MAHBOOB DEEPAK vs. NAGAR PANCHAYAT GAJRAULA

PDF
C.A. No.-005875-005875 - 2007Supreme Court13 December 2007Bench: S.B. SINHA G.S. SINGHVI2 pages
For Petitioner: DEBASIS MISRAFor Respondent: K. L. JANJANI

No AI summary yet for this case.

Ø1%PDF-1.2 %Ç쏢 6 0 obj <> stream xœmXMWI¼ëWÔi¿g]ßU¾ylÖÃ<XÀ{ò¥‘©=’ZÓjÁ²¿~#²%ö˜gäê®ÊÈÈȒÿR•6ªâÏþsºšü59½öj¾˜J=NŒj'•ÎêóÄdtÉ*¤€ÝN­&¦«S!»ÌOS²Ó&píuU”­J¥O«­WӉ5Æ"žÀ–UˉIÉÃu4Åê8>ðNg‹'±èù$;Gë±rF'«L¶…ÖcUUº(CãÉ«Pø 3ÞpJåt•†-Y§rژÂ5œf•­Ó©BPa ¹Š:CQ{œ`üÅbƒÊˆƒ7IWr 'í2xl°AåâtXä[ÁE´€,arIb+­*ŨmŽhŒÎN%e=އT´58‹«øÄfí£Š!Ã9NxuN8‘µ©Ü˜‚†ìÈÓÀ;ªSyD   ªV%e¬§Kì'>û±`úì|Am6•vFù˜€‰S6‡ã`Úƒv–'2?QãRd£mþ6lQ¾Cÿxs n¾ dxæT;)ŸJ$<6Á}ä‘ŠW6O"ùT¢81ÑhoKÒb³BUQdoá \ 6˜\1S < nò*‘‹†™Ñ¨ ^§¬L{yÂb'ÙPD‹¸Ø ÎâD¨à ;<=|¦^Èä‚(E)û„Y+T„yeËF1 낼Y)KòZk²4™EæY q ?ùí@$h2d«M:פ–…-FiCeIÒ`qÌZ¬Šµ n£'&"R¨XŸĬúJF;Ö €®‹¬‘[eýXUp–`˜ªÀƳ§65[Ô §-²÷V¹„^´ÂiîŽI¹He#h`I[aœÑì@œqpÈeZÈô΢€ˆèoÔ ²;ñÄG'‡$VP8B#@ ô"E™2€C;ØâPÉ¥ ³a͖j´n ØX¼¨”s°ë*<3ìe磴‚3”7ĎJI8F”$•êè|’.ÉX¡þ8Ñþà· @ÛbGÎŽAˆ EÛ(¨@`ِû›eG%\AÐDö©‘Žs°K…“€å’†cÆåD‹™5,D¡‡#]ü¨Y¢ÓH(Ó²åj©–%Sä  ÒbèH±cxb½±qÖ"fÙ«‰5Ä\ÈrÂB\ˆ¥ÐM\áœóY–Tl.9-l<ÀYGF­lœ¢â`ša— fCc !`ÌPUÑÊÄPáS(@™"õCãSWÑ6 F’'ÐÈ%ÚÝSy—tŒ¶ENš”I8@¡w8ƒàP"Dväƒuå0 PJ çîÊp¸{ªM!™©elNÒfTÁO›˜Àh#jî Z\u=Q²€d¡¨¢”†¥å¼c[#}µ!(J¢6¸Œ!