HINDUSTAN PAPER CORPORATION LTD. vs. KAGAJKAL THIKADAR SRAMIK UNION

PDF
C.A. No.-008601-008601 - 2001Supreme Court14 December 2007Bench: DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT P. SATHASIVAM2 pages
For Petitioner: FOX MANDAL & CO.For Respondent: SUDHIR KUMAR GUPTA

No AI summary yet for this case.

†5%PDF-1.2 %Ç쏢 6 0 obj <> stream xœ}XMwÛF¼óWÌiW~O0ߘÜdY+ëH^‰~{Ñ"A6IÐhEÿ~« H9ÊÆ/fNUWWó]å™V9ÿŒŸ³õäûäìÖ©Çn¢sõ4ѪžäY¡~›èÂú,ÊGÓV­':y“Y«|a ~êTØL{>»,OÊä)Ï<-´ÉŒS³‰ÑÎÞÀ—Q«‰ŽÑ!tÐÉdaxálV¼ ) o ké=äVgÑ(]˜Dï!Ïó,)MçÑ)Ÿø‰  |קּ¤Üfy4L*²dUá}¦uâ3‚ª06‹9’²H[¸(òÅ¤é"dÌ? l6g!> ó ðáLfÉÆ# &•­ñ. ã1Ê>‹°p„`ӄ“>‡/FÑÖq…ÑüB›"e‰ÌŽ`Œ¦+2…笸(!gO\Á4 `žó¨3˞ÐÄç$Ϩ-7nè*8K0tž`í8ÓH›€ z€…ÓÕ;£lÄ,á4O‡¨l ²À‰4ðH“ã5c؁8óLà-è¡`t6DÄ|£Ó‰7.X1’\Aá)0Èm*ÆÁ$‹H- “ o&åƒw ÀÁäD¥¬…_›ãæ,[d¬¦¼!wtJ2€Q¶Tª£uQ¦ !Gÿa0þà·õ@ÛàDQä0ƒ! @‹±%PP϶9²8pnmžTœñøŒVÞ ¥&gÙ ‹`‘]¦™{((-Îx Âo5€`5—׆Õ! žšÞ¬ ›dº-ôÜ—Ü `<:a’&*ðO´Ü;8€g¡±t8 X6fclͼ¬…hñ «†g€(ô°¤‹4Ktôl¸¤›^ºeÈ14^F S)¶¬oŒ³"6Ö¸DÄ g5²‡Ø …Xˆ q ¦‰O°³®G*6¹-LØÃØGã­l9‚¢ã`šæ” gMãBÀœ¡ª¢•‘©"¦,:PЃ2Iú‡Á§®bl@(o 3KŒ»£ò®c‹š 4© ᐅÞÂÉ¡;IˆlÉ&kÓ~ -”,4ΠܹærwT›D2S;Ò0œ ¤)ÐGt}bc´¨¹MArÕ"õHÉ’‰¢ŠVj¶–gð§Øh™kÖî¸X¸­´¬×ä©r—ý4— —°Ô>É­X;‚†Ò¹g@Gmƒì,Ì$@çæÊ#CÐ-îXŸäú€tr>òÒÈgpËp’Ab‹8ixmÖܱ€NSx;æs1pÌa¶dª-uãà­©—ÛªUM»mÚ²¯›úÔϳƒùíåÝç›ë—×Ó#ó—å×oˆ>]ÖßÊyÙª»¶\×ßԗ =üCݴݑçÓKÂÈ~ûƒž@á3mΐhÄ©“÷—׏Üh3uÞÖ_ëéuåsÙÃåçLݕý²ìêåúàûÅçÁ|ÿêƒcÛSõ;s;ÑČÿ ˆN•œø¯yÝV³¾š+Yoº^õËJ-ê ¾ýº›?