M/S. STAR DELTA TRANSFORMERS LTD.,2015-16 vs. PR. CIT -1, BHOPAL

The present two appeals are directed at the instance of separate assessees against the orders of the learned Pr. Commissioner of Income-tax- 1, Bhopal dated 27.12.2019 in the case of M/s. Bansal Pathways Pvt Ltd and dated 15.01.2020 in the case of M/s. Star Delta Transformers Ltd., passed for Assessment Year 2015-16 (for both assessees), under Section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. & 105/Ind/2020 Star Delta Transforers Ltd & Bansal Pathways Pvt Ltd AY : 2015-16 2

Since common issues are involved in both these appeals; therefore, we have heard them together and deem it appropriate to dispose of by this common order.

First we take up in the case of M/s. Bansal Pathways Pvt. Ltd. The brief facts of the case are that the assessee has filed its return of income on 25.09.2015, declaring total income at Rs.8,810/-. An assessment order was passed under Section 143(3) of the Act on 18.12.2017, accepting the returned income. The learned Commissioner perused the assessment order as well as records and found that the assessee did not file audit report in Form No.10CCB alongwith return because 3CA report was signed and verified by the accountant on 25.09.2015. The learned Commissioner further observed that as per provisions of Section 80-IA(7) r.w.s. 44AB of the Act, the audit report in Form No.10CCB from the Chartered Accountant was required to be signed and verified on or before the due date of filing of the return, i.e. on or before 25th September 2015, for claiming deduction under Section 80-IA(4) of the Act.

Now we take up the facts from the case of M/s. Star Delta Transformers Ltd. ( ). In this case, the assessee has filed its return of income on 26.09.2015 declaring total income at Rs.2,05,50,430/-. An assessment order was framed under Section 143(3) of the Act on 08.11.2017 determining the taxable income of the assessee at Rs.2,18,87,400/-. In this case also the assessee had claimed deduction under Section 80-IA of the Act and the learned Commissioner, after perusal of the records, formed an opinion that audit report in Form No.10CCB was not filed alongwith the return, i.e. within the due date of filing of the return. Therefore, in the opinion of the learned Commissioner, the assessment orders in both the cases were erroneous and cause prejudice to the interest & 105/Ind/2020 Star Delta Transforers Ltd & Bansal Pathways Pvt Ltd AY : 2015-16 3 of the revenue. He accordingly issued showcase notice under Section 263 of the Income-tax Act. Both the assessees have apprised learned Commissioner that the filing of the report alongwith return or due date of filing of the return is a directory condition. If the audit report is being filed during the assessment proceedings or even at appellate stage, then it will be construed as sufficient compliance. It was further stated that both the assessees have filed the report during the assessment proceedings and after perusal of these documents, learned Assessing Officer has granted the deduction to both the assessees; so, however the learned Commissioner, without making any analysis of the submissions, just set aside the assessment order in both the cases and directed the Assessing Officer to make de novo assessments.

With the assistance of learned representatives, we have gone through the record carefully. There is no dispute with regard to the proposition that From No.10CCB is required to be filed by an assessee for claiming deduction under Section 80-IA(4) of the Act. The dispute is that whether such report is mandatorily required to be filed alongwith return or it is directory condition which can be fulfilled during the assessment proceedings. The assessee, in the case of M/s. Bansal Pathways Pvt. Ltd., filed its written submission before the learned Commissioner wherein it relied upon large number of decisions in which it has been propounded that filing of the audit report is a directory condition and it can be filed during the assessment proceedings. The written submission filed by the assessee before the learned Commissioner reads as under:-

On due consideration of the above facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that the learned Assessing Officer has not committed any error in granting the deduction to both the assessees. The assessees have duly complied with the conditions as contemplated in & 105/Ind/2020 Star Delta Transforers Ltd & Bansal Pathways Pvt Ltd AY : 2015-16 5 Section 80-IA(7) of the Act, i.e. to file the audit report in Form No.10CCB. These reports have been filed during the assessment proceedings and the Assessing Officer has the benefit of going through these documents; therefore, the assessment orders cannot be branded as erroneous. The learned Commissioner has not justified in taking action against both the assessees. We, therefore, quash the impugned orders passed under Section 263 of the Act in the respective case of each assessee and allow both the appeals of the assessees.

In the result, both the appeals of the assessees are allowed.