B.K.N.PILLAI vs. P.PILLAI

PDF
C.A. No.-007222-007223 - 1999Supreme Court13 December 1999Bench: S.P.Kurdukar R.P.Sethi3 pages

No AI summary yet for this case.

žB%PDF-1.2 %Ç쏢 6 0 obj <> stream xœeW]sÛF|ç¯Øº‡³]%ÁØOìúM–u±.ެ“˜\]_@aƒ €bôpÿýº å$q9ô.wfgzzz–ßUži•óÏô¹Ü̾ÏÞÞ9õØÏt®3­êYžEõÓLG볕/ârX8²XÀ"f:·cwà„Gž·£:¹C´J£jy¡´q¼ç‰OÂùõÌœ˜Î;—PcužY­\(€‰U&ú—5À4)øÌZD~¢Æ)$lD™üM¡qD¹ä5ïÇFˆž¸¹„q3 Ú…rE „Ǹ>ÁGᐊSÆ'G"¹T‚\¢ƒ#ÐΤ"Ÿ9ªŠ";ƒËÀ5p¨à€Ž93ÑIãÄM^ä¢fftª½ËЍt{iap’lö(¢AÜìgaás\†Ž‚‰wx¦žÈÍ QŠ$W¤ì ”È ˆ£"Ì+6Š.°Nț•2$¯1:J“d ú“ßôG‚Æ"sO¶š" ÀÎ3RËÀ£4>7$©70³‚•³v>àÚ 6g"> ò ðáLfÉÆãt*Kã]Æ£•}VÀ‚ tNú¾x‹¶Æðˆ‹Fó mbÊ™ÁMWd ÏYqBΚ¸È0 `Öy¡3˚ÐÄu’5rˍ« Î 'X;ö4¦F`ƒš`á´AöÎ([ pš§C¡l ²À‰4° ¤ˆÉ±FÎhv Î88d#=DÞ΢€ˆèoÔ °;±ã‚#‰ÐýHQ¦àÐ&YÔ@rIèlx3)½kH&'*e-üÚ{š½l]V°šò†ØQ)‰fDÙBR©ŽÖÒe°9ê‹€ö¿­Ú'bÌa!B€mK  že q`ßÚ<¨8ãñYXÙAIÑLβ@L À"ºL3ö)-Îx Âo5€`5‡džÕ#! žšÞ¬4‹¤»-ôÜ—Ø `<*a‚&*ðO´œ;8€µÐX*\X¶È ǘšqY ÑâAf ÏQèaI7j–è4Šôl8¤š^ªeÈ14^Z ])¶Ì;ÆYk\"b†½Z°†˜ Q, ā8P ÝÄ쬋²¤bsÉia¶À:?j `Ëq)*¦iv bÖd1ÖÆ U­,*î”A zP&IýÐøÔU´ ¨QÈtr‰vwTކ£m‘“&EPè-lª“„È–\`°6GÊBÉBá¬ÀkwGµI$3µ#Í Bšˆ*8¢ãè­ EÍmB ’«¡”, ™(ª(¥fiyß±‹–¾ÆZ¥ 6؈!‚ÚIM]!¨:î±@åî8X8­”¬×ä©ò–û4—‡°Õ>É«X;‚†Ô9g@GmƒÌ,ô$@çæÈ#CP-ÎXŸäù€tr¾à£‘kpËp’Ab‡8 iøl֜±€NSø:æ:Žsè-éjK]Ç8øjŠ£GoDPœã„tàÖÒZÂXþ®àC 2.R„¤)­Fù v|£WG‰ÉÑšïÖè$Ɯo¾=´èºptd-^0Bª8žl¨µ,,Bk´~AY¸ÇïžÃ,ǯãrÅ¿>àJu¾þŽç´ü`š>–õ~ŽN‰ó‡ÙøkŠ"­ ¾Û!(óÍìõzvïÞ¾ý篮ﳛëËìúF½™ŋ„óÕìõý¯·wW¿\©ËÏ¿ÞÍÕç¨ë›×r¦8ž¹-+øn”ë·w0ï=‡ ©s-7ÚñðÕüz~ýùæêîÏâäüÓìõûìç󛋻‹ÿ\Ü\¨ÛëOŸ.