‚ÚIM}T=Ÿ±@ÜCP!V‰× K#‘ˆ@›#åB\dÂ$ 8HZ®P*(¶µ(U ʐ_+RaÖ゚žh1ʘƺÚã˜NDäÆ †ðDT¦P ™L>¦Â²á L* ˜ N¡G{ñ–A¡ŠF&“g)"5!xqÁ±H§‘³3 :É2ÇQ}¼—ÐÀb1K˔"¶0NœôX¡j$r3Ц¯pOå1eQ† ?u¾€:Ö¸ŒðÓ$\«0w`¼äŒãeJ\ Œ‘«„§‹ŠRi(•\Úñ^Á°ÌQŽ1€Ñ7ê3ðÂäÃTMd¯“ÁiO†}ŸE O‚6Î#ÌF¸\/¡ðcëŽdG‘ͱ¼ 9éò¼0-o™8ŸX™Ú¦ 0NȈcCE©<¬¥EæÑhƒ£X³2à {9:Oã˜xÂGÑiC¾ÏÝs°p$:)5XoÈSå.‡{i%á0ª}‘[±ñ ©s΀ŽÆE™YèI€Î!̑G† Zœ±¡Èõ-èe⥑kpËr’ArqÒòÚl8c¡þðvÌu9æÑ[ÒՎºŽqð֔G‹ÁŠ øÇ éÁc¤1Œ„uü^Á‹d\¤IS8"[òÝx'F¯Ž[¡# ï­ÙKŒï ¼{ÑuáèÈZÜ`„Tyܹ¤Ö²°PcÐú‰²pƒï=“ ßz¬¯ÿ†ˆ_ ¥ú¯ÿÂuZ¾0í?¦+õÛ-¾8>¸½ŸŒß¦(Ò*ñÞA¹]MNðyzúÇ·Oç7úâü£>¿PonàF·³ÉÉÍ·«ë³¯gêãå·ë[uù/u~ñéüƒìI‡=Wõ¼íî^99}zã£ßw4õŽ¥—ØüñÃ͙º¸Ôï¹ûn¿LN>l6M½TßO¦íC»üþFá+-4úÍ?1®dßÕÙíùíùåÅÙõ{<ÜþZ/îºîN}jšMýçqóõÙÍÕåŧ³‹Û›/êyÝ««z=]ÔOõ >×?úz·¬Õ?ԇu¯§?}¸=cº€æóWÚsO=ÝtòÛÙÅÇß_¾Ñ¿iuÓ®4õYßÈb¾xh&ŸMOý¡¾©Oê³úª€‰º¥áï'úv‹³ªÛ „àæËùT.:ÆÒˆKøþû‰ê+÷oÕLãÄh%¾4õC£æ}½š™>º¶û÷Ä~¹Ä[õXoU½Ùt-w*.Ô¬n—Ox1ozÕ­ñ oV»uÓ×C‹%â §ë­¶Õé;µÁ¦Yý¤ÚµÚ6ýC;m¶ÜÖ7ÛM·ž5ð‚$ȕ5æ N˜}hB¥~oT»UÛº‰Å¡S F}×4k˜{è–ˆvïÛ5Jׂ+mß7s®o‡¶ÙÒ \>6}3ZjúÎ0!Æ¿ž©û¾[A¶FßeôÝ×í–)ÓÙl·zz˜µÛÍnÍL;`²ž±*ôYüâ !ßÁÐ>¦ÿÑÚ=œc{ß4j…ó A‚ÈÐâÀ<š;"…`n¹$ £GYê26fq÷$G®€h+ñÐØåý=Î÷o՗ú®Ûõê#~ ċq֏u?CaxÚUÃxhVwÜ‘—û‚àß Êä­<= ¸/øËªòuýŠ>÷ݏX´Ëe3¯—°O›çã†YÛ7SFò^¸þ½²¿ªÂO1È@i¼žu’ðpÌ¡Ym–ÝS3x#À~m^6¿Úžv /ZõŸ„[Pmõr)g¤BÍv¨ï–ív1r‚æ7Ýv8ÐtÎvþŠâÝrvÈ\Hč~õ꾞¶Kü…ªëÕ¦~Z‘æûƒÜ¸jg³eÃöh»-@.(P?g%ãzÙ៏-êÃs‹vºP8,äê%9ŸƒØÛ.ºB»!Ù €š˜ú£èHü–Ø“&»åÀ¡NM$öÉôM½í„ûº.›º_¡WDÛKÇßÒí…vº½´Ì¿·¨€lx«ÝcóÀs ñèðà­]mvsºû±›Í¿£·M½ÝŽÝϝhxd?´Ržûvyì‰"ƒÊ4‚ÖkgÍk~lZ ¨ÌëÈÄóQu _˜‚ÒÛf j÷beS÷¬õ[uN5Úë5áèþÝ3Q…ò,^)ª”XTQ~\"Ãwçççj &Ì»þI8_ Ywª†R´£„¯Ü3Ú>î¥Z£Þ«z¶çÅ®oðx ˆ¬ëkx¸.