®«M¯ÊÍ\6íÎKAx°;PY®¶e×áÍóxø€6uDç}µ™-Ù'¾e"¿•»% WëÇ%:±k{UoÔ[”?6ùºÉ@O# ÏO˪­à—ÖôrdY®VÍ¢òõ] …Âe$ËU]žŽ%֛Ǘxjµ*QZß ñgU}ß!0ëìêu½B‹ŸÀØNÞ4°jÕCµ©ußÑbŸÈ¬Ùôm9ëÕª|@:UÛ!×F=5í7Ö4"YwKÆþÚ<¨Ý†ÐÑüv·ª + ´AcîO~à喇½×Oâ_ÞV»Õ@×±'çͪæ؝w]¹Vô؝1 Ýý !CDa”FŒîïscå$ÿËÝ¿Ëԁ7fO‘÷m]-Ô9t¬£T›]¯º% Se[©²S‹†ÀwG4¹5€Ru·ÚªÛ6(X9‘t%^?Ö’C^Ó¶œmæiYþ 1±>:Õ,õ ±9$`Ô#&$ëú¶R4þX¢o߀O}:"_Õ²\-DwÜ[íZÖíÀYaÅˉ¦E…­ öB•_þŸŠÐœJä/ÊÙüÎüQ¯VÒ_ÔÝ-›¶?tA¾š–°A¥¸i«-0^ƒç‡ ™Tb6òáFhÏ®6ݶ’\QžT|ú°j›†…XÒk-}`iõz»ªÖ/QàAIûŸXyR¸)ÔQ?à‡u«VUß¿¨®ê̬ɔ¸šþ%k!ðQæÃ”<@«º}Œ®¬ço!1Ҙ٣՟[tE¾9ÃÁÕ³Z´ÍúµBŒLîêÍLòŽO ï¦YÙU§o«r Äf˜ý×EF\Z¤H©¥…t€îã|1â^!ºÝÊDìg͚Xwûz%Ã×å!Ï«ÍA ð’$åæùÅþÍt·m³m(½ˆ»lVó1uLî÷]Ý>3&nb¼ù$Üa˜óÂz@ƒ¾w›z&ʼnÛÞ9ׂX°|&T~i¼¨ÿ¬ø?8DøûÖcºæ»Ùª}zL=}*±Vö30¿/ ¢ ^çÃ>ÆÍΪzÛïy3k¶ÏNjF@ÞGؘ¾SQ’…ÉKŸÇ}µoܾôq”z_a¢d‡”½zCý_mE­ûýW`[ÿÔ`- ¢ŒaC•ìö†83JcÙ5›òaÇÙ ‹µ^°AƒôOU%Ygƒâ¾†™»OqǏ ÒǸ¬ùce`Áð!cB2BwŒÄÏÒ܏›¸«ªoÄâM^q4@=\Coq÷”ðå:æ™Æ ³ââˆÌ NÖ8ÖÖåªû©cH§îxí kY“²(Õf^ÍäZò&8§?3àØçá²ÄCð]sôþ®^É2@šó 9¯ëÍ å®]+ÓôöeaÙìºøã®¼Z~Ï/L£n3酕úá+Ôûy×v»ñÊóºÚ¿ò—ºy—{%qŒ4\.ª?qÞì/Wc]G‰óÚóPñ{ìC4b}¸#¾±÷כ}eÖTó\UÝcɗaœéès†õ5²Ü½×Ýy+yX_NÕ&üó?ÆȖendstream endobj 7 0 obj 3288 endobj 15 0 obj <> stream xœWM—ÛF¼ëWô-Î{cšýIö^ö9v6q6v{ürñ…#Q#&”(“ÔLæßoš”4¶7N¬j B¡}Vy¦UÎ?Óçr»ø¼Ð¹º]hÕ,ò¬T?-ti}Kå cVm:z“Y«|iK~êXÚL{>»,Êä1Ï<-´ÉŒS˅ÑÎÞÀ—QíB…ÝAG“…ôÂÙ¬4xbߔÖÒ{È­Î £ti"½‡<ϳ¨4NùÈOÜá±Ä÷ÞzØÁAÌm–—ÃÄ2‹V•ÞgZG>ãÒR•ÆfEŽ ,ÂÖ.ʳ†%?Qã^”:3%ð7…Æå¢×¼/B鉛‹7óª](WÄ@xLë#|©8e|t$’ @%È%:8íL,2ñ™£ª(²3¸ \ è2g&:j܀¸É«‚\Ô̌NµwYQ*À^Zœ$›=Šh·»ÁYXø—á„#‚`¢Ãž©GòF³0ED”€"Ê)»%2"ä¨ó* ExŽÈ›•2$¯1º”&3ȼh,èO~[Ð ‹Ì=ÙjŠ,8ÏH-_ŒÒøÜ¤ÞÀÌj VÎÚù€kƒ¼°9ñ‘g2ëH.0· SYï¢0­ì³Ž$0ÐM8ésøâ-ÚÃ#®4š_hSÆ,’ÀŒÑtE¦ðœ)䬉+ĬÃs^è̲f4ò9Ê3rˍKUg †Î£¬{aS#°AͰpÚ {g”-ЋF8ÍÓ¡P6PYàD x ¤ˆÉñŒœÑì@œqFpȖôPòvDD£Ý‰7.X1’XAá)Јe*ÚÁD‹H. o&æÉ»†à`t¢RÖ¯ÍñN³—­ Ò VSÞ;*%ÀŒ([H*ÕѺBº !GýaÐþà·õ@ÛàDYæ0ƒ! @‹¶%PPϲ9²8°omžTœñø,¬¼AIÑLβ@L À"ºL3öPRZœñ"„ßjÁ"jŽ «! žšÞ¬4‹¤»-ôÜ—Ø `<*a#‚&*ðO´œ;8€g¡±T¸°l‘AŽ14㲢Ń̞¢ÐÒ..i–è4*éÙpH5½Tː)bh¼´ºRl™ÞgEl¬q‘ˆöjÁb.”ba .āRè&>ÁκR©Ø|ä´0a†-°ŽÆ'­l9.EÅÁ4Í.A̚,Æ3„€1CUE+ †Š;eЁ‚”‰R?4>umjò:¹D»;*oˋѶÈÉ@“JPè-lª…È–\`°6Σe¡d¡pVàÎ5‡»£ÚD’™ÚSs‚¦DÑqô‰ ŒVТæ6¢ÉU‹Ð JŒU”R³´<ƒïØÅFK_ãY¥ 6ØCµ“šºBPu|Çñ A…X\7 "m”q” SEÀAÒò ¥‚bƒRy¢ ù5"EæÌc\PÓ z 2¦ñœOøy¦‹€¼Ñ˜€Až€JÃ*!“ÉÀY6ʤ€ñr©'ôh/nª e29–"Ps‚“+8yiàlãLƒN²Ì!©ÓàX<–Ò21Š/Œ+=©¹ééÓåØS@yLO”q…Ÿ:Ak,#üÔÖ*Ìx/9ã¸LÉè£e•p¼"§TjJ%MÚKX#Vr”c `ô%}^˜|˜ªÙke°ú…aߗ" š– u³.ë%>µá(LIÑÃeÈJGç‘i9ÃÄùÆÈÔÖ…±BF˜ P]¤Bðð,-j1’Žb ÌȀ×ìQähcâ E¤ ø”»ã`áH´Rj°^“§:È.‡½4—‚CØ'µ²kGА:ç è¨m™…žèÂydªÅ룬hA'ç .|· ‡!$XÄYHõYsÆ:MýávÌç2qÌ¡·¤«-uãàÖT&Þˆ 8҄tàÖÒZÂXþ®à")BÒŽÀV£|›vbôJä(19:Bso-Ä˜sáî¡Eׅ£‰µØ`„Te:ÙRkYX(„Öhý‚²ð¿{n9~õ—+þçþ* Pª¯ñõg¬ÓòKiúXnÕ—‹ï#_\®égEZÜÛ!(—ÛųÍ8îÿõâÅ/_¿ù½{ó*{óN}ù6\®Ï>|üýýoT¯~ûøþRýöõæÝë7/åL1Ÿù½º®•QÝZY±~ñæéÞç4õ\ˍV÷õ¾ëG5®¶Í8Ö+uu§ÆM­^C3ŒÕnT¿VWÝ¡W¯ºí¶ÁËnW÷â^/EHM»ÜT½ÚWÃûj§šÝX÷ÍVuýªîÕª¢[þˆ/°ü_Ð_ãžï¿[<«Ú¶»mv×riýîäòۭšw1‹[ä3ÀïJu´TëjÙ´ø/ÇNœà8̵›¶UëC/çꛪ=Tâ…Æ•Z7»ªUC=Žm½­‘Z3¤ú¾¹AŒÍÕ»®úUŠpì2¥^^_÷M}sf¨šUÊL—}µªÕǯZ7-¿jnšV½?´µz7bÄT˜¿ºª×]_‹ñ$Û&¿V(BàûŸªÃ‘«Ÿ›ë GBå_´uÕïà2£ ±Gxäs޹ž1jÕ ,_½:%qÛ7£˜îëQÀžîxœM¥þäٗû} %!