®ß¼Â”’/Õôßo}†Í×wW÷·Ÿo>\ÝÌßa99¸…ñÝÍÕý¿ñy3yPW7wً£ó+æ€|ú…ö“cmßjóV§”èÿýÕÍåÇ\ßg·ÙÏûnµÿVvgê«ûjX×8Uၓ;l¡‰^BþT•O•zìÊíP­2¥>Ve·:ÏþœY6þ¯+³ßµÛUµÎwMYo‡úáA=ÔMµR¥ê÷õ Tùˆý~xõàCUîvUÓà¦óUõPmWø—Úuåóæ®ÚNñ”„ÂBmJœÚî™ ãß8Ú®ëEÍ-Uo¿î·Ë¡n·ª¯ªoõöQUOõ¸Q6MõX­šg…\Òþ±k÷pA¿j]÷jQÁänêeµ]Vý\Êý‡®†j«T?”CµAš´óSL®ªŽ”Ú5U¹Âa]Ê®R‡²WjÛ ÚO×à‹Åž{ª©z޼?ì;FOÏCW— C”kF(§ø¸s‚zË8ඔœ‰^‰`W øèbJ…ö§dà±UÈuÙv»¶Ã¦xj†ªÛ¨ÀTÆ<˜Ø²ìå~‰hÙî; PÊn¿Ô’9Ÿ­ÎŽ8ОH4u¹h*Þ¿¨Æj1˜,ÌJ@hQœx¼í뮫žÚ%IÕBúøžÄ¥e¹"_¨»~@v+Ú¿ê«eKoU׫=2XPGµ(qÉ*[֏kڏßN MíxâZ{×ö¤Ã‘ÃgrÑf?ìû¢«ªºýR8ªëz¹>ìööP­p¾Ý7t󐜘£P­ƒ_¸Ê‡zX¯ºò !”«MÝ÷ԏ šËý$æDš 8s҉SgýE3_¹óݾcfŠõnÿlþs‡º¨ îöh<.o/‘LϨ^4S2SU-> stream xœm˜ÝwÛÔÅßóWœÅÃmY«¨:úâ>µi/J)I€‡Ë‹bˉŠmÉNÈ{d'¡½tµ‰ä3sföìÙ3æ/—gÞåúsø¹Øœüuâswwâ]’gµûîÄױȚÚUÁ±è6'¾)B£+êXë§oê˜ùBÏ)Ëò&Ï Yø…ä'Áœ•¼ÁWpë_U‰;K߄¬œ_¤˜Õ7e“•¥ÞÔ1Ê{™GŸUÁù:4ò^æyž5ÎËy•\Ñè'w4x¬ù¼ˆv8hò˜å5a„¦Îšèê¢È¼oôÌ¥µ«C̪œ "aû€‹:/³ªñrQf Åßž«BAÕĈa‘|•åfPWY¬1H…«›˜Ïùæ\Q «x.}V˜IªÌG]U–Y¨8QzŸÕÑUŸU“EI,1כPg©teQs9)”Y]aQg>sÍœ(ÈÓs;ÕÉÑ”§jyå|Hº’ó§áüõI(9˜©»ÔPãPû<‹Þ¥²“èB]<>fhÊ"‹Aµ~Rã¦$^Ô> 5ø‡ÊsÄ¥¦ðºŸe]·Ô27ëÕ®\ªšRð„Šë|T‰T’ E“D¤T‚Ji—ø2 èš*3Ÿ9U¥È)p\ƒ‹ Â_çÊÄ7žˆ[¼ªÄE¯ÌäÔ)«jçKØ+‹ÀI±¹ ˆ¸#솳X9—q" A˜˜¸£PêxãU˜ª!J hì BÊ©¢D ʜŠ(¯:¨Q|ÅsCÞªTyCðµ5Y óÚ ‰Ð_üŽÐŸC$óBl UV‚ Î3Q+àKQ†""i0€Yk•«vEɵ¥½ˆ¹)J"/ >Îd1‰\0ž[èT•¦H1žV.² ‹$f0è&N9¾t‹!