[>¢bÃ4?Ægõ>©¿Ëg*t[wà }æÞcŽsU‚{RÓ缞ã=¨ß~ÌHàá%úˆ|ÑõÛ±®»%zKŽ1åc’ˆÍÁh¨”©#l÷ÃnÝO‡.dEYjTI$­]‰ÄPá›õögm#*¤ç½(^B¡É³Ýt™Ñœ©ÄÝÏÞóõ¡þ¹kxhêY;b û$k?Θ_Ä·ç+A[´œÿÏ"3LXv쒾¹Gt"§Sj»ÝˆÞë‘)õx•ԞРú´9´Ûqø@þíû¯é÷#ë5Ç*“°V›ÿ¶ 'µyìú?Ÿùö¸hÄg?¶ x/¯‡_Ì?·ÐÙ­ú÷„?ÿÖÌ endstream endobj 7 0 obj 3143 endobj 15 0 obj <> stream xœ•XM—ÛÆ¼óWÌ-ò{4„ùÀcŸ6’“lbˎ´>E9€äp (\fóëSÕìre%ïÅ¢˜éé®®®nø³Ê3­rþ=ÿn«Ï+«ËJ«f•g•úóJW¶ÈB¥Š²À6«Ž+ “Y«ŠÊVüÕ¡²™.¸vY”ÉCž<¡MfœÚ®Œ60æñ¶ŒjWº,îô:˜Ì§Îf•Á2ïù¤²–Ö}nuV¥+hÝçyž¥i¼tªüÅ+¼/ls0r›åÜ0¡Ê‚UUQdZ®qi¥*c³2‡SnkUî³2hšð™Ã ú ÖeA§*øˆƒ…Óe–ˁªÌl…L¡ª`³¢Àº@¼9®ð•X{rAÄÊç[Ué}fJìðZg•U%œ2ï‹2dFㄇ/6çSeÎ+_T¸'œñYUâD•éܦ0à4îÀŽqj܎ìäÞ(¬å¥ÒÆñJì'>û+ã±`ºع€›Jç™ÕÊù˜Xeªây 0MðEf OTüEŽCHxPéÌTÀߔ[” …æýxૂ¸¹—q3· Û¥reð„Ç”¸>ÀFéŠS¦ŽDr¨x¹D{G  e&6 Iv—kà"PÁ]åŒDà7yU’‹š‘Ѩ.\VVJ{°—' v’Í’hà·»ÁYœ(r\†Ž‚‰w =7š‰)¼A® (ٕH‘>GFWeX(ºÄ: nfʐ¼ÆèJŠÌ òJ ± ?ùmAh,"/ÈVSfØÀxFjØ¢—¦È IZ³Z‚•3w…ǵ^؜ž{{2ëH.0· R™šÂaCUE+KºŠ;¥Ñ‚($(|ê*ÊÔ(å tr‰rwTޖ£l“&U$ Ð[œsÈN"[rÎÚ°´¤…’…ÄY;×lîŽjHfjGHÅ Bš YpDÇÑ&:0JA‹šÛ€$W-\/)Y@2PT‘JÍÔrÞ±Š–ºÆZ$¥¤6Ø M¹“œºRPu|ÆqA…X•7 x"mö”qSEÀAÒr…TA±Aª ¢ ù5"Eæ¬@» ¦—´è¥McÏø '<âFaMx<2 SȄt&çS`ÚpP:L!—„åÅ)ƒBåµt&ÇTxj\prÛ"/õìmìiÐI¦Ù'õq\B‹ÅJJ&±…vb¥ÆU£$7 Út9æP]¦ ʸƒÂO ›5†þêcú,‚—ìq¦ä TœÑ2J8^‘S*5¥’K“æֈ€Ulåhh}IŸ:ºjIöZi,žöDaX÷•ƒæIÐÆ:¸€Þ—ñ ŸJ‡p”&‰¤hŽá0d¥"ÈóÀ°œaà|b¤kë€ÄX!#Ž iP]„Bð°–µèGÉ[±8f¤ÁkÖ(b´ŽÆÑñ„¢ R†p|ŽÝ±±°%ZI5X¯ÉSíe–Ã\šËÁ&\$µ2kGÐ:û 設—ž…šèlÂlyd²Å[P‚Nö—¹· ›!