DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALAJEE MINI STEELS & REROLLING PRIVATE LIMITED , PATNA

In the result, the appeals of the Revenue are dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shripradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

2,97,52,993/- to the income of the assessee. 15.2. In the appellate proceedings, the ld. CIT (A) deleted the addition made by the ld. AO by observing and holding as under:- “7.2.1. I have perused the assessment record as well as the submission of the assessee. On examining the same, it is found that the assessee is engaged

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND CEMENT & ROOFINGS PRIVATE LIMITED , KOLKATA

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shri Pradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

purchases. Balmukund Lease Fin Private Limited; A.Y. 15-16 to 18-19, 23-24 Balmukund Cement & Roofings Private Limited AYs 15-16 to 21-22, 23-24 Balmukund Sponge and Iron Private Limited; A.Y. 23-24 42.1. The issue raised is similar to one as decided by us in ground no. 1 & 2 in ITA No. 1700/KOL/2025

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND SPONGE AND IRON PRIVATE LIMITED, PATNA

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shri Pradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

purchases. Balmukund Lease Fin Private Limited; A.Y. 15-16 to 18-19, 23-24 Balmukund Cement & Roofings Private Limited AYs 15-16 to 21-22, 23-24 Balmukund Sponge and Iron Private Limited; A.Y. 23-24 42.1. The issue raised is similar to one as decided by us in ground no. 1 & 2 in ITA No. 1700/KOL/2025

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND CEMENT & ROOFINGS PRIVATE LIMITED , KOLKATA

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shri Pradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

purchases. Balmukund Lease Fin Private Limited; A.Y. 15-16 to 18-19, 23-24 Balmukund Cement & Roofings Private Limited AYs 15-16 to 21-22, 23-24 Balmukund Sponge and Iron Private Limited; A.Y. 23-24 42.1. The issue raised is similar to one as decided by us in ground no. 1 & 2 in ITA No. 1700/KOL/2025

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND CEMENT & ROOFINGS PRIVATE LIMITED , KOLKATA

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shri Pradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

purchases. Balmukund Lease Fin Private Limited; A.Y. 15-16 to 18-19, 23-24 Balmukund Cement & Roofings Private Limited AYs 15-16 to 21-22, 23-24 Balmukund Sponge and Iron Private Limited; A.Y. 23-24 42.1. The issue raised is similar to one as decided by us in ground no. 1 & 2 in ITA No. 1700/KOL/2025

GOPAL & SONS HUF,KOLKATA vs. I.T.O., WARD - 32(1), KOLKATA, KOLKATA

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am & Shri Pradip Kumar Choubey, Jm

purchases. Balmukund Lease Fin Private Limited; A.Y. 15-16 to 18-19, 23-24 Balmukund Cement & Roofings Private Limited AYs 15-16 to 21-22, 23-24 Balmukund Sponge and Iron Private Limited; A.Y. 23-24 42.1. The issue raised is similar to one as decided by us in ground no. 1 & 2 in ITA No. 1700/KOL/2025

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND SPONGE AND IRON PRIVATE LIMITED, PATNA

The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by the AO\nas under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied upon by the\nassessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case as in these\ncases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has been made

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND SPONGE AND IRON PRIVATE LIMITED , PATNA

The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by the AO\nas under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied upon by the\nassessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case as in these\ncases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has been made

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE- 4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND CEMENT & ROOFINGS PRIVATE LIMITED , KOLKATA

The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by the AO\nas under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied upon by the\nassessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case as in these\ncases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has been made

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA vs. SHAKAMBHARI ISPAT & POWER LIMITED, KOLKATA

2 & 3 in respect of alleged transaction of purchase of\ncoal with Anup Majhee and addition made thereto for different\n assessment years as follows:-\n Assessment Year\n2016-17\n2017-18\n2018-19\n2019-20\n2020-21\n2021-22\nAmount

