MR. GAURAV SUNIL MANSINGHANI ,MUMBAI vs. ITO WARD 22(1)(5), MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 751/MUM/2025Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 April 2025AY 2016-17Bench: SHRI AMIT SHUKLA (Judicial Member), MS PADMAVATHY S (Accountant Member)3 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the debit balance in the broker's books represented an amount to be received by the broker from the assessee, while a credit balance in the assessee's books indicated a liability to pay the broker. Therefore, the debit balance could not be treated as the assessee's income.

What were the facts?

The assessee, engaged in F&O trading, filed their return declaring income. The AO added Rs. 4,33,564/- by treating a debit balance in the broker's ledger as assessee's income. The CIT(A) dismissed the appeal ex-parte.

What were the issues?

Whether a debit balance in the broker's ledger account can be considered as the assessee's income.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ‘H(SMC

For Appellant: Ms. Rupal Shah
For Respondent: Shri Sunil Mathews, Sr
Hearing: 15/04/2025Pronounced: 22/04/2025

आदेश / O R D E R PER AMIT SHUKLA (J.M): The aforesaid appeal has been filed by the assessee against order dated 13/12/2024 passed by Addl/ JCIT-4, Kolkata for the quantum of assessment passed u/s.143(3) for the A.Y.2016-17. 2. In the grounds of appeal assessee has challenged the addition of Rs.4,33,564/- by treating the debit balance in the ledger account of the broker as ‘income’ of the assessee.

1.

1. Gaurav Sunil Mansinghani 3. The brief facts qua the issue involved are that assessee is into business of trading in F & O. He has filed his return of income on 06/12/2016 declaring total income of Rs.3,71,820/-. Before the ld. AO assessee has filed financial statement of stock broker, Anurag Stock Broking Pvt. Ltd., from such statement AO inferred that assessee has profit of Rs.4,33,564/-. He has considered the closing debit balance as profit of Rs. 4,33,564/-. Without giving any reasons that how it is an income, he has made the addition of Rs.4,33,564/-. Ld. CIT (A) has dismissed the appeal exparte.

4.

Before us ld. Counsel has submitted that the ld. AO has misunderstood and misinterpreted the ledger account of the broker and in support he has filed the ledger account of the assessee in the books of the broker wherein the closing balance as on 31/03/2016 was a debit balance of Rs.4,33,563.98. This means this amount was to be received by the broker from the assessee. In the assessee’s books it was credit balance which means there was a liability to pay to the broker. Thus, the closing debit balance in the books of the broker of Rs.4,33,563.98 could not have been treated as ‘income’ of the assessee.

5.

From the perusal of the said statement which was filed before the ld. AO it is seen that the ledger account of the assessee in the books of the broker there was a running account for debit and credit entries through which assessee had been doing Gaurav Sunil Mansinghani 6. Thus, it was F & O bill credit margin that means broker has to receive the money from the assessee. Similarly, there is a credit balance of the same amount in the accounts of the assessee which means there was a liability to pay to the broker. Accordingly, no way a debit balance in the books of the broker can be treated as income of the assessee. Accordingly, addition of Rs.4,33,563.98 is deleted.

7.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed. Order pronounced on 22nd April, 2025.

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →