THE ITO-1, RATLAM vs. SMT. BILKIS BAI BADNAWARWALA, RATLAM

PDF · subscribers
ITA 205/IND/2017Status: DisposedITAT Indore08 January 2019AY 2008-097 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the CIT(A) had provided a finding of fact that the assessee, Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, initially had a 50% share in the property. As per Hibba Nama under Muslim Personal Law, she transferred 25% of her share to her son, Mr. Kalimuddin Badnawarwala. The CIT(A) observed that all legal formalities, including registration before the Sub-Registrar, were completed for the 25% share transferred by the appellant and the 25% share transferred by Mr. Kalimuddin. The CIT(A) recalculated the capital gain by considering the sale price at Rs. 37,50,000/- (25% of total consideration) and the purchase price at Rs. 8,28,250/- for the assessee's 25% share. This resulted in a Long Term Capital Gain of Rs. -1,03,206/-, leading to the deletion of the AO's addition. The Tribunal found no infirmity in the CIT(A)'s finding, as the Revenue did not rebut it with adverse material. Therefore, the grounds raised by the Revenue were rejected, and the appeals were dismissed.

What were the facts?

These are two appeals by the Revenue against orders of the CIT(A), Ujjain, for assessment year 2008-09. The appeals were consolidated due to common issues. The Assessing Officer (AO) reopened the assessee's case and framed an assessment under Section 143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The AO made an addition of Rs. 25,75,513/- and assessed the income at Rs. 26,09,433/-, against a declared income of Rs. 33,950/-. The AO observed that the assessee claimed a capital loss of Rs. 1,03,206/- on land sold for Rs. 1,50,00,000/-. The assessee appealed to the CIT(A), who deleted the additions. The Revenue is challenging the deletion of this addition.

What were the issues?

1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 25,75,513/- on account of Long Term Capital Gain, ignoring the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act regarding mandatory registration and stamp duty for valid transfer of immovable property? 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 25,75,513/- on account of Long Term Capital Gain, ignoring that the transfer claim of entities created thereunder as co-owner has no legal sanctity, rendering the 25% share transfer void? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee's counsel supported the order of the CIT(A), submitting that the AO was not justified in making the addition and that the CIT(A)'s finding was contrary to the recorded material. The assessee relied on Hibba Nama under Muslim Personal Law for the transfer of property. The assessee also stated that all legal formalities, including registration before the Sub-Registrar, were completed for the 25% share transfer by the appellant and the 25% share transfer by Mr. Kalimuddin. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue's Senior Departmental Representative supported the AO's order and argued that the CIT(A) was not justified in deleting the addition. The Revenue contended that the transfer of property was void as legal formalities under the Transfer of Property Act were not met.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 147

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, INDORE BENCH, INDORE

Before: SHRI KUL BHARAT & SHRI MANISH BORAD

For Appellant: Shri K.G. Goyal, Sr. D.R
For Respondent: Shri T.H. Khamosi &, Shri Kaid Kangsawala, A.Rs
Hearing: 10.12.2018Pronounced: 08.01.2019

Heard together (2 matters)

ITA No.204/Ind/2017
ITA No.205/Ind/2017

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

आदेश / O R D E R

PER KUL BHARAT, J.M: These two appeals by the revenue against two different

orders of the Ld. CIT(A), Ujjain pertaining to the

assessment year 2008-09. Both the appeals were taken up

together as the issues are common and are being disposed

of by way of a consolidated order.

2.

First we take up ITA No.205/Ind/2017. The revenue

has raised following grounds of appeal:

On the facts and in the circumstances of the case Ld. CIT(A) erred in 1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, Ld. CIT has erred in deleting the addition of Rs.25,75,513/- on account of Long Term Capital Gain. 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, Ld. CIT has erred in deleting the addition of Rs.25,75,513/- on account of Long Term Capital Gain ignoring the provisions of Transfer of Property Act, wherein it is mandatory to register any change in right, title or entitlement to be registered before the registering authority i.e. Sub registrar and stipulated stamp duty, as per prevailing circle rate of Jantri rates shall have to be paid. Only after completion of such legal formalities, there can be valid transfer of immovable property. 3. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, Ld. CIT has erred in deleting the addition of Rs.25,75,513/- on account of Long Term Capital Gain ignoring that transfer claim entities created there under as co- owner also have no legal sanctity. As such, 25% share in whole building

[ITA 204 & 205/Ind/2017] [Shri Kalimuddin Badnawarwala & Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, Ratlam] transferred by Mrs. Bilkisbai Badnawarwala in favouir of her son Mr. Kalimuddin Badnawarwala is void. Note: The matter is covered under the exception as mentioned in para 8(c) of circular 21/2015. The appellant reserves his right to add, amend or alter the grounds of appeal on or before the date; the appeal is finally heard for disposal. 4. Briefly stated facts are that case of the assessee

was reopened for assessment and the assessment u/s

143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter

called as ‘the Act’) was framed vide order dated 29.2.2016.