èHªƒ×>ÔMֈàc¼\‰):ÍEI ¹j’j…À:žóÊgQ5ÐFύ=“[Ò\U8+0|ÞÀ>©§ [Àš°q:} .Vôb0NëtY¹XJYpâ KQ$ä<“3Í⊳C±–‡Z·«(‘þ¦¥º“7©Œfd±Bፀô‘R¦àh‡ÐDj`¹4t6ÞB“ÏÞ=ÀÁ&™JňߘóΫ—c*­¢—¼;•²0ÊI•:ÆTY—aQæÔ‹’ö‡ß±íÀ‰ºÎ1Cˆhi[… *[‹KõmÌs@åLÁÏ*ÚJJ3¥¨)Y@$ºÌ+ö²–´¤P˜XþèBEô Ñτ@=½¼Ek8µ´îŽèƒ¸o± ‚<•ˆ A üK#£æx6[…++VrÌðŠ+FDK•5žÑèE—4k–é4 Õò4¬š…U+ˆ)f k1º)ŽÊ€7!E›R#ĂzµR ™ µYą@”¢›ô„]Lµ=J±õ¨iÊ#l¥êŠYk€-çR*Ó¼º„˜½XÌ3B ˜QUÓÊJ¡r§ :(X@™ÆêGãKWi¨QÙt¹¤Ý“”w­‹i[r hR-€„>bCpT§1"GqAÁÆæ8 (‹$‹ÂEƒ;÷îIjӈÌҎfnNjª„N’O&0­àMÍcC Š«‘Ð+IH6UJéUZá3uqðÖ×<{á@Q*iC¬"ÔÎjš*C5é ¤3±ª´n9)…Ú\JþâÆ&LŠÀ!Òê‰R¡Ø!PªB(#¿Á¤aΠƅ4½’ÇÒÆ4Ïù¿B)aQ’7 ^ð”TWTÂ&S*©QÙ0´Iŀ)ìÒBÐÓ^Ú2$T¥·É”TŠRšCÉ®ÐXÔ¥¥f›f:©2—³ú$—h`óX[Ë4ùbœDë±FªQ‰›…|¦œ=Ê3e ¡Ì~é|u4¬YFôÓW¬UÌ<ÂKÍ8-SvÝ@0ÞV‰¤+rI¥—Tê1Ì{I kLÀjrÆ£oÖgðbò1U+±7Ú`)åÏF}_›0xYB›˜Ùˆ€Ûz‰ÂÏ­#8ª0‹¤iNÐ2­#ÄóFi¥ Äõ&ØÔö …‰FF̆ (‰.©<ž­E#óhö¡Qlð^=JŽ1É9Ïøhº`mHà‡Ü“‹Fb´RÃz/žúÒv9öÒÜ ábVûƶbŸ©kÎ@GK›Yô$ kkä‰!TK3¶hl} “¯´4ên C1È,XÄUÈ µÙkƝ—þh;Ös=s,Ñ[ÖÕQºÇ4´5Õ³Ç"˜ ¤¢œ'd‚?Þ[cxˆõ½B‹2nRDÒŽR­&ù*ã¼Ó+FIÈ鯽µNc®D»‡7]7ŽÎ¬eƒ1RÕóɵ´V…E!¼§õ+ÉÂ9ß{îNr¾õ„”;ý-Jþ©(7v|üë´}S:üXlÜ닓—g^\¬Næ¯QiWioGP.6'ϯw»›o_¾üá×7ïγïN³wÜןØHdp±«Jܨ2Û”‚†œ(§†wT'wˆ@iT-/•6Ž.qžøœØ3ÓÀÎÔØT:ϬVΗÀÄ*S—g€i‚/2kx£â'j@‹Jg¦þ¦Ô8¢\(4ýㅯ âæB†gAµKåÊà )á>ÀF鐊S¦ŽDr¨xq¢½#Ð΄2›9ªŠ";gà¸Tp@W93ÑAÃâ&¯JrQ33ՅËÊJiöò†ÁI²¹@ â¶`78‹Eg8ሠ˜èà£`ꁼÑ,L% ₠ eW¢DAøa^•a£èÏy³R†ä5FWÒd™WýÉo ú#Ac‘yA¶š2óÀÆ3RËÀ£4EnHÒÂà˜Õ¬œµ+<Üzyas&RxDî>œÉ¬#¹ÀxxA§²4… Âx´r‘•¸áA݄“E[ô¢­1<â*£ù…6UÈ™ÁM ÏY1á‘BΚ¸Ša@ À:<ç¥Î,k@Ÿƒ<#·Ü¸TUp–`è<ÀÚ±§65Ô § ²wFÙ½h„Ó<íKe=•F´ GOŠ˜ÏÈÍÄg‡lE ½³( "ú5ðìN¼qÞÊ%‰öАýHQ¦ À¡L°¨äÐÙ°fBž¬kH'*e-ìÚï4{Ù:/­`5å ±£R®e I¥:ZWJ—á†ÏQÜðhðÛ@ÛàDUå¸!B€mK  ËæÈbϾµyPq¦Àgiå JŠfr–b²hÑeš±ûŠÒâL!bAø­,¢æPàØ°:ê©iÍJñ¨^ºÛBÈ}‰Í°È£6 h¢ûÔH˹ƒxK…K˖ä@3.k!Z<Ȭa =,éâ’f‰N#¡Š– '€T³j2E.