MAGNA PUBLISHING CO. LTD. vs. SHILPA S. SHETTY

PDF
C.A. No.-000344-000344 - 2002Supreme Court14 December 2007Bench: DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT P. SATHASIVAM1 pages
For Petitioner: E. C. AGRAWALAFor Respondent: S. K. BHATTACHARYA

No AI summary yet for this case.

™#%PDF-1.2 %Ç쏢 6 0 obj <> stream xœuWÛnÉ|çW4òµo«ï¿É¶²–±–‰À/#r(Ά"¹Ã¡åëSu†”´Z¯ ›˜aŸ[:uš¿+£­2ü{øœÝM~Ÿœ\u»›X£î'Vu£‹úeb‹ºsÄi¯î&¶F§½W±øÂO[‹×6ò9hS•3ÕèH ë´ j6qÖÁYÂørj5±9„N¶:ÆÁëâð&Ußïé=ouvÊWé=ctU–ÎsP±ò1*<|}„Tãµ)HÃÕ¢«W%Fmmå3‚Uœ×Ù )´­ƒ‹b’ÎÕÒEÒÌ¿:<çȤ r„a 6k#%k_`pÀEUª×1â9¢^ƒÉ²Œçdu ‰U2GUNI»ŒÉZ]¼ÊHÊ|sÕÎÂ"!oøÆ’J± 8,‚KºdXmË@҈uZDGwL@¶Ê¢k&+ëCâ<ñ©8¿œ¸„33D`*zìŠ5Ú[R&^¹Ÿž¦«)jïhQø‰× ð¢Xí ðwÙ∠5ZÆÇ‹T"q )#2 ÛY…\áqá+|ä€R‚r±)$ ’$ˆM@W³Ÿ]E“ƒC0p \*8`‹a%¶ZD@ÞäU&-+£SƒÎEÙöÒÂá$ÙÑD‡¼=Ø ÎÂ"É@ÁĀ‘¥WòƲ1¹"K@Q%AAÉ!£EI$ƒŽ°®â8(6ã¹¢nvʑ¼ÎÙ"CæPyh<èO~{Ð:Ê#Ùê²NÀÎ5©åà‹YºhI À¬Á2ì]L›ä…7,$&dž>œÑ>\`<¢`Rٚª0£u†E #˜&œŒ¾Åzçx$gù…u¥êJfG0ÆÒ™Âs^\$”`ؓP˜ĬóÉV{ö €V>WyFmƅ±«à,Á°¦ À6p¦‘65;ô §ªNùŒYtÂižNYùDe+hà1‘"Îà5c؁8ó¬à/ôPM1ßèAâtâMH^Œ$WP8A#@ Ì2E› €Ã8¸êÑ©¥b²áÍU3z·¬ATÊ{øõï,gه$£à-å ¹£S’̈²‡¤R}È2e°Hý‡EÂøƒß>m‡¥˜Aˆ ÅØ(¨@dÛYœ8·Þ€Š3ŸÙË´Ã<Äb1l ²Ó–¹§Bi .ŠX~o›h¹¸6¼ õ´ôæeàØÔ$Óí¡ä¾äæØäÑ _‘4Qj¤çÞÁ< ¥ÃYÀòYCޱ,óò¢Åƒ¬ž¢ÐÓ.aÔ,ÑiTèÙqH7£tˑ)b袌¦RìYÞ¸àEl¼ •ˆ9Îjf±ŠX8ˆ   ¦‰O°ó¡È#›Ü.aK죋£Ö6ƒ è8˜f9%ÈْÅx†0g¨ªhefªˆ)‹Œ L•það©«P#Ëè ä㨼+ÆØ¢&M*$ Ð{Ø 9t§ ‘=¹Àd}=®´…’…ÆyÛX.÷@µ©$3µ£ŽÃ Bº‚.¢è£`EÍ}Å’«©gJ¬U´Ò²µ<ƒï8ÅÎÊ\ãÙ4%S|ÁA蠟! ªïØ ž!¨«Ì놣“DD Í‰ò!®²a2P$-ŸÐ*(¶shU$ʐ_'RaÖ낚žé1ɚƳ9àY,êÆ`Kx: Wè„l¦SeÛ`(› &JÐHè1^¼eP¨’•Í؊DÍA ABp-2hânãNƒN²ÍiTŸ`Á% °x,22µŠ/¬/3V©™ÜŒô î) <¶L$ʈAá§ÎWP‡Ë—~ڌkö<‚—Üq¼LIL’±r• a(•–RÉG7ÞKX#V¸Ê±°úF}^Ø|ت™ìõ²Xý‰Âp¥%hãRÀn„€Ëõ ?ŽáÈnIÑÇː—‰ Ï+Ë Ž…ó“­m+ㅌ0#² (º(…àáYFÔc>¸Š%1' ÞrFQ£tŽ'|]1Dâ‡Ú W¢—Vƒõ–<µIîr¸—¹@p ÇQí«ÜŠm h({t´>ÉÎÂLt.a®<2Ý⎍U®Á ç3/|·—!$¸ˆ³‘Ž×fË è,õ‡·c>—‘c³%Sí© àoMeôJˆiܐü±VÊ@8Ïß¼HAÆEŠP4…#qÔ(_ɏwbÌJå*qayo-Ar4¼ƒðîaEׅ£#kqƒR•ñäŠZËÆB!