$'0ˆ3‘†c³ftšúÃé˜ë*qÌ¡¶¤ª-ucàÔT%‹…Aq…Oҁ?ZKahcù]ÁA 2.R„ )ž¥Fùò6ÍĨ•ÀVbrT„æÜZ9ñ1ç ÂÙC‹® Gk1Á©ª´³¥Ö2±P­Qú%eá¾{.«_=ÆåŠÿ”(5D¼þŒqZ¾”æŸíQýñnõú}àƒ»ý*}FQ¤Uɹ‚rw\½:LÓé»×¯ÿúëÛÛÙ»Û7Ùí;õÍÝo˜Hxàn·zõá×_ÞÿðÓêÍÏ¿¾¿S?ÿIݾ{{{#{ÊeÏ/õ}TFõ{eåôë÷8žîý‚¦¾Õr£•ÍlFՌj׌§Øq§.Ít?úó¤êîQuýÔl£ê±kw?®^õ§S?L箙y×!ÖCÓݯU|ˆNtß±‹—ºåËoþ°zUcÓMÇØMªéÔ¶ïÆ¾«;؝z5ð‡ãˆûv²ïwÍÔ` ¼8<Ò!Õ´m¼¯ÛL©;æ‘Sœä:ÔÛÔÐܦå†S?" =.Rµj›c3ÅÝ|rhú]öñ#H¬‰ "t°Í¿~3õá<Äñ þv>"̵jm‡ÃÛþ ÈZú—âW{ Ä»ø¤mënZ#ZÞ»3ruÛÔk5ž7p€L‡nrlŒÃ°– _˜Q—8T›¨Žõn‰x8ÖAIQM‡!âußM‡q-çÿ‚øÕ›þ2õÐÄËâà¾ÞN)‚ËAÁ¥‘I£½Ë)56Ó¹æÕ’—ME$ˆ§õm'd#"&çá>îÖDgqpœêé<õÃ#Jíó¹"÷ »5]M&ÐÉхSº=Qìxj›™ð ®úR»%´_òfGp~ÞïabP#J¢Ý1xâ.£¡b&ÊÝ Àª®}ÒD‰D„©ï?ñA¿ð—Æ!ù/¬=¬4œ?6#Ëâ¼½Nææñ ¢ ±éàÍÝîŸ)uÅ #œŸo¹@噋Xû¦{èÛli^û†õÚ ¤›aˆ÷$ê-‚iµÚE²„Ááõiè·1 r´3çi7ßMS d£‘ëëûºéP–‡æ—oxë®Ù&®H ›ˆÔÆõâT=~Â+æÖ~ƒ(àd"ÇîLgÔ%‹Ù0+1Ê¡çð•Ÿôá¼=ü~¬IzŒÈȁY2žé} …vÏĉt‘Ú¿«¥\/ýðIí΢µJ’Âçhb©"KÜ&X„Èu“Ìííú¥DKQƙˆÀó¡-ü·â»·¼ÿ5û%KÙ9Æi`ŠÞBÎÏð¸Ù²¸nëZñÈ'hóö jÊúO)~húö •iÖTqòé~0–] ßBC6”+*øª6gѰþ•K=c¦çœ¡¤C¸ ê[£°Uw>n’O»¸M®©NOeH°à¥È—òƒéµØ;ô¨Å°¦'54á÷·u ½IQÍ5P^•'óÙ£?\ ¨P¬ä6>°n¨ »˜Øñœ£c|Y­ÒʆøüÇÇWÍÇoÄöåEþ Û§åøUÛJúr%^疕Óì)zë'j v/„éûå¦ù*!D"×LI/îž÷¥‹Gü#ªø¯fLÒÿ™Dö¶ß?õZzHƗC°Üo&T&ŽŒý1ÎâáWÿ(¹˜eƒÜ]:üua]u–¥“1§sFª9#ïãx‚ Í]½V?öHŸº9ƒd–ǹ·?/‡Zºö(ݓžD0ŸÙ½ïA.ñ°žábë‹T̞½ë_Ì3Í¥W‰…/<|“ö}Ûö—%ïқ_-Ÿ¢ú‡s“ /wÞ ×ÊM_ãSëc1ÊI–ZݎI£Ø20ùœ¹΍ÛC$Þkc¹üÝD¤ò“å­ãºê®Õ|ý$Zsºý1ÖÝÜ€äËi’8¯óÒ×ÿ-ê)ð$ù½9ÚÇÅ™½áUƒà$JVOšÿ²q'êCϒ¿÷Ä6!