in the land, in accordance with law, after allowing the deductions admissible to the assessee.

11.

Insofar as the building constructed on the said land is concerned, the ld.CIT(A) observed that the construction had been completed during the financial year 2012-13 and that the property was subsequently sold on

:-5-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

01.10.2013. The ld.CIT(A) also took note of the recital in the sale deed dated 01.10.2013 describing the building as being two years old. On these facts, the ld.CIT(A) held that the period of holding of the building was less than 36 months and, consequently, the building constituted a short-term capital asset within the meaning of section 2(42A) of the Act.

12.

As regards the value to be adopted for the building, the ld.CIT(A), in the absence of any material to rebut the value determined by the Stamp Valuation Authority and having regard to the provisions of section 50C of the Act applicable to transfer of a capital asset being land or building or both, held that the stamp duty value of Rs.99,18,137/- was liable to be adopted as the full value of consideration attributable to the building component for the purpose of computation of capital gains.

13.

The ld.CIT(A), however, took note of the assessee’s contention that his ownership in the building was also restricted to 50% and, therefore, only 50% of the value attributable to the building could be brought to tax in his hands. In this regard, the ld.CIT(A) referred to the observation of the AO in para 11 of the assessment order that, “For the building, the representative has stated that the entire land was utilized by the assessee himself only and the entire expenses were incurred by the assessee himself only.”

14.

The ld.CIT(A) further observed that, during the appellate proceedings, the assessee had expressed his inability to furnish complete particulars regarding the expenditure incurred and the income, if any, offered to tax by the co-owner, Shri Daniel Jayakaran, in respect of the building component. The ld.CIT(A) also took note of the fact that, under the General Power of Attorney executed in favour of the assessee, the assessee was required to maintain accounts in respect of the expenditure incurred on behalf of the co-owner. It was further observed that the assessee had acted as the General Power of Attorney holder

:-6-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

of Shri Daniel Jayakaran, had coordinated and supervised the construction activity and had received the entire sale consideration of Rs.1,50,00,000/- in respect of the land and building.

15.

In the aforesaid circumstances, the ld.CIT(A) held that the onus was upon the assessee to establish that the capital gain attributable to the 50% share of the co-owner, Shri Daniel Jayakaran, had been duly offered to tax in the hands of the said co-owner. Since, according to the ld.CIT(A), the assessee failed to discharge such onus and merely expressed his inability to furnish the relevant particulars, the ld.CIT(A) held that the short-term capital gain arising from the building component was liable to be assessed in the hands of the assessee. At the same time, the ld.CIT(A) directed the AO to verify whether Shri Daniel Jayakaran had offered to tax the capital gain or any income arising from his share in the building component in his return of income. Upon such verification, the AO was directed to recompute the short-term capital gain assessable in the hands of the assessee in respect of the building component, after allowing the admissible cost of construction, if duly substantiated, in accordance with law.

16.

Thus, the ld.CIT(A) directed the AO to assess the gain arising from transfer of the assessee’s 50% undivided share in the land as long-term capital gain. As regards the building component, the ld.CIT(A) held the same to be a short-term capital asset and directed the AO to compute the short-term capital gain by adopting the value determined by the Stamp Valuation Authority in terms of section 50C of the Act, subject to verification of the extent to which the income attributable to the co-owner’s share had already been offered to tax in the hands of Shri Daniel Jayakaran and after allowing the admissible cost of construction in accordance with law.

17.

Aggrieved of the above order of the Ld.CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before this Tribunal.

:-7-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

18.

The ld.AR, appearing for the assessee, submitted that the ld.CIT(A) had re-characterised the income arising from the sale of the building, which was originally offered by the assessee under the head “Profits and Gains of Business or Profession”, as “Short-Term Capital Gains”, without affording adequate and effective opportunity of hearing to the assessee on the said issue. According to the ld.AR, such re-characterisation of the nature and head of income, without confronting the assessee and granting a reasonable opportunity to put forth its objections, is not sustainable in law.

19.

The ld.AR further contended that the ld.CIT(A) erred in sustaining the valuation adopted by the AO by invoking the provisions of section 50C of the Act, notwithstanding the fact that the income arising from the sale of the building had been disclosed by the assessee under the head “Profits and Gains of Business or Profession”. It was submitted that the applicability of section 50C of the Act necessarily depends upon the transfer of a capital asset and, therefore, the said provision could not have been mechanically invoked in respect of an asset/income treated as forming part of the assessee’s business.

20.

The ld.AR further submitted that the ld.CIT(A) had failed to adjudicate the specific grounds raised by the assessee with regard to its claim for deduction/exemption u/s.54 of the Act. It was contended that once the income arising from the transfer was sought to be assessed under the head “Capital Gains”, the consequential claim of the assessee u/s.54 of the Act ought to have been considered and adjudicated on merits.

21.

The ld.AR also assailed the action of the authorities below in bringing to tax, in the hands of the assessee, the portion of the sale consideration/income attributable to the share of the co-owner. It was submitted that the assessee held only his respective undivided share in the property and, therefore, the

:-8-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

income attributable to the share belonging to the co-owner could not be assessed in the hands of the assessee. According to the ld.AR, income arising from the co-owner’s share, if otherwise taxable, could be brought to tax only in the hands of the concerned co-owner in accordance with law and not in the hands of the assessee.

22.