¬ÅègÊÂ5~÷ÜO ~õ¸`ÿńÿ2Jõ-¾þ×iùÁtø˜Ý©wSüpª|1]LÆ_Si•yo‡ Lï&¯–ð}{ròéë‡ók}qþ^Ÿ_¨×Óßp#¡Át>yuýõòêìó™zÿåëÕT}ù‡:¿øp~*gòñÌesÛÂ÷f¡œXŸ\Á|Œû3MýÌÖJH~z}¦.¾è·<‰sÓ_'¯N·Û¶Y©o¯fÝ÷nõíµ"!ş1îõOØVrìòlz>=ÿrqvõ/¶Ÿ›Ûu£.÷7«n·lûz¿Ñê×a®Õß՗~§ŸÌ¯Î®/¿\|8»˜>3¿^v«m£®µº^¶ÃððtüÃéôŒœ_>Ód=±î9eœzõîìâýÇgž>ôZ^:ŸªËÓëÓŸN‘Á%üžN?ž^Ÿÿëôó“ïGŸOæŸÔWõAý¢>+À£¦ø‚€ýÐïõ‰e"~oµ’?Û¦Ÿ«þ_·s5Ûì×»v¥›^ ËVm›~èZãp´R,Å\œªa+€â°lõ½›·ªY«n=´}w§6ý¼íÕ¼C†ýkŒ}#.ãcw»üû~P·}³æ©fþhÜ­Û¯gC·YÃ%¾QÐìÍv=[²åtônswÓ<<÷×·‹ýþ†ÍèoÑöí³ÖúC§ê¦ïڏãÀzÖҀÍl؃bÍnÛΆºßìWsµÛ/ݬ}û&.§°îÛÝv³ž·ëA-º˂i7¨Ùªéîºõíˆ觺¾Ã™;ñ 0ݱ¬ÛÍñTŽóZ½oû¡é€º2[µHùªíÅíÕ»æ¶ù_·~þí̓Å^­Vz§f͊y}û¡¹@„ýnà;{*®$a²aÞÀc+I]íÐA5ë7ÈRÑÃíc1âÿ˜\ƒÜècÞ.`ô³]ϟÚÝ·ÏÎCÃìy‚÷á Ú*çïûnàQ"÷̲Y?ü]Žõ?4wŒ"Ήþ§ØbÄ×C·XHmÍ÷#'ûvÕ°d„ÞŽ­ß $>F~´*PjúþÒ]³~£î—Dî¾[­Ô BGÕÀšwИXóŒzœYÍ1|ŠÏi×tó—rlŽzŒN¯7¢¾7›ïè< M³%ë[ߎ¥_QD_=Š^:„x'œ‘<UZú¼géˆÓ_Ìۑ<{Ó>@DGTûæ©ß5ó§ÞŒSLûÇIÖRë³50–%A9@/ÿͳ™ÿŒzp?Nˆ´¶íïvoË ?N o[Ñh±ZBŽL[tœi!؋V±MŒ †|ܬºáÆtoÙ`)—×n·—•:öŽ~Ÿ¡5ëórXØ9ýûqÖ³©úç„ÿÇI®¨endstream endobj 7 0 obj 3012 endobj 15 0 obj <> stream xœu—[sÇ…ßñ+¦ò¹J^í\w&oñ%‰\¶ìHtùy.ŵAÂE ÿ}¾Ó в+%B³;ӗӧO>º¾ó®×Ïåsý°ú¸ò½{\y7¯ú®º®|¹kÕå!³-º‡•o9t1º\cÕ§o5v>kº¾¹Ð·¾Ë:áC’[¯‚+<ÁVp›•†„Ïâ[èÊò Å®ž”Ö•¢'5FY/}ôÝœ¯¡Ézéû¾kÎËø\núÄGÃbå}Ž™sh}ìúJ¡Õ®EWsî¼oZã´ºb7ô ÛLÔ¾tCó2QºÄ Åßë!+¨JŒÌÉ]oêÐÅʁƐ]m±Ë™u&ß%ÙÀºø.Û ’Ȫô‰­n(¥ ;Š÷]n ¨xŸ‡ÖωB,±×“P»T\ÉçœH¡tuàDí|—4ìÈäéñNuúD´å©Z?8’\²_ø4ö߯Ba`¦ v©QãP}ßEïRÀ$ºPóïkÀ ­ä.¨ú¤Æ­ªïBÿ0x¶¸Ô²—”š…[j„Œgm¡ÚƒKC+‚' ¸oØ©$rK"R* R̉/I@§Ð†ÎlöT•"§€3¸A… ¾öÊÄ7â¯qÑ+3õ9uCu¾À^ì›3E Äa7œåDîqƎ$abÂGVêM¼ñ*ÌЈ(š¹(¤œJ¢ôTDyÕ FñëFÞªTyCð՚,y5h"ô¿#ô'ÁÉ<‹­aè Ø`¼µ¶eÈ}IsàÌÚ¬^µË·ÅÄ^‰äBäÅàcO“ÈãñB§ª495c<­œ»I,`ÐMìÌ=¶äÅÇ´%Õàõ‡ں&f€#Œñ2%¦h_4…zÕ$U…À:Öý໨šhӺٚÜú–ªÂYáûfû¤ž&lijÀÆé@ö)¸8ЋÁ8­Ýep±HY0⠖E =kr¦ÙA\q68«,TyWQ "ýM Šº“'©D;d±Bá‚F@ úƒH)S8Ú!