½¯Ð~?êÎ#͏õ†¯ç®AÍî©í4‚©|¦û³LHØRiç°HÈ ÃÇ· nuïÉ! ðÙüÕÉmV·¤z”ÇßG Îe@Kb³ß£3~ñ<•ÿw÷þZç–*ÝÂ{ØÍó·ÀFº›©MS/Å·[Œùk5=ÿç©^jÈ|;F]@ƒ¶eS"q¾ºúESN®âDʅI¸™¦|ÎöOsí¢ ÊZN½OØÚ:²Ã˜dÖºnïòÝ)ƒ&ô…¿ý”t!QˆmW3øÂ$ég~]p̊S=<> i &ˆùPn?Õ»ÃcÁGð5w³c«ìÉý‡LÝ ÍæpÞÔÝZ™> stream xœE—ËŽœ·…÷ýÜ‘‹bïÙ%¶(HdGï¼H-Ïs‘fÚPòöùNýbÙj“MÖåÔ©SìO©dKE¾|¾»?}:YIŸO–nO%¯ô·“­Úó^©ÏαšîO¶»çZS_uéÓöªÙºÖ-—¼ì’»n˜goéÝÉÍ16ØÁ–§»“ÍÙð9l{ÇF«y9;cç1´³j•õQªåéɖoY¥”¼“Éøl©o}âccqñ}¯{Ø¥æ²Ã÷Ê»¦Õ{6ÛZãt¥å5ÏBP•°Í1±ÊÈs›LŒÜ¸¡ø·³ž]A-bäbo6s‰ k溸Ð8à=­]sï¬;ù\ ²ÉzXîqƒ$º°¥q4Í1²ON ³¼jšåïûÜٍƒXjю¯ÜF}áœÍG^“+[©GNtò4¼SÒˆ Œª•™Ì›\r^ølÎߜ|p0[»¶©±/+¹Zjc‚IM¾úÿ׀é{ô\]7–>©ñÞ€ÄÆ²ì ü}GRÛÝ䟍±ºpk›ñ¬#T{¦6÷<>q¿±1©´ä}7© PáÄFÐÍ÷Ìa³PUŠÜgp .‚ lebÛð@ÜâÕM™É¨õ–çJ6`¯n8'ÅæN¸+솳ÜègœhB&6|t¥¾ÅSaæ&J ØáB r›”È b*¢¼–«Ql²Þä­J¹Èën+šÌÉ|4ú‹ßú“ W2ïb«Ï<ÀãYÔrl)JïÅEÒî\€Yw«¨v}àvÄF-J¤"grm"ŒÇ ªÒô¶ƒñ´rϓM`ÐMœì[òbÕ]GÚrÓækç-f€#Œ1™St®†‰A E5iKa °Žu™–«j [ëkr+ގªÂYaeÀÖÔӄ-`§fœv²ožê¤=8­Óc¦:¤,±@ƒåE¼°&gšÄç†CuÉ’w"ÒßÔ`¨;Ùi£Æ¥ˆ 4RÐDJ™ÀѾ+5ˆ\65ßå°nHw •ª»µ°gêåÚF´B5ɱS©ˆ€kB¹"©RÇÚft7F¡þÜ´?ü®´k®!D„´´­€BºÊÖÄ⡾­¥*g:Ÿ³Æ%¥™ZU”,  ]6Å>–¤¥y±üÕBE4 j!PO“µ §¢ŽèîŠ>ˆû›«ä©DÝ-T°/¬š;`4Ž ϫΌ3LqՊhé ²Æ2 =ªèÒÍ &¡%Ë® ÕìQ-Sâ¢÷h1º)®Ê€o5ĦzÛBÌÕ«S5d.¬¸áˆ 4(E7iŽÚV,¥ØZjZøø ÛP½Zl§T¦™º„˜M,f(fT5´r*T|Æ ƒ‚Ê쨍/]¥m ÆŒt¹¤Ý›”÷NŽi[rr4i‰p ¡¯Ü!8ª³ƒÈU\P°u”E’EájÀ]LýIm¶È,íØGsBH_T¡ &›L`ZÁBÍë¦ÅÕJèS’’[¢J)M¥Õ¾S»E_³6á@Q¦´¡.†µ‹š¶¨6í©@:#P«©ç†ËÈ"hóü#Ä;&ÌEàiµ¢T(¶;¥êBùõ"„9wƅ4}Êâˆ1ͺ|Á¯+%n ò¦1ÁϠҘ¢1™Ú¦­²q1&¦‡Ó.