šBZ ])¶ÌoŒ³"6Ö¸@Ä {µd 1*¹a .āRè&>ážu•eЁ‚(¤~h|ê*ÚÔ(å tr‰vwTޞŽÑ¶ÈÉ@“*Pè-î 8T'‘-¹À`mØFÊBÉBá¬ÀkwGµ $3µ#¤æ!M…*8¢ãh­ EÍm@ ’«¡—”, (ª(¥fiyß±‹–¾Æ³&(JIm°†j'5u¥ êøŽâ‚ ±*¹nñDÚì)ÿâ ¦Š€ƒ¤åJÅ6¥*ˆ2ä׈A˜³゚^Ò¢—1ç|ů`J¸á‘70hÂãQi˜B%d29˜ˆ‹2©0` qZz´· •×2™Ká©9Á‰ ŽE:õœmœiÐI–Ù'õq\B‹ÅJZ&±…qb¥ÇU£$7 Út9öPS¦ ÊðAá§ÎP‡ÃË?u‰µ sÁKÎ8.Sâ݀`´¬Ž.rJ¥¦TòѤ½Äƒ5"`G9ÆF_Ògà…ɇ©Z’½V‹§=Qö}% y´±!`6BÀe½„§Ö!¥I")šc¸ Yéò<0-g˜8ß™Ú: 0VȈkCE©<ƖÆaúöÇÝ«û8ÄIn«»gUÓxœºz¥%gµÔ¿ÅA¾RÇzZžÕÓC×<(u8ÍË×_í^ £jOw ¾|†×AíÇI"é†fãÐÅ¡‰ /ãïÇ8 à¦>ͱUËÈû<©Füœ”š»ûi<(ÅôÄ«ëPé‚/6ógëDðó)¦Qî3”ã?ÚÕEA~t¿EqTã´ZÈØ«Á„e÷Û¸‡Ëš<Ԅ/.iƒrªî—8 õÒ=F€kRr©Iù“†¯qy|‚ééu"Å|ºû„ÚÓ ¨oâ‘«i¼áGž¤á‹ÜW ÑG§¾%ËØ7›ažO¼ígVhh7õ€FiWÚªCÝ j_?¢$WõKõïö{ÆM/OÝòÐNõӐ¾éû—u_kBZ”læý5>'¥Dd©3Yó!6¨F==K3¶PBêŸ?÷ÝѠ˰L…iî@d)ò?uhj¼m"‰Ú0þœQkǘ2’±Ñ YN(XžRÇ3º9ó'¹¹«çNLÁóÕ" Ø^õ_Íꉍ[w,”dr®¿èù¤n¨3°²H ¥)%€Õ,ãĶêûx/éŸù?¬/XÏ5=na‰‘d'ß±^{ÄÌ֛¨y‹ôiâï¼L§FøyewҕkO"zxXukœŽ#{¤MÄ<ÄzX{ü%'ÏáËO-zõóŸñ÷…Ëù|¨—6]m þ/%wÕtŽ‹-^Lªõ%<wþ~¼®ÿæõK&ÆéK5˜ÀµÆÎø³”@Œ„w„¯_@—_¬ 8¥D%ýjZ¼úú˜èµt‡˜%láŽZ®~èz1ÆŠK½ñq…Ý֜êÒçÜD„ÿqJõÿs|ÿҔ¿³M¬ºýyní§úԞz¸~}ñ²b/ºQ«{è5¬í<ªÏ&ג7BSž¸Rðu¸àõ:þÅ »I{ƒùüß}m~sQé'üHüO—A&}9ˆ rgÈupQHD–^êæmãé×2Cb|ÍoÙø0Ó-}òú_hFؾ“?Ƴøü×Ww¿~­6•¼0äõ®ž×±¨¾i€±æÿ#SêÇXOKFö̱ߨp•ö&ÉÀ0NèsœGܗŽ]¥!Uâ ̵«$aaU.™«Æ`ÀoeZ1¡ ˜ç*’,Jmm“㉽!L.ž-sŠÝnªrсŸâñt?0«µŸRluñoŸ_„xžÊMÜ6‰/†ð†¨˜º’°tÿŠ .t2V(‹Aü_ÏS’ÛV±N¦ù8-.¿Qê2+Ù]S¼;- ×Y1oOqíª³™ 'S+ýÒc«ƒ`sMÒº•a-õek”ü;¸gÁ„5BÏãÄçšx¼2œU¨'1ÿtÆUt-S|욕=Ô« æ¤O•àxÓTJS¹¯ŸÎ[Ü!ro—Éç#¨ã¾ë×ùüGUPõžó˜!