´H ,—Fgc-´~±î‘6¶d*#vcÏ3¯^Ž©X+D/y#v*epL(G$UêÓ`]ƉÒSNÚ~Ç ÚµöCˆhi[… d•-‰ÅE}ûPٓù¢=¡¤4SŠ*’¥T@¢ë¼b/UҒB6±üÑ„Šè546¢_zzY‹Öp*j±îŽèƒ¸o± ‚<•ˆ … ö¥‘Qs‡ ¬ÆVáÁÀŠC‡3¼âŠÑÒFee@4zDÑ%-še:MBU–ƒ&€U3[µ‚˜bC¶£Kâ¨ xR4±‰!5!Ô«ƒjÈ\¨v" .’ ݤçbª¶”bk©iʶ¢:†¼h °õ8¥â0Í«KˆÙ‹Å¬ŌªšV Ÿ6è `†2ÍêGãKWi¨1Øt¹¤Ý“”w#Ç´-94©Šp ¡œ!8ªÓŒÈQ\P°±]Ge‘dQ¸hp÷^Ã=ImšÈ,íhKsBÈP©B:I6™À´‚75W#¡’,lUJéUZí᝺8xëkÖ^8P”AÚ+C„ÚYMÓ`¨&=S´G "Vƒ®AFŠA›‹ä!n6aP‘V+J…b‡@©²PF~ƒIÂÜeƅ4}ÅbcšuÁ/+%Nò¦1Á žB¥1E%l2¥LMeã M*L6§YÐÓ^ºeH¨Š·É”TŠ"Í!„d.4å´h¶i¦¡“*sYÔ'y¸D›Åj-ӚÙbœDë±&ÕÄÍ,›©çžå™2Y(ãCÂ/oPGÚˈ>ýÀµŠ¹ƒEx©§Ë”¹ ÆÛU"ÉE/©ô’J-Ãr/)°Æ¬j”3}‹>ƒ“©:ˆ½ÑK‘=Sõ}5að: mb"f#n×K~iÁ1„E$Ms‚.CÑ:BLnü0ÎÛãɝî'÷Å_W/öÖ§ùîî/KyåøÐ9ûsæoæOó#î«i»¾wãQ¡ëøÝùÀÇÁ}š§GŒÏF/A|?‡ítëÞøfrߝoIü~¼uÛÝÉ}8ŒÛ/q>æ·?ìNÓZÑZXï§§9<ʪ\î㻕—–ëݧéÀúý“ù´·‡ÎNÖÏbßY|Ǔ޽Ÿîväúß)Yø:þ°{˜¶'÷ëù(óÚðs3l¦ñvº})˜Y[,’Ésæsþ/§Ìþ¸9îàÞ¯¼%ì£êB5ÍëèöÓáxÉ»BÓVå%Eм{Ôþã™p÷ç÷›K`ŸvIþ»?„}¼ç¤l¦çYxvZNøÇÆñ^ˆ.U;Í“ê*#÷Ô͸¶”ùxžOŠBèñôi¾·I|yaPë?íw؁çÑ0š'ÈõyŽ„²¹ä¾s›qýÛÕéþb¨ÞïÎKP‡éÊ`+üú~<ŒàwèþHL_*y·;³oAU€/é>Χ{™<žß+"·óã~?;mZ¯wE°yr·óña>§ÛÕç$‘#ûÿ•Ùkü§ ~°Ln6›ÐgUlÃÐ((§ñ·iûÿÉØ¹Hï+28Ê÷iz)à͛ñãOÓqO£ˆ²Çó~¿;\=’˵#~ß/áÿBïÎW ´5!Ú¥6ÓQ°Aï+±Í’»Æÿx?ÓËÖ½ª"±}š^~ք™½Ve¯6°> /Contents 6 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj <> /Contents 15 0 R >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 5 0 R 14 0 R ] /Count 2 >> endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>endobj xref 0 18 0000000000 65535 f 0000006281 00000 n 0000008625 00000 n 0000006215 00000 n 0000006329 00000 n 0000005911 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000003097 00000 n 0000006496 00000 n 0000006558 00000 n 0000007564 00000 n 0000007622 00000 n 0000006384 00000 n 0000006414 00000 n 0000006071 00000 n 0000003117 00000 n 0000005890 00000 n 0000006455 00000 n trailer << /Size 18 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R >> startxref 8675 %%EOF