èi/½2$TÃb25•bHs¡… E9šmšiè¤Ê<õi—hà°¸¢eö[Œ“=¶¥SÜì²Ù ï(ϔéB~éü†:Ö~õx+IÿõÁ_JOg¾þÄs:~)}ùxwŸþruzõvkãêÃéø%‘NSïvåêþôâærùø§W¯þþË÷¯Îo^—_¿Iß\ý›‰.\½?½øù—ŸÞþðÏÒw?þòö*ýø×ôúÍ÷¯ÿgæ×3?]ÿvN5=~à/}óê-׿/´ôÒÂcÃ—›Ûçôþúrþ6}¸¾½»}ø-}¾¹}w“.7çô|}NŸoïîһ맧ÿ¦Û‡Ëùéü|Iéúž¸(Gûéãù)¼áëê§×¿ßçoþxze“þ¹âüõǏç뻄Ëë»»ÇÏç÷éò†®?<>ïÏ—ÛÇvÏÿ¹ðÿ¸¾Ü¤wÏ—gLÈÖw¿?<Ÿï~ýµ¸?§g.>?Ÿù÷½"zË1+ßòÃïÕK¹þá*ýë¤?ÿú;endstream endobj 20 0 obj 2015 endobj 5 0 obj <> /Contents 6 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj <> /Contents 15 0 R >> endobj 18 0 obj <> /Contents 19 0 R >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 5 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R ] /Count 3 >> endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>endobj xref 0 22 0000000000 65535 f 0000009806 00000 n 0000012191 00000 n 0000009733 00000 n 0000009854 00000 n 0000009285 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000003228 00000 n 0000010062 00000 n 0000010124 00000 n 0000011130 00000 n 0000011188 00000 n 0000009909 00000 n 0000009939 00000 n 0000009445 00000 n 0000003248 00000 n 0000007156 00000 n 0000009980 00000 n 0000009589 00000 n 0000007177 00000 n 0000009264 00000 n 0000010021 00000 n trailer << /Size 22 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R >> startxref 12241 %%EOF