·`L²Ø\í6"7Jð_%Gå¥è<gÇ©~¦AÊpלúzâÊúô‡³ÿ¿([³ ˆ—ªy÷|ž)ÿ‰/¶qUßO‘4"L)é}7H1×2üsB©ï¸ån‹×ÿÙê»)íu %=ÙÖ-ðˆ Àâ&ø]ïnwÏòOÊ`}adHõßöß4o¦).S…Wƒ˜†/p})Ë ÷âcÜúˆdtu·p¹«Vn|[O/ey…E¢ï:FÿP?EYÆÃ9 ùua…»A#J'? Õùü›Ö•sÉE£4H HqËÄlïâ>“¨WYç† ÄöÂÝ ŒÜøiõXw­˜ëS©= Ÿ<’iR|.¯óYÞ붕݌ûáz ƒ2 'Ñهä?­ÜÙ$È·!Ù^O¢—ÃoÝ_pÿÝ­ú÷Žþ¤YåHendstream endobj 20 0 obj 3585 endobj 23 0 obj <> stream xœU—[“É…ßõ+êm!šº_ü¶f±‡Í®a¿l8BH=Œ]f%1ÿÞßɞÁ»  ©îʬ̓'O–~s~ ÎëçñssXý¶ Þ}]·[ù©»¿®BOeݕVؖÜaF‰SJ®ôÔõFOS(ZçÉýðS‘EˆSÌn³Š!â¬ò_ÑíW¡µÌ™5Œ8ÕåANS<©cªUOzJò^} S‹.ô8ä½zï§á‚œ·ìÊÐ'g ‰Z_Š2EÒ1€Y{åU»R9¶Úƒä•H©D^ >öL)‹\0žSèT•¦äaŒ§•Ë԰Ȃ`ƒnbgñøÒ)!Ũ-¹Ç !ö1 1aL+1Eû’¹¨¤àU“ÜbëXû¦¤šèÐzؚÜ|ÌKUá¬À~À!«§ [À‘š°q:’}Ž.5z1§µ»6—ª”'ÁÐ`YE‘èY“3ÍâŠsÀ¡Ôå¡ët"ÒßÔ ª;y’k2#‹ W4RÐDJ™:ÀÑq$j`¹ :oqøÅ{@Ø8²©TJøMžgA½œrµVHAòFìTÊ"ÀL('$Uê˜r³.âzêE¥ýáw* ÙÑ»Ç !"  ¥m*PT¶,WõmòPÙSølɞPRš)'HÉÒ* ÑMA±×.iɱ˜XþBE  ),„@=ƒ¼%k8µZw'ôAÜ·Ø¢ @žJ¤AÐBÿÒȤ¹ÃÖFc«p3°R›c&@P\)!ZÚ¨¬ñ ˆF$ºäE³L§I¨ËsÔ°j«VSÌ0k1º)Nʀ'1'›óbQ½ÚTCæB7‹ˆ¸H†Rt“VØ¥Üm)ÅÖRÓ"Ö'تêË¢5Àæ9”ŠÃ´ .!æ ³F3ªjZÙ*gÚ ƒ‚Ê «/]¥m F³'è rI»g)ï^Ó¶äѤ.€„>aCpTg‘“¸ `Óx”E’Eá’Á탆{–Ú ‘YÚ1–愐±S…,t²|2i…`jž-(®&Bo’,UJTZí᝺8ëkÖA8P”&mH!Bí¬¦¹ªYÏT í¨ˆUÓu#ÊI"hs•ü#ÄÃ&LEàiµ¢T(vŒ”ªeä7š!ÌSa\Hӛð½çëÊó­'fïô¯Tþk”;ϼþë´}SzüØܟoV¯Þ=¸¹]-_£$Ò®éގ ÜVÏî®×û?½zõ·?½ý0½{ûzzûÎ=¿ùD7ÛÕ³yÿæoÜëŸ?¾¿q?ÿŽ}÷ÓÛmO{ÚóËúóì²;ÝòŸÞ¼zùrîKͽ vb²Í×»Ù¹õýý¼ß¯W·oçãV¿}šÝvwž7×yë®'w¿þæÖû½[öŸÏóú|‘s\ßü}õŒÃ–WûÝf>nfw;ϓsÿâ—Ýqë.Ÿ.×µžïŽytØ].»Óñù«g‡õvv§#§Þ­÷·Š]›ÎóåþtÜÎÇëebò¨³œýÁ»ûÈ»³íÜìΛ‡ÃrÆå…=RRë=±Î üô•<>}ÃËcėùzÝ?“ÌeÇÙ²8qwq»ÃýÃçã¼å„›G?