While framing the assessment, the A.O. made addition of

Rs.25,75,513/- and assessed the income at Rs.26,09,433/-

against the declared income of Rs.33,950/-. The A.O.

observed that the assessee had claimed capital loss of

Rs.1,03,206/- on the land sold for Rs.1,50,00,000/-.

5.

Aggrieved by the finding of the A.O., an appeal was

filed by the assessee before Ld. CIT(A), who after

considering the submissions deleted the additions.

[ITA 204 & 205/Ind/2017] [Shri Kalimuddin Badnawarwala & Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, Ratlam] 6. Ld. D.R. supported the order of the A.O. and

submitted that Ld. CIT(A) was justified in deleting the

addition.

7.

Per contra, Ld. Counsel for the assessee supported the

order of Ld. CIT(A) and submitted that the A.O. was not

justified in making the addition. He further submitted that

the finding of the Ld. CIT(A) is contrary to the recorded and

the material placed by the assessee.

8.

We have heard the rival submissions, perused the

materials available on records and gone through the orders

of the authorities below. The Ld. CIT(A) has given finding

of facts by observing as under:

5.1 Ground No.1:- Through this ground of appeal the appellant has challenged the addition of Rs.25,75,513/- on account of long term capital gain. During the year under consideration the appellant sold the property situated at 37, Mitra Nivas Road (Tashkand Marg), Ratlam in which she was having 25% share. The appellant was having initially 50% share in the above stated property. As per the Hibba Nama under the Muslim Personal Law, she transferred 25% property to Mr. Kalimuddin who is son of the appellant. The 25% property has been sold by the appellant and the 25% has been sold by Mr. Kalimuddin. All the legal formalities like registration of the sale documents before the Sub-Registrar in respect of 25% has been done by the appellant and in

[ITA 204 & 205/Ind/2017] [Shri Kalimuddin Badnawarwala & Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, Ratlam]

respect of 25% is done by Mr. Kalimuddin. The A.O. while calculating the capital gain has considered the sale price in respect of the appellant at 50% of the total receipt and the purchase price of the property also at 50% of the total purchase price and other expenditure like cost of construction at 25%. Since, the appellant owns 25% of the property at the time of transfer then it will be appropriate to consider sale price at Rs.37,50,000/- instead of Rs.75,00,000/- being 25% of the sale consideration. The A.O. should also have adopted plot purchase amount at Rs.8,28,250/- instead of Rs.16,56,500/-. Therefore, the capital gain of the appellant should be calculated as under:- Sale Assessee’s 1,50,00,000/- 37,50,000/- consideration 1/4th share Less: Year of Cost of Index Indexed cost acquisition acquisition of acquisition 2001-02 8,28,250/- 551/426 10,71,281/- 2001-02 3,10,750/- 551/426 4,01,933/- 2002-03 5,53,092/- 551/447 6,81,776/- 2003-04 12,74,976/- 551/463 15,17,304/- 2004-05 1,57,600/- 551/480 1,80,912/- 38,53,206/- LONG TERM CAPITAL GAIN -1,03,206/-

Therefore, the addition made by the A.O. amounting to Rs.25,75,513/- is Deleted. Therefore, the appeal on this ground is Allowed.

9.

The aforesaid finding on fact is not rebutted by the

revenue by placing any adverse material on record.

Therefore, we do not see any infirmity in to the finding of

the Ld. CIT(A) and the same is hereby affirmed. Grounds

raised by the revenue are rejected.

[ITA 204 & 205/Ind/2017] [Shri Kalimuddin Badnawarwala & Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, Ratlam] 10. Now we take up revenue’s appeal in ITA

No.204/Ind/2017. The facts are identical as were in ITA

No.205/Ind/2017. The respective representative have

adopted the same arguments as were in ITA

No.205/Ind/2015. We have sustained the finding of the

Ld. CIT(A). As revenue has not placed any adverse material

representing finding on fact by the Ld. CIT(A). Therefore,

taking a consistent view in the present appeal as well, we

do not see any infirmity in the finding of the Ld. CIT(A) and

the grounds raised by the revenue are rejected.

11.

In the result, appeals filed by the revenue are

dismissed.

Order was pronounced in the open court on 08 .01.2019. Sd/- Sd/- (MANISH BORAD) (KUL BHARAT) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIALMEMBER Indore; �दनांक Dated : 08/01/2019 VG/SPS

[ITA 204 & 205/Ind/2017] [Shri Kalimuddin Badnawarwala & Smt. Bilkis Bai Badnawarwala, Ratlam]

Copy to: Assessee/AO/Pr. CIT/ CIT (A)/ITAT (DR)/Guard file. By order

Assistant Registrar, Indore

More judgments on Section 147

All 49,210 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →