COMMNR. OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT), MUMBAI vs. M/S. DILIP KUMAR AND COMPANY
C.A. No.-003327-003327 - 2007Supreme Court30 Jul 2018
Bench: A Bench Of TwoJudges. The Matter Then Went Before A ThreeJudge Bench Consisting One Of Us (Ranjan Gogoi, J.). The Three Judge Bench Having Noticed The Unsatisfactory State Of Law As It Stands Today, Opined That The Dicta In Sun Export Case (Supra), Requires Reconsideration & That Is How The Matter Has Been Placed Before This Constitution Bench. 2
202. It
may be noted that this case was dealt with by five
learned Judges of this Court resulting in two different
opinions; one by the then Chief Justice of India, S.R.
Das for the majority, and Justice B.P. Sinha (as His
Lordship then was) rendering minority view. The
question before this Court was whether the sale of goods
made
