THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION CORPORATION LTD

I ifi flJj HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DAflD THIS fiB 13Th DAY OF WRCH 2012 U UI THE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE N KUMAR THE HOWBLE MR JUSTICE RPM MALIMATH I Between: 1. The Comni ámr ofIncome-tax LfI, JSS Tower,s BSKfflStage, Baiaiore 0 2 The Income-Tax cer, 2 Aayahr Bwn, 5 Sedam Roads Gulbarp 3 The Ixo.me Tax Ofiker LiUrnzs), JSS Tow., BSI.: ifi Stage, BaraIore AP;LISNTS I Sn z0U

2 And: Karnataka Power Tramnission Carp. ration M, Oulbarga Major Wor (8) Division, Sharan Nagar Clulbarga RESNDE141 (By Sri Chytkwnya KIC, Adweate) This TM is filed under Section 260A of LTAct, 1%1 afislng out of order dated 18 (13 2011 passed in I’M No233/BamJ2OlO, for the Asssment year 2007- , prayirs.g that this Hon’ble Court may he phased formulate the substantial questions of law sated that This TM coming on for Hearing this day, wja,j, delivered the folkiwing This apl is by the rnue. The substantial questions of law that arise for consideration in this appeal are as under:— (1$Thether the ‘Iflbuncd was right m splitting tsp the confrad, which, acm titling s the ret anus, ii as — AL?)

1- 0 Ur 3 I z cf the asmposlte oflrad frito part O suth as part of the inWad atfr’Lbutable fl value cfthe materials bwolved lu the execuuon ofthe wart a.r4 otherpan :0r ofthe ara such as thil works and taking the vin that tax was required to be deducted at source only fri respect of theworkpaftofthaa,rawaa and not 2 materialpan ofthe ntraotP j2$øtethera lWbunal was justified 201(1A) of the Inaime Tax Act, 1961 le not testable, as the assessee was not liable to make any deductions fri respect ofthe value of the material part of the wntraot 4 .thouhthecxmtrrflwasoneof whole oontrndP’ I I Court had an occasn to consklar the 12 I appeah where the said qutions were inIved in the case of Commtsdansr ofIncome lbzc and othen 0 W ranta sanr anaed CiaporcUan Ltmtted dEsed of on awn date and has answered I z0U

H COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATA cA HIGH COURT OF KARNA\KA HIGH COURT OF ‘cARNAYAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COU * — 0 J4 c,j 0 i I