M/S. SHAKAMBHARI ISPAT & POWER LTD.,KOLKATA vs. DCIT, CC - 3(3),, KOLKATA

2 & 3 in respect of alleged transaction of purchase of\ncoal with Anup Majhee and addition made thereto for different\n assessment years as follows:-\n Assessment Year\n2016-17\n2017-18\n2018-19\n2019-20\n2020-21\n2021-22\nAmount

M/S. SHAKAMBHARI ISPAT & POWER LTD., ,KOLKATA vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE 3(3), , KOLKATA

2 & 3 in respect of alleged transaction of purchase of\ncoal with Anup Majhee and addition made thereto for different\n assessment years as follows:-\n Assessment Year\nAmount (in Rs.)\n2016-17\n2,02,84,550/-\n2017-18\n3,70,00,000/-\n2018-19\n25,14,67,500/-\n2019-20\n29,93,22,967/-\n2020

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND CEMENT & ROOFINGS PRIVATE LIMITED , KOLKATA

The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by the AO\nas under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied upon by the\nassessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case as in these\ncases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has been made

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE- 4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALAJEE MINI STEELS & REROLLING PRIVATE LIMITED , PATNA

In the result, the appeals of the Revenue are dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am\Nand\Nshripradip Kumar Choubey, Jm\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Years: 2015-16 To 2018-19)\Nita No. 1725/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Year: 2016-17)\Ndcit, Central Circle 4(3)\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling\Naaykar Bhawan Poorva, 110,\Nprivate Limited\Nshantipally, Kolkata-700107,\N603, Shantikunj Apartment,\Nkolkata\Nphulwanipatna, G.P.O.800001,\Nvs.\N(Appellant)\Npatna\N(Respondent)\Npan No. Aabcb7265J\Nassessee By\N:\Nshri Manish Rastogi, Ar\Nrevenue By\N:\Ns/Shri Praveen Kishore &\Npradeep Dungdung, Drs\Ndate Of Hearing:\N01.12.2025\Ndate Of Pronouncement:\N15.12.2025\Norder\Nper Rajesh Kumar, Am:\Nthese Are Appeals Preferred By The Revenue Against The Orders Of The Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Appeals), Kolkata-27 (Hereinafter Referred To As The “Ld. Cit(A)"] Dated 13.04.2025 For The Ays 2015-16 To 2018-19.\Nas The Facts & Issues In All The Appeals Of Revenue Are Exactly Identical, Hence, For The Sake Of Brevity, We Take Ita No. 1688/Kol/2025 For A.Y. 2015-16 & Decide The Issue Accordingly.\Nα.Υ. 2015-16\Npage 2\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025&1725/Kol/2025\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling Private Limited; Ays 2015-16 To 2018-19\Nita No. 1688/Kol/2025\N3.\Nthe Only Issue Raised By The Revenue Is Against The Deletion Of Addition By The Id. Cit (A) Of ₹1,07,03,817/- As Made By The Id. Ao On Account Of Suppression Of Income In Respect Of Bogus Purchases.\N3.

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by\nthe AO as under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied\nupon by the assessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the\ncase as in these cases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has\nbeen made

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA , KOLKATA vs. BALAJEE MINI STEELS & REROLLING PRIVATE LIMITED , PATNA

In the result, the appeals of the Revenue are dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am\Nand\Nshripradip Kumar Choubey, Jm\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Years: 2015-16 To 2018-19)\Nita No. 1725/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Year: 2016-17)\Ndcit, Central Circle 4(3)\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling\Naaykar Bhawan Poorva, 110,\Nprivate Limited\Nshantipally, Kolkata-700107,\N603, Shantikunj Apartment,\Nkolkata\Nvs.\Nphulwanipatna, G.P.O.800001,\N(Appellant)\Npatna\N(Respondent)\Npan No. Aabcb7265J\Nassessee By\Nshri Manish Rastogi, Ar\Nrevenue By\Ns/Shri Praveen Kishore &\Npradeep Dungdung, Drs\Ndate Of Hearing: 01.12.2025\Ndate Of Pronouncement: 15.12.2025\Norder\Nper Rajesh Kumar, Am:\Nthese Are Appeals Preferred By The Revenue Against The Orders Of\Nthe Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Appeals), Kolkata-27 (Hereinafter\Nreferred To As The “Ld. Cit(A)"] Dated 13.04.2025 For The Ays 2015-16\Nto 2018-19.\Nas The Facts & Issues In All The Appeals Of Revenue Are Exactly\Nidentical, Hence, For The Sake Of Brevity, We Take Ita No.\N1688/Kol/2025 For A.Y. 2015-16 & Decide The Issue Accordingly.\Nα.Υ. 2015-16\Npage 2\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025&1725/Kol/2025\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling Private Limited; Ays 2015-16 To 2018-19\Nita No. 1688/Kol/2025\N3.\Nthe Only Issue Raised By The Revenue Is Against The Deletion Of\Naddition By The Id. Cit (A) Of ₹1,07,03,817/- As Made By The Id. Ao\Non Account Of Suppression Of Income In Respect Of Bogus Purchases.\N3.

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by\nthe AO as under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied\nupon by the assessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the\ncase as in these cases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has\nbeen made

DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALAJEE MINI STEELS & REROLLING PRIVATE LIMITED , PATNA

In the result, the appeals of the Revenue are dismissed

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar, Am\Nand\Nshripradip Kumar Choubey, Jm\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Years: 2015-16 To 2018-19)\Nita No. 1725/Kol/2025\N(Assessment Year: 2016-17)\Ndcit, Central Circle 4(3)\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling\Naaykar Bhawan Poorva, 110,\Nprivate Limited\Nshantipally, Kolkata-700107,\N603, Shantikunj Apartment,\Nkolkata\Nphulwanipatna, G.P.O.800001,\N(Appellant)\Nvs.\Npatna\N(Respondent)\Npan No. Aabcb7265J\Nassessee By : Shri Manish Rastogi, Ar\Nrevenue By : S/Shri Praveen Kishore &\Npradeep Dungdung, Drs\Ndate Of Hearing: 01.12.2025\Ndate Of Pronouncement: 15.12.2025\Norder\Nper Rajesh Kumar, Am:\Nthese Are Appeals Preferred By The Revenue Against The Orders Of\Nthe Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Appeals), Kolkata-27 (Hereinafter\Nreferred To As The “Ld. Cit(A)"] Dated 13.04.2025 For The Ays 2015-16\Nto 2018-19.\Nas The Facts & Issues In All The Appeals Of Revenue Are Exactly\Nidentical, Hence, For The Sake Of Brevity, We Take Ita No.\N1688/Kol/2025 For A.Y. 2015-16 & Decide The Issue Accordingly.\Nα.Υ. 2015-16\Npage 2\Nita Nos.1688 To 1691/Kol/2025&1725/Kol/2025\Nbalajee Mini Steels & Rerolling Private Limited; Ays 2015-16 To 2018-19\Nita No. 1688/Kol/2025\N3.\Nthe Only Issue Raised By The Revenue Is Against The Deletion Of\Naddition By The Id. Cit (A) Of ₹1,07,03,817/- As Made By The Id. Ao\Non Account Of Suppression Of Income In Respect Of Bogus Purchases.\N3.

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by\nthe AO as under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied\nupon by the assessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the\ncase as in these cases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has\nbeen made

M/S. SHAKAMBHARI ISPAT & POWER LTD.,,KOLKATA vs. DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE 3(3), , KOLKATA

2 & 3 in respect of alleged transaction of purchase of\ncoal with Anup Majhee and addition made thereto for different\n assessment years as follows:-\n Assessment Year\nAmount (in Rs.)\n2016-17\n2,02,84,550/-\n2017-18\n3,70,00,000/-\n2018-19\n25,14,67,500/-\n2019-20\n29,93,22,967/\n2020

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-4(3), KOLKATA, KOLKATA vs. BALMUKUND SPONGE AND IRON PRIVATE LIMITED, PATNA

The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed

2. 3. The assessee distinguished the Hon'ble ITAT Kolkata decisions relied by the AO\nas under.\n\"It is in this regard respectfully submitted that none of the case laws relied upon by the\nassessing officer is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case as in these\ncases percentage disallowance of the bogus purchases has been made