ÎËïà(âÝÅÝÏçÃîúÐúÀ;sóõ¬‡GG4י§W½Ö‹ù¿W­N·fܜÎ÷§óz‰Bïï÷óZ©ßᛍ»ëþæŸæã|»{²ÿ@iï¹¿>ûôëó'ÈÞ·»õѽY_Ìöâ~Ü\_ˆÎx÷ßû,å·v¥UOÕ},®ª±ÞlNñïëêÖÇ­ì7§ þÁï2ówËoW÷þ2¥|ó~õÒ}Ý]ï¨öZ0íN[99)üát¼ÞÉþö|:<’a R¬Ï×Ý|q_þ}úÈ¢g7ç…t¯Oç«ÊNUdO܏â*›yw}‚á{Œür§,ARö ðô€ýýyþò°eÛÒçÝç»ëåÉ×SH_ïv›;w ûõÖ¬Ö"ÔZâ¿Z¬›ÇP_D§Û~ÏHQò;ççõ囸ýæÆýs¥ŸÿmIáíendstream endobj 24 0 obj 2377 endobj 5 0 obj <> /Contents 6 0 R >> endobj 14 0 obj <> /Contents 15 0 R >> endobj 18 0 obj <> /Contents 19 0 R >> endobj 22 0 obj <> /Contents 23 0 R >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 5 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R 22 0 R ] /Count 4 >> endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj <> endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>endobj xref 0 26 0000000000 65535 f 0000013979 00000 n 0000016405 00000 n 0000013899 00000 n 0000014027 00000 n 0000013307 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000003381 00000 n 0000014276 00000 n 0000014338 00000 n 0000015344 00000 n 0000015402 00000 n 0000014082 00000 n 0000014112 00000 n 0000013467 00000 n 0000003401 00000 n 0000007138 00000 n 0000014153 00000 n 0000013611 00000 n 0000007159 00000 n 0000010816 00000 n 0000014194 00000 n 0000013755 00000 n 0000010837 00000 n 0000013286 00000 n 0000014235 00000 n trailer << /Size 26 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R >> startxref 16455 %%EOF