ä‘ò éöSN¯‘:i¢~¨wË |þpwŸ X@Ñéøy~¡n7͔~ýOµmv3P¹¸ã|¾Ï¨‰iSAhý$G£„m´ûûzª™lãðïW‰€«¦¯—㙃 ´-Úäù[R|¼•Týù öÕÝm¯ê]½¦#šÍIܾZŽª•ê×àjÏX@ÆC‹Îª·û¶»«ë`þq¨ÆJ¤èá)JJ(8JÕã+¸GX•0£!V 6¯ýô½’~®Éû·¸âæ?€z¯6Ýa…¾¾»8’nÙvCÝ&7ýÁ¤(ºè> LÿmŸ©×Ù3ôRÕßVíÉ!o`—xè{ö¸núaâ€R=?+OvÊÄ͙ÂÝ®½Sû´7€yhOª²ôZ%¡A¸ÝÔR¢S:¼8‘mâÄ"Áè¯ ±nª+0RãNDdFçd<Çäµ΅Tí®“&­€ˆ¦}Y‡oh£°Côð ٛ%¯ÿ}‚ÐϾ‘3C¤Ö}·•¶c­ÚAíÛj)´"KSÚWÕÐH<÷|Ð^èZn=:D¦#@w[òñ,5PÊ'öè‚ÛfÜþöxÛ6,ÕÈÄÜ,ÿÈ„»J*0Uòó4޲ŗ·]ÿ÷ V(þù\|b¾4ôl©pjh¶ ªzlL—@mÀNM·’’£cj”«Z’X}s&«û =ÝßFd™—ihM+Ín”ægŒî›/ véÍ¿wi—œDD¦²—YÜ Í¤þËö°še•_'d¿ÔIœ£K2`%:U7¬¬&Ãpàßê°[ÕGé>› 5Œ5& ×Ëiò›®>ö¿ ïê0nºž í?=…´Òs˜1;)ÄQLQ% —DÚûYN!O7~kµÿî´ÓËÞ|jÖ¹›‘ ܏÷#ÚÞۑïGû¾»8\ŒþkÑSC€V¦f=)ÀÙbÖw{ 4Ö't³y´m¹Aœ©Ç-¡—wÝxVFv`žA\¶U³}if%›ð|í™v¥%¤™–ºãž°ì¶ <ƒ»PMVg_že˺:«þÈWgcÂ‰ Dcâe:YÍÙÃÉ6£*?}Ne˜Z\?$[­×–1”l¼­‰<Þ`wç öƒy=ƒF:\̸Oïnšúö$s4ÐåÝò!UB”› Cáâ֕"«P¨f÷ùÐôw'2Š.5*j~3WôIŽp"Uª=ôòÛåXF¬¹Hú¡&á6u;©ÝQ°æ@dÝrY%M—fr§¾H/c'Õ2xâa°0þñRý±àŸÿpÞùendstream endobj 16 0 obj 3435 endobj 19 0 obj <> stream xœWMwÛF¼óWÌmå÷ó=“›£då%N֖7] r$"!  ÅտߪB¦ã=¬ü"àtOwuuuë“j­Zþ;.·‹O ݪÓB«~Ñ6Iý¸ÐÉú&'å£Ç1«¶ ½i¬U>ÙÄO“m´ç³kÚ¬L›ÛÆÓB›Æ8µ\mà,à |µYèî :›&ÔÎ6ÉàMÈM|“¬¥÷ÐZÝD£t2™ÞCÛ¶MVšÎ£S>ówdxLøÞ[;8È­mڄ0LNM¶*yßhùŒK“JÆ6±EPak© M̚.Bã`Áø³Ásô *!Fz§cӊAŠM0p8`¼JÙ6ÞãÙ#ßWÈ"žƒn¼X O¬BëpTÅq"hÝ$«"‚2ßû˜£a‹mùƤÆ|Âå°p&4)Â"5ºµ5 ;pÂ#OÛQÖ!Z¥Qµ6*m¯Äyâ“q~½0g¦óÀÎeÔØ$Ý6V+"0±Ê$ÿù`š|c -?Qãœ^$ݘüMÔ8¢\öš÷ãEHž¸¹Œq3 ÚQ¹˜á1×gøˆ©8e|v$’ @%È%:8íLŽølQUÙ\®‹@tj™‰Î7 