In support of the aforesaid contentions, the ld.AR placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. D.P. Sandu Bros. Chembur (P.) Ltd. (2005) 273 ITR 1 (SC) and submitted that the ratio laid down therein had not been properly considered by the ld.CIT(A). The ld.AR, therefore, pleaded that the findings of the ld.CIT(A) on the aforesaid issues be set aside and appropriate relief be granted to the assessee.

23.

Per contra, the ld.DR strongly supported the orders of the authorities below and submitted that no interference with the findings of the ld.CIT(A) was called for.

24.

We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. On a careful consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, we find that certain material aspects arising from the impugned order require fresh consideration by the ld.CIT(A). It is an admitted position that the assessee had offered the income arising from the building component under the head “Profits and Gains of Business or Profession”, whereas the ld.CIT(A), while disposing of the appeal pursuant to the earlier order of the Tribunal, has treated the building as a short-term capital asset and consequently directed computation of short-term capital gain by invoking the provisions of section 50C of the Act. The specific grievance of the assessee before us is that such re- characterisation of the head and nature of income was made without putting the assessee on notice and without affording an effective opportunity to explain its case on the applicability of the provisions relating to capital gains, including

:-9-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

section 50C of the Act. In our considered view, when the very character of the income returned by the assessee is proposed to be altered and consequential statutory provisions are sought to be applied, the assessee ought to be afforded a reasonable opportunity to put forth its case in this regard.

25.

We further find merit in the contention of the ld.AR that the applicability of section 50C of the Act is intrinsically connected with the determination as to whether the asset transferred is a “capital asset” and the income arising therefrom is chargeable under the head “Capital Gains”. Therefore, the question as to the correct head under which the income arising from transfer of the building is assessable and the consequential applicability, if any, of section 50C of the Act require to be examined together after considering the nature of the property, the conduct of the assessee, the manner in which the construction activity was undertaken and accounted for, and all other relevant material available on record. The contentions of the assessee in this regard, including the reliance placed on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in CIT v. D.P.Sandu Bros. Chembur (P.) Ltd. (2005) 273 ITR 1 (SC), shall also be considered by the ld.CIT(A) in accordance with law.

26.

We also notice that the assessee has specifically contended that its claim for deduction/exemption u/s.54 of the Act has not been adjudicated by the ld.CIT(A). Once the income arising from the transaction is considered under the head “Capital Gains”, all consequential claims for deduction/exemption arising therefrom and specifically raised by the assessee are required to be adjudicated in accordance with law. We, therefore, deem it appropriate that the claim of the assessee u/s.54 of the Act, subject to its maintainability and fulfilment of the conditions prescribed under the Act, be examined on merits without our expressing any opinion thereon.

:-10-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

27.

Another aspect which, in our view, requires proper examination is the taxation in the hands of the assessee of the amount attributable to the share of the co-owner, Shri Daniel Jayakaran. The ld.CIT(A) himself has recorded that the assessee held only 50% undivided share in the property and has directed the AO to verify whether the income attributable to the co-owner's share had been offered to tax by the said co-owner. Prima facie, the taxability of income has to be determined with reference to the person to whom such income accrues or belongs in law. The mere fact that the assessee acted as General Power of Attorney holder, supervised the construction or received the sale consideration on behalf of the co-owner would not, by itself, be conclusive for determining the person in whose hands the income is chargeable to tax. At the same time, the exact nature of the arrangement between the assessee and the co-owner, the source and incidence of the expenditure incurred on construction, the terms of the Power of Attorney, the manner in which the sale consideration was received and appropriated, and the other relevant surrounding facts require examination before arriving at a conclusion on this issue.

28.

Considering the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, and particularly taking into consideration the aforesaid contentions advanced by the ld.AR, we are of the considered opinion that the issues relating to (i) the correct head of income under which the gain/income arising from transfer of the building is assessable; (ii) the applicability of section 50C of the Act; (iii) the assessee's consequential claim for deduction/exemption u/s.54 of the Act; and (iv) the extent, if any, to which the income attributable to the 50% share of the co-owner can be brought to tax in the hands of the assessee, require fresh adjudication by the ld.CIT(A). We accordingly set aside the impugned order on the aforesaid issues and restore the same to the file of the ld.CIT(A) for adjudication in accordance with law, after considering all the contentions, documentary evidence and judicial precedents that may be relied upon by the assessee.

:-11-: ITA. No:2076/Chny/2026.

Needless to say, the ld.CIT(A) shall afford adequate and effective opportunity of being heard to the assessee before deciding the issues.

29.

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in the open court on 01st September, 2026 at Chennai.

Sd/- Sd/- (एस एस विश्वनेत्र रवि) (एस. आर. रघुनाथा) (S.S. VISWANETHRA RAVI) (S. R. RAGHUNATHA) न्याविक सदस्य/Judicial Member लेखा सदस्य/Accountant Member

चेन्नई/Chennai, ददनां90क/Dated, the 01st September 2026 Devadas आदेश की प्रतिलिपि अग्रेपिि/Copy to: 1. अपीलार्थी/Appellant 2. प्रत्यर्थी/Respondent 3.आयकर आयुक्त/CIT– Chennai/Coimbatore/Madurai/Salem 4. ववभागीय प्रनतननधि/DR 5. गार्ा फाईल/GF Digitally signed by DEVADAS DEVADAS GOPALANACHARY GOPALANACHARY Date: 2026.09.03 10:09:43 +05'30'

More judgments on Section 45(2)

All 262 judgments and leading authorities on Section 45(2) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →