SIR RATAN TATA TRUST,MUMBAI SUBURBAN vs. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (EXEMPTION)-2(1), MUMBAI

In the result, both the appeals of the assessee in both AY 2014-15 and AY

Bench: Ms Padmavathy S, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

House, 24, National Faceless Assessment Homi Mody Street, Fort, Centre-2(1), Vs. Mumbai-400001 MTNL Tele Building, PAN : AAATS1013P Cumballa Hills, Peddar Road, Mumbai-400026. Appellant) : Respondent) Appellant/Assessee by : Shri P. J. Pardiwala a/w Shri Sukhsagar Syal, AR Revenue/Respondent by : Shri Sanyogita Nagpal, CIT-DR Date of Hearing : 22.07.2024 Date of Pronouncement 26.08.2024 : Per Padmavathy S, AM: 1. These

SIR RATAN TATA TRUST,MUMBAI SUBURBAN vs. ADDITIONAL /JOINT/DEPUTY/ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, NFAC, MUMBAI

In the result, both the appeals of the assessee in both AY 2014-15 and AY

Bench: Ms Padmavathy S, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

House, 24, National Faceless Assessment Homi Mody Street, Fort, Centre-2(1), Vs. Mumbai-400001 MTNL Tele Building, PAN : AAATS1013P Cumballa Hills, Peddar Road, Mumbai-400026. Appellant) : Respondent) Appellant/Assessee by : Shri P. J. Pardiwala a/w Shri Sukhsagar Syal, AR Revenue/Respondent by : Shri Sanyogita Nagpal, CIT-DR Date of Hearing : 22.07.2024 Date of Pronouncement 26.08.2024 : Per Padmavathy S, AM: 1. These

MMTI'S EDUCATION & RESEARCH TRUST,MUMBAI vs. ITO (E) 2 (1), MUMBAI

In the result, the appeals of the assessee are In the result, the appeals of the assessee are allowed partly for allowed partly for statistical purposes

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy () & Shri Om Prakash Kant () Assessment Year: 2011-2012 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, The Dy. Director Of Income- New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Tax(Exemption)-I(1), Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera 5Th Floor, Piramal Chambers, Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, Parel, Lalbaug, Andheri (West), Mumbai-400012. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2012-2013 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, 12. Andheri (West), Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2013-2014 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), Victor House, 2Nd Floor, End Of Veera Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Desai Road, Next To Chitralekha Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent

House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. PAN No. AABTM 2192 E Appellant Respondent MMTI’s Education & Research Trust MMTI’s Education & Research Trust ITA Nos. 5866/M/2015, 451/M/2019 & 2974/M/2017 Assessee by : Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Revenue by : Mr. Manish Ajudiya, Date of Hearing Date of Hearing : 14/06/2023 : Date of pronouncement Date of pronouncement

MMTIS EDUCATION AND RESEARCH TRUST,MUMBAI vs. ITO (E) 2(1), MUMBAI

In the result, the appeals of the assessee are In the result, the appeals of the assessee are allowed partly for allowed partly for statistical purposes

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy () & Shri Om Prakash Kant () Assessment Year: 2011-2012 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, The Dy. Director Of Income- New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Tax(Exemption)-I(1), Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera 5Th Floor, Piramal Chambers, Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, Parel, Lalbaug, Andheri (West), Mumbai-400012. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2012-2013 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, 12. Andheri (West), Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2013-2014 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), Victor House, 2Nd Floor, End Of Veera Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Desai Road, Next To Chitralekha Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent

House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. PAN No. AABTM 2192 E Appellant Respondent MMTI’s Education & Research Trust MMTI’s Education & Research Trust ITA Nos. 5866/M/2015, 451/M/2019 & 2974/M/2017 Assessee by : Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Revenue by : Mr. Manish Ajudiya, Date of Hearing Date of Hearing : 14/06/2023 : Date of pronouncement Date of pronouncement