nò*’‹š™Ñ©ö®‰IéöÒÂà$ÙìQDƒ¸-Ø Î·¸ 'îðL=“7š…‰QŠ,W¤ì"JdDhQæ• EG ò ðáLcÉÆãt*Kã]Æ£•}aáA݄“¾…/Þ¢­1<â’ÑüB›”›LfG0FÓ™ÂsV\¤Ð²&.1 ˆX‡ç6êÆ²f4ó9Ë3rk«Ug †n³¬{aS#°AͰpÚ {g”èE#œæé• T8т)bZ<#g4;gœ²‰ogQ@Dô7j؝xã‚#‰ÐýHQ¦àÐ&[Ô@rÉèlx3¹­Þ5$³•²~m‹wš½l]V°šò†ØQ)‰fDÙBR©ŽÖEé2X„õ‡E@ûƒßÖmƒ)µ0ƒ! @‹¶%PPϲ9²8°omÛTœñøŒVÞ ¤h&gY &‹`]£{H”g¼ˆá·@°ˆšCcÃêJ¨§¦7+ Ç¢én } ÷%6ÃX J، ‰ üS#-çàYh,Ž– ä@3.k!Z<Ȭá =,éâªf‰N#¡Dφ@ªé¥Z†LCã¥ÅÐ%bË ðÆ8+bcËD̰W#kˆ¹ÄÂ@\ˆ¥ÐM|‚uI©Ø|ä´0a†-°ŽÆW­l-.EÅÁ4Í.A̚,Æ3„€1CUE+#Cŝ2è@AÊd©ŸºŠ¶5¢¼Î@.ÑîŽÊ»áÅh[äd I‰„Cz ‡êd!²%¬Íó(@Y(Y(œ¸[Íáî¨6™d¦väڜ ¤I¨‚#:Ž>1Ñ ZÔÜf´ ¹jz¤dÉLQE)5KË3øŽ]l´ô5ž5q@Q"µÁ& ÔNjê¢ êøŽâ‚ ±Š\7 "m”q– "à iù„RA±A©àïžÓ¢Å_=ƵŠÿù€_¥Æ‚¯?a–¿”ÎË­úîvñæ}æ‹Û‡Eý3Š"­"÷vÊívqµ>öß¾yóóÇïo>4ïn®››wêÕíŸØHhp»Z\}øøûû~ýA]ÿöñý­úíŸêæÝ÷7oåLœÏüÞ=eÕð€_üæÍ{˜×{¿ ©o´ÜhåpùϾ¬úC?§Í³êeÄï‡a\õ»G5ì÷Ãx8îúó: ê~8¬Õ¾}™%Îáúö—ÅÕíz8>®_«Ãº¨MéÆ]Y©ð°)êçã ñ¬»Iýãú€[Vý´&œ@ˆ4xõÅÕiìj_ e§ºÝJõ;õԗÓ|è¡[ð?ÝAž¶Ý‘Òë});q±,Þ?ˉ_ºûá8ªëa»í§ NËXÃû¾êù¬¾+»åºZò®p±*ã8Œ¼}U–½ @«©Û£mA “HK¸>òòAäO¹e)9/þÚo6 aö ö0UûqØ#xÚwÇÃz€ÇgÀy#_OåpØ ’ê‘~˜ó}AIª!u9^[»Ã8<•qz® ¾ø¤»‡± ¥û« )€ÖoU7ŽÝî±lËî .öe'‰>ô»n#yOU˜Ž€©>sØ ›ú±»ßÔ(ž\¾èÀ7ÊeQӏÜß]øD`ïÅá\p€a}NböÌ 4r*ܽRòS;”µ:­ûd:\:£ÿrŸ°‡¯³¢£ï~úáõÇ0þÅÌÞNÓ°ì;bþZýԍ«S7Jè¿1ÊIý{ª·ܝýÝ´îâÄkuw…QâV®¯U°-Ãz¸XزBjýŸÃ#}Ê\Ü#{ê–T6›áĂ ¶ËÍQ8‡ŒîëT@ ݔ§nwø–ïïîZcñ cçò÷ÍÆÝ®¶ÞñPÔ©dcyDšs,‡ç}aZҍÀ¤’i6`§Q*¤«Ï}v½îËÃÜm´½ì8 r”Çns÷ª9—kI}¨¬þ½7}'4¤Z“Yðµé§5în³ñ7Õ? ïÕô$Á̔ޤ¹´Îb AýÈ.