MMTIS EDUCTION & RESEARCH TRUST,MUMBAI vs. DDIT (E) I(2), MUMBAI

In the result, the appeals of the assessee are In the result, the appeals of the assessee are allowed partly for allowed partly for statistical purposes

Bench: Shri Vikas Awasthy () & Shri Om Prakash Kant () Assessment Year: 2011-2012 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, The Dy. Director Of Income- New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Tax(Exemption)-I(1), Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera 5Th Floor, Piramal Chambers, Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, Parel, Lalbaug, Andheri (West), Mumbai-400012. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2012-2013 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), New Excel House, 2Nd Floor, 41-B, Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Azad Nagar Road No. 2, Off. Veera Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- Desai Road, Behind Icici Bank, 12. Andheri (West), Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent Assessment Year: 2013-2014 Mmti’S Education & Research Trust, Ito(E)-2(1), Victor House, 2Nd Floor, End Of Veera Income-Tax Office, Piramal Vs. Desai Road, Next To Chitralekha Chambers, Parel, Mumbai- House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. Pan No. Aabtm 2192 E Appellant Respondent

House, Andheri (W), 12. Mumbai-400053. PAN No. AABTM 2192 E Appellant Respondent MMTI’s Education & Research Trust MMTI’s Education & Research Trust ITA Nos. 5866/M/2015, 451/M/2019 & 2974/M/2017 Assessee by : Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Ms. Arati Vissanji, Adv & Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Mr. AmodPrabhudesai, Revenue by : Mr. Manish Ajudiya, Date of Hearing Date of Hearing : 14/06/2023 : Date of pronouncement Date of pronouncement

DCIT (E)- 2(1), MUMBAI vs. J.R.D TATA TRUST , MUMBAI

In the result, the appeal of Revenue is dismissed and that of the assessee is allowed

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singhaayakr Apila Sam./ Ita No. 3082/Mum/2018 (Inaqa-Arna Baya- / Assessment Year 2012-13) J.R.D Tata Trust, The Income Tax Officer, Bombay House, 24, Homi 2(4), Mody Street, Fort, [Now Assessed By The Mumbai-400 001 Deputy Commissioner Of Vs. Income-Tax (Exemptions)- 2(1), Mumbai, Piramal Chambers, Lalbaug, Parel, Mumbai-400 012 .. (P`%Yaqaai- / Respondent) (Apilaaqai- / Appellant) स्थायी लेखा िं./Pan No. Aaatt0165F

House, 24, Homi Commissioner of Income-tax Mody Street, Fort, Vs. (Exemptions)-2(1), Mumbai, Mumbai-400 001 Piramal Chambers, Lalbaug, Parel, Mumbai-400 012 (ApIlaaqaI- / Appellant) .. (p`%yaqaaI- / Respondent) अपीलाथी की ओर े / Appellant by : Shri Percy Pardiwala, Sukh Sagar Sayal, ARs प्रत्यथी की ओर े / Respondent by : Shri Rajat Mittal, DR ुनवाई की तारीख / Date of hearing: 24.06.2019 घोषणा की

J.R.D. TATA TRUST,MUMBAI vs. ITO (E) - 2(4) (NOW ASSSESSED BY THE DCIT (E) 2(1), MUMBAI

In the result, the appeal of Revenue is dismissed and that of the assessee is allowed

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singhaayakr Apila Sam./ Ita No. 3082/Mum/2018 (Inaqa-Arna Baya- / Assessment Year 2012-13) J.R.D Tata Trust, The Income Tax Officer, Bombay House, 24, Homi 2(4), Mody Street, Fort, [Now Assessed By The Mumbai-400 001 Deputy Commissioner Of Vs. Income-Tax (Exemptions)- 2(1), Mumbai, Piramal Chambers, Lalbaug, Parel, Mumbai-400 012 .. (P`%Yaqaai- / Respondent) (Apilaaqai- / Appellant) स्थायी लेखा िं./Pan No. Aaatt0165F

House, 24, Homi Commissioner of Income-tax Mody Street, Fort, Vs. (Exemptions)-2(1), Mumbai, Mumbai-400 001 Piramal Chambers, Lalbaug, Parel, Mumbai-400 012 (ApIlaaqaI- / Appellant) .. (p`%yaqaaI- / Respondent) अपीलाथी की ओर े / Appellant by : Shri Percy Pardiwala, Sukh Sagar Sayal, ARs प्रत्यथी की ओर े / Respondent by : Shri Rajat Mittal, DR ुनवाई की तारीख / Date of hearing: 24.06.2019 घोषणा की

DY.CIT (E) -2(1) , MUMBAI vs. MUMBAI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MUMBAI

Bench: Shri Prashant Maharishi, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

c) and s. 13(2) were ITA Nos. 1828 to 1831/Mum/2022 Mumbai Education Trust; A.Y. 08-09 to 11-12 not attracted- property in question was not made available for the use of any person referred to in sub- s (3) of s. 13, within the meaning of s. 13(2) even if no rent or compensation was charged installation

DY.CIT (E) -2(1) , MUMBAI vs. MUMBAI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MUMBAI

Bench: Shri Prashant Maharishi, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

c) and s. 13(2) were ITA Nos. 1828 to 1831/Mum/2022 Mumbai Education Trust; A.Y. 08-09 to 11-12 not attracted- property in question was not made available for the use of any person referred to in sub- s (3) of s. 13, within the meaning of s. 13(2) even if no rent or compensation was charged installation

DY.CIT (E) -2(1) , MUMBAI vs. MUMBAI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MUMBAI

Bench: Shri Prashant Maharishi, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

c) and s. 13(2) were ITA Nos. 1828 to 1831/Mum/2022 Mumbai Education Trust; A.Y. 08-09 to 11-12 not attracted- property in question was not made available for the use of any person referred to in sub- s (3) of s. 13, within the meaning of s. 13(2) even if no rent or compensation was charged installation

DY.CIT (E) -2(1) , MUMBAI vs. MUMBAI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MUMBAI

Bench: Shri Prashant Maharishi, Am & Shri Rahul Chaudhary, Jm

c) and s. 13(2) were ITA Nos. 1828 to 1831/Mum/2022 Mumbai Education Trust; A.Y. 08-09 to 11-12 not attracted- property in question was not made available for the use of any person referred to in sub- s (3) of s. 13, within the meaning of s. 13(2) even if no rent or compensation was charged installation

ITO (E) 1(3), MUMBAI vs. FREE TRADE UNION, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

M/S. FREE TRADE UNION MULTIPURPOSE PROJECT TRUST,MUMBAI vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

ITO (E) 1(3), MUMBAI vs. FREE TRADE UNION, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

M/S. FREE TRADE UNION MULTIPURPOSE PROJECT TRUST,MUMBAI vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER (EXEMPTION)- 1(3), MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

M/S. FREE TRADE UNION MULTIPURPOSE PROJECT TRUST,MUMBAI vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-43 OR CIT CENTRAL 4, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

M/S. FREE TRADE UNION MULTIPURPOSE PROJECT TRUST,MUMBAI vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER (EXEMPTION)- 1(3), MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

ITO (E) 1(3), MUMBAI vs. FREE TRADE UNION, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate

M/S. FREE TRADE UNION MULTIPURPOSE PROJECT TRUST,MUMBAI vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-43 OR CIT VENTRAL 4, MUMBAI

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & G. Manjunatha, Am

House, 4 th Floor, Vs. Goregaonkar Road,Nana Chowk, Mumbai-400007. Appellant .. Respondent Assessee by : N. R Agrawal, AR Revenue by : Pooja Swaroop, Sr.DR Date of hearing: 28-06-2018 Date of pronouncement : 04-07-2018 O R D E R Per Bench: These cross appeals filed by the assessee, as well as the Revenue are directed against separate