ÙÉug4»={qDÕÁ\¨Ç¤Ž»Âþpîa¨æY~®çHhvÎöîê}y‹[ÑÏ@þE&ÈúfŪ® L‘J¦")ѳ³ύJÃ/û®\B_g Ô8ë+f‹²:n>Šÿ«:3ž¼ÁÌÙö°êùK /a“ŒW`§X‚"_!7](þ¨¦ê²Ú± È\ɑ>Îã—Èî,ÿ¸¾çs›€d»e¿ izþvdü_# ê—=wŽø«¾û¢ç*HõR´Ç4Ð -ß¡Æß]©¾Ww¯î®žø«ck~¥Ô'VêüóGÕWÆ2í‘åÃíóE‚E©¸õ«ÝmàÕpExQí³£ Lœz–yžêͧ®v͟GTQNÂÛyá@ûŸéÓo÷Çǝ°“ÉKãÌ5Ä *ãS™õKx]ÀC’êµê–˺ì h'0d¡Ã? §òĕá4ÏôË­â+ûÜ¥Ÿe}ìú‹}¤Ž <œºÚ•(ýXöÀèÕ¦„5fÞ4 òpϸëWÛnõÂ5ÿ )æK8¸¿TX¶5vª±Ϋwi40~ÍÝ`ØV‘§þI<ËÒïÏr²~šb…»è]QÎÿsG¬Ú'á_ÿ©Æ±î°1±ÂØBÄ$ Ø3T²ù”yß:ËÈrÓa}ÁƒÜ2wþÅFú¶ø²#T?QVµiy”ÖQ·¦`ô~_Ð¥ubŸÉÖq—.x7™éÀ»øƒ#?ܪ-øï¿gÎendstream endobj 20 0 obj 3213 endobj 5 0 obj <> /Contents 6 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj <> /Contents 15 0 R >> endobj 18 0 obj <> /Contents 19 0 R >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 5 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R ] /Count 3 >> endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>endobj xref 0 22 0000000000 65535 f 0000010748 00000 n 0000013133 00000 n 0000010675 00000 n 0000010796 00000 n 0000010227 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000003373 00000 n 0000011004 00000 n 0000011066 00000 n 0000012072 00000 n 0000012130 00000 n 0000010851 00000 n 0000010881 00000 n 0000010387 00000 n 0000003393 00000 n 0000006900 00000 n 0000010922 00000 n 0000010531 00000 n 0000006921 00000 n 0000010206 00000 n 0000010963 00000 n trailer << /Size 22 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R >> startxref 13183 %%EOF